Carl F. Young has written a wide-ranging book on two related mass movements in modern Korean history, called Tonghak (Eastern Learning) and Ch’ŏndogyo (commonly referred to as Religion of the Heavenly Way). The temporal frame within which Young discusses their emergence, development, and significance is 1860–1919, and he examines them as both individual and sequentially linked movements. In fact, Ch’ŏndogyo slowly evolved from Tonghak as an expansive, vigorous, and largely distinct organization without renouncing this intimate connection. Young recaptures what is already known, especially about Tonghak, and adds numerous new findings, especially on Ch’ŏndogyo. In the early sections of the book, he also deftly covers the theoretical debates on the subject and amply weaves in the many insights and opinions of both Korean and foreign scholars.
Paradoxically, Ch’ŏndogyo formally came into being under the Japanese Protectorate of Korea. Unlike Tonghak, which had to maintain a stealthy existence, it operated as an open organization. In part, it had to do with the marginally liberal Japanese state under the Meiji Constitution, but more substantially it was because Ch’ŏndogyo had taken a deliberate decision to depart from the violently confrontational methods of Tonghak. It initially showed ambivalence overlaid with acquiescence toward the Japanese presence in Korea, because its main leaders had come to admire Japan as an Asian variation of Western modernity worthy of emulation by Korea—a model of munmyŏng kaehwa (enlightenment and civilization) in the common parlance of the era.
Young lucidly elaborates the fact that in both Tonghak and Ch’ŏndogyo the fundamental religious and ethical core was the same. It was articulated by, among other concepts, the latter's doctrine of “in nae ch’ŏn,” rooted in the teachings of Tonghak's founder Ch'oe Che-u, whose life and teachings receive substantial coverage in the book. Essentially stressing the identity of humankind with Heaven, it is a philosophy of divine immanence, which inevitably creates an emphasis on social and political egalitarianism as opposed to the rigid hierarchical structures of neo-Confucianism, the official ideology of the Chosŏn state.
The intellectual grounds for this message lay in a blend of ideas from Buddhism, Daoism, and Korean Shamanism and, interestingly, some fraught terminology drawn from Catholicism, although Tonghak avowedly rose as a counter to the Christian penetration of Korea. Similarly, the more harmony-oriented neo-Confucian tenets were co-opted into the mix. This contrived confluence of ideas became quite appealing to the downtrodden. Apart from its uplifting exhortation of “serving Heaven by serving humanity,” it seemed to promise opportunities for everyone's progress, including women's advancement. To the state, it all too obviously had an ominous potential for subversive political action. Hence the state's alarmed repression, leading to the 1864 execution of Ch'oe Che-u and later of other leaders and activists, especially after the 1894 Tonghak Rebellion in several parts of southern and central Korea.
Of course, ideas pronounced and ideas practiced are not always the same. Some contradictions in the foundational doctrines of any movement have a built-in quality, the more so in an eclectic ideology like that of Tonghak-Ch’ŏndogyo. Others result from the inevitable zigzag course of any large movement as it tries to capture the hearts and minds of people through situational improvisations under changing national or global forces impinging on them. Young covers that ground quite well, especially when he discusses Ch’ŏndogyo's rise as a universalistic religion with both spiritual and secular goals but with a philosophical and ethical base in the “unique” Korean tradition. (Considering the provenance of its main constituent elements, it might actually be more fitting to call it the Sinic tradition with a distinctive Korean variation.)
The especially troubling contradiction that could not—and cannot—really be resolved lay in the attempts to reconcile Heaven's (or God's, if one prefers) immanence with the concept of divine transcendence. Intellectual historians of Asia may find that duality in the book to be particularly stimulating for its pretzel-like logical twists and for its parallels with ancient Indian thought. Be that as it may, when Tonghak became Ch’ŏndogyo, a radical reorientation of the latter gradually took shape under its charismatic leader Son Pyŏng-hŭi. Looking at all the details about its gospel, rituals, and organization, it becomes clear that Ch’ŏndogyo eventually became a kind of Korean answer to the Christian movement.
Other parts of Young's book cover the activism and martyrdom of Ch'oe Si-hyŏng, the second patriarch of Tonghak; offer biographical sketches of other major Tonghak and Ch’ŏndogyo activists; and examine Ch’ŏndogyo's initial ties with several other organizations and their leaders, especially the notorious pro-Japanese body called Ilchinhoe (Advancement Society). The tense, at times murky, goings on between Ch’ŏndogyo and Ilchinhoe during 1905–10 throw much light on the poverty of political choices before the modern-minded Koreans boxed in by the relentless imperial-colonial forces of the times.
The moment of political clarity for Ch’ŏndogyo did come, but later. The tightening and suffocating Japanese grip on Korea eventually broke Ch’ŏndogyo's patience like that of countless others, and it decided to throw itself with energy and commitment into a nonviolent movement for national independence. Fully fifteen of the thirty-three eminent Koreans who signed the March 1, 1919, Declaration of Independence in Seoul were Ch’ŏndogyo figures, led by Son. With this high-profile political role, Ch’ŏndogyo finally acquired solid nationalist credentials.
Young has woven all these strands and a whole lot more into his book, including a brief section on women's roles in Ch’ŏndogyo's activities. Some repetitions creep into the story here and there, but they do not burden the reader too much. Before the book's publication, one could have suggested a few other lines of inquiry logically related to the topic, but they are better left unsaid here, for their absence does not detract from the book's overall value to historians of religion and politics.
