In a research note written in 2005 and subsequently rejected by three leading political science journals as too speculative and not adequately statistically anchored, we sought to update Brunell and Grofman's 1998 research note in the APSR on divided Senate delegation by showing that we were right in predicting that, in the Senate election years taking place immediately after our original data analyses, the number of states with divided Senate delegations would continue to decline.1
Those interested in obtaining a copy of Brunell and Grofman's 2005 paper are invited to email the authors at tbrunell@utdallas.edu or bgrofman@uci.edu.
Brunell and Grofman (1998) use the number of divided Senate delegations as a (leading) indicator of realignment. In our 2005 unpublished paper we wrote: “If we were to take 1952 as a baseline for how far the number of divided Senate delegations might be expected to drop in the modern era, it may well be 2004 (or at date close to it) which will prove the high point of Republican dominance—at least as judged by the reduction in the number of divided Senate delegations.” In fact, in 2006, the number of divided delegations increased by two states to 15 total. This is the first time since 1974 that the number of divided Senate delegations has gone up by more than just a single state.
In our 2005 paper we further argued that, with more data points to examine, the suggestion in Brunell and Grofman (1998) that 1980 was a realignment year looks even more plausible. We also think 2006 is more than just a blip, i.e., that it reflects more than an idiosyncratic confluence of unrepeatable factors such as a botched and unnecessary war, corruption scandals, and a president in his second term who is perceived as having surrounded himself with incompetents and yes-men.
David Mayhew's (2002) seminal work notwithstanding—and we agree with just about everything he said about flaws in existing realignment theory—there are cycles in American politics, and 2006 may well be an inflection point signaling a change in the direction of the recent pro-Republican partisan tides.
