When Schumann announced the arrival of the young genius composer Brahms in his famous journal article ‘Neue Bahnen’ in 1853, the response was wide-ranging. ‘New paths! Intricate, complex demon for every artist who surrenders himself to it! Never has any artist actually stepped on a new path. In the best case he would pick up where his most recent predecessors had left off.’Footnote 1 Felix Mendelssohn's words, recorded in 1847 and published posthumously in 1853, address the difficulty of Schumann's grand promise. Above all, it raised the expectations that Brahms was facing even before having produced a single major work. Not only the burden of these expectations, but also Schumann's dramatic suicide attempt and Brahms's bonds to Agathe von Siebold contributed to his withdrawal from the public,Footnote 2 and to his withdrawal, after some failed first attempts, from tradition-laden genres such as the string quartet.Footnote 3 During the years preceding his first sextet, especially between 1855 and 1859, Brahms undertook ‘intense self-scrutiny and musical study’.Footnote 4 His opposition to Liszt and the Neudeutsche Schule became more and more pronounced, and at the same time, he found support and friendship among the likeminded members of Schumann's circle, such as Joseph Joachim, Clara Schumann, and Julius Grimm, among others.Footnote 5
The first sextet, op. 18, is among the group of works produced after the gap of silence between 1855 and 1859, together with the two serenades op. 11 and op. 16 (all finished between 1858 and 1860). Though garnering curiosity, this string of works also elicited some scepticism. In their reviews, the critics of the Allgemeine musikalische Zeitung (AmZ) tirelessly sought to advocate Brahms as Beethoven-epigone or as a new successor of Schumann; as a result, their criticism focused on his originality, compositional technique and aesthetics.Footnote 6
Recognizing op. 18 as Brahms's most important chamber work to date, critics lauded the diversity of sounds (‘Klangbilder’) produced by way of ‘new combinations’, in particular the composer's use of the lower registers.Footnote 7 These ‘new combinations’ highlight the viola and cello as leading thematic carriers. More specifically, the ‘baritone-like singing of the cellos’ was praised, as was the lyrical treatment of the viola, which ‘reveals Brahms's secrets of the heart’.Footnote 8 Critics also positively received the serenity of the first movement, its rich thematicism and expression, which follow ‘out of inner necessity’.Footnote 9 However, they cavilled about the ‘cliffs of the development’, and, referring to the development, Brahms's ‘crossing the border of the beautiful’.Footnote 10 Furthermore, critics lamented that the overall arch of the piece lacked intensity. The last movement's deficiency of creativity and lavishness was highlighted as a perceived failure to round off the piece with an appropriate climax.Footnote 11
If Brahms's op. 18 signals his break-through in chamber music, his op. 36 reveals a mature work whose overall expression is more organic. AmZ critic Hermann Deiters, comparing op. 36 to op. 18, asserted: ‘With this work [op. 36] we evidently see a climax of Brahms's development up to this point; from a gradually growing insecurity, discontent, agitation or however one may call it, Brahms arrives at an expression of desperate tempestuousness; and one may say that this expression has developed naturally and organically.’Footnote 12 The melodic content of this sextet is less engaging and singable, and its expression less mellow and more gripping than in the B-flat major sextet. The organic development of its emotions, as expressed by Deiters, shows a mature composer who has overcome the initial phase of searching and experimentation.
Joseph Joachim and his colleagues played Brahms's first sextet in numerous performances (of which four were reviewed between 1860 and 1876); however, the second sextet, in G major, was performed less often, perhaps because of its technical difficulties, which explains why it was less frequently represented at Hausmusiken or embraced by amateurs.Footnote 13
The new Bärenreiter Urtext publication, edited by Christopher Hogwood, offers the first scholarly-critical edition of Brahms's two sextets. In the preface, Hogwood quotes Margit McCorkle as he states the objectives for this edition: to ‘identify, collate, and restore the original states of the compositions and to gain keener perception of the compositional process’.Footnote 14 Hogwood provides detailed information about the compositional process, publication history, performances, reception, publication, arrangements, sources and editorial principles as well as performance practice issues.Footnote 15 Of these aspects, the section on the compositional process is most revealing, because it informs the reader about early performing materials, manuscripts, parts, and other related sources that contain alternative readings from both before and after publication. The modern editing practice of using the score (autograph or printed) for making a new edition would have failed to show the important details of Brahms's compositional process, which, however, can be recovered to some extent from the working parts. These are the parts from which Joachim and his chamber group presumably performed, with Brahms in attendance. Although Brahms transferred some of these changes into his autograph manuscript, many did not find their way into the printed score.
In the case of op. 18, two major structural changes throw light on the compositional process.Footnote 16 As the parts reveal, ten additional bars were added as a preface to the beginning, which originally started in bar 11 of the first movement. Brahms's correspondence with Joachim reveals that the latter proposed the addition of the ten introductory bars with a smaller combination of instruments. The second structural addition of op. 18 was a coda to the scherzo, thus broadening the previous da capo senza replica form. Concerning the coda, Brahms asked his friend Joachim for advice about whether a ‘più animato’ should be added to the coda. Joachim's reply is clear from the working parts, where we indeed find this tempo marking added in pencil.
In the case of op. 36, the manuscript sources reveal structural changes to the outer movements, later incorporated into the score.Footnote 17 In the first movement, the repeat of the exposition was added, and in the last movement, first and second endings were inserted at bar 51, among other minor changes. Such insights into Brahms's compositional workshop are rare, given his attempt to conceal all traces by destroying sketches (let alone whole works).
Joachim's importance for reconstructing the compositional process cannot be stressed enough. His correspondence with Brahms and his own writings and recordings also yield significant documentation regarding the performance practices of both sextets. As Hogwood mentions in his preface, Joachim's performance style is characterized by rhythmic flexibility (partly a consequence of his portamento) as well as an ornament-like use of vibrato, documented in his Violinschule (Moser/Joachim, 1905) and in his earliest recordings (1903).Footnote 18
In conclusion, we may consider briefly a few specific performance practice issues in the sextets. Rapid passages of semiquavers marked leggiero or molto leggiero occur in the first viola part of both sextets, the former with staccato dots, the latter without (op. 18, finale, bar 468, and op. 36, also last movement, bar 56). Because of the leggiero marking and the fast tempo, both instances necessarily require using the spiccato bow stroke (which in faster tempo is called sautillé). As spiccato is a springing bow stroke, however, there was disagreement as to whether it was appropriate for classical repertoire (springing bow strokes were associated with virtuosity, suitable for less elevated repertoire). Ludwig Spohr, among others, defended the view that springing bow strokes were ‘unidiomatic in classical repertoire’, a point of view Joachim presumably also adhered to before Mendelssohn made him change his mind by saying: ‘Always use it [spiccato], my boy, where it is suitable, or where it sounds well’.Footnote 19 The alternative to spiccato for executing staccato-marked notes was martelé. Martelé is carried out on the string by using sharp attacks, which produce a short stroke with marcato quality, suitable for moderate tempo. Martelé is utilized less today than was customary in the mid to late nineteenth-century, when it contributed to a great variety of articulation.Footnote 20
The earliest recordings by Joachim (of 1903) also document a particularly strong sense of phrasing, described as ‘quite logical’ regarding the use of phrase separation.Footnote 21 Brahms, commenting on Joachim directing the Berliner Hochschulorchester, pointed out: ‘One can hardly play better than those young people. How they phrase. Our musicians [i.e. at the Meiningen orchestra] have no perception thereof!’Footnote 22
Except for Joachim's bow technique, which was rather progressive, he remained conservative in his use of vibrato, portamento, and rhythmic flexibility. While violinists of the next two generations, such as Eugene Ysaÿe, Jenö Hubay and Fritz Kreisler, show more openness to vibrato (in Kreisler's case even continuous vibrato) and an overall more disciplined approach to portamento and rhythm, Joachim and some of his students and followers (Leopold Auer, Arnold Rosé) cultivated an older style of violin playing, which gradually came to an end after Joachim's death in 1907.Footnote 23 Clive Brown points out that the style of today's performers of Brahms's music is quite removed from how Brahms himself would have heard his works, played by Joachim. To gain a deeper perception of Joachim's style of performing is therefore just another important step toward understanding Brahms's string chamber music.Footnote 24
