Birrell and Gray have given us what is possibly the first full account of the effects of devolution on the control, financing and delivery of welfare services across the UK's four constituent countries. They dive straight into the details in the first chapter, picking out a number of key agendas which, they suggest, have influenced (to differential extents) the evolution of the partly or wholly devolved range of welfare services. These are: devolution itself, contracting out, austerity, rolling back the state, partnerships, localism, participation, personalization and co-production, performance and scrutiny, and e-government. They also offer a discussion of the contested alternative meanings of ‘social welfare services’, although this section ends inconclusively, leaving the reader unsure of exactly which services they intend to cover and why. Subsequent chapters reveal that, de facto, their coverage includes health care, social care/social services, social security, housing and education. So there is little on the police, for example, or much on the probation service, both of which arguably make a considerable contributions to social welfare.
The intended audience for the book does not seem to be defined or discussed anywhere, which does not make the reviewer's task any easier. My own take would be that it will be a good source for masters’ students and academic staff, but is too dense and assumes too much for first year or even possibly final year undergraduates, unless the latter are already specializing in social welfare.
The second chapter covers the financing and organizational structures of the devolved administrations, with the emphasis on service delivery. It is clearly structured and fact-heavy. One quibble would be that the potentially very useful section on the Barnett formula is undermined by the failure to elucidate what the main variables mean – the formula is summarized in a text box, but the key components (‘comparability devolved percentage’ etc.) are never explained.
The third chapter focuses on what is left in Whitehall (quite a lot, including the UK's largest department, the DWP). Again, it is rich with facts – reports, white papers, organizational arrangements and changes – and only occasionally offers tantalizing brief glimpses of larger ideas (such as when passing mention is made of Taylor-Gooby's suggestion that the coalition government reforms after 2010 were aimed at entrenching a permanent neo-liberalism).
Chapter four shifts the focus to local government. The authors catalogue the frenetic waves of re-disorganization to which local government in England has been subjected by the centre since the 1980s. Greater stability has prevailed in the other three countries of the Union, though there have been important changes there too. In England far more has been taken away from local authorities (especially in housing and education) than has been given to them (in public health). On top of this, the period since 2010 has witnessed an unyielding programme of austerity, for which there is currently no clear end in sight.
Chapter 5 looks more closely at those areas where local government has clear responsibilities for social welfare delivery. It is again an overwhelmingly fact-listing chapter, with minimal interpretation or argument.
Chapter 6 is entitled ‘Delegated governance: “quangos” and services’. It notes that quangos now account for a higher proportion of central government expenditure than local government, and then goes on to chart the tortuous history of quango ‘culls’ and renewed growth. Quangos have ‘become closer to replacing local government as the main vehicle for delivering social services’ (p.115). This is another workmanlike chapter, bulging with information about what has happened and how it has varied between the four countries. Once more, however, there is a certain shying away from issues of theory and definition: after a discussion of the difficulty of defining quangos, the authors fail to come to any clear position of their own. Neither do they here make full use of some of the more conceptual and theoretical literature on quangos, although there is plenty of it.
Chapter 7 deals with partnerships. Like chapter 4 this is partly a story of instability and endless tinkering. Consider the helter-skelter of local authority partnership initiatives listed in Table 7.1 (p. 155): Local Area Agreements (2005), Total Place pilots (2009), Community Budgets (2010), Whole-Place Community Budget pilots (2010), Local Enterprise Partnerships (2010), Our Place (2011), Public Services Transformation Network (2013), and more since. One might have thought that the immense popularity of partnerships with governments of all hues would be linked to demonstrable success; but no, as the authors make clear, the jury is still out and, indeed, the firm evidence is barely sufficient to mount a decent trial. Individual partnerships have clearly been successes or failures, but the business of constructing a contextualized analysis of when which types of partnership are likely to work and when not is still unfinished and contested.
Chapter 8 looks at privatization and welfare delivery: the ‘mixed economy’ of welfare delivery. In a now familiar way, it begins by citing various alternative definitions of privatization, demonstrates that it is a ‘slippery concept’, but then fails to take a clear authorial position. It then looks at the record of privatization, sector by sector, providing as we go along many relevant examples, data bites, and references. Prisons and the probation service make a rare appearance. Across several sectors the chapter chronicles the very mixed record of privatizations, with problems of inadequate governance, capacity issues and overbilling plus, perhaps most disturbing, the weakness of government responses even when serious problems have clearly manifested themselves.
Chapter 9 concerns itself with the involvement of users and the public. In familiar mode it notes that there are multiple and contested definitions of involvement/participation/co-production, and subsequently that ‘There are not well-established, evidence-based or large scale studies about the effectiveness of user and public participation’ (p.203). It lists many pieces of legislation, initiatives and ideas about this trend, acknowledging that ‘User participation is now in the mainstream’ (p.189).
Chapter 10 deals with new forms of welfare regulation and, in particular, the burgeoning of various performance management and performance indicator systems. Inter alia, it notes a shift in focus from outputs to outcomes. The coverage is, as usual, broad and well-informed. A quibble would be that the problem of outcome attribution (whether the outcome is wholly/largely/somewhat attributable to management's actions) is left until the very last sentence of the chapter, and thus not adequately discussed. Outputs, for all their other weaknesses, are less subject to this particular problem.
A short concluding chapter – 11 – follows. It reprises the agenda from the first chapter and offers boxed summaries of the differing arrangements in the four countries. A brief reference to ‘disputed discourses in the narratives’ is left to the last paragraph – to my mind it is a pity that this was not a red thread running through the whole book.
In sum, this is a good book, painstakingly assembled from many sources, and cautious and balanced in its interpretations. It is certainly also a very useful book, bringing together an overview of the increasingly diverse patterns of provision across the UK's four constituent countries in a comprehensive manner which I have not seen equalled elsewhere. I hope the authors will now deploy their vast knowledge in a different way: that they will consider writing another, more theoretically-oriented work. This would be much shorter and sharper. It would articulate one or more theoretical interpretations of all this detail and compare their strengths and weaknesses. It is the complement for which this fact-saturated volume is crying out. Courage, mon braves!
