Relatively few Americans are comfortable with the idea of the United States as an imperial power. Although “imperialism” appears frequently in invective criticizing US foreign policy, acceptance or rejection of this characterization does not easily correlate with one's position on the political spectrum: there are neoconservatives who embrace American empire as an established fact – and see no shame in it – and political liberals who deny it. The way that Fiona I. B. Ngô frames her provocative Imperial Blues makes American imperialism a more difficult concept to dismiss lightly. She implicitly likens Jazz Age New York – “the Empire City” – to colonial municipalities such as Shanghai, Kolkata, Singapore, Hong Kong, Cairo, Casablanca, Batavia, Cape Town, or Yangon, a polyglot “contact zone” inhabited by migrants from virtually everywhere in the world an American intervention had occurred. Puerto Ricans, Filipinos, Japanese, Cubans, Jamaicans, Hawaiians, and Chinese rubbed shoulders, danced, and copulated with people of European and African ancestry (many of whom were themselves recent arrivals either from overseas or from the American South, via the Great Migration). Consorting with one another to the accompaniment of jazz music, these people explored new modes of artistic and sexual expression, tried on new identities, and breached virtually every imagined barrier (racial, sexual, or class) that conspired to divide them. A moral panic ensued, dictated by an “imperial logic” of essential difference, and given teeth with a regulatory regime that sought to prohibit such transgressions and restore a more segregated normative order that reflected this logic.
To be convincing as a comprehensive perspective on Jazz Age New York, Ngô's study requires an interdisciplinary approach. She deftly employs social history; ethnography; “queer” studies; and analysis of literary, visual, and musical texts, making her book of potential interest to a diverse audience.Footnote 1 Imperial Blues is an occasionally dense read, with many arguments and sub-arguments to follow and a variety of theoretical approaches to absorb; most undergraduate readers would struggle with it. That said, it is a rewarding and insightful book, tying together multiple threads that were at some point disentangled by scholars with narrower foci on specific components of the Jazz Age and Harlem Renaissance. From the opening analysis of Cab Calloway's seminal hit “Minnie the Moocher” (1–3), I repeatedly found myself thinking, “Oh yeah!” and wondering why it has taken so long to acknowledge the imperialist and orientalist aspects that suffused Jazz Age culture.
Empire serves as Ngô's “central analytic” because “the domestic or national organization of race and sex during the Jazz Age, and in New York City as an exemplar of the period's sensibilities, cannot be understood except in the context of the growing ambitions of modern U.S. empire” (4). She contends that “empire at home” operated under an “imperial logic” that, “through a sometimes contradictory flow of signs,” enabled New Yorkers to experience both “distance and intimacy” with the colonial world without leaving the bounds of their own city (3–5). As in any imperial setting, some who crossed figurative borders could imagine themselves as prestigious cosmopolitans (92), while others who did the same were considered dangerous transgressors. The key insights of Ngô's study are that those for whom skin color or sexual orientation were disadvantages in this milieu made free use of orientalist imagery to craft alternative identities and to critique the imperialist/racist/sexist/heteronormative order, but that these critiques themselves were embedded in imperial logic (75, 78, 87). In an analysis of the drawings of Richard Bruce Nugent, the author notes, “Empire thus became a place for queer subjectivity; however, that queer subjecthood is made viable and visible through imperial logic” (82, original emphasis).
Imperial Blues explains and links a variety of cultural phenomena that permeated the Jazz Age: the “oriental” as a sign of “sexual alterity” (80, 104, 109), the notion of Harlem as “Mecca” or “Araby” (156, 161–62, 164), the linkages between the Arab-themed “Dance of the Seven Veils” and the hoochy-coochy and shimmy (129), popular understandings of emergent sexological science, and the rage for Egyptian motifs and Tutankhamen in interior design and popular song (175). “Jazz cultures” themselves served as “contact zones” in which experimentation with “indeterminate” identities and practices could occur (152). Although vice squads emerged for surveillance and control of these zones, Ngô insists that imperialism led not just to “repression” (190) but also to potentially emancipating modes of self-expression and identification.
