Here is a real treat for those interested in the broader issues in moral, social, political, and economic theory of how modern commercial or capitalist societies should be organized and structured. Given various recent disturbing world events in the twenty-first century, I can think of few or no more important topics.
The book is a collection of papers originally presented at a joint meeting of the International Adam Smith Society and the Rousseau Association at the University of Glasgow, summer 2015. Confession: I was there, it was a terrific conference, and another group of papers from the conference is scheduled to be published in volume 11 of The Adam Smith Review, including one by this reviewer (Reference PackPack Forthcoming). As the editors point out in their excellent introductory essay, it was not that long ago that “there was a popular, if crude, notion that the two [Smith and Rousseau] were in some sense opposites or even enemies” (p. 3). I can certainly attest to that. Near the end of the twentieth century I sent out a short article on the (then) surprising similarities in the thought of Adam Smith and Jean-Jacques Rousseau to a major North American journal in the history of political economy (not this one!). One referee flatly rejected it for publication, despite writing that I was a good writer and a thoughtful scholar who used a substantial range and depth of citation and quotation, and expressing admiration for the scholarly level of my work. At least that reviewer was succinct, rejecting the paper in one mere page. It took the second referee eleven pages to properly castigate me, finding, among other things, “Pack’s argument is entirely unpersuasive”; “Pack’s interpretation strains credulity”; “cannot imagine that any reader … would find such a conclusion credible”; “I confess I find it astounding that one could claim, as Pack would have us believe.…” Ouch! Well, fortunately, I found another place to publish that piece (Pack Reference Pack2000), and I decided it was basically time for me to stop writing about Adam Smith for quite a while (which I suppose was actually the ultimate or final goal of that second referee).
But, at least in the field of Rousseau–Smith studies, the twenty-first century has been a good one so far. As several of the papers point out, the study of the intricate complex connections between Rousseau and Smith is flourishing. Nonetheless, as the editors correctly state in their introduction, we are “still in the early stages of the exploration of their relationship” (p. 3). Essentially, the conference and this book are an invitation for others to join this massive, important, multidisciplinary research project evaluating, dissecting, comparing, and contrasting Rousseau’s system with the system (or systems) of Adam Smith. Given the complexity of the subject, and the youthfulness of the endeavor, most of these articles raise more questions than answers.
The book comprises fourteen papers, grouped into five categories: “Adam Smith and Jean-Jacques Rousseau”; “Self-Interest and Sympathy”; “Moral Sentiments and Spectatorship”; “Commercial Society and Justice”; and “Politics and Freedom.” Among my favorite contributions are:
1. Tabitha Baker’s article (pp. 143–165) exploring Smithian themes of space and sympathy, which are to be found in Julie’s garden in Rousseau’s enormously popular and influential novel Julie ou La Nouvelle Heloise. Baker then relates these themes to the eighteenth-century English gardening revolution, and the changing conceptions of the proper form of government as well as the geographic size of a country; fascinating.
2. John McHugh’s article (pp. 109–123) attempting to interpret Smith’s implicit critique of Rousseau’s work (which is nowhere explicit or elaborated) by examining Smith’s explicit critique of Bernard Mandeville in The Theory of Moral Sentiments. This is because “[o]ne of the most remarkable things about Smith’s 1756 review of Rousseau’s Discourse on the Origin of Inequality is how assuredly it identifies Rousseau’s conception of human nature with Bernard Mandeville’s” (p. 109). Yes; exactly! Notice, also, that it is the second, not the more widely read first, volume of Mandeville’s Fable of the Bees that Smith sees as having given occasion to Rousseau’s system; a brilliant investigative strategy.
3. Jimena Hurtado’s use of Aristotle to attempt to understand and compare the views of Smith and Rousseau on justice (pp. 214–237). Hurtado, by the way, appears to be one of the few contributors to this work who is trained and/or works as an economist (the only other one apparently being Paganelli, one of the book’s editors). Hurtado astutely notes that Rousseau (unlike Smith) closely follows Aristotle’s definition of the subject matter of economics as administration. Also, she notes that Rousseau, again, as opposed to Smith, shares Aristotle’s deep concern with the possible corrupting use of money—i.e., bad chrematistics. These are both crucially important points that merit further future exploration.
4. Mark Hulliung’s article, “Rousseau and the Scottish Enlightenment” (pp. 32–51). Hulliung correctly emphasizes that most recent work on Rousseau and Smith has been by students of Smith, not Rousseau; and they tend to use Rousseau as a conventional foil, arguing that Smith wrote in response to Rousseau and soundly defeated him in a debate over the merits of commercial society. In contradistinction, Hulliung points out that it is not evident that the subject of analysis of Rousseau’s scathing critique was commercial society at all but rather modernity or civilization itself. Moreover, at the very least, scholars must realize that “there was not one Enlightenment but many, each needing to be studied in its distinctive national context” (p. 49). Touché.
Other readers will have other favorite articles, depending upon their interests.
I noted above that there are relatively few professional economists in this collection, and it seemed to me that there were also relatively few economists at the convention. This is to be regretted; indeed, economists and those explicitly interested in the history of economic thought have much to contribute to this budding research program. For example, here is an explicitly economics research question that has puzzled me for decades. Adam Smith is more or less correctly held to be the “father of [modern] economics,” where the subject of economics (or political economy) is held to be the study of commercial or capitalist society, or price theory or exchange value, or some variant thereof. Yet, the whole pre-modern subject matter of economics, going back at least to the days of Xenophon and ancient Greece, was the study of administration (e.g., Lowry Reference Lowry1987). Rousseau wrote an article on “Political Economy” and may be considered to be one of the last to write in that long tradition of economics as administration. Yet, no doubt thanks in large part to Adam Smith, by the middle of the twentieth century, the subject matter of economics had changed so radically and completely that Joseph Schumpeter could charge that Rousseau cannot be called an economist, and “[h]is article on political economy in the Encyclopedia contains next to no economics” (Reference Schumpeter1954, p. 139). Therein lies a puzzle.
As frequented alluded to in this book, the second and last issue of the short-lived Edinburgh Review contained a long anonymous letter written by the young Adam Smith. That thirteen-page letter devoted about three pages lauding the publication of the French Encyclopedia. About four more pages were devoted to praising Rousseau’s 2nd Discourse; indeed, three pages were Smith’s translation of key excerpts from that work. Yet, there is no discussion or even mention of Rousseau’s “Political Economy” essay in that very same Encyclopedia that Smith knew about, studied, and lauded; or mention of Rousseau’s essay anywhere else in Smith’s entire oeuvre. Granted, as perceptive readers of Smith from Karl Marx ([Reference Marx1859] 1970, pp. 167–168) to Salim Rashid (Reference Rashid1998, pp. 200–208) have noted, Smith tended to be unduly parsimonious in recognizing his predecessors. Nonetheless—four pages devoted to Rousseau, the author of the 2nd Discourse, but zero mention to Rousseau, author of “Political Economy,” both published in the same year. What’s up with that? And is it related to the ensuing complete change in the subject matter of economics? My guess is yes. More research needs to be done; volunteers needed to join the program.
