What happened to Romans after they died? For too long, the answer has been straightforward: Roman religion did not include clear ideas on the afterlife. While Elysium and Tartarus might appear in poetry, most Romans focused on preserving their memory among the living rather than imagining a life among the dead. The Ancient Roman Afterlife upends that narrative. Charles King practically buries the reader in evidence for a very different understanding, arguing that Romans worshipped deceased loved ones as gods and themselves expected to become gods after death. The book makes essential reading, not only for specialists in religion or funerary studies, but for all Romanists and anyone with an interest in Roman culture.
The opening chapters establish the argument. First, K. contends that manes were gods and did not belong to a separate demigod or other lower category. Indeed, thousands of surviving epitaphs attest to this status in their first line: dis manibus, ‘to the divine manes’. Defining the manes as non-imperial deified dead, K. shows that common translations such as ‘to the spirits of the dead’ or even ‘to the gods of the dead’ simply cannot represent the Latin. He deals with number in the second chapter, discussing instances in which Roman authors use manes to indicate worship of one specific, deceased individual. Although the plural form has been taken to designate an undifferentiated mass of spirits, K. parallels the word with others that lack a singular form but could be used in a singular sense. Ch. 3 is especially compelling, analysing the legal evidence that governed who was responsible for worshipping individual manes and demonstrating that Romans expected nearly everyone to enjoy their own cult after death. The sources converge around the idea that property rights, rather than blood ties, were key to determining responsibility from a legal perspective. Leaving property — and in some cases, even leaving debt — furnished a newly-established god with worshippers, and this benefit extended to women as well as men and across nearly every point on the Roman social spectrum.
Ch. 4 is the crux of the book, presenting the theoretical argument that underpins its approach. The variety of afterlife scenarios present in late Republican and early Imperial literature, in contrast to the consistency of Christian beliefs, has been taken to imply agnosticism: as Paul Veyne put it, ‘Lacking a common doctrine, Romans … assumed nothing and believed nothing’ (P. Veyne, The Roman Empire (1997), 219). As K. demonstrates, however, variation was common across Roman communication with the gods, which was structured by belief without dogmatic creed. Drawing on the concept of polymorphism — the idea that deities could possess more than one form, each with distinct or even contrasting attributes — he encourages pursuing ‘belief clusters’ by grouping common assumptions within the fractured particulars. The chapter fits well into current directions in studies of Roman religion, and although K. does not discuss it explicitly, has particular resonance with Jörg Rüpke's influential Lived Ancient Religion project.
With the final chapters, K. uses the concept of belief clusters to explore Rome's cult of the dead more fully, highlighting shared patterns within the literary and epigraphic references to manes. Ch. 5 lays out the powers of the dead, identifying widespread ideas that manes controlled the duration of worshippers’ lives and the conditions of their deaths, monitored the actions of the living and intervened in their favour or against them, and secured desirable situations in the afterlife for former worshippers. Ch. 6 attempts to reconstruct a standardised Roman funeral, arguing that its central rites transitioned the dead into gods and their loved ones into worshippers. Ch. 7 examines potential belief clusters surrounding post-funerary rites for the manes, from the Parentalia to private worship in the home. A brief conclusion lays out directions for future research, most notably through consideration of ‘mystery cults’ and Christianity, while appendices discuss two subjects in more detail: the sometimes malicious dead known as Larvae and the chronology of the Lemuria.
In a book this ambitious, some weaknesses can be expected. Ch. 6, on the funeral, largely abandons the idea of belief clusters, instead opting for a more traditional method that attempts to mould scattered evidence into a unified picture of ‘the’ Roman funeral. A more consistent approach might have built the argument from clusters of belief/practice by which funerals often included processions, sacrifices, incense, garlands, communal meals and other common indicators of cult, without necessitating a more complete — and significantly less trustworthy — narrative of rites. More broadly, the use of belief clusters sometimes seems to universalise the data in ways that might be counterproductive, discouraging investigations into changes through time, for example, or even into how genre might impact the ways an author discusses death and the afterlife. Nevertheless, these issues do not compromise the significance of the work, instead indicating areas where future research might expand and refine it.
The Ancient Roman Afterlife grew out of a dissertation completed more than two decades ago, and the many years K. has spent grappling with his question are clear throughout. The central thesis is simple and strong, leaving the reader wondering how the field could so thoroughly have overlooked such a key aspect of Roman life. As importantly, this is a book that invites questions. Its implications are far-reaching, and its conclusions cannot be ignored. It should generate discussion and debate well beyond the field of funerary studies.
