In 1826, the violinist Karl Holz declared that op. 130 was his favourite work in Beethoven's set of Galitzin quartets. Beethoven rejected the premises of this judgment: ‘Each in its own way! Art does not permit us to stand still. You will notice a new type of part writing, and there is no less imagination than ever before, thank God.’Footnote 1 This remark is usually interpreted in terms of Beethoven's quest for continual innovation. Yet we might also construe his remark as a reference to musical temporality. Music does not permit the listener to stand still: musical works inevitably unfold in time. Indeed, the imaginative shaping of musical time is a hallmark of Beethoven's Galitzin quartets. In the Cavatina from op. 130, the section marked ‘beklemmt’ is cut short by a return, at first hesitant and then emphatic, to the first theme. The ‘beklemmt’ section thus showcases the ephemerality of sound. The urgency to return to the first theme, however, suggests a restless search for something stable and permanent.
The dialectic between ephemerality and eternity in Beethoven's music has long captivated scholars of musical time.Footnote 2 In Bach's Cycle, Mozart's Arrow: An Essay on the Origins of Musical Modernity, Karol Berger examines this dialectic through a study of parenthetical interludes in Beethoven's music.Footnote 3 These interludes, though fleeting, seem to conjure up images of infinity and transcendence. Benedict Taylor opens The Melody of Time: Music and Temporality in the Romantic Era with some of the same repertory with which Berger concluded his study: Beethoven's last three piano sonatas. Building on Berger's account of Beethovenian mysticism, Taylor observes that Beethoven's ‘idea of variation structure […] contains a certain inherent Platonism in the contrast it fashions between an underlying theme and its varied manifestations – a quasi-supertemporal essence and its temporally changing surface phenomena’ (p. 32).
The same could be said of Taylor's own work. The Melody of Time, like Beethoven's variation structures, probes the implications of a single theme from multiple vantage points. It draws on a diverse set of methodologies in the service of illuminating its central theme, musical temporality. Taylor seeks to unite two different interpretative projects that revolve around this theme: the hermeneutic explication of musical works and the close reading of philosophical texts. In the service of these dual goals, he adopts by turns the stance of a philosopher, a nineteenth-century music critic, a critical musicologist (his critique of Austro-German hegemony is a case in point), a music theorist and even a cognitive scientist. The advantages as well as the limitations of Taylor's methodological flexibility open up broader questions about the relationship between historical context, music analysis and textual interpretation.
National boundaries and transnational tropes
One of Taylor's central goals, in this book as well as in his earlier work, is to use philosophical texts as interpretative keys to musical works. In Taylor's 2008 article ‘Musical History and Self-Consciousness in Mendelssohn's Octet, Op. 20’ (later incorporated into his book Mendelssohn, Time and Memory: The Romantic Conception of Cyclic Form), he approaches this goal empirically, focusing primarily on philosophical and literary works that Mendelssohn is thought to have studied, including works by G. W. F. Hegel and and Johann Wolfgang von Goethe.Footnote 4 The Melody of Time departs from this approach, extending its reach to philosophers who lie beyond the documented interests of the composers whom he examines. By broadening his previous approach in this way, Taylor allows his philosophical analyses to move flexibly between nations and periods, though sometimes at the expense of addressing the intellectual traditions that made a direct impact on compositional practice.
In the absence of evidence linking specific texts to particular composers or musical cultures, it often seems that Taylor has chosen his philosophical approaches on the basis of general affinities and resonances, rather than direct influence. Yet this approach ultimately proves to be a good fit for the theme of musical temporality. As Taylor demonstrates, many nineteenth-century composers were themselves responding to diverse fields (e.g. philosophy, literature, physics, history, theology) when making decisions about the temporal unfolding of their musical ideas. Thus, some of the temporal patterns in nineteenth-century Russian compositions were influenced by the novelist Leo Tolstoy (pp. 182–3), the theologian St Augustine (pp. 189–90) and the political theorist Vasily Danilevsky (p. 200).
Despite Taylor's commitment to methodological diversity, the structure of his argument prevents him from thinking outside national boundaries. Except in Chapter 2, which addresses philosophies of time across different regions and historical periods, Taylor organizes his chapters by nationality. Chapters 1 and 3 focus on Austro-German repertory, represented by Beethoven and Schubert respectively. Despite noting differences between these two composers, such as Schubert's stronger interest in the psychology of nostalgia, Taylor nevertheless subsumes them both into what he considers to be a coherent Viennese tradition: ‘It is not so much the case that the time sense suggested by Schubert's music differs from Beethoven's simpliciter as that both these composers, living alongside each other in 1820s Vienna, departed from the temporal qualities formed by Beethoven's “Heroic” style some twenty years earlier’ (p. 131). Here (as elsewhere), Taylor appears to overstate the significance of geographical proximity. After all, Rossini spent time in Vienna during the 1820s as well, and his operas arguably do not have much in common with the works of Beethoven and Schubert.
Chapter 4 focuses on models of temporality that developed in mid-nineteenth-century Russia. Here, Taylor defends Russian music from the charge of inferiority to Beethovenian developmental techniques. He seeks to explicate and ultimately to celebrate the Russian predilection for varied repetition. I wonder, though, if his apologia for Russian music is really necessary in this day and age. He appears to be contesting prejudices that are no longer expressed (at least not overtly) in contemporary scholarship. Indeed, the authors whom he cites as exemplars of anti-Russian sentiment – Gerald Abraham, Donald Francis Tovey and Theodor Adorno – are mostly from the first half of the twentieth century. Surprisingly, he gives short shrift to Richard Taruskin's groundbreaking attempts to revalue Russian musical strategies.Footnote 5
Chapter 5 turns to cyclic form in late nineteenth-century French music. The framework of this chapter derives from Marcel Proust's fictitious composer Vintueil in Remembrance of Things Past. Perhaps inspired by Vintueil's fictitious violin sonata, Taylor focuses on evocations of unreality and illusion in cyclic works by Saint-Saëns, Franck and d'Indy. One of Taylor's goals is to explore how the cyclic soundscape in late nineteenth-century France might have influenced Proust's philosophy of time. This approach is a refreshing departure from standard musicological practice. Musicologists usually trace the influence of literature on music, but here Taylor reverses this paradigm.
Chapter 6 focuses on British music through the example of Elgar's ode The Music Makers. Taylor situates this seemingly marginal work in a rich aesthetic context. Examining its portrayal of musicians as artists of time, and its complex network of self-quotations, Taylor argues that The Music Makers is in fact Elgar's aesthetic manifesto. He then touches briefly on Elgar's allusions to Rule, Britannia and La marseillaise. For Taylor, the brevity of these allusions indicates an ‘imperial pride’ which ‘is shortlived’, reflecting Elgar's ‘clear self-consciousness of the rise and fall of empire’ (p. 279). A more detailed account of Elgar's attitude towards British imperialism would have been welcome here. Elgar wrote some overtly imperialist works, including his incidental music for The Crown of India.Footnote 6 These works might provide useful context for Elgar's veiled references to empire in The Music Makers. Moreover, the quotation from La marseillaise could profitably be situated in the context of foreign relations between England and France.
As already mentioned, Chapter 2 offers a glimpse of the transnational spread of intellectual paradigms – something that is largely missing from the other chapters. This chapter moves beyond the nation-based structure that governs most of the book, taking a broader view of philosophical theories of time. In addition to discussing nineteenth-century German philosophers (Hegel, Arthur Schopenhauer, F. W. J. Schelling), Taylor extends his reach to include thinkers (St Augustine, Henri Bergson, Jean-Jacques Rousseau) from diverse geographical and historical contexts. Echoing the book's title, The Melody of Time, this chapter privileges melody over other parameters such as harmony and form. He invites readers to meditate on Aristotle's question, ‘How is it that rhythms and melodies, although only sound, resemble states of the soul?’ (p. 66). Initiating a transhistorical dialogue about the significance of melody, Taylor looks to Hegel's musical aesthetics for a potential answer: ‘In Hegel's opinion, “every melody, although it has harmony as its basis, has a higher and more free subjectivity in itself”’(p. 67). Taylor then proceeds to find an unexpected link between Hegel, who had a low opinion of music, and Schopenhauer, who placed music at the top of the aesthetic hierarchy: both philosophers shared a strong interest in melody (p. 67).Footnote 7 In these and other passages, he identifies melody as a unifying theme in otherwise divergent philosophies of musical time.
This emphasis on melody in Chapter 2, prompted by the philosophical texts under consideration, sits uneasily with Taylor's approach to music analysis in other chapters. When analysing specific musical works, Taylor often focuses on harmony rather than melody. Thus, he examines how Tchaikovsky's Souvenir de Florence generates momentum through harmonic disturbance: ‘The sextet's opening eight-bar unit moves from an initial dissonant first-inversion V9 in b. 1 to a root-position tonic in b. 2, immediately causing a subtle hypermetric ambiguity between phrasal and harmonic accents’ (p. 204). Here, Taylor endows harmony with the very power that he attributed to melody in Chapter 2: the ability to represent the temporal movement of consciousness.
The divergence between Taylor's philosophical and analytical sections is not necessarily a flaw. After all, musical analysis and musical aesthetics are different fields with different priorities and methodologies. These two fields cannot always be brought into a harmonious relationship with each other. But perhaps Taylor should have acknowledged some of the dissonances. One of his main goals is to trace the interactions between musical and philosophical approaches to temporality; it would be interesting to hear his thoughts on the difficulties inherent in this project.
The structure of The Melody of Time has the unfortunate effect of obscuring some of Taylor's most provocative insights into these approaches. His geographically based structure conforms to a conventional view of national traditions. When he engages with specific works, however, his insights reveal that certain musical approaches to temporality cut across different countries. Thus his analytical accounts often dissolve national boundaries even as his chapter format upholds them. His discussion of thematic overlaying provides a case in point. In Chapter 1, he calls attention to the superimposition of previously separate themes in Beethoven's op. 110 (p. 26). In Chapter 4, he makes similar claims about Borodin's melodic combinations in On the Steppes of Central Asia (p. 187). His treatments of these two works, which he never mentions in connection with each other, are separated by many intervening pages. Nonetheless, these analyses reveal transnational resonances. These commonalities belie Taylor's insistence on distinct national approaches to temporality.
The framing of musical material as imaginary – a technique that makes time itself seem unreal – constitutes yet another trope that crosses national borders. He finds this technique in music from every locale under consideration: Austria, Russia, France and England. His first reference to this trope is prompted by the muted dynamics with which Schubert opens the A minor Quartet, D.804: ‘The opening of Schubert's work offers a dreamlike way into experience, the fainter echo of a beautiful world already lost’ (p. 150). He then uncovers a similar technique in Russian works such as Balakirev's Symphony no. 2 and Rimsky-Korsakov's Sheherazade, in which the use of framing chords ‘can give rise to a fairy-tale, wistful quality […]. The entire story told by the music is merely a myth’ (p. 188).
Musical signifiers of unreality resurface in his discussion of Saint-Saëns's Violin Sonata no. 1. The recapitulation brings back the exposition's accompanimental figuration, but omits the main theme. For Taylor, this partial recapitulation creates the impression ‘that its tones are an illusion’ (p. 223). In the final chapter, Taylor revisits the musical evocation of illusion yet again. He hears the hushed conclusion of Elgar's The Music Makers as creating a sense of unreality: ‘The tale of history and human endeavor is itself a dream, as insubstantial and ethereal as the voices of the music makers who dream it’ (p. 283). In sum, Taylor's analyses of works by Schubert, Rimsky-Korsakov, Saint-Saëns and Elgar indicate the transnational spread of an aesthetic of illusion. Transnational similarities also manifest themselves through the trope of parenthetical digression. This trope, which he introduces in his discussion of Beethoven's op. 109 (pp. 23–5), reappears in his analysis of d'Indy's Symphony no. 2. Its final movement includes ‘an event that seems to stand outside the rest of the immediate music: the visionary episode that twice breaks in to the latter stages of the rondeau’ (p. 253).
Taylor's findings suggest that many nineteenth-century composers took a pan-European approach to temporality. To highlight these transnational connections, he should perhaps have organized his argument around nineteenth-century tropes of temporality in music. A trope-based structure would have allowed each chapter to examine one or two compositional strategies across a variety of works from different regions. For instance, one chapter could have been devoted to the tropes that evoke a sense of unreality, with other chapters focusing on tropes such as thematic superimposition and parenthetical digression. This organizational format might have liberated Taylor's insights from the constraints imposed by geographical boundaries.
Looking back: temporalities and musical evocations of the past
A trope-based chapter structure might also have allowed Taylor to think beyond temporal boundaries. As many scholars have shown, the nineteenth century was shaped by a growing sense of historical consciousness. Indeed, the nineteenth century saw the formation of a musical canon which included works from previous centuries. This canon gradually became a guiding force in musical culture.Footnote 8 Taylor, as a scholar of musical time, would seem ideally positioned to contribute to our understanding of how nineteenth-century composers engaged with the past. Surprisingly, however, he stops short of ever doing so. He does not ask how the new types of historical awareness which developed in the nineteenth century might have generated new approaches to temporality in music.Footnote 9
His avoidance of this question sometimes leads him to overlook earlier precedents for the features that he observes in nineteenth-century music. For instance, his discussion of the variation movement in Beethoven's op. 109 would have been strengthened by a consideration of its historical background. He observes: ‘At the movement's close the theme returns in its original limpid simplicity. Its recall imparts a circular frame to the music […]. We are back again, but everything is new, fresh, rediscovered. The theme now contains a lifetime worth of experience’ (p. 14). He situates Beethoven's amalgamation of cyclical and linear temporalities in the context of Hegel's philosophy of history. Unfortunately, his zeal for nineteenth-century philosophy leads him to overlook an eighteenth-century musical precedent for Beethoven's reprise: Bach's Goldberg Variations, in which the opening aria returns at the close of the entire work.
A similar oversight occurs when Taylor analyses the fugal movement in Beethoven's op. 110. Here, he discusses how the listener experiences ‘the fugue simultaneously at half and at three times its original speed’ (p. 19) as a result of Beethoven's ‘superimposition of different “times”’ (p. 20). This passage illustrates Taylor's emphasis on internal musical processes to the exclusion of historical precedents. This emphasis impedes his argument, which would have been strengthened by a consideration of this fugue's self-conscious archaism. Its contrapuntal procedures evoke the learned style associated with earlier musical traditions. Thus, what Taylor identifies as the experience of multiple temporalities is not only a function of Beethoven's rhythmic layering. The sense of temporal superimposition derives also from Beethoven's blending of different chronological times, his combination of Baroque techniques with a nineteenth-century harmonic language.
Michael Puri's distinction between the ‘contextual past’ and the ‘historical past’ might have enabled Taylor to bring chronological time into his analyses.Footnote 10 This distinction allows Puri to address issues in early twentieth-century music that seem to be precluded by Taylor's framework. For instance, Puri examines the temporal trajectory enacted in Ravel's Sonatine (1905), in which the musical style becomes gradually more contemporary as the work progresses. He observes that the contextual past in the Sonatine mirrors the flow of historical time. This insight is predicated upon his distinction between two forms of musical temporality. Reading Ravel's Sonatine in the context of neoclassical aesthetics and the rejection of Romantic excess, Puri concludes that the historical past can be both an object of nostalgia and a weapon against a more recent past. This type of analysis is nowhere to be found in Taylor's book, which limits its focus to the contextual past.
In fact, Taylor's only brush with the historical past is to be found in his analysis of Schubert's A minor Quartet, D.804. It is worth looking at this analysis in some detail, for it illustrates his difficulty in identifying relevant historical contexts for nineteenth-century compositions. For Taylor, ‘A different type of nostalgia is created in the quartet by allusion to past musical styles, most evidently in the third movement. By 1824 a minuet was certainly a little old-fashioned, and such is the pervasive air of regret with which Schubert invests the music that it readily evokes a sense of temporal distance and loss’ (p. 142). At this point, it might have been useful to trace the aristocratic histories associated with the genre of the minuet. Instead, Taylor chooses to place Schubert's minuet in the context of Austro-German nostalgia for ancient Greece. In an attempt to demonstrate the relevance of this context, he points to Schubert's use of quotations from his own earlier song The Gods of Greece. He then proceeds to link these quotations to Friedrich Schiller's obsession with ancient Greece. However, in light of the courtly origins of the minuet, it seems that ancient Greece is not the most pertinent context for Schubert's allusion to this genre.Footnote 11
It might have proved more fruitful to hear Schubert's minuet in the context of nineteenth-century nostalgia for a rapidly vanishing (or at least changing) era of court patronage.Footnote 12 The tonal instability of this minuet could provide the starting point for this type of analysis. Opening with a sustained dominant chord, which fails to lead directly to a root-position tonic chord, Schubert's minuet soon slips into the relative major. Taylor hears this harmonic instability as signifying memory and distance: ‘The status as memory might be indicated by a difference in intensity. Hence we find such familiar devices as music […] lacking the reality of true grounding (in inversion, without bass support)’ (p. 150). However, I would argue that the rootlessness of this minuet's harmonic language operates within the context I proposed above: nostalgia for the courtly past. Rather than serving as a generic marker of memory, the harmonic instability could indicate a troubled relationship with eighteenth-century conventions. The vast majority of eighteenth-century minuets are in major keys, as befits the charm and elegance associated with the genre.Footnote 13 Schubert's minuet seems to express anxiety about the continued viability of this convention. Nominally in A minor, the music quickly seems to ‘realize’ that this is the wrong key with respect to courtly standards; it then attempts to modulate to its ‘proper’ major key. But it cannot maintain this key either. Perhaps signifying alienation by means of a tonal crisis, Schubert's minuet then launches into a series of remote modulations. This minuet engages with history by staging its failure to recapture the courtly past. Indeed, this minuet plays with time's arrow, as do many nineteenth-century works. This play assumes different guises in different works: sometimes melancholy, sometimes witty, sometimes spiritual – but often non-linear. Taylor's neglect of historical allusion prevents him from acknowledging the extent of this non-linearity, this radical undoing of time's forward march.
To point out certain avenues of enquiry that would have enhanced Taylor's work, I turn now to the work of Christopher Reynolds. His studies of allusion and influence shed light on some of the complex temporalities that take shape in nineteenth-century music. Historical allusions, as Reynolds demonstrates, perform important work in music composed during this period. One such function is to signal a composer's bid for inclusion in an earlier tradition. Thus, Wagner's Faust Overture alludes to the famous E♭–D–C♯ motive from the ‘Eroica’ Symphony as a signifier of Beethovenian heroism.Footnote 14
Along similar lines, Reynolds shows how contrary-motion counterpoint became a marker of war, but also of Beethoven's Ninth Symphony and thus the musical past. He traces the ways in which composers, especially Schumann and Wagner, employed this marker to mobilize a range of intertextual meanings. These meanings include, in Wagner's Lohengrin, Elsa's ‘grapple with the forbidden question’, showing how markers of musical pastness could carry specific extramusical meanings.Footnote 15 Wagner extended his historical reach even further in Tristan und Isolde with the use of Bach-derived motifs as signifiers of nature, mystery and medievalism.Footnote 16
Reynolds also traces the ways in which Schumann, Wagner and Brahms interacted with one another through their responses to earlier works such as Beethoven's Symphony no. 9. In their hands, the past became a vehicle for staking out positions on instrumental and vocal music. Reynolds thus shows that many nineteenth-century composers engaged with historical time in a non-linear (and strategic) fashion: they resurrected segments of the past to animate their contemporary debates. In sum, his work examines many forms of temporality, including nostalgic temporalities, intertextual temporalities and strategic temporalities.
The values and limits of chronology
Taylor's neglect of historical allusion stems in part from his investment in periodization: his book confines itself to the Romantic period, with few forays into other eras. Historical periodization has long been a cornerstone of musicology, functioning as the organizing principle for many books, seminars and fields of enquiry. Even when examining the nuances of musical temporality, many scholars adhere to traditional labels: Baroque, Classical, Romantic, etc. For instance, Berger, who studiously avoids these standard chronological labels, ends up telling a story about musical temporality which is shaped by the concepts of these style periods. He focuses primarily on cyclic elements in Bach's fugues and cantatas, goal-orientated structures in Mozart's concertos, and moments of rhapsodic imagination in Beethoven's sonatas – a set of interpretations that comes suspiciously close to the conventional definitions of the Baroque, Classical and Romantic periods.
In his book Out of Time: Music and the Making of Modernity, Julian Johnson aims to explode chronological boundaries, arguing that the stylistic features of modernity appear in works from many different time periods.Footnote 17 However, at times Johnson veers away from the stylistic category of modernity, turning instead towards the chronological category of modernism. His modus operandi is to use modernist works (Brian Ferneyhough, Plötzlichkeit; György Ligeti, Poème symphonique) as an interpretative lens through which he views many earlier works. He thus ends up reinscribing the notion of a modernist period, even as he seeks to extend its reach back in time to encompass eighteenth- and nineteenth-century works.
Taylor similarly bases some of his arguments on a term (in his case, Romantic) which can function either as a productive way to describe an artistic movement or as a reductive way of classifying a chronological period. He vacillates between these two approaches to the term. In some of the most nuanced and productive junctures of his argument, particularly in his chapters on Beethoven and Schubert, he takes the first approach, explaining how their musical works resonate with Romantic aesthetics as articulated by novelists and philosophers of the time. In other chapters, however, he deals with repertory that has no evident connection to Romantic traditions of thought. At such moments, Taylor's reliance on the term seems to take on chronological connotations, as though the ‘Romantic era’ were merely a synonym for the nineteenth century. This over-generalizing approach to Romanticism is particularly pronounced in Chapter 5, in which the French repertory under consideration seems to gesture towards modernist forms of fragmented temporality – yet Taylor is implicitly labelling such works as ‘Romantic’ by virtue of including them in this book, which specifies ‘Romantic era’ in its title. The inclusion of this repertory seems to be based on a chronological correspondence to the dates associated with the ‘Romantic era’, rather than any aesthetic affinities.
Taylor's lapses into chronologically based thinking invite broader reflection on how musicologists approach the nineteenth century. Several musicologists (James Webster, Taruskin, David Wyn JonesFootnote 18) have already made significant inroads towards critiquing the notion of a ‘Classical era’, but the idea of the ‘Romantic era’ has not been subjected to the same degree of critical scrutiny. Charles Rosen, faced with the methodological quandaries inherent in the term ‘Romantic’, chose to limit the scope of The Romantic Generation Footnote 19 to the composers born around 1810, thus attempting to sharpen the broad category of Romanticism into a more precise designation. Yet his use of a specific date, 1810, suggests that he too was employing the word chronologically rather than using it to describe a particular tradition – one among many – that existed in the nineteenth century.
In contrast to Rosen, Taylor covers the 100-year period lasting from 1815 to 1915; as mentioned above, his title describes this period as ‘Romantic’. Through staking out his territory in a long – and fenced-off – nineteenth century, tidily subsumed into the category of ‘Romanticism’, Taylor enables himself to construct a unified, coherent narrative. Yet, as discussed in the previous section, this comes at the expense of historical engagement: Taylor rarely examines the historical origins of the temporal strategies that he identifies in nineteenth-century music.
There are only a few brief moments when Taylor transcends his self-imposed temporal boundaries; such moments spark a set of provocative questions, attesting to the potential value of historical engagement. For instance, he observes that Beethoven's String Quartet in F major, op. 135, opens with a cadential formula, creating a premature sense of closure which (as he observes in a footnote) dates back at least as far as Haydn's op. 33 string quartets (p. 25). He points out that, for Haydn, this technique often had jocular connotations. This observation opens the door to many unanswered questions: did Beethoven recode the technique as something serious? Or did he deploy an eighteenth-century mode of wit in this case? Unfortunately, Taylor rapidly closes the door on the eighteenth century instead of probing, or even acknowledging, such questions.
Despite Taylor's failure to address some of these temporalities, The Melody of Time will be an invaluable resource for future scholarship. His exploration of tropes such as thematic combination and cyclic return offers a promising new approach to the semiotics of time. This semiotic approach has the potential to enrich future studies of temporality within as well as across a wide variety of musical works.
On the whole, The Melody of Time attests to the efficacy of a diverse approach that engages with many disciplines, genres and nations. Through his eclectic set of methodologies, Taylor reveals the profound similarities among many nineteenth-century musical tropes and philosophies of temporality. The discovery of interconnections within a domain of apparent multiplicity suits the study of nineteenth-century music quite well. During this period, many composers, music theorists and philosophers searched eagerly for underlying connections among diverse foreground structures. The Melody of Time aligns itself with this nineteenth-century tradition. In an 1810 review of Beethoven's Fifth Symphony, E. T. A. Hoffmann famously asserted that ‘profound contemplation shows the splendid tree, buds and leaves, blossom and fruit as springing from the same seed’.Footnote 20 Through his own profound contemplations, Taylor powerfully recreates a nineteenth-century world of interrelated temporalities.
