Sir Joseph Banks was forty in 1783, and had been President of the Royal Society for five years. The 289 letters in this book therefore cover a period when he was coming to the peak of his power and influence. They are part of a major project to make available a comprehensive collection of Banks’ correspondence. Six volumes of his scientific correspondence have already been published. The present volume provides a fascinating picture of the background to the expansion of British power in Asia and the Pacific in the late eighteenth century.
Banks had of course circumnavigated the world with Cook from 1768 to 1771. He therefore brought a global perspective to his work at the Royal Society and he sat at the centre of an international web of correspondents. Letters came to him literally from every corner of the world, from Australia, South America, China and India.
His judgements were of great importance as was his support for isolated colonial scientists like Anderson and Russell in south India. Banks often expressed his interest and concern by sending books, and in return he got a stream of plants, plant material and mineral specimens. The reliable transmission of knowledge was key to the success of Banks’ network – hence the continual references to publishing, engravings and the need for duplicate letters.
The 1780s were a period of stability before the great upheaval of the French Revolution, and this is reflected in the letters. After 1783 Britain was at peace with France and Banks carried on a warm correspondence with some of the great names of French science, such as Buffon and Brousonnet. The letters give a sense of science as a European enterprise. Banks was equally warm with another former enemy of Britain, Benjamin Franklin, and he clearly regarded scientists as a special breed. But he remained at heart a British patriot. Whilst he liked and respected their scientists he also saw the French as a spur to greater British enterprise: part of the reason for pressing on with Bligh's efforts to transport breadfruit seedlings to the West Indies was to introduce them there before the French did.
It was a world full of possibilities, and opportunities to experiment. The letters remind us of the excitement of discovery at the time, when there were still significant blanks to be filled on the world map, and new areas of scientific investigation, like geology, were just emerging. With the conclusion of the American War of Independence there were more resources to devote to scientific and technological enterprises of all sorts. But like all patrons of science Banks had to make the case to attract these resources; science, economics and politics are closely intermingled in the letters.
Although there were occasional trading expeditions funded by rich merchants who corresponded with Banks, it was only really the British government and the East India Company which had the money and ships to implement the schemes Banks promoted. Part of the fascination of the correspondence is seeing how Banks made the case for scientific enterprises such as the setting up the earliest colonial botanic gardens. His successors at the Royal Society over 200 years later would probably recognise the way he justified the investment by stressing likely economic benefit and national prestige, as well as his flattery of politicians.
Some of the enterprises – the British settlement of Australia and the establishment of a claim to the northwest coast of America for instance – were of immense significance for the future. Others turned out to be less important than Banks had anticipated, the transfer of the breadfruit tree to the West Indies being a case in point. Some projects even proved to be dead ends, like the continual attempts to break the Spanish monopoly of red dye production from the cochineal insect. But Banks could also be ahead of his time, as when he advocated tea growing in India, and when he sent Hove to Gujarat in 1787 to investigate whether cotton could be imported from that region.
There are more letters to Banks than from him. That is presumably because fewer of his letters have survived, rather than his failings as a correspondent. In the letters that have been preserved Banks is often fluent and articulate. There is a good example of this in the note appended to Letter 268, where he speculates at length on the contributions that India could make to the British imperial economy. He is invariably logical and to the point but at times his letters are careless and poorly punctuated. That is not surprising; he is known to have written over 20,000 letters altogether. Like many movers and shakers Banks’ main concern was to get things done.
Whilst some of the letters are about high level policy, few matters were beneath Banks’ notice. He corresponded with fellow landowners in Lincolnshire about individuals who had fallen foul of the law and were being transported to Australia, and he wrote at length about the sort of paper to be used in publishing the account of Cook's last voyage. That was important – one is reminded that in the eighteenth century almost everything was made by hand; enterprises could founder if too little attention was paid to the quality of a product.
Banks nearly always wrote in English, and a surprising number of his correspondents in Germany and Scandinavia replied to him in that language. However, his French correspondents all wrote in French and it seems to have been generally accepted that letters could be sent in one's own language, to be translated as necessary. Only one letter (from Sweden) is in Latin – the great tradition of communicating in that language was finally dying by the end of the eighteenth century. Where letters are not in English the book usefully includes a translation.
Overall the character of the man comes over clearly in the letters. Banks was an assiduous and hardworking facilitator, and a good judge of people. He remembers those who have done him a service in the past and he is supportive of those whose efforts he respects, but he sends stern rebukes to anyone who does not follow his instructions or apply themselves sufficiently. Although he addresses his correspondents according to their status he takes an equal interest in their character whether they are plant collectors or government ministers. Members of his own staff, such as his Swedish librarian Jonas Dryander, and his clerk William Cartlich, worked faithfully with him over many years. Banks seems to have inspired real loyalty in such invaluable collaborators, and shared with them a sense of common enterprise.
This book will be invaluable to anyone who is interested in the thinking behind Britain's worldwide expansion, and the establishment of the second British Empire in the late eighteenth century. It will give them a good insight into the ideas which drove this expansion, and will throw a lot of light on to the associated decision making process.
The volume is meticulously edited and I only noted one error – the repetition of a phrase in the footnote on p. 254. There is a valuable introduction which explains the editorial approach. Even more valuable is the forty page “Calendar of Correspondence” with clear notes and relevant background details on all of Banks’ correspondents. This section of the book is one that most readers will need to refer to constantly. It is obviously the result of a great deal of research, and the editor has done an excellent job. I would only dispute one of the judgements: it is stated on page 417 that the East India Company controlled India, more or less, by the mid-eighteenth century, but that was not really the case until the early nineteenth century.
Near the end of the book there are two letters which presage the tumult of the following years, and the two revolutions which were about to rock Europe. In April 1789 Brousonnet, writing about an unproductive meeting of the French Academy, says “We have spent almost every night in the General Assembly. . .that is what has completely absorbed us. Paris is like a wilderness at the time of an election. We have had sittings which have lasted forty-eight hours. Pamphlets are flying from all sides”.
In the same month Nathaniel Smith writes: “I have seen a specimen of the ye Muslin fabricated in Great Britain that astonished me, asserted to be made by this new invented machine”.
Life was never to be the same again.
