No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 22 July 2005
Nissim Dana presents an overview of the Druze, known as the Unitarians or Muwahiddun, who live in Syria, Lebanon, and Israel. The book's title promises a broad study of Druze “in the Middle East,” but the focus is narrower, primarily on Druze in northern Israel and the Golan.
The Druze survived for a millennium in the Levant by shrouding themselves in secrecy and defending the most remote high ground, severely policing youth so no one married out of the group and refusing to emigrate even in the worst of times. A Druze writer described the task of defining who and what the Druze are as “the 1,000 year old question.” Since Druze society is closed to outsiders, the question is not easy to answer.
Dana's thesis is that the Druze are a unique minority set apart from both the Arab and the Islamic world. The author explains how the sect operates within a larger society, but this leads Dana to overemphasize Druze particularism. The Druze do have a special minority status in Israel, encouraged by the Israeli government, and have a long history of distinguished service in the Israeli Defense Forces. But whether they really are a distinct minority or part of the larger Islamic and Arab world remains a much debated issue.
The book is divided into four major sections. First, Dana describes the Druze belief system, what he terms “the life cycle of the Druze,” and their relationship with non-Druze. In part 2, he describes community organization and the spiritual leadership. He then analyzes the demographic issues facing the Druze, describing what he terms “straying”—the very rare phenomenon of Druze abandoning their faith—so small as to be statistically insignificant. The last section outlines legal issues and personal status laws defining marriage, child custody, and inheritance, with appendixes of documents. The sections on legal issues, personal status laws, and spiritual leadership are the book's strengths, as the author succinctly describes complex relationships and encapsulates Druze history in short, clear paragraphs. These sections are well organized and clearly written.
The book's weaknesses are its limited geographical scope and lack of reference to key scholarship on some central issues. One problem is the brief discussion of Druze women. Dana states that they are forbidden from driving; however, Dahlia Scheindlin has described the growing number of Israeli Druze women obtaining driver's licenses. Reference to Nura Alamuddin's Crucial Bonds: Marriage among the Lebanese Druze would add much to the section on marriage laws.
The greatest challenge for any author attempting to define the Druze is to explain their belief system, since their texts are both esoteric and gnostic. For a millennium, their texts were purposely filled with dissimulation and the interpolation of tangential information. Copies were stolen and translated but remain indecipherable without the cooperation of a Druze aqqal, or “wise one.” Thus, any hermeneutical effort faces major impediments. Earlier efforts by Phillip Hitti in 1928 and Robert Betts in 1988 faced similar challenges. Sami Makarem's The Druze Faith was written by a Druze, but even he acknowledged the inherent difficulties. Dana occasionally cites as absolutes behaviors that apply in some Druze areas but not in others.
Some passing references are inaccurate. Captain Carbillet of the French Mandate is transformed into “Capt Carbier.” Women's veils are called naqab rather than the more common mandīl.
Dana does a good job of describing the spiritual leadership but omits discussing political leaders who have played an important role. In the all too brief chronology, he omits key political events, listing only four in the past century: the Syrian revolt and the deaths of three Druze leaders. Dana does not mention the 1958 uprising in Lebanon led by Kamal Jumblat. He discusses Majid Arslan, but not Shakib Arslan, whose nationalist writings had a powerful influence in the Druze community and bridged the gap to the broader Arab nationalist movement.
Dana makes only a passing reference to Israel's Operation Peace for Galilee, observing that the Israelis “found themselves ruling the Druze” in Lebanon without describing the tragic impact of the war (p. 14). He briefly mentions the turmoil this caused among Druze in the Israeli Defense Forces, but the impact of their deployment is still debated today.
Dana makes little mention of events that challenged the determination of the Druze to remain in the mountains: the post–World War I famine and the collapse of the Lebanese silk industry. Akram Khater found that fewer than 2 percent of Druze men emigrated to the United States, and there was no record of any Druze woman leaving, even as famine swept the region. But after a decade of war in the 1980s, many Druze fled the Shouf.
After focusing on their ability to guard their secrets, Dana argues that the Druze should undertake a program of public education to reinforce this separate Druze identity. He might have referred to Kais Firro's The Druzes in the Jewish State, where this is discussed in detail. After a millennium of survival rooted in religious secrecy, the Druze do not seem likely to open themselves readily to the world.
Dana observes in the book's preface that “finding out about the Druze religion is almost a mission impossible” (p. xii). In the end, this reader concludes that it remains one.