I
Forty years ago, almost to the day and presumably near this spot, Charles Crawley of Trinity Hall, Cambridge, rose to deliver the first Prothero Lecture.Footnote 1 That ruby wedding between the Royal Historical Society and the Prothero family weighed with me in wondering whether his subject, George Prothero and his circle, might not be revisited. Revisited, but not repeated. Crawley had concentrated on what might be gleaned in particular from Prothero's private diaries which had been in his hands since 1934 and which gave him special insight into his uncle by marriage; and it followed that his account has a strongly biographical and familial flavour.Footnote 2 My ambition is a different one. While in no sense seeking to transcend Crawley's helpful essay, I want to widen the lens and think more laterally and more generally about British historiography during Prothero's mature years. Rather than ask you to consider simply the time-line of the Protheros – for there are two of them – I intend to move your thinking sideways and to try to form an image of what was interesting and distinctive about the two generations of British historians who flourished in the fifty years after 1870, beginning always with events and contexts in the lives of the Protheros but then envisaging those environments as a place on which to build a structure that includes the two brothers but does not end with them. This means that, like all historians afflicted by periodisation and seeking escape, I shall speak of the long fin de siècle. The result will have neither the systematic virtues of a survey nor the immediacy of a single story but it may gain in atmosphere and flavour. Purists will say that an ‘age’ has no identity beyond that imposed in retrospect but I hope to propose that the age of Prothero yields significant characteristics that earlier and later periods sometimes reflect yet never fully share.
But first, the Protheros themselves. There were four brothers of whom two attract our attention: George, the eldest, born in the year of Revolution, 1848, and who died just after the First World War in 1922; and Rowland, the third son, born three years after George and who survived him by fifteen years. Why do they matter? G. W. Prothero became an influential historian of his generation; he played a major role in the Royal Historical Society (RHS) and was its president between 1901 and 1905. He spent the major part of his professional life as editor of the Quarterly Review in which post he succeeded his brother Rowland in 1899 and assumed the role of what nowadays we might call a public intellectual in the years before and during the First World War. R. E. Prothero was a professional author who did not hold a university post but wrote on a wide range of subjects from religion and poetry to the history of the countryside. After leaving the Quarterly he became a land-agent, later entered parliament as a Conservative and served as Lloyd George's minister of agriculture after 1916 when he was responsible for a programme to overcome the German blockade and feed the nation.Footnote 3 I have to say that it was the ‘wrong’ Prothero, Rowland, whom I came across first as a sixth-form schoolboy in the mid-1960s. Our A-Level bibliographies stood as monuments to the dead and out-of-print and I lacked the curiosity to notice that our text for rural economic history, Lord Ernle's English Farming Past and Present was in its sixth edition of 1961 which camouflaged an original date of publication in 1912. Nor did I have the remotest clue who Lord Ernle was. Only some years later, working on the politics of the First World War and beyond, did R. E. Prothero come into focus as the same man. His elder brother, ‘our’ Prothero, also remained no more than a name to me until I wrote about nineteenth-century historiography and realised that he had made sharp comments on the writing of history and participated in the nearest England ever got to a Methodenstreit concerning the right way to study it.
The brothers seem never to have been close. George cleaved to others in the family and Rowland as a younger child was left mostly to his own devices, a fate cruelly worsened when an ocular disease eventually led, with periods of remission, to total blindness.Footnote 4 Educational trajectories further separated George and Rowland for the former went off first to Eton and then King's College, Cambridge, to read classics since the Historical Tripos was not then available;Footnote 5 and Rowland to Marlborough, where he was unhappy, and Balliol College, Oxford, to read the new Modern History syllabus there and take a distinguished First Class followed by a Fellowship of All Souls. For all Rowland's achievements one senses a slight de haut en bas from George as the acknowledged family scholar and historian,Footnote 6 and an impression, compounded by Rowland's self-effacement, that the younger Prothero could claim competence as an author but little else. Yet they sprang into their careers from the same loving, clerical family, displaced from Wiltshire and Worcestershire where George and Rowland had been born, to Whippingham on the Isle of Wight where they spent their childhood. George, senior, their father, became a chaplain-in-ordinary to the queen and the family's proximity to Osborne meant that they saw much of her and the itinerant court. What the boys appropriated from Whippingham was, inadvertently, connection in its eighteenth-century form with a ‘x’ and, more consciously, churchmanship. That in itself became a further source of division because George took his Anglican stance around middle-stump and turned into a robust anti-ritualist when ritualism was the Church of England's obsession in the 1890s, while Rowland's position was, if not ritualist, then most certainly high and dry.Footnote 7 But the vicarage, home until their father died in 1894, united what religion sundered and formed both men, a fate frequently replicated in their generation.
Possibly this generation within the age of Prothero would prove the last to demonstrate so compellingly its origins in rectory, vicarage and manse and to issue in historians who, ecclesiastical or not in their focus, bore through their lives that indelible imprint. George's friend John Robert Seeley, from the generation before his own, still carried the virus of rationalist evangelicalism instilled at home and had produced not only an heretical life of Christ in Ecce Homo (1865) – ‘vomited from the jaws of hell’ as the dependable Lord Shaftesbury was heard to exclaim – and who went on to develop the idea of a National Church that had more to do with Stein's ambitions for the post-Napoleonic German lands than a realistic reading of British prospects.Footnote 8 Or bring to mind Samuel Rawson Gardiner, his eccentric childhood in the Catholic Apostolic Church and his later marriage to its founder's daughter. In the Prothero generation itself one thinks of the Plummers, Alfred and Charles, descended from the vicar of Heworth, once part of the parish of Jarrow with its echoes of Bede. Charles would hold the chaplaincy of Corpus Christi College, Oxford, from 1875 to his death in 1927 – fifty-two years! – whilst distinguishing himself in Anglo-Saxon history with his other hand.Footnote 9 Or perhaps of James Headlam-Morley, son of another vicar and brother of Arthur Headlam who became bishop of Gloucester. There are those historians of the Church itself: James Pounder Whitney, son of the perpetual curate of Marsden, ordained priest in 1885, and who after the First World War fused the Dixie Chair in Cambridge with the rectory of Wicken Bonhunt in Essex.Footnote 10 There was the terrifying H. M. Gwatkin, Whitney's predecessor and Mandell Creighton's successor in the Dixie Chair, who, following his four first degrees – how satisfying that he was placed in the First Class only in three of them – went on to compound a clerical childhood by taking Orders himself.Footnote 11 Then there were the churchmen who were also front-rank historians: Dean Stanley, son of a future bishop of Norwich, who wrote Dr Arnold's life; Dean Church, who made up for a secular father who had traded in Portuguese wines by writing the history of the Oxford Movement; Mandell Creighton who was bishop of London; William Cunningham, the economic historian, who became archdeacon of Ely; and of course, too early to count but too seminal to exclude, William Stubbs who moved from the Regius Chair in Oxford to its bishopric.Footnote 12 They join up with the Protheros, all these luminaries – not least through Rowland who wrote the life of Dean Stanley and a widely selling book on the Psalms.Footnote 13
But they join together, too, through the mood of febrile concern over the future of English Protestantism and its relation to the state that so characterises the two decades either side of 1900. Those elements of the controversy that separated George and Rowland Prothero found their reflection in the wider historical community as the plain, unproblematic Protestantism of a James Anthony Froude or Edward Augustus Freeman encountered a more rampant version whose roots might equally lead down into evangelicalism or a newly aggressive Anglo-Catholicism that looked back on the Tractarians as a precious heritage. The sometimes farcical trial of the ritualist bishop of Lincoln, Edward King, in the late 1880s merely decorated some deeper attitudes that reached the thought and work of historians quite as much as others in the intellectual community; and those thoughts turned on possible doom for a church divided. George Prothero thought it likely, in the privacy of his diary, that schism must come out of the antics of ritualists and that disestablishment would follow.Footnote 14 Rowland, who had taken Holy Orders himself as the King trial proceeded, took the other side ten years later in telling the medievalist John Horace Round that ‘the “cant” of the Evangelical makes me creep all over’.Footnote 15 For Montagu Burrows, a colleague of Rowland's at All Souls and holder of the Chichele Chair at Oxford, the Church of England was not the enemy; instead he focused on the Roman Catholics. Gathering that a proposal was imminent to make Lord Acton an honorary Fellow of his College in 1890, Burrows began his protest, as all bigots do, by proclaiming that he was not a bigot, and then quickly got into his stride:
If he comes much to College we shall be liable to have his Romanist friends more with us than we may wish and . . . they are ‘all tarred with same brush’. . . [A]nd if we elect Roman Catholics others will follow. The history of Oxford has surely not been written in vain.Footnote 16
One begins to see why the young Lewis Namier's later rejection by the same College had a certain inevitablity about it since Jews were presumably more ‘other’ even than Catholics.Footnote 17
Back at Whippingham in the 1860s the two Protheros knew nothing of these troubled waters gathering for the future and they made their way into their universities expecting to develop professional careers. George intended to become an academic historian and duly became one for a time. Rowland had ambitions in the Law but his eyesight deserted him and made it impossible. Both their wanderings throw light on some key tendencies. As a Fellow of King's College, Cambridge, George Prothero completed his first book, a biography of Simon de Montfort, in 1877. It is hard to know which predicament gave him the most difficulty: that Stubbs had not completed the second volume of his Constitutional History or that Reinhold Pauli had published his own life of de Montfort as Prothero wrote.Footnote 18 For whatever reason, Prothero's book was not very good, which is presumably why Cambridge University Press turned it down; it is remembered for youthful excess (‘the pent up spirit of feudalism burst forth’) and its echoing of Stubbs, who read the proofs, in identifying the parliament of 1295 as the embryo of all that followed.Footnote 19 But we have a better reason for remembering it. Prothero had wanted to teach for King's but the requirement was for medieval teaching: he wrote the book in order to teach its contents to undergraduates. Here is a rich and distinctive theme in the fin-de-siècle university. The development of professionalised dissemination in historical work produced the inverse of what we today regard as de rigueur. For in the age of Prothero it proved less important to supply research-led teaching than it did teaching-led research. So many streams fed into that development, the widest, perhaps, in a changing clientele. Memorising the text book would still do in many departments of history; but in the better schools and colleges a demand now existed for, at the very least, textbooks written by experts. Publishers drove that vehicle and expanded its range through their increasing contact with professional historians. And one did not write for Macmillans or Murrays or Longmans, or Duckworths: one wrote for Alexander Macmillan or John Murray or Charles Longman, or Gerald Duckworth; one knew those men personally; one dined with them at one's club. They knew what would sell and in an explosion of secondary and tertiary provision in education from the late 1880s a new market arose from the school and university syllabus. It was the beginning of a process that has come to dominate academic outputs in the twentieth century: the complex negotiation that makes academics write the things that they never wanted to write in the first place and which gives their books an intellectual patina that their publishers would gladly do without but on which academic historians insist for their own self-respect.Footnote 20
A related and powerful feature of this environment arises in Prothero's third book, perhaps his best known. Select Statutes and Other Documents Illustrative of the Reigns of Elizabeth and James I appeared in 1894 but its inception dated from 1885 when regulations governing the recently introduced Historical Tripos in Cambridge allowed for the provision of a special subject; and the point of Prothero's collection of documents lay in presenting students with an array of constitutional documents for the purpose of mounting precisely that form of tuition. These years mark the apex of constitutional history, through which Prothero and colleagues in other universities could direct their advanced teaching. But this book also suggested something deeper. Prothero's collection stood among his contributions to editing texts and documents. Between them, he and Rowland played a lifelong tennis-match in edition: George edited Thierry's letters; but Rowland edited Gibbon's. George translated and edited some Ranke; but Rowland edited Byron in six volumes. George edited Voltaire on the age of Louis XIV; but then Rowland edited the Hispanist, Richard Ford. George and Rowland both edited the Quarterly Review. Deuce. But George edited the Cambridge Modern History and then, a crushing ace, the twenty-five volumes produced by the historical section of the Foreign Office after the First World War. Game, set and match. Whilst ever Rowland's eyes held out, not a year passed when the Protheros did not have in hand the work of editing and annotating and, though they may have been extreme in their devotion to that art, they reflected a generational imperative, for the age of Prothero was an age of edition.
It was a new kind of edition. Certainly the enthusiasm of an amateur devoting labour and love in order to interest others in a chosen subject still abounded: Joseph Gillow editing his English Catholics in five volumes; George Hill editing Boswell in six; Helen Foxcroft editing Halifax and Gilbert Burnet; Herbert Maxwell editing Creevey: it is not difficult to extend such a list.Footnote 21 Yet from that day in 1884 when Frederic William Maitland walked into the Public Record Office and emerged with his edition of Pleas for the Crown in the County of Gloucester, presaging the three volumes presenting and annotating Bracton's Note Book in 1887, history had changed for good.Footnote 22 This was not amateur enthusiasm; it was professional specialism and its rigours formed the contours of British historiography in this generation. Of course medievalists had Stubbs's Select Charters at their backFootnote 23 and knew the value of precise scholarship. The clinical eye of this generation, however, could encourage the congenital editor: a Plummer with his Bede, a Round with his Pipe Rolls, above all the phenomenon of W. H. Stevenson who between 1882 and 1916 staggered under the weight of paper he edited from the records of the boroughs of Nottingham and Gloucester and the eleven volumes of the Calendars of Close Rolls through his edition of Asser on Alfred to the index of place-names, his sole relaxation.Footnote 24 The early modernists were not far behind with Charles Harding Firth's editions of Lucy Hutchinson, Edmund Ludlow and the Clarke Papers, or J. R. Tanner's edition of Samuel Pepys's correspondence. The modernists, not an available mental category in this period, of necessity courted reticence because the material for editing was still sensitive, as those hoping to edit the queen soon discovered, and because documentary history stopped in 1815 where politics and journalism began. Their efforts swung away from texts and towards editing and contributing to the vast collective enterprises that dominated their day either side of the century's turn: the Dictionary of National Biography and the Cambridge Modern History.
Almost twenty years had gone into the original DNB when it was completed in June 1900 though the Supplements were still to come.Footnote 25 It had begun with an editor, George Smith, and had been carried forward, famously, by Sir Leslie Stephen who lived to see the end; but for the age of Prothero the significant forces would prove to be two assistants who shouldered the main burden in the later years: Solomon Lee, better known to an anti-Semitic society as Sidney Lee, and Albert Pollard who would go on to make the Tudor period his own. Lee contributed 820 articles to the Dictionary, frightening enough as a statistic but awesome when one of his articles, required by Queen Victoria's death in January 1901, ran to 94,000 tentative and wavering words. Pollard ran him close with 500 articles over his name. But the commitments ran far beyond the project's editorial team. Firth, for example, wrote over 200 articles for the venture, Tout some 240. The historical community as a whole became sucked into a remarkable success in editorial publishing. The Cambridge Modern History began also with an editorial vision, not from a publisher but from the teeming brain of Lord Acton who designed the shape of the project, commissioned many of its authors and wrote the celebrated letter of guidance to contributors, one of the most-quoted texts in modern historiography. He then died without writing a word of the venture he had brought into being.Footnote 26 The team left behind to prosecute the project through the eleven volumes that occupied the next ten years faced a back-breaking task of calling in chapters and making them ready for the press. Two of them did the the bulk of the work: Adolphus Ward who had just accepted the Mastership of Peterhouse, Cambridge, and who now had to manage both responsibilities; and the gay bon-viveur of Trinity College, Stanley Leathes. Between them these two scholars made regular contributions to the volumes as well as editing the whole. A third editor was today's hero, George Prothero, who had originally been asked to edit the whole thing by himself.Footnote 27 But he was in his third year of editing and writing for the Quarterly, as well as presiding over the RHS, and could find precious little time to write chapters for the Modern History. In fact he wrote only for volume iv on the Thirty Years War.Footnote 28 Going beyond the editorial team into the contents pages of each volume is a journey into the heartland of English historical writing – some contributors writing several chapters, often far outside their specialisms – and increasingly, as the volumes proceeded, into many centres of European intellectual life for reasons to which we should return.
These interventions had cosmic size and significance but what did all this editorial effort mean? Description is easy, after all; explanation comes harder. Why now? Why a generational commitment to the editing, the annotating, the grounding of text? Simple availability has something to say about it. The opening of the Public Record Office in 1857, the work of the Rolls Series and many provincial societies dedicated to publishing local sources, the RHS in which Prothero took so great an interest, the British Academy's foundation in 1902, the Historical Association in 1906: all these developments accelerated the possibility of, as much as the need for, editions of historical material that would be reliable and form the platform for future study. Relatedly, their generation saw itself as working at the beginning of something important in historical work. They had read their Macaulay and Stubbs, their Freeeman and their Froude but they raised their eyes and their game: they wanted a more scientific understanding of the past which would place historians on the same level and in the same mental universe as those experimenters and inventors, mathematicians and philosophers who were changing the face of human knowledge in late Victorian Britain.Footnote 29 We have to ask our own questions, however, about the character of that knowledge. What the historians wanted, above all, was facts, the motif of these years. If they revered narrative any longer it was the grinding factuality of Samuel Rawson Gardiner's eighteen volumes that earned their admiration, constructed as they were within the walls of the archive and avoiding what he austerely called ‘knowledge which has long been common property’.Footnote 30 Editions grounded that knowledge. Besides, narrative was transitory while editions seemed permanent. In a world convinced that all history began with its sources and their ‘authorities’ (what a significant word), texts formed the building blocks on which everything else must one day rest, part of a building-site where one could make a difference to the solidity of what was coming to be thought of as a discipline. The Protheros played their small part in the process of change within that discipline and their early careers point to three of its locations, each significant in itself and all interesting for none of them having been English.
II
In 1873 George Prothero, now a Fellow of King's, set off for Bonn in the new German Reich with the intention of studying with Heinrich von Sybel. At this stage of his career Sybel, founder of the Historische Zeitschrift, soon to become director of the Prussian state archives, had not yet become part of the infamous trio: Sybel, Treitschke, Meinecke. Prothero's year there seems to have been less than happy and he came away with a critical view of German Quellenkritik in which, he thought, procedure did duty for creativity. The Germans were far too ready, he later complained to Oscar Browning, ‘to stop at a collection of facts, to let the facts speak for themselves . . . One wants a people with more imagination, with less caution, perhaps, to extract the essence from the material they collect, & that is what we ought to do in England.’Footnote 31 But the greatest German historian, Leopold von Ranke, had been extracting essence, the true referent for eigentlich,Footnote 32 for fifty years and was still going strong. It was his work, and not the inflamed writing of Sybel and his colleagues, whose translation into English had been organised by Stubbs: indeed George Prothero would himself translate part of the vast and unfinished Universal History.Footnote 33 The point is that Germany had established its reputation as the premier historical culture in Europe, soon to be challenged by the claims of Paris; and young scholars from England who felt serious about their work received encouragement to go there to learn the language and assimilate German method. Rowland Prothero followed his brother there a few years later, this time to Darmstadt, to improve his German. So did Headlam-Morley who worked under Treitschke and Delbrück in Berlin. Charles Harding Firth went, too, with portentous consequences a quarter of a century later when, as the new Regius Professor of Modern History at Oxford, he tried to impose on recalcitrant colleagues the advantages of German Hilfswissenschaften as ancillary tools for the historical research that he believed Oxford students should carry out.Footnote 34 An unimpressed Charles Oman soon put a stop to that if only through his knack of pronouncing Hilfswissenschaften to make them sound like a German sewage system.Footnote 35
Yet in a sense Firth's battle was won though he died believing himself defeated. Curriculum reform had made some difference in the adoption of the special subject even if Belgium's other famous historian, Paul Fredericq, had found fault with English provision in his probing inspection in the early 1880s.Footnote 36 The English professoriate could not approach the German in number and quality, perhaps; but the size and range of the history schools in Oxford, Cambridge and Tout's Manchester broadcast a developing confidence by turn of century.Footnote 37 The real indicator of German success might be found in two particular events all the same: the founding of the English Historical Review (EHR) in 1886 on lines plainly reflecting the German model; and the appointment to Cambridge's Regius Chair of Modern History in 1895 of the man whose impenetrable article on ‘German Schools of History’ had launched the first number of the EHR Footnote 38 and who could claim to be Britain's most cosmopolitan, as well as most knowledgeable, student of history. EHR's origins are too well known to rehearse here, though we might reasonably resist the idea that the founders were moved by ‘exclusiveness’: they merely held a view of factuality that outlawed imprecision, a trait shared by George Prothero, as we shall see in a moment.Footnote 39 Well established by 1900, the journal had become driven, through the later years of Mandell Creighton's editorship, by one of the most attractive and impressive men of his generation, Reginald Lane Poole, who alone edited seventy-nine issues of EHR when teaching fifteen hours of tutorials and delivering six lectures every week in term and reading history in his five European languages or turning for relaxation to his studies in Latin, Greek, Hebrew and Arabic.Footnote 40
George Prothero, meanwhile, had reason to resent Lord Acton's intrusion: he had nursed some hopes, in the reticence of his diary, that he himself might be appointed to the Regius Chair, if only as a Stop-Oscar-Browning candidate.Footnote 41 Acton's appointment brought none the less a sense that historical thought had arrived at the pinnacle of the profession. Acton's greatest critic and greatest supporter, Herbert Butterfield, reflected in 1954 that Acton's presence marked a turning tide and his premature death an ebbing one. ‘[H]e stands in 1900’, Butterfield said in his Wiles Lectures, ‘on the crest of what might be called a great wave of historical thinking; and perhaps it is not going too far to say that the wave has been receding ever since’.Footnote 42 Acton's illness and death brought a lesser man into the chair in J. B. Bury with his over-egged inaugural lecture hailing historical science ‘no less and no more’.Footnote 43 Yet, again, Bury's cause needed no manifesto by 1902: it had become implicit in the way a younger generation thought about history and how to prosecute it.
Had Prothero's dream of the Regius Chair come to fruition he would have had to return to England from our second distant location. For in 1894 the University of Edinburgh had announced a new chair in history and Prothero decided to put forward his name. Why he wanted it remains unclear. Perhaps he felt that his Cambridge career had lost impetus; he had certainly associated himself with Seeley's reforms and turned into a young Turk. He may have felt that a fresh start would reinvigorate him pedagogically – he confessed to growing ‘rather tired of going over the same subject so often’Footnote 44 – or at least enliven his curriculum vitae. There was an inside candidate in Peter Hume Brown, biographer of George Buchanan, author of a textbook on early modern Scotland and about to complete a life of John Knox.Footnote 45 Maybe these interests suggested a temperament better fitted to Edinburgh's cultural climate. But if Prothero, once appointed, had hoped for a better life, then those hopes soon darkened in that first, dark winter. He tried to stay cheerful. ‘Eight lectures a week’, he told Seeley in December, ‘give me plenty of employment when added to the monthly exam[inatio]ns which the classes have to go through.’Footnote 46 Optimism waned when he came to see himself as nothing more than a machine for ‘grinding out lectures’ and having no time to read or think,Footnote 47 which is doubtless why, when his brother relinquished the editorship of the Quarterly Review in 1899, Prothero responded positively to the chance of succeeding him.Footnote 48 His own unhappiness in Edinburgh, fuelled by the greater sadness of his wife, should not blind us, all the same, to the burgeoning significance of Scottish historical cultureFootnote 49 and its professionalisation within British historiography as a whole. Just as Prothero moved to the Edinburgh Chair, another Englishman, Richard Lodge, took the Chair of Modern History, likewise newly created, at Glasgow; he then succeeded Prothero at Edinburgh where he remained happily for a quarter of a century. Chairs specialising in Scottish history then came into being in both Glasgow and Edinburgh within a few years.Footnote 50 Or consider the less metropolitan perspective offered by the Carlyles – Robert and Alexander – sons of the manse from Brechin who witnessed to that fusion of experience between Scotland and the Empire, about which John MacKenzie has reminded us, before their great work on medieval political thought appeared in the second half of their lives.Footnote 51 The Bryces, too, had highland roots and James might have been a happier man if they had remained attached there; but the family uprooted to Northern Ireland and the historian of American democracy discovered himself to be that formidable thing, an Ulster Presbyterian.Footnote 52 Ireland and Wales meanwhile deserve more than a footnote to the same story. When Bury arrived in Cambridge he did so from Trinity College, Dublin, and it was at the Queen's University, Belfast, that Maurice Powicke occupied his first chair before coming to Tout's Manchester. And would Tout's Manchester have become what it was without the crucial three years that Tout had spent at St David's College, Lampeter, where he learned how to teach? The impact of Bangor on H. W. C. Davis admittedly turned out harder to document. ‘I know that ninety per cent of my pupils are fools’, he wailed to the Warden of All Souls, ‘but I always have the hope that with patience I may discover a genius among the other ten’.Footnote 53 He ran out of patience within the year and returned to Oxford.
But let us follow Prothero to Edinburgh and see what he was doing there as a microcosm of his age. We can do that because he left a detailed Nachlass of his lectures and reading from which a fascinating image focuses of how history was taught to undergraduates in the late 1890s. Prothero lectured on everything from the Greeks to the nineteenth century, with British coverage one year and European the next. He took close notes from what he still called ‘authorities’, many of which were general texts – Macaulay, J. R. Green, Freeman and so on – but also German texts: Below, Maurer, Eichhorn, Gfroerer.Footnote 54 He then made a time-line of parallel events across territory or category. The lectures themselves were written in almost unintelligible abbreviation but seem to have been mostly read out from his pencilled text. What they contained was information arranged in chronological order, not out of convenience but on principle. He told his audience this at the beginning of some lectures on Russian history in remarks that would have struck him as obvious:
History is a study or science of the sequence of events. Thus chronological order is essential to history & the purpose of history is to relate and explain that chronological order, to say what the events were, and why this event followed and did not precede that, and why it was this event and not some other.Footnote 55
One would have to go a long way to find a better adumbration of l'histoire événementielle as a positively charged doctrine, from a reader, incidentally, of Seignobos;Footnote 56 it speaks volumes for the epistemology, as well as the pedagogy, of Prothero's generation. The dependence on chronological knowledge also strikes up from his examination papers which we also have and which we should all assuredly fail, through ignorance in my case, through a failure to acquire speed-writing in yours. General British History, 19 March 1895. Two Hours. Answer not more than seven questions. Question 4: Write a short life of Clive or Wolfe. Question 7: Compare the positions of Walpole, Lord North and William Pitt as Prime Ministers. One begins to see where Sellar and Yeatman found their material.Footnote 57 February 1896: What do you know of the Statute of Gloucester, the Statute of Praemunire, Sir John Falstaff, the Treaty of Pecquigni, the Star Chamber? Behind the humour of our world lies distance from his and behind the distance a parallel universe of assumption about the nature of our subject.
In our own current context of the Anglo-American Conference of Historians it is a pleasure as much as a requirement to place beside the German and the Scottish a third historical culture of escalating importance as the nineteenth century became the twentieth. George Prothero again leads us there for in 1910 he went to deliver a course of twenty-eight lectures at Harvard on ‘The Making of the British Empire’, anticipating the visits of Harold Temperley in 1913 and Albert Pollard in the following year. The visit mattered to Prothero in opening lines of contact with senior figures in the American historical establishment, as we shall see in thinking about the impact of the war in 1914. But it also symbolised an emerging congruence. The new graduate schools at Johns Hopkins and Columbia had now produced a generation of home-trained scholars, some of whom directed their attention at British history. An older one had brought its expertise to bear on traditional British concerns: the empire and sea-power with Alfred Thayer Mahon. But, in the generations of Charles Gross, James Baldwin and C. H. McIlwain, we see a turn to British constitutional history that would make a fundamental contribution to its direction as a reverse side of what Peter Novick called American Anglo-SaxonismFootnote 58 and deserves a lecture to itself. One important export we might note from the British side was the Scot, Morse Stephens, a future president of the American Historical Association who emigrated to the US in 1894 and assumed an active historical career, first at Cornell and then for many years at Berkeley.
III
Where, then, in this widening gyre of historical sites and concerns do we find an impact in the nature of the writing itself? One might expect a new thrust towards the history of Germany and France, for example, but the expectation seems only patchily satisfied, as Professor Robert Evans reminded us in his recent Creighton Lecture.Footnote 59 Outside Adolphus Ward for whom Germany was home, that country's history, so far as British historians were concerned, remained in the hands of military men such as G. B. Malleson or those with German experience as in a James Headlam-Morley.Footnote 60 France hardly fared better. The ecclesiastical historian W. H. Jervis (né Pearson) contributed a general history; Louise Creighton, wife of Mandell, included a volume on France among her historical primers for the young.Footnote 61 Acton's lectures on the French Revolution came out posthumously in 1910. Yet the anniversaries of Oliver Cromwell and King Alfred came closer to home in the fin de siècle than had the centenary of the Revolution in 1889.Footnote 62 If anything the balance of power between Britain and the Continent swung the other way, as in the American case, with Frenchmen such as Charles Petit-Dutaillis, Charles Bémont and the young Elie Halévy taking an interest in British history and Germans making an impact on, say, eighteenth- century studies of British politics in the manner of Wolfgang Michael and Albert von Ruville.Footnote 63 An interesting project consists in counting how many essays on European or extra-European subjects for the Cambridge Modern History were written by British authors: frequent enough in the early volumes but scarcer by volume vi.Footnote 64 George Prothero had already borne witness to the problem in his final presidential address to the RHS in 1904. ‘We in England’, he said, ‘are badly off for foreign histories in general – where are we to look for an adequate history of France or Germany or Italy or Spain or Russia, written in England for English readers and embodying the results of recent research?’Footnote 65
Within English constitutional culture, meanwhile, it is important to locate absence as much as presence and in the age of Prothero one can hear four separate forms of silence. England possessed neither a Lamprecht nor yet a body professionally aspirant Jungrankianer to fret about one; so the bitterness of argument over method that disfigured German universities made virtually no impact in Britain outside the new field of economics, apart from raised eyebrows at the inaugural lectures of Bury and Firth.Footnote 66 England possessed, second, no Berr or Bloch or Febvre; and the proto-annalistes made no appearance across the Channel. England did have, for a time, Charles Beard;Footnote 67 but the forces that would take American academia in the direction of Paris after 1903 failed, thirdly, to generate in England. And finally where is the voice of women in this masculine and imperial age? John Richard Green's protégée, Kate Norgate (1853–1935), had won a reputation as a defender of Freeman against his detractors but strongest among female whispers at turn of century was that of Mary Bateson (1865–1906) of Newnham College, Cambridge, who achieved professional success through qualities of intellect but also through being a Bateson, daughter of the Master of St John's College and related through her elder sister to the Heitlands. Hers was a minority voice in this period, for all her distinction, and a brain haemorrhage swept even that away when she died at the age of forty-one in the same year as Maitland.Footnote 68 It would be the next generation in which the voice of women gathered strength.Footnote 69
It is all too easy, on the other hand, to amplify silences by starting in the wrong place, because in at least one respect Britain had, as we have seen, been feeling the weight of German historical culture for some years, not only in its constitutionalism but also in a new economic history that found a considerable audience in the country whose Industrial Revolution came first. The tradition says that the school of National Economy in Germany – principally List, Roscher, Schmoller, Knies and Hildebrand – became a model for economic historians in Britain.Footnote 70 Looking back on these currents of thought thirty years later, R. H. Tawney still thought them fundamental.Footnote 71 Whatever the inspiration, from the time of Arnold Toynbee's lectures on the Industrial Revolution published in 1884,Footnote 72 the concerns of economic history moved away from the wings of the national stage. They gained currency through the work of William Cunningham at Cambridge, William Ashley, in Toronto after 1888 but an habitué of Oxford and Göttingen, and a young Fellow of King's College, Cambridge, called John Clapham who fought a bitter war with colleagues to insist on the teaching of economic history within the Cambridge syllabus and who first professed it in 1928.Footnote 73
This mode of working had its hard and technical side: some found it rebarbative. But there existed too a long tradition of humanist scholarship in economic thought, one running from Cobbett through Ruskin and Hobson and into a generation that voiced anxieties about modern capitalism and its effects on ordinary people unprotected by birth or private means. Here a junction existed between economic critique and a liberal, or at least social-democratic politics. It had an imperial wing, unsurprisingly in these years of the Boer War, Joseph Chamberlain's campaign for imperial preference in commercial policy and the benefactions of Rhodes and Beit establishing imperial history securely if on a fairly narrow base. It also had a rural wing occupied by those who believed that urbanisation and enclosure of open fields had destroyed much quality of life for the rural poor in the early years of the nineteenth century. As the Great Depression, mythical or not, became a firm impression in the 1890s, the idea of an historical countryside worth reviving for a modern readership held an obvious attraction to authors and one of them was Rowland Prothero.
We left him trying to cope with incipient blindness in the early 1880s. He did so in a remarkable way. Gathering old clothes and boots and a little money, he set off to walk the length and breadth of France, living cheaply and resting his eyes on the French landscape, its farms and fields. When he returned with vision partially restored he decided to try his hand at writing for a living and contributed, among many other pieces, some articles to the Manchester Guardian on the rural depression. He had always taken an interest in farming since Whippingham days – the rectory had a bit of land attached to it – but on the cusp of the new century his life changed forever when the duke of Bedford invited him to become his land agent at a salary five times that paid by the Quarterly with a pension of a thousand a year and the run of and free accommodation in five country houses. The post gave him unparalleled access to farming practice and blended with a culture of rural commentary from Frederic Seebohm's influential meditation on The Village Community to an expanding documentary literature;Footnote 74 and as interest slid towards expertise he expanded an earlier manuscript into the book with which I began, English Farming Past and Present (1912). By that time he had competition, not least from a young female voice. In 1895, whilst Prothero was deep in writing and editing, a female examination candidate of Lady Margaret Hall in Oxford topped the Greats’ class list in her year and met along the way Lawrence Hammond. The marriage of Barbara Bradby and Hammond produced one of those Edwardian powerhouses of writing alongside the Webbs and the Chesterbelloc. Their first major work, The Village Labourer (1911), a scream against the evils of enclosure, may stand with Prothero's blander survey of rural life. In its own way, and against the current of a far more powerful political, constitutional and legal historiography, the age of Prothero had begun a peculiarly English form of social history.
Rowland's excitements meant that when George Prothero accepted the presidency of the RHS in 1901, succeeding Adolphus Ward, he was already editing the Quarterly and hoping to ride both horses. His direction at the RHS was more eirenic than revolutionary but he did move forward one idea for which he has been blessed by those who benefited and damned by those who had to carry it out. He thought it would be nice if there were to be an RHS Bibliography of British history,Footnote 75 a vast engine of misery under whose pistons have since perished many good men and women.Footnote 76 But in honesty he had little time for writing any history himself and his many articles for the Quarterly were about other things. In fact George Prothero had begun to drift, like his brother, towards becoming a public figure known to those who controlled the state, once it became clear that he would not be elected provost of King's in 1905 – another disappointment.Footnote 77 When the Master of the Rolls needed a new member for an advisory committee on the publication of public records in 1912, he turned to Prothero who by then had become a man known to club-room and west-end society.Footnote 78 The deepening crisis over German nationalism Prothero already knew well from his days with Sybel; and his evaluation of the German character turned into a harsher form of Germanophobia. Rowland, for his part, entered the House of Commons at a by-election in 1914 just as his old tennis partner at Balliol was declaring that the lights were going out all over Europe. Their own lights were about to do the same. Once sportsmen together, Rowland Prothero and Edward Grey went blind together.
IV
The war terminated the age of Prothero but it would have terminated anyway because its brightest lights were now in their sixties and presiding over the historical work of new dynasties. To R. L. Poole, father of Austin, one should now add a younger generation – that of H. W. C. Davis, father of Ralph, of Bernard Pares father of Richard, of Robert Seton-Watson, father of Hugh, of Albert Pollard of this College, UCL, of H. A. L. Fisher, of Maurice Powicke, of Harold Temperley, of the younger Toynbee and Lewis Namier born within a year of one another. London's hosting of the then International Congress of Historical Sciences in 1913 under the presidency of James Bryce and the organising energy of Harold Temperley presented an opportunity for much of this talent, including Prothero's, to find a role.Footnote 79 But war with the Central Powers supplied a final occasion and duty to rally to the support of their own state. Rarely does one read a biography of an historian from these generations without watching its subject disappear into the maw of Whitehall after 1914 to work in intelligence or propaganda or supply expert knowledge of little-known territories. For George Prothero it brought a late but real recognition. He turned his facile pen against Berlin in a series of powerful broadsides presenting the British case for resistance and deploying historical knowledge as his most effective weapon.Footnote 80 Eighteenth-century connecton came into its own as Prothero maintained a huge correspondence with overseas countries, especially the United States. Not every historian had their war relieved by letters from inside the Washington embassy. Still fewer received letters beginning ‘Dear Uncle George’.Footnote 81 But Prothero's writ ran far beyond family, thanks to his Harvard visit, in an extensive interchange with Lawrence Lowell, Charles Elliott and especially the historian of Europe, Roger B. Merriman. Historians in France, meanwhile, kept him abreast of events there, especially Henri Omont who, bunkered in the Bibliothèque Nationale, took a magnificently archival view of the carnage on the Western Front in 1915. ‘[H]euresement les vieux manuscrits de Rheims, Soisson et Arras ont pu être mis en sureté.’ Meanwhile at home connection could oil wheels which might otherwise jam. Witness the delicious majesté of Victoria, Lady Wemyss, who was married to the Admiralty and used its writing-paper as her own.
Dear Mr. Prothero,
I spoke to my husband about your projected visit to the Fleet and I am sure he will do everything to have matters facilitated for you. . .Footnote 82
So, when the new historical section of the Foreign Office needed an impresario to guide their pamphlets on the peace, Prothero's status as a public figure made him an obvious choice. Had the notorious ‘flu’ not got him in 1919 he would have been in the thick of things at Versailles as were so many of his historical colleagues declaiming to deaf ears what they ought to learn from the lessons of the Congress of Vienna a century before.Footnote 83 The end of the war brought the end for both Protheros, too, and history would make its next moves in different hands but ones which their generation had trained.
Standing back from these two generations it becomes a simple matter to see them as part of a process, as Charles Crawley did when he looked back to his uncle's ‘typify[ing] the process of transition among English historians from the amateur to the professional’.Footnote 84 We have a similar implication in the common view that the age represents a transition from whig history to something better. I have quarrelled with this latter judgement in a recent book and shall not repeat that quarrel here. If I have to differ from Crawley's view let me at least differ from his use of a poisonous notion. No age is ‘transitional’ – a word we might profitably delete from our lexicon. George Prothero had translated Ranke and would have known the great man's mantra jede Epoche ist unmittelbar zu Gott, best rendered into English by the Augustinian thought that every age is equidistant from eternity. The period of Maitland and Firth and Tout and Poole was not some groping apprenticeship, trying to master the basics of modernisation theory. It behoves us to consider it in its own terms as an exciting and accomplished moment in British historiography. The age had its silences, its failures, as does ours. It committed itself to a vision of knowledge that we may feel it necessary to question and revise. It brought to bear an unconscious apparatus of criticism and social observation about empire and race and class that feels strange and sometimes uncomfortable to us. But it also broadcast an image of intelligence, humanity and above all service that can teach resonantly to an over-professionalised, celebrity-ridden historical culture that permits itself various styles of stupidity as the assumed cost of disinterest, and imposes forms of self-harm as an assumed requirement of intellectual hygiene. It is not in despite of its own terms but rather because of them that a later, very different historical community might wish to reconsider the age of Prothero. Those historians who comprised it – their perspectives, their diligence, their narratives, their values, for all their blind-spots and shortened horizons – those historians merit and more than merit our collective recall.
