In the 1990s, Germany broadened its citizenship law and included immigrants as citizens of the nation, Russia eliminated ethnicity from its passports, and Turkey lifted its prohibition of minority languages. How and why did these changes occur? Şener Aktürk has written an admirable comparative study of “ethnic regime change” in Turkey, Russia, and Germany after the Cold War. Aktürk asks the relevant question: why did definitions of nationality in Turkey, Germany, and Russia de-ethnicize in the period following the end of the Cold War? This book argues that for ethnic regime change to occur, counter-elites with a new discourse on nationality need to gain political hegemony. The book has a straightforward, clear structure: two chapters are dedicated to each case, and each case can easily stand on its own.
The main thesis is persuasive and original, and offers a fruitful theorization of ethnicity and nationhood. Aktürk's model of change is based on an almost brilliant simplicity, which is nevertheless convincing. The argument boils down to the notion that political elites have to be willing (i.e., formulate a “new discourse”) and able (i.e., “establish hegemony”) for policies of nation formation to change. The book's empirical underpinnings are based on an impressive plethora of published primary and secondary sources in German, Turkish, and Russian. This source material is sufficiently digested and supports overall the claims made in each chapter's conclusion. The book contains a coherent, clear presentation of useful tables and maps, and Aktürk employs a straightforward, lucid writing style, at times interrupted by bouts of rhetoric, such as: “Are there any common features in the discourses in favor of preserving the status quo and opposing reform? There are” (p. 112). The book bears the marks of a revised PhD dissertation, although much less so than is commonly seen, and would have benefited from slightly more rigorous editing. Some footnotes are overly long, the conclusion digresses somewhat from the main issues, and the thesis, because it is repeated in every other chapter, may seem overstated.
The comprehensiveness of each case-study is matched by that of the comparisons between cases. A thorough comparative study focused on the history of nationalism in Russia, Germany, and Turkey had not been written until now. This book boldly and originally embarks on congruence testing: using the fruits of profound historical research to improve our understanding of three cases that exhibit a particular, causal sequence or pattern. One major accomplishment of this book is that it remains respectful to each country's historical context, discovers a novel explanation, and refines preexisting theoretical reflections in light of new evidence, thereby achieving more conceptual validity. Aktürk has carefully chosen the political entities to be compared, which made it possible for him to control for three different sociocultural environments. Comparison also elucidates each case study: we now have not only a comparative analysis of these countries, but also a fuller grasp of nationhood in each of them. The conceptual apparatus that he uses is drawn from comparative history and therefore entirely adequate. The comparative framework is proportionate, although the chapters on Turkey have greater depth than those on Germany and Russia.
Aktürk's explanations are convincing, but also limited in scope: they certainly seem to apply to Turkey, Russia, and Germany, but more cases must be examined using the same kinds of sources and approach in order for him to develop his theory. The author's claim that “there cannot be and are no cases” (p. 28) of his variables coexisting and not producing the same outcome, or that this typology is “exhaustive” and “superior” (p. 43), may be viewed as a rash conclusion. In other words, rather than advancing generalizations subtly the book sometimes overreaches a bit. Further research controlling for domestic institutional changes and focusing on international shifts would elucidate his thesis. In the book's conclusion, Aktürk stimulates the reader by suggesting counterfactual scenarios and the limits of his argument. The open-ended nature of his discussion will spark future discussion of ethnicity regimes in other countries with similar historical trajectories, such as Hungary, Greece, and Israel. The question remains whether the regime change he describes occurred at the national or global level. Did the consistency and isomorphism of the nation-state system weaken or abate when the Cold War “ended” in 1991? What did political elites learn from each other? Also, if the simultaneous co-occurrence of the three factors explains de-ethnicization, would their simultaneous divergence give way to ethnicization?
There are only minor issues to be taken up with the book: it surprisingly refers to the Kurdistan Workers’ Party (PKK) solely in terms of terrorism (or the oxymoron “guerrilla terrorism”). As a study of discourse change, the book could have benefited from more linguistic precision. On a related note, contrary to Germany, Russia and Turkey both went through destructive civil wars in the 1990s (involving Chechens and Kurds, respectively), and one wonders where these conflicts figure in the explanation of ethnic regime change. Also, the book treats Turkey's Alevis as an ethnic rather than a religious group, which may not find unanimous approval among the Alevis of Turkey. Further, the book argues that the efforts of Turkish immigrants were decisive in the change of Germany's ethnicity regime. But rather than a shift in hegemony, this seems to me to be a broadening of the democratic mandate and a proliferation of emancipation in the Bundesrepublik. Finally, the Russian chapters draw heavily on evidence from Tatarstan and less equitably from other multiethnic federal republics, such as the North Caucasus, Sakha, or Altai. But none of these minor quibbles detract from the book's formidable intellectual potential. Regimes of Ethnicity rightly takes its place in the flourishing academic landscape on changing forms of nationhood. Anyone interested in any of these three countries, or in comparative nationalism studies, is wholeheartedly recommended to read this book.
