Near the end of his December 1899 lecture at the annual Farmers' Convention in Connecticut, Cornell University professor of horticulture Liberty Hyde Bailey made reference to an emerging nature study movement. Nature study, Bailey told his audience, was a means to open a “man's mind to the conditions in which he lives,” putting him into sympathy and harmony “with everything that is,” giving him a desire for knowledge instead of cramming his mind with facts, and giving him a new horizon and a wider and broader view on life. In the ensuing discussion, the president of the Connecticut Board of Agriculture asked Bailey “what kind of practical application he would make of this last principle to which he alluded relative to boys and girls starting in the world and making a living.” Noting the poverty that existed in rural communities, the president expanded his question: “If we are going to have these very fine theories of putting ourselves in harmony with nature and the world around us, we somehow must have clothes on our backs, and we must have shoes on our feet . . . I only ask this question to know how we are to go to work to make this beautiful theory practical?”Footnote 1
Kevin Armitage's important and superbly crafted book provides a groundbreaking study of the “beautiful theory” that inspired and animated the nature study movement of the late-nineteenth and early-twentieth centuries, and the ways women and men worked to make it “practical.”Footnote 2 Armitage positions nature study as a neglected thread in the history of America's conservation ethic. He notes in his introduction that conservation has been, and still is, viewed by historians as an idea that “was fundamentally motivated by efficiency and the bureaucratic application of scientific knowledge to resource policy” (10). He not only offers a critical revision of this idea; he also opens up a new line of inquiry. His main project is to reveal the “multitudinous cultural complexities of the conservation movement” by focusing on work at the grassroots that other historians have neglected (10).
Nature study engaged people in the examination of the natural world in their day-to-day lives and contexts, rather than in distant and isolated wilderness areas. “Armed with guidebooks, cameras, collecting jars, and unrestrained curiosity,” Armitage writes, “Americans flocked from their homes and classrooms to nearby forests, prairies, rivers, and mountains to gain greater insight into the wondrous workings of nature” (3). Nature study activists and educators “used instruction in basic natural history, such as plant identification, animal life histories, and school gardens, to promote the skills needed to succeed in industrial life and to cultivate the spiritual growth that modern life occluded” (3). At the height of the movement, they established a professional society and a scholarly journal. They also secured the adoption of nature study in the official courses of study in elementary schools in almost every state in the country.
Armitage's telling of the nature study movement story centers on a key contradiction of modern industrial society. As he puts it, modern science helped create instrumental rationality, yet people longed to find values in nature that were suppressed by science. In the final analysis, he writes, nature study was an attempt to reconcile science with sentiment. Although Armitage argues that nature study was “at base” a pedagogical movement whose chief object was to reform children, he shows that it was also a political and cultural movement that was meant to reform adults as well. Whereas some saw nature study as a means of teaching children scientific knowledge and skills, of popularizing science, or of relieving stress among urban adults through direct interaction with nature, many of its leading theorists and practitioners—including Liberty Hyde Bailey—held a much larger view of what it was and what it meant. For them, it cultivated a worldview that blended an embrace of science with a deep ecological sensitivity. It was both a reaction against several aspects of modern industrialized and bureaucratic life and a call for ecological sustainability and cultural preservation, with profound pedagogical, epistemological, and ontological implications.
The Nature Study Movement is not a single historical narrative. It consists of seven related essays, sandwiched between introductory and concluding chapters that frame the book and discuss nature study's contemporary relevance. The essays trace the origins of the movement's philosophical and pedagogical ideas. They attend to specific topics and events, including the connection between nature study and the concept of recapitulation, the creation of Bird Day, the educational power of school and community gardens, aesthetics and photography, and the use of nature study in agriculture and rural life. Along the way Armitage examines the ideas and work of key movement leaders including Francis Wayland Parker, Wilber Jackman, Anna Botsford Comstock, Mabel Osgood Wright, Gene Stratton Porter, and Liberty Hyde Bailey.
Bailey exemplified one of Armitage's key arguments: “Environmentalism, along with its embrace of science, is simultaneously infused with criticisms of modern life” (211). This is revealed in Bailey's response to the question the president of the Connecticut Board of Agriculture posed about how nature study would help farmers and their children make a living. “I think that most farmers can make a living now,” Bailey replied. “But what our farmers need, is not so much to know how to make more money as to know how to live.” I doubt the president was satisfied with this answer. It illustrates the depth of meaning and purpose—well beyond simply the popularization of science or the promotion of a conservation ethic through state action—that leaders like Bailey and his Cornell colleague Anna Botsford Comstock invested in nature study. By sketching the story of how these leaders developed and made practical the “beautiful theory” behind the nature study movement, Armitage makes a major contribution to the work of illuminating and interpreting a neglected chapter in American life that offers many lessons for the present.
