In Afro-Central Americans in New York City, Sarah England provides an ethnographically rich exploration of the ways in which Garifuna communities and grassroots organisations negotiate the transnational complexities of race, class, gender, ethnicity and nationhood as a multivalent diasporic people. Drawing upon multisite field research in Honduras and New York City, England underscores the highly contingent, often strategic nature of such negotiations as the Garifuna, a phenotypically black people of African and Amerindian descent, navigate between Central American and US histories and systems of inequality. Rather than a unidirectional model of northward migration, England understands the Garifuna as constitutive of a ‘transmigrant’ community through circular migrations in which boundaries of collective identity are continually reworked at the confluence of racial and ethnicising processes vis-à-vis differentiated nation-states. Of particular note are England's efforts to map articulations between the politics of identity mobilised by Garifuna social organisations, and the ways in which race, class, gender and ethnicity are lived at the level of Garifuna families amidst the fluidity of a transnational condition. In doing so, England considers the political dialogics of identity in that space between social movements and everyday, community-level, agencies.
Following an introductory first chapter, the second chapter of Afro-Central Americans in New York City presents a historical sketch of the Garifuna from their seventeenth-century ethnogenesis on the Caribbean island of St Vincent, to their forcible removal or ‘exile’ to Central America in 1797 by the colonial British, to their more recent migrations to the United States in the late twentieth century. The chapter's title, ‘From Indigenous Blacks to Hispanic Immigrants’, reflects the complex, ever-shifting racial categories the Garifuna have occupied through time and space: formerly enslaved African maroons; syncretics of African and Carib/Arawak indigenous origin; racialised ‘blacks’ in Central America; and Afro-Latino immigrants in New York City. At each turn Garifunas' racial multifocality complicates standing racial boundaries, often blurring racial-ethnic lines. England additionally underscores the instrumentality of global capital in shaping the Garifuna and their narrative of continual movement and adaptation, one that roots them definitively within the historical workings of modernity. Here England foregrounds gender in examining the differing relationships men and women had to transnational capital (men as migratory wage labourers, women as focal household/community figures), setting the stage for the following chapter exploring the ‘transnationalization’ of Garifuna family structures though matrilocal kinship networks in Limón, Honduras, and their reconfiguration among immigrant communities in the United States. Chapter four examines the development of transmigrant strategies among Limoñero Garifuna as responses to marginalisation born of national development projects and neoliberal economic reform.
In the book's fifth chapter, England examines two Garifuna grassroots organisations in Limón and their strategies for community development. Her discussion is framed around competing notions of superando and desintegrando (progress and disintegration) regarding the perceived benefits versus consequences of US migration with respect to the social integrity of Garifuna as a transnational people. Internal debates are explored in which concerns about economic dependence and the fragmentation of communal ethos by entrepreneurial individualism resulting from remittances from the United States are paramount. At this juncture England introduces the play of land and identity as a key site of political struggle among Garifuna communities vis-à-vis the Honduran nation-state, a discussion more thoroughly explored in the following chapter. The central question presented here is one concerning Garifuna organisations’ understandings of the imbricated workings of racial and class oppression in their efforts to promote community development and combat poverty via transnationally responsive strategies.
England's sixth and final chapter is, for this reviewer, the most compelling chapter with regard to the poetics of Garifuna identity politics. As the chapter's title ‘Black, Indigenous, and Latino: The Politics of Racial and Ethnic Identity in the Garifuna Diaspora’ suggests, the paradigm of diaspora operates as a central organising lens through which the Garifuna both navigate and employ shifting categories of race and ethnicity while conceiving themselves in (trans)nationhood. The implication here is that Garifuna forge collective identity at the intersection of two overlapping notions of diasporic belonging. The first site is one fashioned via the trope of ethnicity, in which assertions of Garifuna cultural distinctiveness are understood as the social glue that bind Garifuna as a people regardless of spatial dispersion, a ‘nation in diaspora’. Within the current context of Central American land struggles, England observes that this language of cultural difference is mobilised similarly to Latin American indigenous communities in affirming cultural autochthony as the basis for land claims vis-à-vis the mestizo nation-state. Indeed, Garifunas' self-conceptions of cultural uniqueness (for example, language, music, religious systems, foodways, etc.) are celebrated as living testament to a history of resistance in the face of slavery, colonialism, and now state and private challenges to communal lands. In keeping with recent scholarship, England situates Garifunas' play of cultural difference within a broader shift in Latin America towards state-encouraged multiculturalism in which limited forms of land and cultural rights are recognised, a move England argues as partially informed from below by Garifuna grassroots activism. The analysis here, however, could be a bit more explicit in addressing the articulation of neoliberal processes and the rise of multiculturalism as a mode of commodification and appropriation of cultural difference towards incorporative market ends.
Yet of critical importance, England additionally addresses the politically positioned ways in which Garifuna communities and grassroots organisations engage transnational notions of blackness by way of membership in the African diaspora. Within the Central American context, black difference serves as an inclusive, nationally transcendent counterbalance to an ongoing history of racialised marginalisation, exclusion and discrimination within the Honduran mestizo nation. Alternative frames of race and ethnicity are therefore mobilised, sometimes in seemingly contradictory ways, for strategic advantage in local struggles for land, economic resources, and questions of citizenship. Such plays are however by no means wholly contingent, but rather are shaped by histories of racialised and ethnically configured forms of oppression which structure everyday Garifuna life as well as the political strategies they employ. England does, however, underscore how such frameworks and strategies are complicated by transmigration. In the case of immigrant Garifuna communities in New York City, England's account suggests that racial identity (blackness) assumes added political significance where Garifuna come to occupy a marked ambivalence as Afro-Latinos within the US racial system. Here England's examination might have been further nuanced if she were to consider the generational dynamics of identity between migrants and the growing numbers of US-born Garifuna, as well as greater attention to the impacts of circular migration on local processes of Garifuna racial identity formation in Central America itself.
