Family Policy in Transition is an impressive first book by Dorian R. Woods who is a lecturer in political science at the University of Tübingen. Rather than focus on Germany, where she has done extensive work on family policy, Woods uses this comparative study to examine four key family policy programs in two liberal regimes, the United Kingdom and the United States. In a fine-grained analysis of policies developed over the past thirty years, she shows the similarities and differences in British and US treatment of welfare reform, tax credits, childcare and family leave. Her study is beautifully anchored in major modern works on social policy. Her use of the comparative method is very effective. She manages to capture and document each case study at a remarkable level of pertinent detail. All these strengths result in less emphasis on the various ways in which economic and demographic challenges interact with ideology and political institutions.
To appreciate what Woods has accomplished, her book should be placed against the background of other work in family policy that has accumulated over the past three decades. She begins with Esping-Andersen's (Reference Esping-Andersen1990) typology of liberal (Anglo-Saxon), conservative (continental), and social democratic (Scandinavian) regimes to account for major national differences in the way family policy develops. Woods uses this framework to good advantage by carefully limiting her study to the two comparable liberal regimes that are both relatively limited in their public support of social programs when compared to the continental or Scandinavian models. Guided by the comparative method of Charles Ragin (Reference Ragin1987), Woods also compares four major social programs that are analogous across national boundaries. Even among a lay audience who are unfamiliar with the concept of family policy, these programs can easily be understood as contributing to family well-being. Moreover, such programs are the frequent focus of scholarly attention both in Great Britain (Lewis, Reference Lewis2006; Rapoport, Reference Rapoport2002; Sainsbury, Reference Sainsbury1999) and in the United States (Lotte et al., Reference Lotte, Bookman, Harrington, Kochan, Pitt-Catsouphes, Kossek and Sweet2006; Ellwood, Reference Ellwood1988; Gornick and Meyers, Reference Gornick and Meyers2003; Kamerman and Kahn, Reference Kamerman and Kahn1978).
Woods is especially good at applying the ‘method of difference’ as originally put forward by John Stuart Mill. The choice of case studies must be structured so that they are similar with respect to known explanatory factors (e.g., both countries are ‘liberal’ regimes). Also the policy domains that are being compared must be similar (e.g., social assistance, tax credits, childcare and family leave). When the ideologically similar countries are compared on how these programs develop, the ‘method of difference’ helps to explain why welfare reform, under both Blair and Clinton, emphasised self-reliance and self-help. By encouraging single mothers to work instead of stay at home, both countries were implementing their values of independence and self-sufficiency. Yet national differences are also evident, for example in childcare programs. American childcare is more privatised and limited in its availability, whereas public support of British childcare is more generous and has gained much wider acceptance as a way to free parents to do paid work. Woods’ explanation points to the greater ability of New Labour to open the discussion to wide public participation by labour unions and child education experts so that the government could proceed with an expanded agenda. In the United States, by contrast, the Republican takeover of Congress in 1994 derailed the Democrats’ broader plan to link childcare and work support. National differences in use of power and political institutions thus produced differences in childcare policies and programs.
Family Policy in Transition carefully limits the research project to two comparable countries and four types of public policy that affect families. But limiting the time period under study to the past three decades provides only limited space for consideration of the different national histories that produced the New Deal and the Beveridge report and that probably continue to exert an influence on the breadth of coverage. These two revolutionary periods created a somewhat different legacy for each country. Woods concedes that race is an important fault line in the US whereas it is class in the UK. But the differences go even deeper to the Great Depression that precipitated the American New Deal and the British experience of national destruction and widespread privation during World War II that brought Labour to power. The Great Depression in America with one-third of the nation ‘ill-housed, ill-clothed, and ill-fed’ produced a drive to help the poor and the unemployed but it could be slowed by economic recovery so that a sense of public obligation to provide assistance for a long time did not extend beyond poor children, the old and the disabled. The ravages of war subjected Great Britain to a much broader levelling experience – bombing that destroyed homes and lives irrespective of age, class or socio-economic status. This experience produced a turn toward early nationalisation of health care and broadening of other social programs that were never paralleled in the United States. These very different economic and national emergencies operated selectively to reinforce somewhat different values and political structures. This new book puts a much-needed emphasis on the importance of values and ideas in the shaping of family policy. A next step is to expand the theory of family policy as part of an interactive system within each nation where ideas and material challenges mutually affect each other. Values and ideas at times appear to determine the course of action, but at other times they are an adaptive response to threats against the well-being of family and nation. In the United States, family policy is just beginning to be understood as necessary to the country's economic and demographic well-being and to its place in the world (Giele, Reference Giele2012).
Dorian Woods has made a careful and authoritative entry into the family policy field. If she can extend her reach beyond recent decades and include other social programs such as healthcare, education, housing, and immigration policy, she will do a great service to the family policy field. An expanded comparison of the United States and the United Kingdom in these other domains is well worth doing.
