Samuel Johnson defined exercise in his 1755 Dictionary of the English Language as ‘Habitual action by which the body is formed to gracefulness, air, and agility.’Footnote 2 A century and a half later, Eugen Sandow explained his exercise regime to readers of Strength and How to Obtain It (1897) in rather dissimilar terms:
Exercise, indeed, without using the mind in conjunction with it, is of no use. It is the brain which develops the muscles. Physical exercise must be commenced by degrees first bringing into play one muscle, then two, then three, and so on, being careful all the time to put the mind into every movement. Let me strongly advise every student to study well the anatomical chart which is published with this book. By its aid you will be able not only to receive a useful lesson in anatomy, but you will be able to see at a glance the exercise which each muscle may be developed.Footnote 3
Exercise in these cases produced two strikingly different bodies: one created a body that was graceful, poised and agile, the other a body that was muscled, powerful and strong. Although Sandow noted the importance of brain and will power in developing a body, it was increased size that was the desired result. Indeed, Sandow included his own spectacular bodily measurements in the book, and offered prizes to readers for the greatest strength or the best development attained from using his physical culture regime, determined by before and after measurements of their biceps, triceps, thighs and chest.Footnote 4 This paper traces these ideal bodily styles for men, to argue that poise and power were two, not always oppositional, aspirational models of manly bodies across the two centuries, which could be used by men from different social classes to construct individual and collective identities.
To date, scholars have scrutinised male bodies in a number of ways. Those who investigate the culture of war show that the state and nation literally and figuratively shaped men's bodies. Military demands and techniques of war required certain types of manly form, shaped by uniform, training and drill.Footnote 5 Moreover, the idealised male body came to represent abstract notions such as the strength of nation and progress, and symbolised ideologies underpinning empire and various political movements.Footnote 6 In most cases, these were idealised, whole bodies. The damaged male body, however, has also been scrutinised. Historians of emotions, war, labour, health and safety and disability reveal the many ways in which fighting and working men were psychologically and physically damaged by their activities. All reveal the significance of bodies to masculine identity, since maimed or incapacitated men were unmanned in their own and society's eyes.Footnote 7 Histories of sex and reproduction also provide insights into changing medical understandings of bodies and the ways in which gender attitudes shaped them.Footnote 8 Scholars of the print culture of erotica and pornography, and work on same-sex desire, address the eroticised male body to reveal its cultural force.Footnote 9
Histories of consumption and material culture indicate that men's bodies were the site of debates about luxury and anxieties over effeminacy.Footnote 10 Similarly, historians of fashion and clothing explore the ways men dressed and fashioned their bodies and hair as external markers of sex, virility, maturity, civility and masculinity.Footnote 11 In the history of art and literature, men's bodies are discussed as part of varying aesthetics, genres and gender. Though these studies are predominantly representational, more recent scholarship on personal, class and racial identities exposes the ways working men used their bodies as a canvas. For example, by the early nineteenth century, nearly all seamen were tattooed to illustrate identity, travelling experiences, sense of belonging and also manliness, since it demonstrated their capacity to withstand pain.Footnote 12 Historians of sport expose the changing shape of men's bodies and expectations associated with them, as they chart the diets, training, ‘civilising’ and professionalisation of sports like boxing, rugby and cricket.Footnote 13
Given this apparent plenitude of scholarship on men's bodies, why do we still need to engage critically with male bodies and masculinity? It is necessary because there is a tendency to see some attributes of masculine identity as largely associated with abstract qualities rather than bodies, and with specific classes. Acknowledging that manliness could be defined as merging the ethical and the physical, Tosh argues that nineteenth-century writers nonetheless located it in the mind rather than the body. Thus, he observes that ‘the Victorian code of manliness made scant acknowledgement of the body’, for its predominantly elite cultural form gave it a ‘cerebral and bloodless quality’.Footnote 14 He suggests that it was not until the later nineteenth century that the manliness of muscular Christianity incorporated the hearty, sturdy, male body.Footnote 15 This was a style of masculinity that associated virtue and morality with a healthy body cultivated through sport and piety, which prevailed throughout the second half of the nineteenth century. Admittedly, manliness was an ideal and an aspiration, conveying prized values including virtue, piety, courage, endurance, honesty and directness. John Tosh has identified manliness as a ‘cultural representation of masculinity rather than a description of actual life’.Footnote 16 Yet, as the survey of studies of male bodies above shows, bodies symbolised abstract values and thus it is important to question how far manliness was primarily cultural rather than embodied.Footnote 17
Furthermore, this scholarship is scattered across diverse fields of history, making it difficult for the historian of masculinity to construct an overarching chronology of embodied manly identities. Moreover, discussions of the gendered body in this corpus of work are only one element of a wider investigation. Historians of art, for example, focus on the male form in several types of art, but are predominantly interested in genre conventions, the origins of the iconography utilised and the ways in which the visual product was interpreted, rather than its role in shaping masculinities.Footnote 18 Other scholars treat men's bodies as idealised, aesthetic forms or positive stereotypes and symbols of normative meaning and values. Where this scholarship engages with or contributes to the embodied turn in history, it is driven by other agendas.Footnote 19 Michael Budd's ground-breaking work on physical culture c. 1850–1918 is an early example of this field, but is predominantly concerned with a Foucauldian body politics, and the ways in which nations control, shape and oppress human bodies.Footnote 20 This is crucial, but there is more to be said about the formulation of gender identities.
Alternatively, scholars see some men as bearers of stigmatised inadequate bodies that mark them as ethnic, racial, sexual or class outsiders. For example, working-class men's bodies are treated collectively, for the most part, as passive objects of surveillance by authorities and discipline in work and institutions from schools, to prisons, to insane asylums.Footnote 21 They identify the utility of manhood, which led to attempts to control men through manipulating their health, physical shape and fitness.Footnote 22 As Matthew McCormack observes, for example, eighteenth-century militia authorities deliberately attempted to improve the militia's ‘physical stock’, categorising recruits on their physical appearance, health and wholeness of bodies.Footnote 23 By the twentieth century, as Joanna Bourke argues, men's bodies were the objects of state and employers' surveillance to keep them useful and functional.Footnote 24 This raises questions about the scrutinised men and how they saw their own body ‘type’ and the extent to which they were simply passive victims of corporeal politics.Footnote 25
Moreover, partly because of the fragmented nature of the work described, the vexed relationship between representation and experience remains unresolved. It is only recently that men's somatic experience is being examined. An embodied approach potentially offers a better understanding of individual men's personal experience of their bodies and health, since, as Karen Harvey argues, the body is ‘an instrument that performs socially or culturally constructed sexed or gendered identities’.Footnote 26 Gender is not only performed, it is inhabited through one's body. As such, scholars are increasingly endeavouring to achieve a more corporeal understanding of experience. Thus, Harvey aims to ‘study the lived, embodied experience of gender’.Footnote 27 Elsewhere, she advocates drawing on one's ‘own material experiences’, combined with documentary evidence, to investigate the physical experience of labour skills in the past.Footnote 28 These are noble aspirations, but problematic. How can the historian divest herself of her own somatic sense, her own social and cultural context, to imagine herself into an actor's very different body and mentality? This paper therefore focuses instead on representations of gendered male bodies, gathered from analysis of the term ‘manly’ and ‘manliness’ across a range of publications and visual genres. It aims to assess their impact upon individual and collective masculine identities, in order to offers insights into change over time for historians of masculinities.
This paper deliberately spans conventionally discrete periods in its survey of ideals of manly bodies. Most work, for example, considers either the age of the man of feeling and Christian sensibility from the 1750s to the 1830s or the age of muscular Christianity from the 1840s to the end of the century. This broad chronology also bridges other ways of categorising bodily eras, such as Michael Budd's divisions between the ‘epoch of the glorified body’ (early modern period to the end of the eighteenth century), and the epoch of ‘the age of the sculpture machine’ (1820s to 1930s).Footnote 29 Instead, this survey of bodily ideals suggests that a range of male body styles have coexisted, which varied between poise and power, often influenced by classical statuary, either of which could be acceptable, depending upon context and prevailing fashions. Secondly, it considers the issue of social classes, since research, whether addressing art, or labour, rarely studies both elite and working-class male bodies, to show that the two shared some features and were constitutive of each other.
A chronology of eighteenth- and nineteenth-century manly bodies
One could infer from scholarship on muscular Christianity that the focus on the male body in the post-Crimean War period was new, the result of militarising and imperialising forces and ‘new athleticism’.Footnote 30 In fact, men's bodies were just as central to formulations of masculinity in the previous century, although the idealised male form and related masculine values were mutable. Changing practices in war, empire and labour, understandings of science, sports and aesthetic fashions all influenced the relationship between physiques, minds and gender identities.Footnote 31
Despite considerable diversity, the classical body influenced by Greek antique sculptures was at the core of all formulations of male physical beauty and health.Footnote 32 Two classical male body-types were especially potent models: the young, slim athleticism of the Ephebes, and the mature, hefty, heroic Herculean form.Footnote 33 These images of poise and power were influential throughout the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries and were widely held aesthetic concepts across Europe, since as Michael Hau observes, classicism promoted transnational aesthetic considerations among artists and cultural elites.Footnote 34 Martin Myrone's study of masculinities in British art, for example, suggests that Georgian ideals of manly beauty focused upon the less brawny Greek model. Citing a series of history paintings of Virgil's hero Aeneas by Nathaniel Dance, 1766, he comments that unlike the ‘brute’ Achilles, who killed Hector, and is depicted as a physically massive Herculean, Aeneas bore a form that ‘could be recommended for his genteel accomplishments, sheer physical beauty and his dutiful patriotism, which fitted with a moderate image of masculinity in civil society’.Footnote 35 The poised bodily form was associated with manners. David Hume, for instance, observed that readers were on the side of Trojans ‘now’, rather than Greeks, and were much more interested in the ‘humane and soft manners of Priam, Hector, Andromache, Sarpedon, Aeneas, Glaucus, nay, even of Paris and Helen, than for the severe and cruel bravery of Achilles, Agamemnon, and the other Grecian heroes’.Footnote 36 By the second half of the nineteenth century, power prevailed as the Herculean body-type came to symbolise muscular Christianity.Footnote 37 Nonetheless, by the early twentieth century, the two ideal Greek male body-types were increasingly linked with specialised forms of physical fitness and sports.Footnote 38
In the eighteenth century, manners, feelings and utility dictated men's ideal physiques and associated styles of bodily deportment and ideals. These were influenced by polite sociability, the cult of sensibility and eighteenth-century military techniques. All required a male body that was graceful, slim and able to move in dance-like forms. This dexterous idealised man fitted a commercial, colonial society whose interests were protected by an army trained in linear tactics.Footnote 39 Thus, the Georgian manly body was graceful and strong, but not burly. In 1804, The Lady's Magazine explained that sixteen-year-old Selina was wooed by Edward whose ‘form wore every manly grace; his manners were soft, persuasive, elegant’.Footnote 40 This manly body was well proportioned and composed of ‘manly’ ‘parts’, which like musical notes, formed a satisfactory whole.Footnote 41
Poise and grace were not coded as feminine, although men needed to be cautious that softness of manner did not become softness of body. In 1783, a newspaper defined effeminacy in men as ‘the absence or debilitation of masculine strength and vigour, or the happy metamorphosis of the gentleman turned lady; that is, female softness in the male discovered by outward signs and tokens, in feminine expressions, accent, voice, gesture, dress, and deportment’.Footnote 42 Grace and refinement had to be combined with strength and dexterity. Indeed, David Hume described a man as having ‘beauty and vigour’ because he possessed ‘dexterity in every manly exercise. . .farther adorned with a blooming and ruddy countenance, with a lively air, with the appearance of spirit, and activity in all his demeanour’.Footnote 43
Physical exercise produced this nimble manly body through exertion or recreation. This included walking, riding and dancing, rather than a specific organised game.Footnote 44 In 1750, the Youth's General Instructor recommended
Dancing. . .which gives a graceful motion, and above all things, Manliness, and a becoming confidence to young children, I think it cannot be learned too early, after they are once of an age and strength capable of it. But you must be sure to have a good master, that knows and can teach, what is graceful and becoming, and what gives a Freedom and Easiness to all the motions of the body.Footnote 45
Physical exertions were important to masculinity for two reasons. First, they trained men to be skilful and light on their feet. Secondly, outdoor activities hardened the body which would lead to manliness since physical hardiness was equated with male virtue. In his Code of Health and Longevity, published in 1807, John Sinclair observed that air was essential to athletic exercises since the more men ‘are in the air, the firmer their flesh becomes’.Footnote 46 This was also classically inspired, for example, Samuel Johnson's definition of manly included Juvenal's mens sana in corpore sano (via Dryden), meaning a ‘sound mind in a sound body’.Footnote 47
The idealised manly body was in transition from the 1790s into the first half of the nineteenth century becoming solid, broader, rugged and perhaps less elegant. There were numerous causes of this shift. The resurgence of classical ideals in neoclassicism influenced clothing fashions, which evoked nude sculpture, and ideal bodily types.Footnote 48 This was a more outdoors, less ‘feeling’ version of the idealised manly body. A ‘young man's’ letter to the Lady's Monthly Museum, 1801, criticising men of fashion, hints at this:
I have not scrupled to wear brown paint, like other gentlemen, to increase the manliness of my appearance; nor to gape and stare at the women; nor to walk past them without deigning to look at them; nor to assume pride and reserve, or apathy, or rudeness, as suited the caprice of fashion: yes, Sir, all this I have done, but in vain. I never can be a man of fashion, because unfortunately, I am not devoid of feeling.Footnote 49
The brown paint was make-up aimed at making men look more tanned and physically active.
A combination of expanding print culture, industrialisation and consumption, along with the perception of national crisis during the Revolutionary and Napoleonic Wars, also influenced these ideas about the male body. Indeed, the slender, sensible manly form was viewed as less suitable to sustain and defend a nation. For example, thinness was increasingly associated with poverty and the French enemy. Problematically, while the portly English body of John Bull – the ‘common man’ – was emblematic of loyalist visions of manliness, he was hardly a fighter.Footnote 50 Perhaps unsurprisingly celebrated military and naval men were often depicted as large and/or robust and therefore appealing. Corporal John Shaw, a boxer and life-guardsman was feted for his bravery and sacrificing his life at Waterloo, stood over six feet tall, was admired for his size and was nicknamed by his neighbours as the ‘Cossall giant’.Footnote 51 Size became a corporeal vehicle through which masculine values were demonstrated.Footnote 52 In 1791, it was recorded: ‘Before I had learned from the note the name and business of my Visitor, I was struck with the manliness of his person, the breadth of his chest, the openness of his countenance, and the inquietude of his eye.’Footnote 53 Similarly, an ‘upright’ posture conveyed both the sense of an ideal body and high moral behaviours. For instance, the periodical John Bull, 1822, paid a tribute to a London lord mayor and member of parliament, praising his ‘manly and upright conduct’.Footnote 54
From the mid-nineteenth century, the ideal male body was increasingly large, robust and overtly muscular with bulk, sturdiness and stolidity offering bodily signs of fortitude. Physical power was the key to manliness. In 1847, Bell's Life commented approvingly on a cricketer of the newly formed I Zingari cricket club: ‘he fought to win every inch of ground with mighty manliness’.Footnote 55 In 1896, a Macbeth actor was described as possessing ‘rugged manliness’.Footnote 56 These mighty manly bodies were less likely to be smooth like their predecessors; indeed, they were regularly described as rough, and faces were bearded. Those extremely corporeal adjectives – plucky and hearty – emerged to personify the manly body. Moreover, since the body was also understood to be related to the mind, it was assumed that strengthening the male body would strengthen the will and character.Footnote 57
Motion and posture were again critical, but significantly different from grace and nimbleness. The manly movement was powerful and brisk. In 1889, The Fishing Gazette declared that Norman Fraser of Kildonan, a ‘household word throughout the whole of Sutherlandshire’ was a ‘brisk and manly Highlander’.Footnote 58 Such an upright, straight posture was partly influenced by a military carriage and ‘New Athleticism’. An advert in 1888 in The Sporting Times announced ‘the Grandest Show of Manly Sports ever presented to the public’ at Her Majesty's Theatre, Haymarket.Footnote 59 In the ‘cult of sporting manliness’, organised sports and games were judged especially likely to produce manliness.Footnote 60 They displayed masculinity through physical prowess and skill, manly values through team spirit, and drew links between physical strength, health and moral wellbeing.Footnote 61 The classically inspired physique also dominated the physical culture movement. Eugen Sandow, for instance, emulated classical statues in building his own musculature, and posed as a ‘living’ classical figure for artists and on stage.Footnote 62
Again, nation and empire were critical to these developments.Footnote 63 Plucky, hearty male bodies supported an industrialised, imperialised and, increasingly, militarised Britain where new weaponry led to skirmish and light infantry battle techniques.Footnote 64 The muscular classical body in an age of empire was deployed to construct hierarchies of race and tied to concerns of imperial power.Footnote 65 It was also related to changing economic conditions when new technology and mechanisation, and the rise of sedentary jobs such as salaried office workers, clerks and deskilled manual labour appeared to challenge men's ‘physical significance’. All were potentially emasculating and thus physical, rough, tough muscularity outside the workplace was reemphasised.Footnote 66
The class dimensions of manly bodies and masculinity
The idealised bodies outlined above were elite: primarily aimed at and understood by educated genteel society. Indeed, the pervasive ideal of muscular Christianity is often envisaged as a middle-class creation, that middle-class and gentry boys engaged with through their public school education, and which was imposed upon lower-ranking men as a way to reform them and society. Thus, the corporeality of Victorian working-class men appears most frequently in scholarship that considers endeavours to ‘remake’ lower-class men by improving their bodies. The combination of social Darwinism and urban industrialisation led to fears that working-class men were physically deficient, which reached crisis point in England during the South African wars. In his 1905 ‘Introductory Address on Efficiency’ to Charing Cross Hospital, the celebrated Scottish alienist Sir James Crichton-Browne's included a section on ‘The National Physique’ in which he bemoaned that ‘We have on our hands hordes of under-grown, under-fed, blemished, diseased, debilitated men, women, and children. . .who are industrially and socially in-efficient.’Footnote 67 Such concern was widespread and prompted institutionalised attempts to salvage the ‘degenerate’ body of the British working man through the Interdepartmental Committee on Physical Deterioration and in the form of boys’ and men's fraternal organisations and school physical education.Footnote 68
The same imperative contributed to new leisure and recreation initiatives aimed directly at the working class.Footnote 69 In 1868, the ‘respectable’ magazine aimed at working-class boys, Boys of England: A Young Gentleman's Journal of Sport, Travel, Fun and Instruction, warned:
Boys of England, in these days of cheap education, cheap standard literature, or cadet volunteer corps, cricket-clubs, and gymnasia; in these days when, even with unaided self-help and perseverance, you may achieve such wonders, it is your own fault if you do not grow up wise and strong men. Scorn aping manliness of mind and body; learn to think, speak, and write, learn to swim, jump, and run, despise skulking laziness, and face hard study and hard hand-labour.Footnote 70
In these accounts, the only agency the working-class man had over his body was to follow instructions. Undoubtedly, the needs of the state and nation were prominent in dictating the idealised male body, and in the deployment of the real male body. Nevertheless, there is evidence that the appeal of the muscular labouring male body could both inspire elite men and offer agency to working men.
The male labouring body was, after all, celebrated in visual, textual and material form, particularly in the imagined forms of the soldier, the sailor, the boxer and the entrepreneurial strongman.Footnote 71 These working men's bodies had a broad dissemination, commercialised in decorative, domestic objects intended to be collected and displayed in the home, such as ceramic vessels and plates, and pottery portrait figures, featuring boxers, as well as soldiers and sailors.Footnote 72 By the later nineteenth century, such working men were also deployed in advertising to sell products.Footnote 73 In examples from the early eighteenth century, the fine body of the labourer was based on classical statuary. This was intended to allude to the natural health and beauty of working men and thereby criticise the more effete, enervated effeminate bodies of those wealthy enough to participate in luxury and consume this art.Footnote 74 Joseph Wright of Derby's nocturnal paintings of blacksmiths, for example, include The Blacksmith's Shop 1771, in which three fine-figured men labour at the anvil.Footnote 75 Perhaps even more overtly indicative of the hearty beauty of male physical labour is the iron founder in Wright's An Iron Forge, 1772.Footnote 76 Overseeing the power-driven tilt hammer, he stands with his powerful arms crossed over his chest. Not only is he literally a glowing example of male strength, he is also surrounded by his family, indicating his virility and domesticity. As Matthew Craske observes, in these paintings Wright produced the opposite of the grand style of history painting, where the blacksmith stood as the lusty everyman essential to the village, and presumably natural society.Footnote 77
By the 1840s, the male labouring body was formulated as heroic. Thomas Carlyle, for instance, elevated work to a religion in his chapter in ‘Labour’, in Past and Present (1843). In his view, work made the man, and in so doing saved the individual and national body and soul. He observed:
Consider how, even in the meanest sorts of Labour, the whole soul of a man is composed into a kind of real harmony, the instant he sets himself to work! Doubt, Desire, Sorrow, Remorse, Indignation, Despair itself, all these like hell-dogs lie beleaguering the soul of the poor dayworker, as of every man: but he bends himself with free valour against his task, and all these are stilled, all these shrink murmuring far off into their caves. The man is now a man. The blessed glow of Labour in him, is it not as purifying fire wherein all poison is burnt up, and of sour smoke itself there is made bright blessed flame!Footnote 78
The elevation of the working man to heroic status was widespread in British art and literature in the second half of the nineteenth century. Tim Barringer's ‘critical iconography of the working man’ suggests that representations of the male labouring body acted as ‘the nexus of ethical and aesthetic value’.Footnote 79 The two best-known visual examples of the heroic working man are found in George Hicks's The Sinews of Old England, 1857, and Ford Madox Brown's Work. Hicks's Sinews of Old England is a particularly appealing example of the genre of the labouring man at his cottage door. The title refers to the phrase ‘the sinews and power of old England’, which was used to describe the navy.Footnote 80 No doubt this drew connections in viewers’ minds with the heroic ‘everyman’, Jack Tar, whose robust, stout, hard body offered another appealing model of working manhood.Footnote 81 The other archetypal depiction of heroic manual labour is Ford Madox Brown's richly iconographic painting Work, influenced by Ruskin and Carlyle and so closely linked to Carlyle's views on work that it portrays him as an observer.Footnote 82 Work is glorified in the navvies’ bodies. In a sonnet that he wrote to accompany the painting, Brown eulogised (Feb. 1865) work as beading the brow and tanning ‘the flesh of lusty manhood’, thereby ‘casting out its devils!’Footnote 83 Brown, a radical and socialist, used the central heroic navvy's body whose pose he based on the Apollo Belvedere, to convey the worth of the lower classes over poorer-quality men who did not labour so nobly.Footnote 84 Brown described the Apollo-like navvy as being in the ‘pride of manly health and beauty’, and of course in this combination his figure merged both poise and power.Footnote 85
Such images can be read in several ways in the light of what has been discussed so far. Manly labouring bodies served as moral exemplars for society. In 1770, Arthur Young complained:
It is not the deficiency of labouring hands, but the progress of sloth and indolence which ought to alarm our fears: it is this which induces the idle part of our people to prefer the less toilsome, but more precarious works of the manufacture to the rough, but more manly exercises of the husbandman.
Here, the labouring rural manly body was the antithesis of an unmanly idleness, that bugbear of social and moral commentators because it damaged productivity.Footnote 86 Those like Hicks's domesticated labourer can be seen as moralistic in intention, reinforcing the gendered spheres of home with the man active in the public sphere and his adoring wife waiting in the domestic sphere.Footnote 87 Like other similar images, it sentimentalised men's hard labour, in the process making industrious working-class men less threatening to higher-ranking people by valorising their work ethic for their families.Footnote 88 Moreover, as with the Jack Tar, this image of the labouring man at the heart of his family embodied the strength of the nation through the motif of familial affection that saturates the painting. Working men's bodies in genre pictures were also didactic in that they were intended to promote manly ideals to their social superiors. For instance, Millais's The Rescue painted in 1855 offers a working-class muscular hero: a fearless fireman rescuing two children from a burning house. The Athenaeum reviewer of the painting declared the fireman to be ‘thoroughly English, cool, determined, and self-reliant. . .resolute, manly, strong as iron, like one accustomed to pass through fire’.Footnote 89
Scholars of labour and art argue that such heroic depictions of male labouring bodies subordinated and objectified men.Footnote 90 This firm-jawed fireman not only reinforced patriarchal hierarchies of men and women, he reinforced those between men, by offering an archetype of tough male body which sedentary men were unlikely to reach. Furthermore, Ava Baron characterises working-class men in these images as passive, because, like women, they became the subject of the gaze; their muscular bodies eroticised and therefore pacified.Footnote 91 Though handsome, heroic and idealised, Ravenhill-Johnson claims, they ‘are still “the other”, not of the same class as the purchaser of fine art; their depiction acts as reassurance that workers are sober, industrious and, above all, nonthreatening’.Footnote 92
Yet working bodies need not be read only in terms of condescension, passivity and subordination. These representations were multi-purpose and working-class men's bodies had dynamic cultural power which spanned social classes. Elite men, for example, were inspired by the idealised hardened working male body. Hardening was a feature derived from plebeian working men. Stuart Hogarth explains that plebeian men needed wiry, tough, enduring bodies in order to carry out their manual labour. As such, their paid physical labour not only shaped and made demands upon their bodies, it was intrinsic to the formation of their gender and class identities.Footnote 93 Men originally of lower social status, writing in the early nineteenth century, referred in their memoirs to a similar notion of body ‘hardening’. Thomas Bewick described compensating for his sedentary life as an engraver during his apprenticeship, and the resulting ill-health it caused, by following medical advice to restrict his diet and train his body through walking to harden it into a manlier form.Footnote 94 Francis Place used cold-water therapy to harden his body against illness.Footnote 95 Studies of twentieth-century mining, steel working and ship building demonstrate that male workers continued to define their masculine identity through a cult of toughness at work, as well as the ability to take and ignore risks.Footnote 96
Elite men emulated the hardened bodies of plebeian men from the early nineteenth century. Admittedly, this was probably derived from representations of labouring men's bodies rather than reality, since, as Pamela Gilbert observes, this was compromised by the fact that labourers’ bodies were formed by hard labour and rarely produced a body conforming to classical ideals.Footnote 97 Still, as Barringer argues, visual images formed styles of masculinity as well as articulating them.Footnote 98 Examples include elite men who emulated the idealised form of boxers. From the later eighteenth century, competitive boxing defined new sought-after models of male stance, use of the body, appearance and body shape. Karen Downing notes the appeal of the ‘gentleman’ boxer's body, which was ‘able to simultaneously convey strength, refinement, and self-control’.Footnote 99 Popular portraits of boxers displayed both male poise and power; as Harvey points out, fighters were posed naked from the waist upwards, but wore trim breeches: a melding of politeness and strength.Footnote 100 The boxer's appeal was commercialised in various ways. Boxers marketed their diet and training regimes to elite men, intended to produce this muscular, but elegant physique. Most famously, George Gordon Byron used a boxing regime to lose weight and improve his body. He even materialised his love of boxing in a dressing screen upon which he collaged coloured pictures of prize-fighters and reports of boxing matches.Footnote 101
Wealthy men also adopted plebeian styles of dress from the later eighteenth century, wearing modest and plain clothing which eventually came to be seen as a distinctively English style. The shift from breeches to trousers in men's legwear in the nineteenth century was particularly influenced by working men's trousers.Footnote 102 As John Styles observes, men who chose to dress down ‘were sharing in a powerful trend towards the rural, the sporting and the plebeian’. In an era of national crisis, this trend personified patriotism through the association with pugnacious plebeian masculinity and English liberty.Footnote 103 From the mid-nineteenth century, a generation of more sedentary middle-class men romanticised, and yearned to possess themselves, the bodily markers of the heroic working body. Of course, there were considerable differences between the social classes’ adoption of sportsmen's training regimes, body hardening and simpler dress. Stuart Hogarth explains that hardening was a necessity for the labouring classes, but the middle-class men who adopted it when formulating gendered identities did so as ‘a reaction against rich living’, both in terms of self-indulgence and mental strain.Footnote 104 Thus, by the later nineteenth century, as Gilbert proposes, the muscular Christian's ‘body was based less on class than on other attributes seen as quintessentially British, and it insisted on a body toughened either by physical labour or physical sport’.Footnote 105
Working men's muscular arms
Tim Barringer describes Brown's Work as composed around the three navvies, ‘who catch the full force of the July sun that reflects harshly from their bared forearms’.Footnote 106 Indeed, perhaps the most potent symbol of working men's labour was the muscular forearm. It was central to the depictions of industrial workers from Joseph Wright's iron-forge workers, to Hicks's agricultural worker, to Brown's Apollo-like navvy. Karen Harvey has focused upon the eighteenth-century elite male clothed leg as a marker of masculinity, conveying meanings of male power, strength, beauty and virility.Footnote 107 This article concludes by arguing that the labourer's forearm was equally powerful in cultural meaning, and was extensively deployed by a range of social classes. The raised muscular male arm, with rolled-up sleeve, holding a working tool was originally the sign of the blacksmith; a single raised muscular arm bearing a hammer was used in trade guilds’ heraldry.Footnote 108 By the early nineteenth century, it became a common icon of skilled labour, adopted for use on friendly societies’ and trades unions’ ephemera and banners to symbolise pride in labour.Footnote 109 Arguably, it only became a more threatening image of class militancy by the twentieth century.Footnote 110
Initially, strong and muscular arms signified generic masculinity, not class- or occupational-specific manhood. An early seventeenth-century poem A Maid's Revenge by James Shirley, for instance, reprinted in 1793, has the count de Monte Nigro (who was described as a braggard) ask: ‘Wherefore has | Nature given me these brawny arms, this manly bulk, | And these collossian supporters nothing but to sling | The sledge, or pitch the bar, and play.’Footnote 111 It was never merely a marker of muscular male strength. The muscular male arm connoted both the capacity to smite and protect. This is demonstrated by a sermon preached following the 1755 Lisbon earthquake, which pronounced that ‘He hath a Mighty Arm; strong is his Hand; and high is his right Hand.’Footnote 112 It was this mighty arm to which one supplicated, as when Roxana in ‘The Rival Queens’ pleaded to heaven following her broken heart and rising passions: ‘What saving hand, or what a mighty arm | Can raise me sinking?’Footnote 113 The notion of the protective male arm was also deeply reassuring. Elizabeth Lichtenstein Johnson, for example, recorded her thirteen-year-old daughter's verses that she had written when fearful during a tumultuous sea passage in 1801:
From political to popular culture, the nation offered its symbolic muscular arm to defend its subjects. Thomas Quayle, for example, declared that Jersey enjoyed a ‘beneficent government; protecting them with a mighty arm, from the ravage, and the insult of the surrounding foe’ in his review of agriculture in 1815.Footnote 115 Thus, archetypal men might stand in for and defend the nation through their mighty arms. For example, in the popular poem ‘The Sailor's Tear’, the sailor raises his arm in all three stanzas – in the first two to wipe away a tear as he leaves his loving family, but in the final verse his arm is raised to slay the enemy:
Of course, the viewer was also meant to admire the sinewy muscular forearms of Hicks's and Brown's working men, because they were symbolic of the manly sinews of patriotism and national strength, as well as the steely, hardened fortitude of skilled labour. Indeed, the workers’ powerful forearm became a marker of Britain's industrial power. Historians of art, and scholars of friendly societies and trades unions’ iconography, for example, suggest that the heroic style of representing the working man from the 1850s was part of a ‘new recognition of the times that the wealth of the nation rested on its industrial output, and the skills of its working men’.Footnote 117 The muscular arm, if first associated with particular trades according to which tools it held, became a political symbol of an entire working class late in the nineteenth century.Footnote 118
There were numerous tensions at the centre of this image of working men's strength and identity. Barringer points out that ‘Industrial work is portrayed as a celebration of the male body, well-nourished and in good health, rather than as a process that disfigures and ultimately destroys it.’Footnote 119 Yet, in some ways, this was recognised, and the concept of the heroic worker was used to ameliorate it. Jamie Bronstein shows how newspapers celebrated working-class men for performing acts of heroism following industrial disasters, casting their actions in terms of self-sacrifice and wartime heroism.Footnote 120 During the 1862 Harley Colliery disaster, the Newcastle Chronicle described resting rescuers: ‘While the ruddy glare of the fire was cast over their broad, manly features and well-moulded forms, they seemed to be the living embodiment of all those attributes of courage and strength which. . .[distinguish] the inhabitants of the British Isles.’Footnote 121 If this smacks of glossing over the exploited male labouring body, it is worth remembering that working-class men deployed the narrative themselves for their own ends.Footnote 122
As this hints, this imagined male body had collective social agency for working-class men too. There is evidence from the turn of the eighteenth century that members of the working classes deployed and politicised images such as the handsome, working man resting at his cottage door to demonstrate that labouring men had the independence and respectability to possess a political voice. As much as in his masculine status, this was measured through his manly, temperate body, and physical strength.Footnote 123 It was central to the attempts to improve working-class men's bodies through the means of self-help. As the literary scholar Michael Budd comments, the second half of the nineteenth century saw ‘the development of a new notion of the embodied self – one emphasizing the possibility of improving the body and character’. He points out that Samuel Smiles promoted this in his ‘self-help’ regime, which saw mutual connections between physical steadfastness, bodily health and self-reliance.Footnote 124 Whether this was a means of social control is open to debate, but working men certainly used these notions of bodily fitness as a way to improve social status. The physical culture regimens commercialised by ‘fitness entrepreneurs’ like Eugen Sandow to working-class men with disposable income also thus ‘offered lower-class men a body-centred form of self-discipline and respectability’.Footnote 125
Accordingly, there is substantial evidence that working men took up the visual iconography of muscular arms as part of their formulations of self- and class-identity. Harvey observes that industrialisation focused more attention on men as workers and upon their occupations, leading to an identification of working men as both producers and workers. She argues therefore that the iconography of men's tools on ceramic objects and in visual culture helped articulate a collective identity of craftsmen in the first part of the nineteenth century.Footnote 126 Muscular arms exposed by rolled-up sleeves ready for labour and grasping tools were the most potent symbol of approved ‘heroic’ men's labour. Alongside others such as the handshake, symbol of unity and concord, they became central to the iconography of working-class friendly societies, trades unions and political movements like Chartism.Footnote 127 Heroic, working men stood at the heart of their bannerettes, banners and certificates; large, noble and elevated, rolled up shirt sleeves showing muscular forearms to present physical strength and health, and occupational identity through the tools they hold.Footnote 128 The illustrations of emblems collected in Ravenhill-Johnson's study offers numerous pieces of evidence spanning the century from the 1820s to 1920s.Footnote 129 James Sharples's emblem of the Amalgamated Society of Engineers (1851) is an excellent example, featuring two dignified working men, a blacksmith and an engineer, posed in the heroic model of history painting; both have sleeves rolled up.Footnote 130
Crucially, these visual representations of working-class identity and objectives were designed and created by working-class people. The artists were working-class and shared similar artistic conventions of male physiques to their elite counterparts. Often trained in art schools, they too had begun training by copying from antique sculpture, and Old Masters; even lesser artists trained at night school would copy from art primers, pattern books and engravings.Footnote 131 The industrial blacksmith James Sharples, for instance, ‘appropriated the vocabulary of high art in order to fashion a corpus of visual self-representation’.Footnote 132 He also constructed his public persona in such terms. Samuel Smiles added him to the celebrated lives in the second edition of Self-Help, published in 1860. In addition, Smiles requested his photograph to add to his collection of notable self-made men. In the resulting studio portrait, Sharples posed as blacksmith not artist, sleeves rolled up to bare his working man's forearms, holding his hammer.Footnote 133 As Ravenhill-Johnson's study of the art and ideology of the trade union emblem demonstrates, their working-class commissioners and creators appropriated Greek and Roman culture to represent their union members.Footnote 134 Perhaps a particularly telling example is on the Certificate of the Friendly Society of Iron Founders of England, Ireland and Wales, 1857, by John James Chant. It shows a typical architectural cutaway with working scenes at the bottom, and two ennobled working men at the top, rolled-up sleeves, holding their tools of trade. However, at the centre is a miner hewing an enormous coal face. He is positively Herculean, bare-chested and heavily muscular.Footnote 135 Here were both the poised and powerful male bodies.
What is also striking about such emblems is that they were not restricted to banners which were publicly paraded, but were also part of the domestic environment Certificates and emblems were meant to be displayed at home. Others had particularly domestic uses and connotations. A touching example is the emblem of the Friendly Association of Cotton Spinners, a Glasgow society, formed in 1806, and printed on a japanned tin tray in c. 1825.Footnote 136 The image was a copy of the Association's bannerette. In front of the power spinning machine stands a male worker extending his hand to a female child worker; his sleeves are rolled up above his elbows, he is neatly attired in a waistcoat otherwise. This demonstrated his paternal benevolence and his respectable status as much as his trade, which is represented by the spinning machinery rather than a handheld tool. The Carlisle branch of the Glasgow Association used the same image in its banner, probably around a similar date. The domestic nature of the banner, however, is particularly vivid, since the banner takes the form of a patchwork quilt, with the emblem reproduced in embroidery on an apron at its centre, surrounded by pieced cotton patches. The apron was apparently worn by a local cotton spinner when celebrating the passing of the 1832 Reform Act in a procession through Carlisle.Footnote 137 This is a reminder of the ways in which working-class masculinities were formulated in the home as much as the workplace or leisure venue.
There is also evidence of the links between the earlier sturdy heroic labouring man and his later counterparts. J. Havelock Wilson, who founded the Sailors’ and Firemen's Union in 1887, recorded in his autobiography that union banners often portrayed national figures of importance to the working-class movement. He recalled frequently seeing his own portrait on the various banners of the seamen's union in all kinds of ‘picturesque positions’. One that he specially noted was his portrayal as the ‘“heroic sailor” Jack Crawford, the hero of the naval battle of Camperdown’. This Sunderland-born sailor became a northern hero thanks to his actions in 1797 in nailing the fleet's colours back onto the mast, and was portrayed on ceramics, and prints through the century.Footnote 138 This hints at a long lineage of working-class heroism, rooted in male bodily strength and evolving from a primarily gender to class identity.
Conclusion
Manliness was not cerebral and bloodless, but was carried within and conveyed through men's bodies whose parts, poise and power were encoded with gendered values and qualities. An embodied approach therefore opens up male corporeality to be read as a site for cultural meaning and social practice. This paper demonstrates that manly bodies were reified as symbols, progenitors and defenders of gender, society and nation. These bodies therefore needed to be manipulated and made-over to improve men and their masculine qualities at an individual and collective level and across social classes. Influenced in form by classical aesthetics, depictions of men's bodily styles spanned a spectrum of poise and power, deployed in either or both forms to embody cultural, social, political, economic and military success. Initially, this was a set of codes originating within and circulated among elite groups. However, men who did not use their bodies to earn a living came to emulate the appearance and exercise regimes of muscular men's bodies trained through sport or work. Moreover, the allure of poised and powerful male bodies extended beyond the upper ranks. From the later eighteenth century, working-class men also adapted bodily symbols of muscularity, strength and skill to construct their own masculine, occupational and class identities.
