The idea that ‘the north’ is a far-away part of England whose inhabitants can barely be understood by civilised people is an old one.Footnote 1 It may be found in the pages of the early twelfth-century chronicler, William of Malmesbury, who, in the introduction of the section on Northumbria in his Deeds of the Bishops of England, described York as ‘a large metropolitan city, still exhibiting Roman elegance’, but went on to comment on the speech of the Northumbrians, especially that of the men of York, that it
grates so harshly upon the ear it is completely unintelligible to us southerners. The reason for this is their proximity to barbaric tribes and their distance from the kings of the land, who, whether English as once or Norman as now, are known to stay more often in the south than in the north. The king himself [Henry I], who in the south of England is content with an escort from his household, does not set forth without a great company of auxiliary troops whenever he is visiting northern parts.Footnote 2
Thanks to a series of papers by John Gillingham, we have been made aware of the way William sought to refashion English identity in a way which sharpened consciousness of those outside her frontiers as belonging to other, lesser nations.Footnote 3 But before we dismiss William's comment as a personal prejudice by a southerner, it is worth asking how far the north in the early twelfth century did correspond to his view, as somewhere distant and dangerous for Henry I.
In his use of the term Northumbria, William was thinking in terms of the old kingdom, consisting of the archdiocese of York, which was made up of the pre-Viking sees of Lindisfarne (Durham), Hexham and Whithorn, which he described as ‘at the very end of England next to Scotland’.Footnote 4 For the purposes of this discussion, ‘the north’ is used in a general sense as meaning the region north of the Humber and the Mersey. In the early twelfth century it was composed of peoples of different ethnic stock and political allegiances. The Anglo-Scottish border cut across earlier boundaries, those of Strathclyde in the west and Northumbria in the east.Footnote 5 Cumbria south of Solway is thought to have been within the sphere of influence of the Scots’ king in 1066.Footnote 6 North Lancashire, or ‘the honour of Lancaster’, had strong ties with south Cumbria, whilst south Lancashire, described in Domesday Book as ‘the land between Ribble and Mersey’, was more obviously linked with Cheshire, and was part of the diocese of Coventry and Lichfield.Footnote 7 North of Yorkshire, in the east, were the lands which historically formed the patrimony of St Cuthbert, concentrated round Durham, but with important estates in Northumberland and beyond the river Tweed, and south, in Yorkshire.Footnote 8 ‘Northumberland’ was the rump of the old earldom of Northumbria, and had been confiscated from Earl Robert de Mowbray in 1095.
William of Malmesbury was obviously correct in one sense, that these regions were far outposts of the realms of the king of the English. Pre-Conquest kings were richest in land in the south, where they mostly spent their time. After 1066 the Norman kings had the duchy to worry about, and the defence of Normandy took them away from England for long spells. Yet from the time of William the Conqueror the kings of England went to the north more often than their predecessors.Footnote 9 William the Conqueror had made forays in 1068, 1069 and 1070 to deal with uprisings, and then again in 1072 as he travelled north to exact submission from King Malcolm III.Footnote 10 Rufus had taken armies north in 1091, 1092 and again in 1095.Footnote 11 According to tradition, Henry may actually have been born in Yorkshire, though this seems unlikely given the volatile situation there in 1068 and 1069.Footnote 12 Henry I marched to Tickhill to secure the castle's surrender in 1102.Footnote 13 He returned to the north in 1105,Footnote 14 again in 1109,Footnote 15 possibly in 1113 (the evidence is circumstantial)Footnote 16 and in 1122.Footnote 17
Why then were the Norman kings so much more in evidence in the north than most of their predecessors? William the Conqueror knew right from the start that the north could not simply be left to its own devices.Footnote 18 Not only was there the danger of northerners rising up against the Normans, but there was the possibility of invasion by the Scots or the arrival of fleets from Norway and Denmark in the Humber. The few Normans stationed in the north were dangerously isolated, and it was only after the harrying of the north in 1069–70 that a framework of lordships took shape, with great compact lordships forming a protective shield for the rich lands of lowland Yorkshire.Footnote 19 Settlement proceeded slowly and was substantially altered in the wake of Norman opposition to the rule of William Rufus and Henry I. The departure of some of the greatest of the first wave of new lords provided Rufus and even more, Henry I, with a great reservoir of land with which to reward their followers.
Henry's dealings with the north were what might be called reactive: his visits were made at times of concern about security, whether this was about the loyalty of the northern magnates, relations with successive kings of Scots or the security of Carlisle. He was driven above all by the need to secure the totality of the legacy of his father, William the Conqueror: not just to keep the English throne he had won, but also to take Normandy from his elder brother Robert, and to ensure that both passed to his heir. The defence of Normandy against rebellious lords and hostile neighbours, only too ready to promote the claim of Duke Robert's son William, was Henry's priority, and necessitated frequent and sometimes protracted absences from England. On his return there were flurries of activity as decisions about patronage and preferment were made. His attention on northern England thus could only be intermittent, and the driving force, here as elsewhere, it will be suggested, was dynastic politics rather than administrative innovation.
The character of Henry's rule over northern England has been assessed very differently by historians. Some have argued that it was a final, somewhat crude phase in the passing of the old English state. According to this line of argument, in the early middle ages, kings had little power outside their own estates and in regions they did not visit. Their authority had to be upheld by forming alliances with those who did exercise power in the localities: their influence was thus exercised at one remove. It was only when kings could deal directly with local communities, or still more, with individuals, that a further stage of development was reached.Footnote 20 English kingship had already made this breakthrough before 1066. Shires, hundreds, and their courts, sheriffs and writs, were the mechanisms by which Anglo-Saxon kings could reach out to the localities.Footnote 21 The arrival of the Norman kings did not assist the further development of these mechanisms, rather they may instead have put them under severe strain, leading to collapse under Stephen and refashioning under Henry II.Footnote 22
The north of England of course did not fit neatly into this model of an advanced old English state. Southern kings had visited less often and had fewer estates there. There were fewer points of entry for royal authority in the form of dioceses and religious houses. The north-west, or Cumbria, was for most of the eleventh century in the orbit if not the control of the kings of Scots.Footnote 23 The politics of Northumberland and Durham seem to have belonged to an earlier, more violent era, to judge from the famous bloodfeud recorded at Durham.Footnote 24 William the Conqueror had faced major opposition in the north, especially in Yorkshire, and resorted to the infamous harrying during the winter of 1069–70.Footnote 25 This further conjures up an image of a region more violent and less orderly than the south. If we are to believe William of Malmesbury, a wide swathe of the north was still desolate some half century or more later.Footnote 26 For those who subscribe to the view that the Norman kings crushed opposition and made use of the resources they inherited rather than developed new ways of ruling, the harrying simply underscores the impression that this was part of the passing of the old order.
By the reign of Henry II, however, the north seems to be a much more settled and orderly place, with sheriffs and justices, castellans and forest officials.Footnote 27 It is the world of the great religious houses and landed families whose lives and lands can be traced in the volumes of Early Yorkshire Charters.Footnote 28 In this process of transformation from violence and self-help to law and order, other historians have seen the reign of Henry I as part of the new world, where England was governed by a centralised administrative system emanating from the king's court. The term ‘administrative kingship’ was coined to sum up its essential characteristics.Footnote 29 At first sight there is a certain amount going for this point of view. More royal writs and charters dealing with northern affairs survive, and the 1130 pipe roll, the earliest original record from the medieval exchequer, has entries which deal with all parts of the north. Nor do contemporary narratives composed in the north support an idea of a political and cultural world separate from the kingdom of the English.
Yet if the north was becoming more fully integrated into the rest of the kingdom, the extent and character of that integration have to be considered. The north beyond the Tees and the Ribble was not shired in the same way as the south, and there were great jurisdictional liberties which meant that many of the duties of justice and police were in the hands of local lords rather than the sheriffs.Footnote 30 It has been suggested that the Normans seemed indifferent to the idea of shiring the north.Footnote 31 By comparison with tenth-century kings, their approach to regional administration seemed almost crudely pragmatic.
One dimension of the rise of modern states which has attracted much attention in recent years has been the establishment of settled frontiers. Recent work on medieval frontiers has distinguished between linear boundaries and frontier zones, where society had special characteristics different from regions closer to the centres of political authority, and local inhabitants sometimes had strong links with those living across a political frontier.Footnote 32 Linear frontiers were often traced by reference to physical features such as rivers, or, in the case of the north, Hadrian's Wall. The location of the Anglo-Scottish border in this era may be identified, as Professor Barrow demonstrated, but questions remain about its permanence, and about society and allegiances of those living to its north and south.Footnote 33 The border came to mean a linear boundary between two kingdoms, but was this quite the case in the early twelfth century? The kings of Scots had territorial claims south of the border, to Cumbria and to Northumberland, which had formerly been united with Lothian north of the border.
Our perception of the status of the Anglo-Scottish border is sharpened by comparison with the Anglo-Welsh border or with the frontiers of Normandy in the early twelfth century. In the case of the border with Wales, it is abundantly clear that the Normans did not regard its location in 1066 as an obstacle to further conquest.Footnote 34 Henry reinforced existing Norman lordships in Wales by making sure those who held them had resources both for their defence and for the consolidation of their power.Footnote 35 There was even some opportunity to push the boundaries further forward, for Henry granted Ceredigion (Cardigan) to Gilbert FitzRichard de Clare.Footnote 36 When there were attacks on estates held by the Normans, Henry was prepared to make a show of strength. In both 1114 and 1121 he marched into Wales and exacted submissions from the Welsh princes and exploited their differences.Footnote 37
The status of the frontiers of Normandy was different again, for these separated a duchy from its neighbours, and from the French royal demesne.Footnote 38 Henry could not simply incorporate neighbouring territories within the duchy. Some sectors of the frontier were ‘hot’, to use Daniel Power's phrase, especially in the Vexin, and in south-east Normandy.Footnote 39 Here warfare was frequent, and local families often rebellious. Henry's reaction was to strengthen the border castles. In some ways his legacy to Normandy was the many stone-built castles which came by the end of his life to encircle the frontier.Footnote 40 In southern Normandy the downfall successively of the count of Mortain (1106) and of Robert de Bellême (1112) provided opportunities for reshaping local society. The confiscated county of Mortain was entrusted to the king's nephew Stephen of Blois.Footnote 41 Those whose families had been rivals of Robert de Bellême benefited. Robert Giroie recovered Montreuil and Echauffour.Footnote 42 Rotrou, count of Perche, Henry's son-in-law, was granted the confiscated lordship of Bellême.Footnote 43 Although Henry restored Robert de Bellême's lands to his son, he retained the castles. Security along the southern frontier remained problematic and trouble erupted again in 1135, but after 1112 Henry did not have to face such a powerful presence in the south. Some frontiers were thus treated with more respect than others by Henry.
The status of the frontiers of England and Normandy raises a further question as to how far Henry intended them to limit his power. It has been suggested that he, unlike his father and brother, was content with the lands he had inherited, and ‘rejected Norman imperialism’.Footnote 44 A variant on this view is that, whether Henry wished it or not, the opportunity for further expansion had disappeared, and that it took all his resources simply to defend what he had.Footnote 45 Yet views such as these are hard to reconcile with the suggestion that Henry sought to assert rights of ‘overkingship’ which the Normans had inherited from their Anglo-Saxon predecessors, and which formed the justification for imperialistic claims towards their neighbours in the British Isles.Footnote 46 The terms ‘overkingship’ and ‘imperialism’ in the context of Henry's relations with the Scots thus need careful consideration.
Finally, there are the questions of identities and allegiances of those living in northern England. The numbers of Normans settled north of the Humber and the Mersey were fewer and later to arrive, and a higher proportion of native landholders survived in the local aristocracy and gentry. The processes of accommodation and co-existence were neither simple nor straightforwardly bilateral.Footnote 47 As well as relations between natives and newcomers, those between Normans in northern England, their kin elsewhere in the Anglo-Norman world, and in Scotland, have to be taken into account. Some families belonged to great Anglo-Norman families, whilst others possessed little or nothing outside the north. Ties of kinship and lordship soon helped to link northern families with those across the border in Scotland.Footnote 48
The political allegiances of both laymen and ecclesiastics thus had to take account of multiple social ties. By the early twelfth century, the desire of Scottish kings and their bishops to be independent, and the pretensions of both York and Canterbury to primacy over the Scottish church raised the potential for conflict between the northern and southern kings.Footnote 49 In Henry's lifetime, good relations with David eased points of tension.Footnote 50 After Henry's death a conflict of loyalty could not be avoided. It was at its most acute in 1138 at the battle of the Standard, when David's army faced that of the northern magnates, and the combatants were forced to choose sides.Footnote 51
In brief, recent historiography has tended to view northern England in the reign of Henry I as a period of peace and incorporation within the kingdom, and to see it as ruled by administrative techniques and officials rather than by punitive expedition. This essay is concerned to explore the bases on which these assumptions rest. It is suggested that we should not treat the north in isolation from other areas of Henry's realms, and that his methods were much the same there as elsewhere. Peace he certainly brought to the north, but the keys were dynastic politics, patronage and the judicious application of pressure. The second part of this essay is thus concerned with both the politics and the administration of the north.
Crucial to peace in northern England was the modus vivendi which Rufus and then Henry were to establish with the successors (bar one, Domnall) of King Malcolm III.Footnote 52 Duncan, Edgar, Alexander and David each benefited from the Norman kings’ support in their efforts to secure the Scottish throne, but that support came at a price. Malcolm had been prepared to perform an act of submission to the Conqueror, but Rufus's insistence on treating him as a vassal had led to a quarrel and, finally, to the death of Malcolm and his son Edward.Footnote 53 Rufus was then able to use the ensuing power struggle to assert his authority over Duncan, Malcolm's son by his first wife, and then Edgar, his son by Queen Margaret. Edgar seems to have acknowledged that superiority in a form more explicitly subordinate than his father had done.Footnote 54 In 1100 Henry married Edgar's sister Edith, and her brother David soon joined Henry's court.Footnote 55 In 1107 Alexander succeeded Edgar, and, if we are to accept the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle at face value, this was ‘with King Henry's consent’.Footnote 56 In 1113 David was permitted to marry a widow, Matilda de Senlis, and to hold her English lands in custody. He was further enriched when, according to the testimony of Ailred of Rievaulx, his brother King Alexander was persuaded to hand over land which his predecessor had bequeathed to David.Footnote 57 Alexander himself married an illegitimate daughter of King Henry,Footnote 58 and in 1114 led a contingent in the army which King Henry took to Scotland.Footnote 59 Alexander thus had to deal not only with Henry's assertion of superior rights, but also with a younger brother, David, who between 1113 and 1124 ruled a great swathe of southern Scotland and was a loyal ally of King Henry.Footnote 60 That territory is thought to have comprised a considerable part of south-west Scotland, and, in south-east Scotland, Teviotdale and Tweeddale.Footnote 61
David's northern lordship was only one of a whole series which formed a cordon sanitaire in the north and north-west. Carlisle may have been granted in the first instance to Ivo Taillebois and, after his death and the death of Lucy's second husband, to her third, Ranulf Meschin. Ranulf served Henry loyally and was one of his commanders at the battle of Tinchebray in 1106.Footnote 62 He seems to have enjoyed wide-ranging authority in the north-west. As well as founding a Benedictine priory at Wetheral near Carlisle,Footnote 63 he seems to have been responsible for the establishment of Robert de Trivers at Burgh by Sands, Richer de Boiville at Kirklinton and Turgis Brundos at Liddel. These lordships were all beyond Hadrian's Wall, and as such springboards for further advance.Footnote 64 Lordships in the remainder of Cumbria took shape.Footnote 65 Some were held by native families, and the daughter of one lord, Forne son of Sigulf, was one of Henry I's mistresses.Footnote 66 Westmorland consisted of two great lordships, one in the north centred on Appleby,Footnote 67 the other in the south at Kendal. Appleby was in the king's hands in 1130, whilst it seems that Kendal had passed to Nigel d'Aubigny.Footnote 68 South of the river Duddon, the two portions of the later county of Lancashire, previously held by Roger the Poitevin, passed to Stephen of Blois, probably in 1113.Footnote 69
In the north-east, Henry made no attempt to appoint a new earl of Northumberland in succession to Robert de Mowbray, who had forfeited his lands in 1095. Instead a patchwork of lesser lordships emerged, some of which were in the hands of native families like Gospatric, earl of Lothian (Dunbar) and lord of Beanley in Northumberland.Footnote 70 In the Inquest of Feudal Service of 1166 a number of the new lordships were said to have been ‘of the old enfeoffment’, that is, they were created before 1135, and most of these were thought to have dated from the reign of Henry I.Footnote 71 The bishopric of Durham by contrast was another great compact lordship, this time in the hands of a bishop. The historic lands belonging to St Cuthbert straddled the Anglo-Scottish border, and the first bishop after 1066, William of Saint-Calais, had to tread carefully between the courts of the Scottish and English kings.Footnote 72 His successor, Ranulf Flambard (1099–1128), suffered a period of imprisonment and exile after Henry's accession, as the minister who had effected the fiscal exploitation of the English church for Rufus. After Ranulf's return to Durham, however, he strengthened the defences of Durham and built a castle at Norham on the river Tweed.Footnote 73 Not only that, but, here, as elsewhere, lordships took shape with members of Ranulf's own family strongly represented in the local aristocracy.Footnote 74
The wreck of the White Ship and with it the death of the king's only (legitimate) son together with over 300 hundred members of the court was a seismic shock which had repercussions in every quarter of Henry's realms, northern England included. His immediate priority was remarriage with the hope of fathering another son as quickly as possible, but he also had to reassert his authority in England after a long absence, and to take decisions about a series of honours whose lords had died. One of these was the earldom of Chester, as the young earl of Chester was one of those who had drowned. Henry decided to allow his kinsman, Ranulf Meschin, to succeed to the earldom and the vast estates, but a price was exacted, in that Ranulf surrendered the lordship of Carlisle, and Henry chose not to appoint a successor of similar status and powers.Footnote 75
There are other indications of Henry's concern about the north. In 1121 a great gathering of northern magnates at Durham is mentioned,Footnote 76 and we know that castles were built at Norham, by the bishop of Durham, and Wark, by Walter Espec, on the Tweed frontier.Footnote 77 Henry himself travelled north late in 1122, proceeding from York as far as Carlisle, where he ordered the strengthening of the town's defences.Footnote 78 A possible explanation for Henry's concern suggested recently is that he was exercised about the prospects for the succession to the Scottish throne.Footnote 79 Alexander's marriage to Henry's daughter Sibyl is not known to have produced children, and in July 1122 she died. Henry presumably felt that his interests would be best served if Alexander were to be succeeded by his younger brother David, but Alexander may have needed some persuasion.Footnote 80 This may well have been the case, but the strengthening of defences along the Solway–Tweed frontier may have been prompted by other considerations.
It may also have been around this time that Henry allied with Fergus, lord of Galloway, who married yet another of Henry's illegitimate daughters.Footnote 81 Galloway was a region largely independent of the power of the king of Scots and of David as prince in south-west Scotland. Fergus, it has been suggested, was keen to keep it so.Footnote 82 When a bishop was appointed for the ancient see of Whithorn, in about 1128, he professed obedience to Archbishop Thurstan of York, an act which, it may be presumed, would not have been welcome to David, who had succeeded to the Scottish throne in 1124.Footnote 83 Between Galloway and Carlisle lay Annandale, where Robert de Brus was established.Footnote 84 Robert seems to have owed great estates in northern England to Henry, but he was and remained a close associate of David.Footnote 85
Another piece of evidence pointing towards concern about the north around 1122 was the foundation by Stephen of Blois, as lord of Lancaster, of an abbey established first at Tulketh and then at Furness.Footnote 86 Stephen seems to have held his great estates in the north-west for some years before taking any steps to assert his lordship there, and the timing may be explained if he had accompanied his uncle the king to Carlisle in 1122.Footnote 87 Savigny, the mother house of Tulketh, had close links with Stephen as count of Mortain. The monks soon moved to Furness, where they enjoyed easy access to the sea and sent out colonies, to Erenagh near Downpatrick in northern Ireland, and to Rushen on the Isle of Man.Footnote 88 These foundations are a salutary reminder that links between northern England and the Isle of Man and Ireland remained very important, though reported in less detail than affairs in southern England and Normandy. Man retained its strategic important in the Irish Sea zone, and its ruler, Olaf, was said to have been brought up at Henry's court.Footnote 89
A map of northern England in this era thus shows a great arc of large, compact lordships from Chester north to Carlisle, and across to Northumberland and Durham in the north-east, with David's lands to the north forming an outer shield. The final piece of the jigsaw was Yorkshire, and here there was considerable reorganisation of lordships in the early twelfth century. As Paul Dalton demonstrated, the harrying of 1069–70 had been followed up by the construction of lordships centred on castles, but confiscations and deaths ensued, and by 1135 the composition and structure of many Yorkshire lordships was very different from the start of Henry's reign.Footnote 90 Holderness was restored to Stephen count of Aumale,Footnote 91 Pontefract was granted first to Hugh de Laval and then to William Maltravers,Footnote 92 and Blyth was accounted for at the exchequer in 1130.Footnote 93 Meanwhile new lordships were constructed for Henry's men, like Nigel d'Aubigny and Robert de Brus;Footnote 94 later Walter Espec and Eustace FitzJohn were granted lands both in Yorkshire and Northumberland.Footnote 95
To this point, therefore, we have seen little that is new about Henry's rule in northern England. He was concerned above all with peace and security. To that end he upheld the alliance with three successive kings of Scots. He asserted his influence at the accession of Alexander, persuaded Alexander to hand over land to David and, it appears, had a hand in securing David's succession in 1124. His methods were distinctly old-fashioned: the assertion of overkingship, the use of marriage alliances and the hint that force would be used if needed. This was much the same as his approach elsewhere, with regard to the Welsh, for instance, or in Normandy. As we have seen, he took care that Norman lordships in Wales were in the hands of men of substance, but, when he felt a show of force was necessary, he took armies to Wales, in 1114 and 1121. He exacted obedience and tribute from the Welsh princes, and those who were prepared to be loyal were left alone. However, he did not turn his back on further advances, as when he allowed Gilbert FitzRichard to take over Ceredigion.
If there were opportunities for military conquest in Wales, it was not the same situation in Normandy. Here the mechanism for an extension of power had to be through oaths of allegiance, marriage and succession, the custody of castles and the occasional show of force. To the south, Maine, long an object of Norman ambition, could not be conquered. Instead Henry cultivated the friendship of Helias of La Flèche and the lords of northern Maine.Footnote 96 He had held the castle of Domfront in the Passais since 1092, and not only ensured that it did not return to the lords of Bellême, but strengthened his hold over the territory south of Domfront with its key castles.Footnote 97
In all quarters of his realms, the marriages of his illegitimate daughters were used to build alliances. His wealth paid for the strengthening of castles, whether at Carlisle or Domfront, and the wages of the men who garrisoned them. Bishops were essential figures: a bishop for Carlisle was one way of separating off Strathclyde south of Solway from the north, which became the bishopric of Glasgow.Footnote 98 Territorial bishoprics in Wales were an important element in the ‘Normanization’ of the Welsh church.Footnote 99 In southern Normandy the bishopric of Sées had suffered from the activities of Robert de Bellême, and after the appointment of a new bishop in 1124 steps were taken to reorganise the see in which Henry played a prominent role.Footnote 100 He was present at the consecration of the new cathedral in 1126, and granted charters to the bishop. Sées like Carlisle was a cathedral church which was staffed by Augustinian canons. The patronage of religious houses provided opportunities for the assertion of his influence, and again there are parallels between northern England and, for instance, southern Normandy, where he showed favour to the abbey of Saint-Evroult.Footnote 101 The foundation of Savigny, within Normandy but very close to the frontiers of Brittany and Maine, gave him the opportunity to extend his patronage in a region authority in a remote area of the duchy.Footnote 102
The evidence relating to royal administration supplies a different perspective on Henry's rule in the north. At first sight our impression, based on the surviving numbers of writs and charters and of the coverage in the 1130 pipe roll, is of growing vigour. A study of writs and charters must be postponed until the new edition of Henry I's acts appears,Footnote 103 but a closer look at the pipe roll is illuminating. Yorkshire was most like the rest of England in terms of royal administration, but even here the crown estates were much less valuable than in southern England, and there were a number of great jurisdictional liberties. The 1130 pipe roll provides a snapshot of the character of royal administration towards the end of Henry's reign. Yorkshire was a full county with a sheriff, Bertram de Bulmer. He was the son of a former sheriff, from a local family, not a magnate of the first rank.Footnote 104 There was recurrent annual revenue from land, from at least one royal forest, and from the city of York, but perhaps the most striking feature of the 1130 account was the number of debts rising from agreements with individual magnates. Already, then, the crown was able to deal with individuals as well as communities, the hallmark, it has been suggested, of a new style of ruling.Footnote 105 Many of these agreements had doubtless arisen from the activity of royal justices, namely, Eustace FitzJohn and Walter Espec, and the royal chamberlain Geoffrey de Clinton.Footnote 106 References are made to those involved in judicial activity, the judices and juratores of the county.Footnote 107 There were possibilities for extending royal influence as the city of York began to prosper. There was a merchant gild,Footnote 108 and a mint,Footnote 109 as well as two castles.Footnote 110 Archbishop Thurstan's refusal to make a profession of obedience to Canterbury had delayed his arrival in his see, but from 1120 he proved to be an active archbishop, promoting the foundation of religious houses, which then sought confirmation charters from the king.Footnote 111 Henry gave churches for prebends at York Minster, and he granted the canons privileges.Footnote 112 He was a benefactor of the hospital of St Leonard's where, incidentally, he may have spent his birthday in 1122.Footnote 113 He was a patron, too, of the Benedictine abbey of St Mary's at York,Footnote 114 and confirmed the endowments of the priory of Holy Trinity.Footnote 115
It is instructive to pursue the treatment of different regions of the north in the pipe roll a little further. The heading ‘Between Ribble and Mersey’ is inserted into the account for Yorkshire. So far as the barons of the exchequer were concerned, the king's rights in south Lancashire had to be maintained, but no revenue was forthcoming, only a record of debts owed for a concord with the count (that is, Stephen count of Mortain), and no reference was made to north Lancashire, the honour of Lancashire, which was entirely in Stephen's hands.Footnote 116 Northumberland follows the account for Yorkshire; no pleas are specifically distinguished as ‘New’, and the account is relatively short: the sheriff, Odard of Bamburgh, accounted for a farm and also for danegeld, levied at the round figure of one hundred pounds.Footnote 117
In 1130 the bishopric of Durham was in the king's hands. Ranulf Flambard had died in September 1128 and as yet the king had not nominated a successor. The royal chamberlain, William de Pont de l'Arche, had visited the bishopric to make arrangements for its custody,Footnote 118 and Walter Espec and Eustace FitzJohn had been about the king's business, and been hearing pleas.Footnote 119 One of the barons of the bishopric, a man named Geoffrey Escolland, accounted for its revenues.Footnote 120 Finally, Carlisle and Westmorland occur on a roll which includes various miscellaneous accounts. The revenues of Carlisle were in the hands of a man named Hildret, and a man named Richard the knight accounted for a geld of animals (no danegeld here).Footnote 121 There are signs of change: money had been spent on the wall round the city of Carlisle, and a gift had been made to the Augustinian canons of St Mary for the building of their church.Footnote 122 Three years later, the first bishop was consecrated by Archbishop Thurstan and St Mary's became the cathedral church.Footnote 123 The silver mines at Alston, which had been opened up recently, had been at farm to the burgesses of Carlisle, but in the year just ended the farm was accounted for by a man named William, together with Hildret, presumably the same man who accounted for the king's farm.Footnote 124 The revenue from Westmorland was accounted for by a man named Richard son of Gerard of Appleby. This included a farm for the king's lands and rights in the region, and a payment for the geld of animals. Once again, there are references to the pleas of Walter Espec and Eustace FitzJohn.Footnote 125
The pipe roll evidence thus demonstrates that, although it was wide-ranging, royal administration was a relatively thin veneer over northern society. No attempt had been made to shire the northern regions: Carlisle was not a county but a potestas,Footnote 126 and Northumberland, administered first by the sheriffs based at Corbridge and Bamburgh, was in the later years of the reign administered from Bamburgh alone.Footnote 127 Durham was only in royal custody temporarily. Relatively little revenue was coming in from the northern counties in comparison with Berkshire, and none at all from the land between Ribble and Mersey.Footnote 128 A good deal of local policing was in the hands of local lords, rather than the sheriff.Footnote 129
On the other hand, the references to the pleas of Walter Espec and Eustace FitzJohn's activities throughout much of the north are striking. They were regionally based justices with a remit to safeguard the king's interests. They supervised restocking of royal manors and work on castles, and imposed fines on local lawmen. Their role possibly derived from that of earlier commissions, including that which had overseen the Domesday Inquest in 1086, and was different from the later general eyre.Footnote 130 References to the pleas of Geoffrey de Clinton at Blyth and the visit of William de Pont de l'Arche to Durham are more significant.Footnote 131 They were members of the royal court and inner circle, chamberlains with special responsibility for finance, the link men between the itinerant royal household and the royal treasury. The fact that royal agents in the north were answerable at the exchequer meeting in the south is a further sign of incorporation within the realm. Administrative innovations were incremental, however, superimposed on the old rather than sweeping them aside, and they form only part of the story, and perhaps not its most important part.
In northern England Henry's aims and methods were much the same as elsewhere, whether in England, Wales or Normandy. Old-fashioned dynastic politics were at its heart: the shrewd appreciation of possibilities to be gained by marrying off a daughter, raising a young prince in his household, punishing his enemies and rewarding his friends, as William of Malmesbury noted.Footnote 132 What differed in the different parts of his realms were the contexts and therefore the consequences of his actions. In Normandy he had to fight to defend the duchy and its future, and to the south the county of Maine was only secured at a high price and as part of a bigger package, the marriage of his only daughter into the comital house of Anjou. In Wales there was resistance to the Normans but also some opportunity for advance, and the ‘Normanisation’ of the Welsh church created opportunities for influence. The idea of a superior kingship over the Welsh and Scots was exploited, and, if this is to be defined as imperialism, then Henry was as imperialistic as his predecessors. Yet the Welsh and the Scots were treated differently, for the Anglo-Scots border as a political divide was respected and even reinforced by the creation of the diocese of Carlisle. The dividing line between the English and Scottish kingdoms was not fixed for good, of course, because after 1135 David took over Cumbria, and Northumberland, and sought to place his own nominee as bishop of Durham.Footnote 133
In retrospect Henry's greatest achievement in the north as in the rest of England was to bring peace. It was a stern peace, with winners and losers, and it depended less on administration than on alliances and patronage. This created conditions in which the new lordships could take shape, and for that great flowering of monasticism of the early twelfth century. The northern chroniclers understood this very clearly. One with first hand experience was Richard, prior of Hexham, who wrote a history of the deeds of King Stephen and of the battle of the Standard in 1138. He began by reviewing the achievements of Henry I, the peace of his reign and the religious houses he had founded. He described the terrible effects of the Scots’ invasions after 1135, their defeat at the Standard in 1138 and the peace concluded in the following year at Durham. It was agreed at that time that David's son Henry would become earl of Northumbria. The barons performed homage to him, and swore allegiance. The Scots handed over hostages and swore to keep the laws, customs and statutes which King Henry had decreed to be observed in the earldom. Just in case readers were unsure exactly what these laws were, the author thoughtfully included a text of Henry's Charter of Liberties in his chronicle.Footnote 134 Peace and the observance of law were no mean legacy.
