Justin Roberts’ Slavery and the Enlightenment uses comparative history to good advantage. Roberts puts large slave plantations in three places—Jamaica, Barbados, and Virginia—into conversation to argue for similarities in plantation-management systems across the traditional Caribbean/North American divide in the late eighteenth century. In doing so he adds an important dimension to a growing body of hemispheric work in the Atlantic world.
Although Caribbean sugar and North American grains demanded very different cultivation techniques, Roberts maintains that planters in both places were “heavily influenced by the same pan-Atlantic Enlightenment discourses” (p. 7). Notably, a belief in the possibilities of improvement: both improved economic efficiency and amelioration in the conditions of slavery. These goals were mostly compatible in an Enlightenment worldview that promoted the idea of work as morally redemptive. But when the amelioration project conflicted with the productivity-improvement project, Roberts notes that amelioration was thrown under the bus. Roberts examines the intersection between Enlightenment theory and plantation-management practice by reading advice literature and plantation manuals against work logs and increase and decrease accounts for the three locations. His use of work logs in particular is very thorough. Slavery and the Enlightenment is a book that is well grounded in its sources.
Roberts examines four plantations: Prospect in Jamaica, a 500-acre estate with 162 slaves, almost exclusively devoted to sugar; Newton and Seawell, linked estates in Barbados, with 459 and 345 acres and 255 and 182 slaves respectively, which diversified somewhat into cotton; and Mount Vernon in Virginia, George Washington's plantation, with 8,000 acres and 317 slaves, which cultivated grains. The slave population on Prospect was predominantly African-born and not self-reproducing; the populations on Newton and Seawell, were majority creole slaves and were close to self-reproducing and the Mount Vernon slave population grew from natural reproduction. Roberts uses these two other variables: creolization and natural reproduction to undercut the dominance of crops in dictating plantation-management strategies. He rounds out his examination with complementary data and evidence from other nearby plantations, like Thomas Thistlewood's Jamaican sugar estate.
Roberts offers three additional interventions in the study of slavery. He conceives of slavery not as a qualitatively different labor regime, but as an extreme form of coerced labor in a hierarchical world where most labor was unfree. He also posits plantations as flexible and innovative institutions, with capitalist tendencies, instead of resistant to change. Lastly, he contests the emphasis in recent historical work on slave agency, arguing that slaves were not autonomous actors, but workers heavily constrained by a coercive labor system.
Slavery and the Enlightenment is neatly divided into two parts, which can roughly be categorized as the ideas and practices of planters (Part I) and the lived working experiences of slaves (Part II). Roberts begins by examining the supremacy of the clock as an instrument of Enlightenment progress and precision. For planters in all three locations, productivity gains came predominantly from an intensification of labor and slave plantations preceded by early factories in their reliance on time discipline and standardization to get there. Chapter two looks at the differences between mono- and multi-cropping estates, which Roberts argues were as important as the differences between the Chesapeake and the Caribbean (p. 129). The final chapter in the first section focuses on gang labor, which was a main form of labor organization in the sugar-growing Caribbean. The gang-labor system was both an apprenticeship system and a means to create a division of labor.
The second part begins with a look at the sick house, which epitomizes the way that amelioration in the early modern world had a harsh dimension. Sick houses were designed as disciplinary and coercive institutions and were not necessarily a nicer (or healthier) place to be than the field (p. 166). Chapter five argues for the growing importance of skilled labor in the plantation system, at a time when the early Industrial Revolution in Europe entailed a deskilling of labor and elision of craft status (p. 209). The final chapter examines hierarchies within the slave community and the impact those hierarchies had on work. While planters organized slaves into gangs, slaves organized themselves into family and kinship groups, passing down skills and privileged positions between generations.
For non-specialists, the sheer amount of detail that Roberts offers in terms of plantation agriculture is also illuminating. His descriptions of the importance and backbreaking work of digging sugar cane holes (“holing”) and manuring the cane (“dunging”) suggest that these agricultural tasks were the most labor-intensive—and deadliest—of plantation activities. His attention to gender is also noteworthy. Roberts points out that women were subjected to fieldwork in equal terms as men, and some women in the Caribbean served as gang leaders.
Although Roberts has done an admirable job of exploring creolization and natural increase, in the end, crops creep back in. This is because of the significant role of seasonality in determining agricultural practices and seasonality was based on crops. Holing and dunging were unique to the Caribbean, as was the gang organization of labor (at Mount Vernon slaves were only organized into gangs for the wheat harvest). Even sickness and fertility had seasonal dimensions. Roberts makes a very good case for comparing the four plantations. But he is oddly silent about the fact that one of his planters doubled as the first President of the United States. This should at least be addressed in an analysis that looks at the implementation of Enlightenment philosophy because George Washington was not a run-of-the-mill consumer of Enlightenment rhetoric. Rather he had first-hand experience putting theory into practice and wide exposure to various strains of abolitionist thought.
But these are more minor points in a book that does exactly what a first book should do: Offer a suggestive and powerful thesis backed by intense and thorough reading of the evidence. Slavery and the Enlightenment will be a good addition to graduate reading lists in slavery and the Atlantic world, and a good choice for methodology seminars to illustrate the merits of comparative history.
