New archaeological finds in the Arabian Peninsula, the Levant and the Persian Gulf have expanded our understanding of the pre-Islamic milieu, including the political structures of the Middle East. The digital archives CSAI (Corpus of South Arabian Inscriptions), based at the University of Pisa, and OCIANA (Online Corpus of the Inscriptions of Ancient North Arabia), based at the University of Oxford, along with the CNRS Laboratoire Orient & Méditerranée UMR 8167, are throwing new light on the material culture and the history of Arabia. Both of the books under review make extensive use of new epigraphic documents as well as a broad selection of the literary sources for the rise of Islam. We will first examine the books individually, and then draw a comparison.
Arabs and Empires Before Islam consists of eight chapters by various hands. As indicated in the editor's introduction, this voluminous compilation aims to ‘study the relationship between Arabs, and empires, in the pre-Islamic period’ (1).
Ch. 1 deals with political alliances from the Arabian conquests of Nabonidus (556–539 b.c.e.), the last ruler of the Neo-Babylonian Empire, down to the late fifth century c.e. The discussion makes use of both local and external sources. For South Arabian history, though, difficulties arise from its remote geographical position and the scarcity of external sources. Nevertheless, ch. 2 succeeds in sketching a historical introduction to the kingdoms of South Arabia, presenting a range of epigraphic evidence produced between the eighth century b.c.e. and the fourth century c.e.
Ch. 3 considers the evolution of the Ḥimyarite kingdom after its conquest of Sabaʾ and Ḥadramawt in the third century c.e. Analysis of epigraphic documents follows each phase of the story, with reference, for example, to the establishment of a form of ‘Judaeo-monotheism’ in Ḥimyar towards the end of the fourth century, and Ḥimyar's turbulent relations with the Christian Aksūmite kingdom before Ḥimyar's collapse in the sixth century.
Ch. 4 examines archaeological evidence for the Jafnids and the Naṣrids, vassals respectively of the Roman Empire and Sasanian Persia, better known to Romanists as Ghassanids and Lakhmids. This examination is based on ambiguous records produced by the inhabitants of the Roman Near East. Definitive conclusions await new archaeological discoveries (not currently very likely).
Ch. 5 explores the military role of the Arabs in the conflicts between Rome and Persia, from the struggle between Anastasius (491–518) and Kavadh I (488–531), to the death of the Prophet Muḥammad (632). The conflicts between these two empires and the Arab raids in the fifth and sixth centuries are mainly seen through the eyes of ecclesiastics. This chapter meticulously discusses the Roman–Persian conflict, and brings new life to the debate on the late antique Arabian frontier. The result is an exhaustive account of the Arabs of the Roman and Persian Near East. However, such complete confidence in ‘external sources’ sometimes results in an excessively broad-brush picture of the imperial federates. It is true that the ‘Arab narrative literary tradition […] should be seen as an “outsider” source for the pre-Islamic period’ (Introduction, 2), since it was composed outside the temporal boundaries of pre-Islamic Arabia. Nonetheless, the contemporary non-Muslim literary documents here examined have clearly apologetic intentions, and are therefore equally ‘outsider sources’. They convey the impression that the Arabs were a crowd of polytheistic barbarians.
Ch. 6 also casts light on the relationship between Romans and Arabs, by examining the emergence of Christianity among the ‘barbarians’ of North Arabia. Both hagiographies and epigraphic documents are analysed. The chapter includes a brief discussion of the identification of the Arabs with the biblical ‘Ishmaelites’ and on the use of the lexeme ‘Saracens’.
Ch. 7 jumps back to the beginning of the second century c.e. when Provincia Arabia was established by Trajan, in order to investigate the emergence of Arabic as a written language.
The Arabic literary sources are discussed in ch. 8. A point of criticism here regards the repeated labelling of authors such as Ibn Ishạ̄q (704–767) and al-Tạbarī (838–923) as ‘medieval Muslim scholars’ (434 and following). Since ‘medieval’ conventionally indicates the middle part of Western European history, it would have been more fitting to have referred to them as ‘Umayyad’ (661–750) or ‘Abbasid’ (750–1258) scholars.
By analysing a wide range of material encompassing two millennia, the authors of Arabs and Empires Before Islam achieve extensive coverage. There is a tendency, though, to present Jafnids, Naṣrids, Ḥimyarites and the nomadic tribes of central Arabia as a homogeneous ethnic group, the ‘Arabs’. This is particularly the case in chs 5–6, which rely on external Christian sources. As already mentioned, this approach sometimes undermines the focus of the volume, and feeds the already contentious narrative about uncivilised Arabs manoeuvred by surrounding empires. In practice, there is no clear evidence of a pan-Arabian population before the rise of Islam. The Arab ethnikon was in use from Assyrian times to indicate several populations. It is uncertain who was ruled by Imru’ al-Qays ‘King of Arabs’ (mlk al-ʿrb), mentioned in the famous al-Namāra inscription (328 c.e.), or the Ḥimyarite kings Marthad'ilān Yanūf (500–518) and Maʿdīkarib Yaʿfur (519–522) who added to their tituli ‘king of the Arabs of the highland and lowland’ (CIH 540; Ry 510). It is no less uncertain whether the Arabic language bonded the Arabs before Islam. Study of personal names raises more problems than it solves, and the existence of no more than twenty inscriptions in Old Arabic is problematic if we consider the wide array of languages attested in the area during pre-Islamic times. Moreover, no substantial reference to the Arab ethnikon has been found in the corpus of pre-Islamic poetry.
Recreating the history of the Arabs before the formation of an Arab consciousness generates a misleading and anachronistic approach. Arabness is a notion that becomes clearly distinguishable only after the establishment of the Muslim community, when a brand-new civilised cultural identity was supplied to the fragmented tribal societies of the future world conquerors. Overall, there are not enough distinguishing features that enable us to talk about pre-Islamic ‘Arabs’ as a unified collectivity.
To conclude, Arabs and Empires Before Islam embraces a remarkable variety of sources, and the secondary references are comprehensive and up to date. The literary translations and the examination of the epigraphic evidence help ease readers into the spectrum of primary sources. A major merit of the volume is to have proved the relevance of epigraphic evidence to this particular historical enquiry. Nevertheless, the repetition of certain literary extracts creates some redundancy. All the chapters are stimulating and informative, but the book as a whole lacks a narrative, and its focus tends to be on external perceptions of the ‘Arabs’.
Glen Bowersock's Crucible of Islam is also a valuable book, which reads well as an outline for those seeking an historical narrative of the rise of the latest scriptural monotheism. The work is divided into nine chapters, preceded by a lively prologue.
Prompted by three recent books (F. Donner, Muhammad and the Believers (2010); R. Hoyland, In God's Path (2015); A. Al-Azmeh, The Emergence of Islam in Late Antiquity (2014)), B. covers the murky history of Arabia from the mid-sixth to the late seventh century c.e., providing a ‘glimpse into the chaotic environment that made Islam possible’ (9), through analysis of a wide spectrum of testimonies. Already the first chapter deploys Muslim literary sources (al-Ṭabarī) and non-Muslim accounts (Procopius) alongside epigraphic evidence, pre-Islamic poetry, a Qur'anic sura and a relief recently discovered at Ẓafār in the Yemen.
B. begins his book with the history of South Arabia from the rise of what he calls ‘Judaism’ tout court in Ḥimyar in the fourth century c.e. to the birth of the founder of Islam in 570. He also considers the adoption of a pro-Christian attitude by the Aksūmite negus ‘Ēzānā in the middle of the fourth century. This event enables us to catch a glimpse of Roman efforts to exercise influence in this region remote from the Mediterranean.
Ch. 2 deals with ‘Arab paganism’, which B. believes co-existed with Judeo-Christian communities and the spread of Neoplatonic theology in Syria. Space is also given to the mercantile and sacred character of late antique Mecca, and to the so-called first hijra (emigration) of Muḥammad's followers to Aksūm.
The Persian conquest of Jerusalem in 614 pivots the book's narrative. Two contemporary sources, Strategios and Sophronius, are quoted, but attention is also given to recent archaeological inquiries. Heraclius’ counter-attack got under way in April 622. Two months later, the hijra to Yathrib (later Medina) took place. B. accepts Michael Lecker's thesis as regards Byzantium's involvement in the Muslim emigration. The alliance between the pagan Arab tribes of the city and the pro-Roman Jafnids is seen as Heraclius’ attempt at destabilising Medina, ‘neutralizing the Jews in the event of any Persian effort to co-opt them’ (112). Apparently Heraclius under-estimated the prophetic career of Muḥammad and, while planning his invasion of 628 into the Persian Empire, saw the rising Islamic community as a resource to exploit against his rivals.
A recapitulation of Muḥammad's conquest of Mecca leads into a discussion of the first four caliphs, drawing on literary sources in Syriac, Greek and Arabic, as well as archaeological material adduced by such as Gideon Avni. The book concludes with discussion of the Umayyad dynasty from Muʿāwiya to ‘Abd al-Malik, who consolidated the caliphate's nascent Muslim identity by establishing Arabic as the official language, creating a new coinage and constructing the Dome of the Rock in Jerusalem. Following Oleg Grabar, B. argues that the Dome of the Rock gave special prestige to Jerusalem, aggressively challenging the ‘associative’ (mushrik) Christian dogma of the Trinity.
B.’s incisive approach to the most problematic century of Islam well complements his brief, precise overview of the sixth-century Arabian background of Islam. Nevertheless, the second chapter, ‘Arab Paganism in Late Antiquity’, is less lucid than other chapters in the book, and indeed than the author's exposition of the same material in the last pages of his The Throne of Adulis (2013). After having criticised the use of terms such as ‘soft monotheism’ and ‘polytheist monotheism’ to indicate the creed of pre-Christian Greeks, B. repeatedly employs the term ‘pagan monotheism’, popularised by P. Athanassiadi and M. Frede in Pagan Monotheism in Late Antiquity (1999). He mentions al-‘Uzzā, Manāt and al-Lāt, attested in the Qur’ān's Sūrat al-Najm (The Star), and remarks that al-Lāt ‘has recently been suggested’ to be ‘a daughter of Allāh’ (39), though this identification was already made by Ibn al-Kalbi (737–819). The five Nabatean inscriptions from Madā’in Ṣāliḥ mentioned in connection with Manāt can be dated between the first century b.c.e. and the first century c.e., and hence are of little interest to this inquiry. We are not aware of any inscription mentioning these deities that is contemporary with the Qur’ān.
Besides possessing different formats, these two books cover different periods, since The Crucible of Islam does not stop with the prophetic career of Muḥammad. Furthermore, whereas B. is keen to make his book suitable for a non-scholarly audience, such readers would easily get lost in the intricate inquiries of F.’s volume. Nevertheless, these works have enough in common to suggest a comparison.
In primis, they both attempt to insert the Arabian peninsula into the broader late antique framework. This periodisation conventionally terminates with the Muslim conquests in the seventh century, but little interest is taken in Arabia before the rise of Islam. These books make clear how the neglected kingdoms of South Arabia, and the interplay of Jafnids and Naṣrids, nevertheless influenced the broader interactions of the period. By analysing a wide spectrum of literary and material sources, their authors avoid the inherent problem of this complex research field, which arises from the contradictions among the ‘external’ and ‘internal’ sources. Nevertheless, there is an evident need for more intensive archaeological research. The lack of a conclusion to Arabs and Empires Before Islam clearly indicates that there is much more to be said about pre-Islamic Arabia. We hope that these works will stimulate and encourage students to offer new approaches to this controversial field in the very near future.
