Change, especially change that seems to constitute a structural break, provides fertile ground for social scientists. It comes as no surprise therefore that the global financial crisis has spawned already, and continues to spawn, numerous publications. Here, the particular focus is on home ownership which has been the site of both cause and effect. In the opening chapter − entitled ‘Households, homeownership and neoliberalism’ − Ray Forrest, one of the editors, sets out some key developments that provide a framework. Since at least the 1980s, housing systems in the economically advanced countries have experienced increasing support for home ownership as superior and preferable to rental alternatives. The expansion of home ownership sectors − to the point where in most developed and developing economies it provides the housing solution for the majority of households − has been based not only on government housing policies, such as the sale of social housing, but also on developments in financial markets toward the increasing securitisation of mortgages. Forrest wraps up this shift, toward a system in which not only houses but also their financing became products to be bought and sold in the market, using neo-liberal packaging, with its associated susceptibilities to volatility, instability and periodic crises. The 2007 financial crisis, then, was located in housing sectors in which, as Forrest puts it, ‘the logic of neoliberalism’ had driven the growth of precarious financial products aimed at increasing business by reducing entry costs.
Whereas home ownership sectors were central to the cause of the crisis, it was also home ownership sectors, and especially those individuals owning homes, who were to bear a considerable brunt of the consequences. Even among this group, Forrest argues, it has been ‘the usual victims’, those households in the most precarious financial positions that have lost most. It is with these groups that the primary concern of the book is focused. In pursuing this focus, the complex intergenerational dynamics have been recognised in which the young struggling to remain in the sector or to enter it may have been affected in different ways to older generations owning outright but experiencing a reduction in their overall wealth.
Given this perspective on the crisis, the editors organised a symposium at the City University of Hong Kong, inviting speakers from a selection of countries. Each of the symposium papers, which constitute the chapters of this book, reports on developments in their own country. Whereas the speakers/authors as a group include many established researchers well-known on international circuits, the selection of countries merits some comment. In some ways, the selection is not surprising: it broadly reflects Forrest's personal academic journey, linking his posts at Bristol University and City University, and his earlier work on the UK with a more recent focus on a number of East Asian economies. Hence of western countries the book includes the USA (Doug Duncan and Cesar Constantino), Australia (Mike Beery, Tony Dalton and Anitra Nelson) and New Zealand (David Thorns) along with a number of European countries – the UK (Peter Williams), Ireland (Michelle Norris and Nessa Winston), Netherlands (Richard Ronald and Kees Dol), Hungary (Jozsef Hegedus) and Iceland (Jon Runar Sveinsson) – with, from East Asia, Japan (Yosuke Hirayama), Hong Kong (Ngai Ming Yip), China (Jianping Ye and Chao Sun), Vietnam (Huang Huu Phe) and Korea (Soo-hyun Kim).
In other ways, the country selection could be said to be either too wide or too narrow. The ‘too wide’ position reflects the thrust of the editor's opening chapter. With some nods towards experiences in Japan and the Asian financial crisis toward the end of the 1990s, predominantly the examples and the literature, on which the arguments are developed, relate to western countries, especially the USA and the UK. There is in any case an argument that the growth and development of housing finance sectors as well as neoliberalism, both of which are key to the framework and rationale, have not been such characteristic features of the East Asian model of capitalism, and that the origins of the East Asian financial crisis in fact lay in too little neoliberalism, that is too much regulation. On those grounds, therefore the book might have concentrated on western countries and looked only to variations there.
The ‘too narrow’ position also reflects some comments made – though in just a few paragraphs – in the opening chapter, to the effect that the impacts of the ‘neoliberal turn that reshaped the financial and mortgage systems of many of the advanced core capitalist economies’ (p. 7) have been experienced in many countries, naming sub-Saharan Africa and Latin America. On those grounds, representative countries from those regions might also have been included.
But, the selection of countries apart, how effective are the chapters in exploring the key themes and particularly the impact on households? This is in fact uneven. All the chapters consider the development and nature of financial crises in their own country; individually, they provide useful understandings of the economic context of national housing markets. Some take the major part of their total word length doing so; however, for those on the UK, Hungary, Korea and Vietnam, for example, using only relatively small parts of their chapters examining impacts on households. To that extent, the investigation of ‘the usual victims’ is not pursued as systematically as suggested in the opening chapter.
Helpfully, Ray Forrest in an eight-page, final chapter brings aspects of the country chapters together. One of his conclusions, in line with the starting framework and its implied hypotheses, is that the housing consequences of the financial crisis have been greatest in those countries which have been most extensively financialised, and, further, that the main losers have typically been younger, more recent and highly leveraged buyers. His conclusion that the impacts do not map onto existing welfare taxonomies is perhaps less convincing, largely because the countries were not selected in a way that would adequately test such a proposition; there are no representatives of the Mediterranean countries and few in mainland Europe for example His speculation about what the crisis might mean for the future of home ownership sectors given that there is already evidence that the expansion of the last two or three decades, common across most countries, has in many gone into reverse is certainly important. Whatever the other challenges facing policy makers in those countries still reeling from the crisis, one concerns the future of housing tenure patterns.
