This volume is a fine work on the Church of the East, well-researched and well-written, deserving to takes its place alongside the few authoritative sources produced on this topic thus far, such as Jerome Labourt's Le Christianisme dans l'Empire Perse (1904), Cardinal Tisserant's article on ‘L'Eglise Nestorienne,’ in Dictionnaire de Théologie Catholique (1931) and Christoph Baumer's The Church of the East: An Illustrated History of Assyrian Christianity (2006). The book is an intelligent and informative romp through the history of a little-known Church that was once a significant player in the history of the Middle East and Asia. The author's previous work on this subject, The Ecclesiastical Organisation of the Church of the East, 1318–1913 (Peeters, 2000), utilised manuscript colophons to fill in important information on the post-Mongol organisation of the Church, a largely-neglected area of research. The current volume broadens the canvas to take in the whole history of the Church, from its origins to the twenty-first century.
The book is laid out in a logical and orderly fashion. Sandwiched between the Foreword and the Afterword are ten chapters, describing 1) the origins of the Church in the Persian Empire; 2) early conflicts between ‘Nestorians and Jacobites’; 3) the new situation inaugurated by the advent of Islam; 4) the era of patriarch Timothy I and his successors; 5) the gradual erosion of the Church of the East during the later ‘Abbasid Caliphate; 6) the short renaissance of Christianity under the Mongols; 7) the decimation and retreat of the Church after the Il-khanid conversion to Islam; 8) the Catholic missions that split the Church into ‘Nestorian’ and ‘Chaldean’ parties; 9) the influence of other European missionaries during the nineteenth century and 10) “the calamitous twentieth century”, as Wilmshurst so aptly terms the latest chapter in the history of this beleaguered Church. Throughout, the theme tying these chapters together is the suffering and martyrdom that the Church of the East has endured through so much of its history, from Sassanid Persia to post-Saddam Iraq, a story that is still little-known outside the field of those specialising in Eastern (and more specifically Syriac) Christianity.
Following an overview of chapter contents, each chapter contains an in-depth discussion of the following topics for the time period covered: Historical Narrative, Ecclesiastical Administration, Monasticism (except in the final chapter, reflecting the end of ‘Nestorian’ monasticism in 1886: p. 403), and Literature and Scholarship. These topics are further subdivided into relevant sections, making it easy for the reader to follow Wilmshurst's train of thought. Most helpful are the subdivisions under Ecclesiastical Administration, reflecting the author's interest in the organisation of the Church, the role and authority of the patriarch and the historical changes in episcopal jurisdiction. This interest in the geographical spread of the Church over time is reflected in six clear and detailed maps at the end of the volume, followed by a very helpful list of the patriarchs of the Church of the East, a bibliography and index. In general, the maps work well as a handy reference, but Chapters 8 and 9 would benefit from maps within the chapters themselves, to diminish the need for flipping back and forth in order to visualise the location of the many less-familiar place-names mentioned.
Before discussing the volume in more depth, one significant drawback from a scholarly perspective must be mentioned, namely Wilmshurst's decision not to include any footnotes; those who wish to follow up the information presented must rely on their own sleuthing skills to track down sources and page numbers. This is an unfortunate omission; although it does not diminish the readability or the appeal of the book to audiences both popular and academic, it does complicate the usability of the volume by the latter, as when I read about a “list of metropolitans of Fars during the Seljuq period” on p. 217, another list of “dioceses compiled at the beginning of the eleventh century” on p. 219 and “eleventh century texts [about] Nestorians in Egypt” on p. 225 – which texts are these exactly? However, sometimes a reference is given in the text that enables the reader to more easily find the article or book referred to (e.g., p. 314).
Some will disagree with the author's decision to use the controversial term ‘Nestorian’ throughout; however, he is well-aware of the issues involved and gives a well-reasoned defence of this decision (pp. xv–xvii). Others may object to his less-than-favourable view of political correctness, including his dismissal of “some squeamish modern scholars” who charge nineteenth century travellers in the Middle East with “flagrant Orientalism” (p. 408). Finally, there will undoubtedly be those in the Church of the East who do not appreciate Wilmshurst's critical perspective on the role that Assyrian nationalism has played in the church since the early twentieth century (p. 416ff). Overall, however, he is refreshingly frank about his interests in the history of the Church, preferring “drama . . . scandal and intrigue. . . [and a] sense of irony” to discussion of liturgy or the ascetic writings of “irresponsible, self-absorbed elitists” (p. xviii). In the process, he does not hesitate to point out that “Nestorians have excelled in the art of plausible invention” (p. xviii; see the extensive listing in the Index under falsification of history, p. 498) and that many of the Church's leaders “have been crooks and charlatans, and some of them have been murderers too” (p. xix).
Thus, this is a ‘warts and all’ history of the Church of the East, but told by one who sympathises with his subject and who manages to live up to his intention to “write in clear, vigorous English prose, and to avoid the obfuscations that disfigure so much contemporary academic discourse” (p. xix). Indeed, the writing style is easy to read and I found only one unnecessary double negative: “not an unmixed blessing” (p. 41). Those who can smile when reading about the tombs of seventy bishops in the monastery of Beth ‘Abe described as “an impressive tally of episcopal corpses” (p. 270) will undoubtedly enjoy this volume.
Reading through the book, one is consistently struck by the breadth of the author's knowledge of both the broader context (historical, political and cultural) of the ecclesiastical story he is telling and the literary sources needed to assemble that story in a coherent manner. Throughout, he manages both to analyse these sources, critiquing them when necessary, and to synthesise their information into his narrative. One of the real strengths of this volume is its presentation of the characters involved not as white-washed saints, but as flesh-and-blood individuals who were all too human.
Also of importance are Chapters 7–9, describing the post-Mongol period, which go into considerably more detail than most scholarly accounts of the Church of the East, particularly about the vicissitudes of the hereditary patriarchate (fifteenth to twentieth century) and the complicated sequence of events surrounding the birth of the Chaldean Church (sixteenth to nineteenth century), both discussed in a manner that paints few of the participants in a favourable light. What is eminently clear from Wilmshurst's narrative is that the ‘conversion’ of ‘Nestorians’ to Catholicism was a far more complex and nuanced process than many Catholic writers on the topic have cared to admit. Chapter 8 is an especially needed corrective to such over-simplifications, although paradoxically, there are places in Chapter 9 which almost read like a Catholic tract, as in the description of Chaldean patriarch Eliya XII, who “launched a mission” to his “benighted Nestorian neighbours”, sending “intrepid Catholic missionaries . . . to penetrate the remote Nestorian villages” (p. 391).
As indicated in the Foreword, whenever an incident involving “scandal and intrigue” arises, the author is not afraid to highlight it, such as the behaviour of “newly-marriageable clergymen . . . [who insisted] on pre-marital sex with their prospective brides” (p. 29). However, the lack of footnotes makes it difficult to follow up assertions such as “Celibacy was enforced in the Nestorian monasteries, with varying degrees of success” (p. 80). Certainly the sexual undertones behind many observations in the book would make a fascinating doctoral dissertation. Equally interesting would be a study of the oft-noted tendency to corruption in patriarchal elections (passim).
In his discussion of the Christology of the Church of the East (relevant to the accusations of ‘Nestorian’ heresy), Wilmshurst ably addresses the Greek and Syriac terminology, but is less than precise about the problematic term ‘orthodoxy,’ stating that after the 497 Synod, the Church “remained within the bounds of Christian orthodoxy” begging the question, ‘Which definition of orthodoxy?’ One paragraph later, he seemingly contradicts this sentiment, speaking of opponents within the Church of the East to the 497 Synod as follows: “their attempts to move the Church back into the mainstream of Christian thought [defined here as what?] were doomed to failure” (p. 31). Similarly, the descriptions of the ‘Nestorian’ community in Cyprus as “heretical” (p. 303) and the Uniate patriarch Joseph III's need for protection from “the violence of the heretics” (i.e. the ‘Nestorians’, p. 331), both without inverted commas, seem to undermine the author's efforts to defend the Church of the East as ‘within the theological pale’ of the larger Church.
The author also occasionally uses loaded terms, but without inverted commas, it is unclear if they are to be understood ironically or in a more literal sense: “another notorious nest of Severans [Miaphysites, Jacobites]” (p. 74); “repellent Severan christology [sic]” (p. 77), “rude Turkish tribes” (p. 78); “[the Parsees] have stubbornly maintained their beliefs to this day” (p. 98). At other times, it is clear that strong language is intended to make a point: “this insidious and unrelenting attrition [under Islam] did more to weaken Christianity than the violent but sporadic persecutions of the Zoroastrians” (p. 100).
My particular interest in the Church of the East in Central Asia prompts the following observations. In recounting the interesting story of Barshabba, the semi-legendary founder of Christianity in Merv (pp. 39–40), Wilmshurst seems to overlook Bardaisan's reference to Christians in Kushan territory (mentioned on p. 6) as an important precursor to Christianity in Balkh. Discussing the murder of Yazdegird III, the author states that patriarch Isho'yahb III recovered the shah's body for burial (p. 104), but Ṭabari (sub AH 31) informs us it was Eliya, metropolitan of Merv. Some of the author's conclusions regarding the conversion of a Turkic king and his army by the same Eliya are also open to question (p. 120): the text is not clear about which river is in question, whether the more distant Oxus or the nearby Murghab, and the diocese (or rather metropolitanate) of Beth Turkaye is unlikely to have been identical with that of Samarkand (an assertion repeated again on pp. 167, 300), as I have argued previously in this journal (Vol. 20, pp. 117–139).
The author's statement that “in the eighth century the Uighurs were Christians before they became Manichaeans” (p. 121, repeated on p. 168) is also questionable, as we have little if any indication of Christianity amongst the Uighurs prior to their ninth-century-arrival in Turfan, where it was a minority faith after Manichaeism and Buddhism (again, footnotes would help in verifying statements that scholars might call into question). Also less-than-certain is the assertion that the name of A-lo-pen, the seventh-century Christian missionary to China, means “God is my origin” (p. 122) – the original form of this name prior to Chinese transliteration is contested by scholars and is more likely to have been Persian Artaban than Syriac Yahballaha.
Wilmshurst's assertion that “Nestorian missionaries” in Central Asia were “working among tribesmen of a far lower cultural level [than in China]” (p. 186) betrays a misunderstanding of Central Asian culture, particularly the highly literate Sogdians, and his dismissal of the possibility that “humble Christian villagers in Central Asia were interested in reading Aristotle” (p. 187) overlooks the very significant intellectual climate in which Central Asian scholars like al-Khwarazmi (d. 847), al-Farabi (d. 950), Ibn Sina (d. 1037) and al-Biruni (d. 1048) lived and worked. Furthermore, the fragmentary remains of Christian literature from Central Asia make it difficult to determine exactly which Christian texts written in Sogdian or Uighur Turkic (not “Turkish and Uighur” as stated on p. 186) and found along the Silk Road were translations of Syriac originals and which were written in Central Asia. Although most Sogdian Christian texts from Turfan are indeed translations from Syriac, more textual work is needed to complete the picture.
The author identifies an unnamed group of 700,000 horsemen who had advanced as far as Kashgar in 1046, described by Bar Hebraeus (Budge's translation, pp. 204–205), as “menacing Tartar troop movements” (p. 220) but these horsemen are too early for the Mongols and must remain unidentified for now. The imprecise term ‘Tartar’ should probably also not be applied to the Christian Turkic Kerait tribe (p. 221); oddly, they are not identified by name in an unrelated paragraph on the next page, where they are referred to merely as “a Turkish tribe”. The dating of Christian gravestones in Syriac script discovered in Semirechye (now Kazakhstan and Kyrgyzstan) also needs clarification; rather than “ranging from the ninth century” (p. 221), the earliest gravestone dates from 1200/01 (or possibly 1185/86, based on uncertain readings of two stones). Daniel Chwolson, who published most of these gravestones (1890, 1897) dated two stones initially to 858 and 911, but later corrected the first to 1258 and discarded the second as too indistinct to read accurately. Unfortunately, secondary literature has not reflected Chwolson's corrected dates. Thus, ‘early thirteenth-mid-fourteenth century’ is a more accurate date range for this corpus (see my article in Hidden Treasures and Intercultural Encounters, LIT Verlag, 2009).
In the context of Mongke Khan's accession to the Mongol throne (p. 239), it is surprising that Wilmshurst neglects to mention Mongke's mother (and the mother of Hulegu Khan and Kublai Khan), Sorqaqtani Begi, a princess of the Christian Kerait tribe. Similarly, the description of the civil war between Kublai Khan and Ariq-boga (p. 242) omits the crucial fact that they were brothers raised by a Christian mother and Ariq-boga was partial to the Christians (surely suitable grist for the mill of drama, scandal, intrigue and irony that the author enjoys!). Furthermore, Abaqa (step-son of the Christian Kerait princess Doquz Khatun), who issued coins with Christian Arabic legends on them, is mistakenly described as an “early Muslim il-khan” (p. 250). However, I think the author is correct to identify the diocese of Kamul not with Qamul (Hami) in Chinese Turkestan, but rather with the monastery of Kamul in Mesopotamia (p. 261). Finally, how do we know that Adam, the author of the Xi'an ‘Nestorian’ stele, knew Arabic (p. 458), since he began his mission to China before the Arab conquest of Iran was completed?
In addition to the above factual issues, there were also a few typos in the volume: “Babowai was unable make a convincing defence” (p. 26); “would have doubtless have been burned” (p. 68); “he must have either have composed” (p. 91); “in the Ch'ang-an” (p. 122); “Sergius of Resaina [recte Resh'ayna]” (p. 185); “he was elected because because he spoke” (p. 248); “weakened remnant of Church of the East” (p. 287); “the Nestorians only appear only to have settled” (p. 305); “In 1616 . . . Eliya VIII complained to Pope Paul VI [recte Paul V]” (p. 341); “the Church's historic hearlands” (p. 459).
However, these critiques aside, the volume is still a must-read for those interested in the religious – and more particularly the Christian – history of the Middle East and Asia. The author is to be commended for his eminently readable re-telling of such a fascinating and important story. It is perhaps fitting to end this review with some thoughts on the Afterword. Wilmshurst's lack of concern with political correctness and willingness to engage with thorny issues is clear in his documenting of “Muslim pressure in the Church's historic [hearlands]” (p. 459). He highlights the fact that the Church of the East is increasingly a church living in diaspora and therefore in need of adjusting to the fact that its geographical and historical core in Mesopotamia may well have very few if any Christians in the near future, given the on-going disastrous fall-out for Iraqi Christians from the ill-conceived 2003 invasion of their country. The author presents an optimistic vision of where the Church could be in 2050 (pp. 463–464) which is certainly believable in parts, although recent events have put the lie to his statement that “the future looks brightest for the Assyrian community in Syria” (p. 460). Furthermore, many with knowledge of the Church will question whether indeed “Nestorians of California might one day press for the ordination of women” (p. 461) and die-hard Assyrian nationalists will undoubtedly reject Wilmshurst's well-argued exhortation that the Church “distance itself from the Assyrian identity” (pp. 462–463). However, it is hard to disagree with his closing paragraph:
The Church of the East has many faults, and I have not attempted to gloss over them in this book. At the same time, it has witnessed to the truth of the Christian faith in and beyond the lands of Islam for more than a millennium, often under the most difficult conditions and sometimes under the threat of persecution . . . Those who wish the Church of the East well, as I do, can only hope and pray that the twenty-first century will be kinder than the twentieth . . . it is a blessing that they now richly deserve (p. 465).
