How has a clerically mandated superstitious variant of Shiʿi Islam, which has been characterized in Ali Rahnema's new book as a set of beliefs and practices rooted in irrational causality (p. 5), ideologically buttressed and contributed to the thriving of a succession of authoritarian and totalitarian regimes in Iran for five centuries, from the accession of the Safavid Ismaʿil I to the throne in the summer of 1501 to the start of Mahmoud Ahmadinejad's presidency in the summer of 2005? This question, which has its genesis in Rahnema's longstanding engagement with the intellectual and sociopolitical legacies of two 20th-century Iranian Islamic revivalists, Muhammad Hasan Shariʿat-Sanglaji (d. 1943) and ʿAli Shariʿati (d. 1977), is the primary concern addressed by the book under review. The interconnected notions of divine intervention (luṭf) and human intercession (shafāʿa) underpin Rahnema's inquiry.
The book is divided into two parts. The first part illuminates and discusses metaphysical yearnings and paranormal convictions of three Iranian heads of state: the sixth president of the Islamic Republic, Mahmoud Ahmadinejad (2005–present), the second Pahlavi king, Muhammad Reza Shah (1941–79), and the founder of the Safavid dynasty, Ismaʿil I (1501–24). The second part concerns the formative phase of what Rahnema dubs “Majlesism,” a superstitious brand of Shiʿi Islam issued from the teachings of the late 17th-century theologian Muhammad Baqir Majlisi (d. circa 1699). Majlesism, Rahnema points out, “sought to assure the absolute rule of the shahs while keeping the people docile and subdued by maintaining them immersed in superstitious beliefs” (p. 17). The second part of the book investigates how, within the temporal scope of the closing decades of the Safavid rule, this superstitious ideology turned Shiʿism into “a conservative, complacent, irrational, timid” and obedient system of religious thinking (p. 292).
Chapter 1, the longest in the book, brings Ahmadinejad's superstitious worldview into sharp focus. Rahnema emphasizes Ahmadinejad's irrational approach to the Shiʿi concept of the Hidden Imam and his claims of being metaphysically in touch with and supported by the extramundane, providing evidence of the latter in an interesting discussion of Ahmadinejad's videotaped statements about a paranormal “beam of light” that swathed him amid his 2005 address to the UN General Assembly in New York City. Rahnema argues that Ahmadinejad's supernatural assertions, and the array of superstitious statements attributed to a variety of like-minded Iranian politicians, preachers, clerics, and even celebrity athletes, can be viewed as part of a concerted campaign of political and cultural engineering. He contends that this campaign has been at work since the early years of Ahmadinejad's presidency to counter reformist efforts from within the Islamic Republic's nexus of power that aimed at subverting the supreme leader ʿAli Khamenei's absolute hold on political power (p. 86). Muhammad Taqi Misbah-Yazdi, a hardliner exponent of a totalitarian, fiqh-minded interpretation of Shiʿi Islam, is a towering figure in this opening chapter. According to Rahnema, Misbah-Yazdi's opinions—along with those of Khamenei—mirror those of Majlisi (p. 21). Rahnema argues that Misbah-Yazdi's bid for weaving a superstitious reading of Shiʿi Islam into the political discourse of the Islamic Republic aims to reproduce the successful example of Ayatollah Khomeini. Rahnema's analysis is built around a detailed narrative account of Khomeini's pragmatic use of Shiʿi superstitious themes and tropes in commutating with his followers (pp. 99–113). Rahnema also highlights the fact that it is on the basis of a delusional reading of the battle of Karbala and the history of Shiʿi Islam, in which the notion of “hidden assistances” (imdādhā-yi ghaybī) has received particular emphasis, that Misbah-Yazdi identifies paramilitary forces (basīj) and the urban plainclothes militia (hizbullāh) of the Islamic Republic with the Shiʿi saints and martyrs of early Islam. According to Misbah-Yazdi, whose staunch disciples rank among the top military commanders of the Iranian Revolutionary Guard Corps, it is imperative for true supporters of the current Guardian Jurist Ali Khamenei to be prepared ideologically and logistically for launching preemptive attacks against the opponents of the Islamic Republic. Rahnema contends that Misbah-Yazdi's seminal intellectual contribution to the development of a superstitious variant of Shiʿi Islam in Iran has been the formulation and propagation of the idea of “preventive jihad,” according to which Shiʿi believers are religiously obliged to wage holy war if they feel “the faith is threatened.” Prominent among those whose assassinations were carried out on the authority of Misbah-Yazdi's religious opinions was Ayatollah Khomeini's disgruntled son, Ahmad (pp. 95–96).
Chapter 2 is constructed around the superstitious beliefs and worldview of Muhammad Reza Shah. The focus on the shah is apt as he, the authoritarian nature of his rule notwithstanding, represents the politically secular sector of the political nation in contemporary Iran. However, Rahnema's linear narrative in this chapter has been confined to the shah's folie de grandeur and his lifelong paranoiac obsession with supernatural forces. The Diaries of the Court Minister Asadullah ʿAlam (d. 1978) constitute Rahnema's primary source on the shah's belief in the paranormal. This chapter concludes that the shah's megalomaniac infatuations with the extrarational was to play a significant part in the proliferation of a superstitious Weltanschauung among later generations of Iran's political activists, including supporters of Ayatollah Khomeini. This line of argument is supported by Rahnema's clarifying analysis of the commonalities between the superstitious and paranoiac beliefs and self-images of the Shah and Ahmadinejad (p. 120).
Taking Ismaʿil I's preternatural mien as its central topic, the third chapter attempts to delineate the historical development of superstitious forms of religiosity in Iran in the opening quarter of the 16th century. Drawing on a patchy selection of primary and secondary sources, ranging from a late 19th-century compilation authored by an Ottoman translator attending the Qajar court to anonymous fictional narrations dating from the late Safavid period, Rahnema's account in this chapter is premised on an apocalyptic reading of early Safavid politics. Dreams as well as imagined encounters with Shiʿi imams and saints receive the lion's share of attention in this chapter, and Rahnema argues that it was owing to the clerical perception of the Safavids as the forerunners of the Hidden Imam's world empire of justice that the Safavid superstitious version of Shiʿi Islam retained its popularity in Iran even after Ismaʿil's defeat at the battle of Chaldiran in 1514.
Composed of seven chapters, the second part of the book under review deals with the formative period of Majlesism in late 17th- and early 18th-century Iran. Rahnema first narrows his focus on Majlisi's biography (Chapter 4), then analyzes aspects of Majlisi's scholarship (Chapter 5), and in four consecutive chapters (6–10) delves into a handful of Majlisi's popular works in Persian. The key issues discussed in this second part include Majlisi's prophecies about the persistence of Safavid rule in Iran until the return of the Hidden Imam, his antirationalist proclivities, and, last but not least, his efforts to transform Iranian Shiʿi Muslims into an acquiescent community of believers inveigled into accepting the superstitious Islam of the mullahs and authoritarian domination of Safavid monarchs.
From a critical vantage point, it should be admitted that some methodological shortcomings and factual errors have marred the explanatory relevance and scholarly value of an important part of Rahnema's arguments and interpretations. For example, one detects the uncritical reception and adoption of Shariaʿti's controversial and politically loaded reading of Iran's post-Safavid history, which inter alia unduly singles out Majlisi as the founding father and the bête noire of superstitious Shiʿism. Rahnema never lays out the criteria that allow him to equate religious life lived under the Islamic Republic to the politics of religiosity under the Safavids. Nor does he care to make clear why the impact of religious trends and events under the Qajars was completely ignored in his study. Khamenei and Misbah-Yazdi are compared to Majlisi, which is reminiscent of “the fallacy of the perfect analogy,” or as “reasoning from a partial resemblance between two entities to an entire and exact correspondence.” Rahnema's reconstruction of Majlisi's life and career is laconic. A glaring shortcoming is Rahnema's reticence on the anti-Majlisi writings of the late 17th-century Shiʿi jurist and preacher, Sayyid Muhammad Mir Lawhi-Sabzivari, whose unpublished treatise titled Arbaʿin (1670–72) voices the outrage of a faction of high-ranking contemporary clerics who deemed Majlisi's writings on the return of the Hidden Imam superstitious and devoid of religious authenticity. Rahnema writes of Majlisi's Lebanese descent (p. 160), citing as his source Muhammad Baqir Khansari's Rowzat al-Jannat fi Ahwal al-ʿUlamaʾ wa-l-Sadat, a late 19th-century biographical dictionary in Arabic. However, nowhere in this source is it mentioned that Majlisi had descended on his paternal side from the Lebanese nobility of Isfahan. The fact, however, is that Majlisi's patrilineal descent goes back to Hafiz Abu Nuʿaym Isfahani (d. 1013), a prominent Iranian Sunni theologian and chronicler whose ancestors were originally among the Zoroastrian nobility of Isfahan before the Arab conquest of the city. Rahnema's reading of early Safavid history is also awash with factual errors. For instance, the third chapter relies heavily on an anonymous work titled ʿAlamara-yi Safavi, which is a replica of the Jahangusha-yi Khaqan, itself a late 17th-century fictional history authored by a Georgian renegade by the name of Bizhan. Rahnema, however, fails to clarify the provenance of this frequently cited source. Nor is it clear why instead of Tahmasb I (r. 1524–76), whose autobiography epitomizes the permeation of superstitious Shiʿism through the Safavid political rhetoric, Rahnema simply focuses on the reign of Ismaʿil I, with the inadvertent result that his arguments on early Safavid history can rarely be corroborated by contemporary sources.
These criticisms aside, the outstanding merit of Rahnema's study of superstitious Shiʿism lies in its perspicuous approach to such a controversial and problematic topic. This book is a pioneering attempt to flesh out in a systematic manner the speculations put forward by several generations of contemporary Iranian thinkers, from Ahmad Kasravi to ʿAli Shariʿati, about the intellectual and political lineages of superstitious Shiʿism.
