Eighteenth-century dramatists had little or no control over the production of their plays after the initial run. In spite of major strides made in copyright during the eighteenth century—developments that have long been studied and celebrated—dramatists were in an unenviable position when it came to owning their work. Literary property law initially extended only as far as print publication, not performance, and any theatrical company that was able to get hold of a playtext could produce that play without the permission of the author. As a result, dramatists received far less for their work than they otherwise might have.
By the end of the century, many major playwrights, including Richard Brinsley Sheridan and George Colman the Elder, began keeping their plays out of print in order to make it more difficult for rival theatres to obtain copies and perform them. Playwrights were not the only theatrical professionals affected. As Julie Stone Peters and John Russell Stephens have noted, managers who initially produced a play lost potential profit when rival theatres bought a print copy and produced the same play. As a result, managers, including Colman and Thomas Harris, began buying copyrights in order to ensure that popular plays would not be printed.Footnote 1
What has not yet been considered is how the limitations of literary property affected actor-playwrights. A great many actors throughout the century wrote plays to create performance vehicles for themselves. But if these actor-playwrights had no control over subsequent productions of their plays, they also could not guarantee that they would be hired to act the parts they had specifically written for themselves.Footnote 2 It was precisely this complex and fluid relationship between acting and writing, between an actor's ability to possess a part and an author's ability to own his or her literary works, that prompted the first major attempt by a playwright to control not only the print publication but also the performance of his works. Actor-playwright Charles Macklin was determined to control the circulation of his plays so that he could perform certain parts exclusively. As early as 1759, after the huge success of his farce Love à la Mode, he began withholding his plays from print, an unusual move at a time when nearly all popular plays appeared in print shortly after the first run.Footnote 3 His innovative strategies for controlling the production of his farce in an era when major questions concerning copyright and literary property were still up in the air set a precedent for later-century playwrights and managers, who learned from Macklin the power of leveraging print for securing exclusive performance rights.
Macklin was determined to possess his dramatic parts permanently as a form of job security, for both his personality and happenstance often left him in a precarious professional state. A talented actor who was known in his own time to have revolutionized acting methods and trained some of the great actors, he was also an argumentative man who could be a difficult collaborator and employee. When he briefly attained a position of power and security, acting as Charles Fleetwood's stage manager at Drury Lane from 1734 to 1743, he made an enemy of the proprietor by walking out with the rest of the actors in 1743.Footnote 4 In Fleetwood's eyes, Macklin's walkout was unforgiveable because he was not just an actor but a trusted lieutenant in the management of the theatre. From that time on, Macklin moved among various theatres in multiple cities, negotiating temporary contracts and occasionally quarrelling with other actors and managers. And he knew that simply writing himself a character would not be enough to secure his employment. After all, what if he was fired after one season and another, more tractable actor took over his parts? Monopolizing a part, as Macklin sought to do, was no easy task, given that an actor could not legally own a part. Part possession, which had been a theatrical custom during the late seventeenth and early eighteenth centuries, was quickly waning by the time of Macklin's acting career. As a result, he needed to find a creative way to possess his parts exclusively. In his arguments for why he should be able to earn and possess parts he had not written himself, Macklin emphasized the creative labor of his interpretation, adopting much of the same language that authors used to argue for literary property. This strategy would prove particularly successful for his famous characterization of Shylock, yet it depended on public support rather than law. Thus, the second way that Macklin turned to literary property as a strategy for possessing a part was by writing his own plays, keeping them out of print and protecting the unique manuscripts so that theatres could not produce them without his consent.
Macklin's quest to possess parts revealed the limitations of literary property for protecting drama. Because performance was not legally considered publication, it was not protected under England's first copyright act, An Act for the Encouragement of Learning, by Vesting the Copies of Printed Books in the Authors or Purchasers of Such Copies, during the Times Therein Mentioned (1710), also called the Statute of Anne.Footnote 5 This was a serious shortcoming, given how profitable performance could be. Macklin was aware of the limits of copyright, and he understood that in order to possess his parts in his plays exclusively he would have to compensate for the lack of performance copyright, or an author's right to control and profit from production onstage.Footnote 6 Scholars have traditionally situated the fight for performance copyright in the early nineteenth century and have taken for granted that the movement must have been motivated by dramatists' aspirations for control and profit.Footnote 7 A careful evaluation of Macklin's career, however, reveals that dramatic literary property was a pressing concern in the eighteenth century and was bound up with the possession of parts, the repertory, and the proprietary privileges of not only authors but also actors and managers. Before the Dramatic Literary Property Act of 1833 endowed authors with performance copyright, a range of theatre professionals found innovative ways to control and repeatedly profit from the performance of dramatic literature. Macklin successfully manipulated the rhetoric of literary property to protect the performance of his plays, and his motives and strategies are critical but heretofore neglected components of the story of the development of dramatic literary property.
Possessing Parts
In the late seventeenth and early eighteenth centuries, even before the Statute of Anne began to grant authors property rights, various forms of “ownership” operated in the London theatres that granted companies, managers, and actors proprietary privileges. One such privilege, which was established by the division of the repertory, made particular plays the exclusive property of specific companies. Another customary “right” was an actor's right to his or her personal repertory of parts. One case, an extreme example in which the Lord Chamberlain intervened in casting decisions, illustrates just how powerful the idea of a personal repertory could be. In 1667, the Lord Chamberlain ordered the King's Company to rehire actress Anne Quin after she had left the theatre two years earlier. Moreover, he commanded that the theatre give her all of her former roles: “that you assign her all her owne parts which she formerly had & that none other be permitted to act any of her parts without her consent.”Footnote 8 Restoration actors and theatregoers held a strong belief that an actor had an exclusive right to his or her parts. There are a number of possible reasons why this practice developed in the Restoration period. David Brewer suggests that it was an “offshoot of the division of the repertory at the Restoration.”Footnote 9 That is, if a play belonged to a single company, it made sense that a single actor within that company would hold a particular part.Footnote 10 Peter Holland connects part possession to continuity of performance, or handing down the same interpretation of a character from one actor to the next.Footnote 11 New plays lent themselves to part possession, as authors often wrote characters with particular actors in mind. Judith Milhous and Robert D. Hume point out that the theatre companies were so small during the Restoration period that few actors were available who could challenge an actor's claim to a part.Footnote 12 In addition, because actors had to act parts in quick succession due to a quick turnover of plays, maintaining a steady repertory of parts benefited actors in terms of workload. During the Restoration period, then, the system of part possession seemed logical and natural.
However, changes in theatrical culture and management over the course of the eighteenth century threatened the custom of part possession. By 1695, the repertory was no longer neatly divided. When Thomas Betterton, Elizabeth Barry, and Anne Bracegirdle left Drury Lane to set up at Lincoln's Inn Fields that year, they disregarded Drury Lane's claim to exclusive rights in the repertory of old plays. For a period, the two London theatres respected each other's rights to new plays during the initial season of performance. But after 1728, when the Little Theatre in the Haymarket put on The Beggar's Opera almost immediately after it closed at Lincoln's Inn Fields, the theatres no longer considered new plays to be exclusively their property.Footnote 13 As a result, actors at multiple London theatres might simultaneously possess a part, occasionally even performing them on the same night. Such was the case in 1750 when Drury Lane and Covent Garden famously staged competing performances of Romeo and Juliet. Critics reveled in comparing the two representations of the play, and as the public was made the judge of competing actors, they came to celebrate multiple interpretations of a role. Part possession across companies had never been a legal, or even a customary, right. What is important is that increased variety of interpretation across companies threatened the custom within companies by fostering a public desire for novelty. A growing belief that a part could be performed well in a variety of ways weakened actors' claims that their success in a part should ensure their perpetual possession of it.
As the custom of part possession declined over the eighteenth century, actors eager to maintain principal roles had to mount a case for their right to a personal repertory. Proponents of part possession relied on two central arguments: (1) that if an actor had won public approval in a part, he or she had earned a right to keep that part; and (2) that part possession was a well-established custom in the theatres. Such were the arguments of Kitty Clive and her supporters in the much-publicized “Polly War” between Clive and Susannah Cibber. When Theophilus Cibber suggested to Drury Lane manager Charles Fleetwood in 1736 that his wife, Susannah, play Polly in The Beggar's Opera, Clive, who had played the role at Drury Lane in 1732, fought back. In a letter to the London Daily Post on 19 November, Clive insisted that the “design” to take away her part was “contrary to a receiv'd Maxim in the Theatre, That no Actor or Actress shall be depriv'd of a Part in which they have been well receiv'd, until they are render'd incapable of performing it either by Age or Sickness.”Footnote 14 Clive argued that she had previously succeeded in the part and that, as a result, it was hers for as long as she wanted it. She knew that because she did not have a legal right to the part, she would have to rely on public support for her case. To that end, she and her supporters repeatedly praised the public's discernment and endowed them with the power to dictate theatrical representation. The originator of the newspaper war, a writer calling himself “Spectator,” reminded the town that they approved of Clive as Polly and argued that “she has a right to” the role “from the town's approbation of her.”Footnote 15
Advocates of part possession further suggested that this custom and actors' respect for it made acting a polite profession. They found examples of actors who had turned down parts that “belonged” to other actors and praised their sense of justice. When, for example, the patentees of the United Company tried to give Elizabeth Barry's “chief Parts” to the younger Anne Bracegirdle, Bracegirdle's “good Sense” prevented her from taking the parts “that properly belong'd to” Barry and “entring into any such rash, and invidious Competition.”Footnote 16 David Garrick, too, deferred to the custom. His biographer Thomas Davies recalls that when he returned to Drury Lane from Dublin in 1743, he relinquished some of his former characters that had been taken by others in his absence. Davies speculates that he “did not wish either to offend, or risque a competition with, either [Henry] Woodward or Macklin, by acting characters to which they had a claim.”Footnote 17
Ultimately, though, both public approval and custom were weak arguments for part possession. Customs are not legally enforceable, and as times change so do practices. A 1765 contributor to The Universal Museum called part possession an “injudicious custom,” arguing that “continuing a number of characters to several of their performers” prevented the public from seeing actors of potentially greater merit.Footnote 18 Moreover, the public could approve multiple actors in a single character. In a case such as Garrick's return to Drury Lane, multiple actors had succeeded in the same set of roles at the same theatre. By the logic that popular success in a role established ownership, Garrick, Woodward, and Macklin would all have had a right to the same parts at Drury Lane. Equally complicated situations arose when actors moved between the two London theatres. Relying on the public's applause to guarantee a role put actors in a precarious position. In fact, Clive succeeded in making her case not because of public enthusiasm about her performance but because of her successful manipulation of their sympathies. As Berta Joncus points out, Clive had not been particularly successful as Polly in 1732, a fact the public must not have remembered as she insisted in newspapers and onstage that she was being deprived of her rightful part.Footnote 19 In spite of Clive's victory, public support was not an approach on which all actors could rely. The question of whether the custom was sustainable or beneficial to drama came to a head in 1800 when a group of actors lodged a series of complaints against the proprietors of Covent Garden Theatre.
The Covent Garden actors were primarily upset about an increased charge for their benefit night. Among a series of lesser complaints, they included the decline in the practice of part possession. In A Statement of the Differences Subsisting between the Proprietors and Performers of the Theatre-Royal, Covent-Garden (1800), the actors observed that “The right to the possession of his cast of characters, a most important privilege which appertained to the Actor, has of late years been so constantly violated, that it can scarcely be said to exist.”Footnote 20 In their shorter “Memorial” to the Lord Chamberlain, the actors summarized their grievances: “they do not seek any new and speculative Advantages, but … they simply beseech the Restoration of Privileges attached to their Profession by ancient and established Usage.”Footnote 21 Their appeals relied entirely on tradition. Harris responded to the actors' demand by suggesting that for the good of the theatre, the most talented and physically apt actors must fill each part: “Can any thing be more preposterous than a right to a Cast of Characters? Granting to the complainants their own estimation of their own Talents, is it impossible that Superior abilities may arise? Must the Romeos, the Young Belvilles &c be for life possessed by the present Actors tho’ years should compleatly disqualify them[?].”Footnote 22 The Lord Chamberlain supported Harris, arguing that it was “necessary for the good Management of the Theatre” that managers should be able to cast actors “in such Characters as the Proprietors shall think proper.”Footnote 23 The actors were ultimately unsuccessful. A once well-respected theatrical privilege—part possession—could no longer be counted on. Yet as one form of theatrical “ownership” was declining, another form, literary property, was becoming stronger. After the breakdown of the divided repertory and the custom of part possession, literary property was the one form of ownership that was still operational within the theatres. As a result, theatre professionals of all types, not just authors, began to look to it.
The Creative Labor of Interpretation
Macklin's unusually long career in the theatre as both an actor and a playwright, and as a member of not only London theatres but also strolling companies and Dublin theatres, exposed him to theatrical politics and showed him the challenges inherent in both professions, particularly in relation to property. From the time he began acting in the 1720s to his retirement in 1789, he was assertive (at times aggressive) about his working conditions, pay, and property. Indeed, this assertiveness sometimes got him in trouble and contributed to his well-known reputation for litigiousness and volatility. His reputation cannot be attributed wholly to professional assertiveness. His temper showed itself in more trivial situations as well. In 1735, he stabbed fellow actor Thomas Hallam in the eye with his cane and killed him, simply because Hallam had used his favorite property wig. Yet the extremity of this situation often overshadows Macklin's serious dedication to ensuring fair working conditions. His quarrel with Fleetwood and Garrick after the actor rebellion of 1743 is one instance in which his determination to secure actor rights threatened his ability to work. Seven years later, in 1750, Thomas Sheridan fired him from Smock Alley after the two disagreed over benefit arrangements, management policies, and, most tellingly, parts.Footnote 24 Matthew J. Kinservik argues that by 1753, Macklin was forced into retirement as a result of his poor relations with three managers and his dwindling repertory of parts.Footnote 25 The success of his farce Love à la Mode in 1759 brought him back to the London stage, but his employment remained precarious. In 1770, George Colman refused to hire Macklin “on the same Footing on which other actors usually engage,” instead offering a contract in which he would act one night a week.Footnote 26 Appleton suggests that Colman proposed this arrangement because he did not want Macklin backstage every night.Footnote 27 Without steady employment or a personal repertory, Macklin articulated an explicit argument for earning dramatic parts on the basis of labor and original interpretation.
Late in his career, in 1773, Macklin began negotiating with Colman for employment at Covent Garden. As he had been three years earlier, Colman was hesitant to work with him. Macklin's contentiousness was not his only obstacle. The type of parts he excelled in—comic roles—were already filled. He wrote to Colman, “I am sensible that you can not make so extensive a use of me in the comic Parts that I used to perform in Drury Lane and Covent Garden Theatre; other People are in possession of them.”Footnote 28 His unwillingness to challenge the current actors in their parts shows Macklin's profound respect for part possession. Thus, Macklin proposed that instead of pursuing his usual parts, he should act a set of tragic roles, specifically Richard III, Macbeth, and Lear, which were left open when William Smith left Covent Garden to set up his own company.Footnote 29 Concerned to establish his “usefulness” in the theatre, or, as he described it to Colman, “the utility that arises from ordinary service,” Macklin did not wish to perform these parts only temporarily; he wanted to make them part of his personal repertory.Footnote 30 To ensure that Colman understood the value of his performance, Macklin emphasized the originality of his proposed interpretations of these characters. He wrote to Colman, “My worth then must consist in shere attraction [and] theatrical attraction has but one source,—which is novelty.”Footnote 31 His performance of Macbeth later that year would show that he was willing to put significant work into creating new interpretations.Footnote 32 If his performances were popular with the audience, he argued, then his experiment in novelty would be “an Ingredient of Utility,” or a way to make him indispensable to the company. Along with the novelty of his interpretations, Macklin offered Colman “novelty in Composition” in the form of a new play and two new farces. In the juxtaposition of his acting and writing, we see that Macklin viewed the two activities in much the same light. He understood that because originality in composition secured him property in his plays, originality in acting might secure him permanent possession of his parts.
Macklin had already succeeded once in maintaining possession of a part through his creative labor. In 1741, he introduced a radically new interpretation of Shylock in Shakespeare's The Merchant of Venice. Macklin's huge success in possessing the character for the next forty years probably resulted from the rhetoric that arose around his performance, which emphasized his labor, his understanding of Shakespeare, and his originality. Much of this language reflected Lockean ways of thinking about property, although neither Macklin nor his critics explicitly invoked Locke.Footnote 33 Descriptions of Macklin's Shylock so pointedly emphasize his creative process that we can take his successful possession of the part to reflect more than just the popularity of his interpretation. In descriptions of his performance, we see theatre critics thinking through what it might mean to earn possession of a character through the same means that authors earned property in literary work.
Macklin's portrayal of Shylock struck audiences as exceptionally original because of both his textual and performance choices. For the forty years before Macklin's debut, the London stage had seen only George Granville's adaptation of Shakespeare's play, The Jew of Venice (1701). Granville's adaptation cut a number of the characters, omitted roughly one thousand lines, and added a masque scene. A number of comic actors, including Thomas Doggett, played Shylock as a comic villain.Footnote 34 Macklin rejected this text, instead reintroducing Shakespeare's original text, or something close to it. Moreover, as reviews of his performance emphasized, he broke with the comic interpretation of Shylock, instead depicting the character as a truly threatening force. John Ireland observed: “I have been told, that previous to Mr. Macklin's performance of Shylock, it was looked upon as a part of little importance, and played with the buffoonery of a Jew pedlar; to the understanding of that venerable performer, we are obliged for the first true representation of the character.”Footnote 35 Critics believed that Macklin's approach best reflected Shakespeare's intention. Such a belief is expressed in the famous couplet attributed to Alexander Pope: “This is the Jew, / That Shakespeare drew.” While we have no evidence of how Shylock was played in the original production, we do know that Macklin's performance convinced audiences that they were seeing the character in his original form. Moreover, audiences equated Shakespeare with nature, so that by adhering to Shakespeare's text and intentions, Macklin was also imitating nature. Arthur Murphy, writing pseudonymously in the Morning Chronicle in 1773, remembered that “Macklin looked deeply into nature, and nature, from the hand of Shakespeare, requires great thinking.”Footnote 36 Macklin had studied nature by studying Shakespeare, Murphy explained. He had also studied nature directly, as the writer of The Present State of the Stage in Great-Britain and Ireland (1753) observed: “The Actor should like the Author, search thro’ Nature for the Constituents of the Character which he is to fill. This Rule Mr. Macklin generally observes, his Distinctions are critically right; and he draws from Nature the Heightening and Completion of his Characters.”Footnote 37 According to limited and anecdotal evidence, he observed Jews in the Royal Exchange and nearby coffeehouses, “that by a frequent intercourse and conversation with ‘the unforeskinn'd race,’ he might habituate himself to their air and deportment.”Footnote 38 He even dressed himself in the style of Italian Jews, describing his costume as “my red hat on my head, my piqued beard, loose black gown, &c.”Footnote 39 Macklin's costume would have been particularly striking because it was not yet common practice for actors to wear period costumes. His costume, interpretation, and performance all gave his audience the impression that he was harnessing nature.
Following his debut as Shylock, Macklin came to have a reputation for the work he put into character development. “Labour” was a word frequently found in reviews of his performances, from an anonymous reviewer who called him a “laborious performer”Footnote 40 to Thomas Davies's declaration that Macklin was the only actor who “made acting a science.”Footnote 41 Even his severest critics recognized the work he put into a role: “It may be fairly said, that he has shewn no evidence of Genius as an Actor, or a Writer. As an Actor, all his merits were the mere result of labour.”Footnote 42 These evaluations reflect his own statements about his creative process. His notes indicate that in addition to observing Jews in the Royal Exchange and studying the clothing of Italian Jews, he read about them in Josephus's History of the Jews.Footnote 43 He took notes in his commonplace book that briefly detailed key moments in Jewish history and advised himself to “go thro the history of it—act the great characters.”Footnote 44 Macklin took character development and original interpretation seriously, and because of that, he expected some security in the possession of his parts.
Contemporary critics were explicit in their belief that Macklin's labor and originality endowed him with a right to perform Shylock. In A General History of the Stage (1749), William Chetwood wrote of Macklin: “The Science of Acting is not to be learn'd without great Labour and Study; and, not copying any Performer that went before him, he has at length shone out a finish'd Original.” Macklin's success was well earned, “since with long laborious Pains” he had created his roles.Footnote 45 Chetwood's use of the word “pains” calls to mind Locke's chapter on property in the Second Treatise of Government, where he writes that he “who takes that pains about” removing something from nature has a right to property in that thing.Footnote 46 Describing Shylock specifically, Chetwood wrote, “Shylock the Jew, in the Merchant of Venice, is so inimitably counterfeited, that we cannot say more than … ‘This is the Jew / That Shakespear drew.’”Footnote 47 His use of the word “counterfeited” is fascinating. In an era when charges of literary plagiarism and an overreliance on imitation were rampant, Chetwood used “counterfeited” in a surprisingly positive manner, praising Macklin for coming so close to the “original” Shylock, or Shylock as Shakespeare drew him. Chetwood's word choice echoes Bassanio's reaction when he sees the portrait of Portia in the leaden casket: “What find I here? / Fair Portia's counterfeit! What demi-god / Hath come so near creation?”Footnote 48 While copying a previous performer would have decreased Macklin's success as Shylock, counterfeiting the original ensured it. Thus, Chetwood concluded by establishing Macklin's ownership of his parts: “This Jew, this Colonel, Lopez, Ben, has shown / He makes each various Character his own.”Footnote 49
Macklin's possession of Shylock was hugely successful and prompted him to view labor and novelty as more effective rhetorical strategies than custom or public approval. He performed Shylock from 1741 to 1789, when he was roughly ninety years old. Because actors could not legally own characters, his possession of Shylock was not entirely exclusive. John Gross counts at least a dozen other actors who performed Shylock during Macklin's tenure.Footnote 50 But very few of them succeeded in the part because audiences were convinced that only Macklin could truly embody Shylock. Macklin's hold on Shylock in the public imagination and within the theatre companies was so strong that Kitty Clive refused to play Portia when Garrick cast Samuel Foote as Shylock in 1758.Footnote 51 Toward the end of Macklin's career John Henderson succeeded in the role, but even Henderson could not act the part without constantly being compared to Macklin, who was called “the veteran” because he had acted for so long. Macklin's performances of Shylock had inspired public interest in the process of character development and what that creative labor might mean for an actor's “right” to his characters. His acting career had coincided with the many literary property debates that used concepts of originality and creative “genius” as grounds for owning literary productions. Macklin took advantage of this concurrence, making a point of emphasizing the originality of his interpretations and staking a claim to his characters.
Reappropriating the Laws of Literary Property
Although Macklin succeeded in possessing Shylock through his creative labor, at no point during the Restoration or the eighteenth century could an actor legally own a role. What could be legally owned, however, was literary property. So Macklin used his playwriting and the rights with which he was endowed as an author to retain and control dramatic parts. In the first legally printed edition of Love à la Mode (1793), Macklin's editor, Arthur Murphy, explained that because Macklin had retired from acting, the farce was “of no further use to him.”Footnote 52 The “use” Murphy referred to is the play's use in providing a performance vehicle for Macklin. Macklin very consciously kept the play out of print so that he could exclusively perform the part of Sir Archy Macsarcasm and repeatedly profit both as the author and lead actor. He exercised his rights as an author to further his career as an actor. In turn, and perhaps more important for literary history, his quest to further his acting career led him to see the limitations of literary property as it applied to the theatre and to treat his plays in a way that anticipated the development of performance copyright in England. Macklin's thirty-year mission to control the production of Love à la Mode illuminated the complex and murky relationship between print and performance and revealed the need for literary property to account for the stage.
Although the meaning of the Statute of Anne was debated throughout the eighteenth century, it was clear on one point: it applied to the “book,” or print publications. This point was reinforced almost a century later in 1793, when Chief Justice Kenyon ruled that the copyright act “only extends to prohibit the publication of the book itself.”Footnote 53 But what of publishers who worked in modes other than print? In the seventeenth and early eighteenth centuries, oral publication was still considered a form of publication, a fact that becomes particularly evident when looking at regulation and punishment. Surveyor of the Press Roger L'Estrange's 1663 treatise on press regulation, Considerations and Proposals in Order to the Regulation of the Press—a document that, by its title, one might imagine dealt exclusively with print—included ballad singers among the usual “agents for publishing.”Footnote 54 L'Estrange recognized the interworkings of print and orality and the ways that one enabled the other. Barbara A. Mowat highlights the complex relationship between print and performance during the early modern period and the “dual (legal) existence” of a genre that was published in two forms: “The printing and selling of plays for readers made the boundary between theater and literary culture increasingly porous.”Footnote 55 To illustrate this point, she turns to a 1611 Star Chamber case in which a group of strolling players defended themselves against charges of sedition by arguing that they were reading from a printed book. They believed that because the book had already been licensed and published in one form, they were safe in publishing it in another mode: performance. As late as the early eighteenth century, performers could be punished as publishers, regardless of whether the play was already published in print. From 1700 to 1702, a series of prosecutions were brought against actors for speaking obscene language.Footnote 56 In his famous speech on the 1737 Stage Licensing Act, Lord Chesterfield argued against preperformance censorship on the grounds that the government could always punish the publishers: one “can be under no difficulty to prove who is the publisher; the players themselves are the publishers.”Footnote 57 In each of these instances, we see performance being imagined as an act of publication that was distinct from but related to a printed text. The porous relationship between print and performance complicated any effort to regulate performance in a consistent manner.
The legal status of performance as a mode of publication was further complicated by the collaborative nature of performance. As such scholars as Gerald Eades Bentley have argued, “every performance in the commercial theatres from 1590 to 1642 was itself … the joint accomplishment of dramatists, actors, musicians, costumers, prompters (who made alterations in the original manuscript) and … managers.”Footnote 58 The same was true in eighteenth-century theatres. Because the playwright was not the sole creator of the performed work, it was more difficult to secure his or her proprietary right to profit by performance. Moreover, as W. B. Worthen writes, while both literature and theatre claim drama as part of their domains, they value plays differently. The theatre, interested in a play's use for the company, decentered the author, whereas a print- and manuscript-based literary culture increasingly celebrated authors as creators.Footnote 59 The centrality of the author was essential to discourses of property. Extrapolating from Locke, Mark Rose argues that an author's personality underwrote his literary property: “A work of literature belonged to an individual because it was, finally, an embodiment of that individual.”Footnote 60 Thus, as vast strides were made in articulating proprietary rights within the author-centric realm of print throughout the eighteenth century, performance remained unaddressed and unprotected. Once a play was published in print, a theatre could perform it free of charge, without having to so much as consult the author. As Milhous and Hume put it, print “publication essentially put a script into the public domain.”Footnote 61
Ironically, it was an early form of theatrical ownership during the Restoration period that had enabled playwrights to begin printing their works in the first place. The clear division of the repertory that followed the reopening of the theatres meant that a manager did not have to worry about the other theatre purloining the script. As a result, managers allowed playwrights to supplement their incomes by publishing their plays. As the divided repertory fell apart, however, and playwrights continued to print their works, performance copyright became an issue.Footnote 62 Peters argues that “[i]n England more than anywhere else, play publishing practices were affected by the vicissitudes of performance copyright.”Footnote 63 Although this proved true by the end of the century, when managers such as Harris, Colman, and Sheridan began buying copyrights to delay publication, for most of the eighteenth century, playwrights did not meddle with issues of performance copyright, instead simply taking what they could get from performance and print publication. Macklin was exceptional in his early challenge to remuneration systems and literary property law.
In order to keep Love à la Mode out of the public domain, Macklin intentionally withheld the play from print. He emphasized this fact in a suit against Robert Owenson, the manager of the City Theatre, Fishamble Street in Dublin, who had performed the farce without Macklin's permission. Macklin's lawyer, D. Hussey, argued that although Macklin could have profited substantially by selling the copyright to a publisher, he “refused large sums of money which were from time to time offered him for the copy or the copy right thereof by persons who intended to print or publish the same.” Hussey explained that Macklin refused to print the play “from an imagination that property of an author in works of genius was as inviolable as any other property.”Footnote 64 However, dramatic literary property was not inviolable, and merely keeping the play out of print was not enough to ensure that managers would not get hold of a copy. So in addition to withholding publication, Macklin carefully protected his unique manuscript copy.Footnote 65 His moves were quite unusual, and contemporary commentators described his eccentric strategies in colorful detail. John O'Keeffe documented Macklin's habit of taking his script home each night:
When he came to rehearsal, his method was to take his MS. from the breast of his great coat, where he had buttoned it up, put it into the hands of the prompter, and, rehearsal done, walk quietly over to him, saying, “Give me that,”—take it from the prompter's hand, button it up close again in the breast of his coat, and walk out of the house to his own lodgings.Footnote 66
Macklin cited his own vigilance when he prosecuted pirates. Macklin and Hussey's bill against Owenson documents the lengths to which Macklin went to protect his script. The bill explains that during the first run of the farce, Drury Lane's transcriber was given a full script so he could copy out parts for individual actors. But “such transcribers were always expressly forbidden to make any entire copys or transcripts of said entertainment or to suffer any to be made there from.”Footnote 67 In forbidding theatres to keep copies of Love à la Mode, Macklin was more or less contracting for a single run of the show. He would earn authorial profits from the play for as long as it ran, and when it was over he could take his script and peddle it elsewhere. This type of contract, which was hugely beneficial to the playwright, was, according to Milhous and Hume, “totally unprecedented in the eighteenth-century London theatre.”Footnote 68
Macklin's strategy of keeping the play out of the public domain was a smart move financially. He earned a phenomenal amount of money from Love à la Mode, particularly given that it was only an afterpiece. His contract with Drury Lane did not operate under the usual third-night benefit system, instead stipulating that he would receive a fifth of the profits from the first five nights at £63 charges (i.e., operating costs) plus a sixth-night benefit. Milhous and Hume estimate that he earned £336 at Drury Lane. Because Macklin was not a regular member of the Drury Lane company for the 1759–60 season, the remuneration was for both his writing and acting.Footnote 69 The next season he contracted with Covent Garden on similar terms and earned an additional £340. These first two runs alone earned him significantly more than the average afterpiece earned for its author. Typically authors who sold afterpieces on a benefit system might earn around £100 from the theatre and an additional £30 or £40 for its publication.Footnote 70 Thus we can see that a successful play had much more profit potential for its author in the theatres than in print. Macklin's decision to keep the play out of print and guard his manuscript proved highly profitable.
Macklin's protection of Love à la Mode also ensured his employment as an actor. In contracting with theatre managers, he used the play as a selling point. If theatre managers wanted the popular afterpiece, they had to take Macklin as well. William Cooke remembers that as Macklin brought the piece to new theatres in London and Dublin, he “retained the character of Sir Archy M'Sarcasm for himself.”Footnote 71 According to Shirley Strum Kenny's count, Macklin played Archy 135 times out of a total of 147 eighteenth-century performances of Love à la Mode.Footnote 72 With a few exceptions, then, only Macklin could play Sir Archy. When Garrick wrote to Tate Wilkinson in 1760 asking him to perform Sir Archy at Drury Lane, Wilkinson declined, purportedly out of respect for Macklin's right to the character. At this point, Macklin had left Drury Lane and was staging Love à la Mode at Covent Garden. Wilkinson writes that Garrick intended to “hurt (if possible) Mr. Macklin's property in that excellent piece.”Footnote 73 If Drury Lane put on Love à la Mode at the same time as Covent Garden, Macklin's authorial profit would have been lessened as the two theatres competed. Wilkinson situated the phrase “Macklin's property” in a section about his decision not to play Sir Archy, implying that Macklin had property in the role as well as in the text. Wilkinson added, as an afterthought, “surely the labourer deserves his hire.”Footnote 74 In referring to Macklin as “the labourer,” Wilkinson did not differentiate between the actor and the playwright. Wilkinson's vague use of “property” and “labourer” is reasonable, as the acts of writing and acting were bound up in each other for Macklin. If Macklin's literary property in the piece were not respected, his hold on Sir Archy would not be guaranteed.
And in fact, Macklin's property in the popular farce was not wholly respected. Love à la Mode was both printed (in part) and performed without his consent. In April 1766, the Court Miscellany printed the first act of Macklin's farce with a promise to print the second act soon thereafter. The magazine's owners, Richardson and Urquhart, had hired shorthand writer Joseph Gurney to go to the theatre and copy down the play. Macklin sued the printers. The defendants claimed that because the farce had been performed, it had been published already, which “gave a right to any of the audience to carry away what they could, and make any use of it.”Footnote 75 But the court held that performance was not a form of publication and that because Macklin had never printed the work himself he held common-law property in the piece perpetually: “[W]here the author did not print or publish his work, it was never doubted that no other person had a right to print or publish it.” When a work was published in print, it became a “gift to the public,” enabling the public to make use of it in various ways, including reprinting small pieces in newspaper reviews and reciting it aloud. “Representation” onstage, however, “was no gift to the public.”Footnote 76 Ironically, the same logic that enabled Macklin to claim the exclusive right to print his piece—that performance was not a publication—would in future cases disenfranchise authors seeking performance copyright. If performance was not a form of publication, it could not be protected under the copyright act. Thus, when Macklin was faced with the dilemma of theatres performing Love à la Mode without his consent, he had no legal recourse.
In spite of the fact that Love à la Mode was not fully printed while Macklin was still performing it, provincial and Irish theatres found ways to recreate the script, enabling them to perform the farce without having to pay Macklin an author's benefit or hire him as an actor. Cobbling together an entire version of the script was tricky work, but it was worth the trouble for such a popular farce. Wilkinson, who in 1760 had declined Garrick's invitation to play Sir Archy at Drury Lane, decided in 1766 to put on the play at Newcastle. He explains, in his Memoirs, how he reconstructed the script by piecing together individual parts:
The part of Sir Archy I had to prepare myself in; Mr. Garrick sent it to me at Winchester in the year 1760; Squire Groom from my friend Ned Shuter; Mordecai from Mr. Creswick, who had acted the part at Covent Garden; the lady's part from Mrs. Burden's copy, who played it at the same theatre: So I had only to make the Irish character of Sir Callaghan, which by the frequency of seeing the farce, and the help of the first act being printed in a magazine, made it with a little trouble more than half ready to my hands; Sir Theodore, a part from remembrance; the rest of my own manufacture.Footnote 77
While Macklin made a point of taking the full script home with him each night, he did not, apparently, take the actors' sides from them at the end of a run. A number of other theatres performed the play without Macklin's consent, perhaps using techniques similar to Wilkinson's to create a text. Based on Macklin's angry letters to managers, we know that James Whitley's strolling company performed it in 1771; Henry Mossop and his company at Smock Alley performed it in 1762 or 1763; and Robert Owenson's company at Fishamble Street performed it in 1785. Macklin prosecuted or threatened each of these managers, emphasizing the “Great Labour Assiduity Care and Study” that had made the work his own and arguing that the property violation was doubly damaging because he had gained “very considerable reputation Profit and Benefit [from Love à la Mode] both as an author as well as an actor.”Footnote 78
Although performances were not technically a violation of Macklin's property, he compensated for his lack of legal recourse by making a show of his ownership. He embraced his threatening and litigious public character to scare managers away from using his work. When Macklin discovered that Whitley's strolling company intended to perform his farce, he suggested to his lawyer that they should file a bill without warning Whitley, as that “would be more alarming to him, and to others of the same character in life, who have taken the same liberty.”Footnote 79 On another occasion, Macklin assured Tate Wilkinson that the only reason provincial companies had recently gotten away with performing the farce was that he was in Ireland: “[B]ut now I am returned, and … depend upon it, I shall put the law against every offender of it, respecting my property, in full force.”Footnote 80 Macklin probably benefited from popular equation of the actor with Shylock, his most famous character. The public thus saw Macklin as a vengeful figure. In fact, in a rare case when Macklin forgave Wilkinson for performing the farce, Wilkinson commented, “Mr. Shylock to me proved himself no Jew.”Footnote 81 In 1800, Charles Dibdin recalled that Macklin did not write many plays and instead tried to make a single play support him financially. As a result, Macklin became “a torment to himself and to every body else.”Footnote 82 Admittedly, Macklin's celebrity persona was often cartoonish in its focus on litigiousness and vengeance; certainly he was more complex than many contemporary descriptions made him out to be. Yet it was this very persona that aided his success, and he seems to have cultivated it when it was convenient to do so. Macklin was famous for vigilantly protecting his plays, and his public character and almost theatrical level of litigiousness made his crusade to limit performances of Love à la Mode surprisingly successful.
Through retaining his property in Love à la Mode, protecting the manuscript, and threatening managers who performed the play without his consent, Macklin managed to control the production of his work in the absence of performance copyright. Doing so benefited him hugely not only as an author but also as an actor looking to ensure his employability. His strategies were unorthodox but effective. Appleton claims that Macklin “championed the property rights of authors.”Footnote 83 This may be going too far, as Macklin actively championed only his own rights. In the course of his many fights with theatre managers, he never presented a coherent, legal argument for why performance should be protected. Although he was vocal about his literary property, he secured control over performances by carefully protecting his script instead of through legal means. Nevertheless, his strategies for controlling the production of his work influenced later playwrights and theatre managers, many of whom began keeping plays out of print in order to limit performance. Macklin's eccentric approach to keeping Love à la Mode out of the public domain drew attention to the limits of copyright and set in motion a gradual movement by theatre professionals to attain clearer, more empowering laws on dramatic literary property.
Macklin's Successors (or We All Came out of Macklin's Greatcoat)
In his 1790 Memoirs, Tate Wilkinson complained of the trend among managers and playwrights of keeping plays out of print: “The fashion of not publishing is quite modern, and the favourite pieces not being printed, but kept under lock and key, is of infinite prejudice to us poor devils in the country theatres, as we really cannot afford to pay for the purchase of MSS.”Footnote 84 Wilkinson was troubled that he could not simply buy a printed a play and perform it free of charge because many of the most popular plays were being jealously held by their owners. By the end of the eighteenth century, the lack of performance copyright had caught up with theatres. Playwrights were upset that they had no control over the production of their plays after the first run, and managers who had paid for the initial right to perform the play were upset when rival theatres could easily buy a printed script and perform the same play, undermining the initial theatre's profit potential. These managers adopted Macklin's method of keeping plays out of print. They began buying copyrights and prosecuting theatres that pirated and performed plays to which they held the right.
Thomas Harris at Covent Garden was one of the first managers to begin buying copyrights. In 1774, he bought the copyright to Sheridan's The Duenna to prevent other theatres from performing it. An article in the General Evening Post complained that “the comic opera of the Duenna is not to be published; the managers of Covent-garden house having bought the literary property of it, to prevent its exhibition at any other Theatre.”Footnote 85 Harris withheld the extremely popular play from publication for two decades. George Colman, manager of the Haymarket, followed suit, buying the copyright to a number of John O'Keeffe's plays, including The Son-in-Law and The Agreeable Surprise, for a mere £40 each.Footnote 86 In his Recollections, O'Keeffe explained that Colman had asked him to sell him the copyright “instead of disposing of it to a bookseller; as in the latter case, he said, the winter houses would hack it out, and take from [The Haymarket] that novelty which was necessary to attract an audience in the hot summers.”Footnote 87 By his own account, O'Keeffe went along with the arrangement both because he was thankful to Colman for producing his first play and because he feared that if he refused, Colman would not stage his future plays. Colman kept O'Keeffe's plays out of print for years, and as late as 1798, when O'Keeffe wanted to publish his complete works, Colman's son refused to allow him to print the five plays to which he held the publication rights. (Managers also occasionally paid playwrights to delay publication. In 1780, for example, Harris paid Hannah Cowley £100 to hold off on publishing The Belle's Stratagem and Charles Dibdin £120 to delay publishing The Islanders.)Footnote 88
Managers who were also playwrights had a creative stake in protecting their work in addition to a financial stake. Colman and Sheridan kept a number of their own plays out of print so they could exclusively produce them at their own theatres.Footnote 89 In restricting performance, these playwrights were able to exercise a greater degree of creative control over the production of their works. It is a truism that playwrights have more control in print than onstage. It should come as no surprise, though, that playwrights who wrote specifically for the stage—often with particular actors in mind—would want to have some control over theatrical representations. Yet without performance copyright, dramatists were unable to restrict the staging of their works or demand to be involved in production decisions. Sheridan was particularly wary of what theatres might do to his works without his supervision. Thus, when he became manager of Drury Lane in 1776, he staged his plays there and kept them out of print. John Bernard speculated that Sheridan protected his manuscript of The School for Scandal “in order to preserve his language from mutilation, and prevent the play from being produced at any theatre where the proper attention could not be paid to its ‘getting up.’”Footnote 90 The play was not legally printed in Sheridan's lifetime. And although Sheridan occasionally loaned the manuscript to other managers, he largely kept it close so he could limit and control performances. The Morning Chronicle commented on 17 May 1777 that “we hear it is Mr. Sheridan's intention not to publish the School for Scandal; in which case, as there will be but a small part of the town, comparatively, who will have an opportunity of seeing it this season, there is no doubt but its attraction, next winter, will operate as forcibly as it appears to do at present.”Footnote 91 The limited number of performances increased demand, which worked in Sheridan's favor. But as was the case with Love à la Mode, the popularity of The School for Scandal led to piracies, both in print and onstage.
As theatres found ways to perform the plays that playwrights and managers were deliberately keeping out of print, these playwrights and managers began to realize, as Macklin had decades earlier, that literary property needed to protect not only the printed book but also the staged play. Whether printed or not, any play could be produced onstage without consequence. Harris and Colman encountered this gap in the law when they brought managers to court for piracy in 1777 and 1793. Harris and the proprietors of Covent Garden had bought the copyright to The Duenna from Sheridan in 1774, before Sheridan became a manager of Drury Lane. Sheridan's comic opera turned out to be one of the most popular plays of the period; it was acted 164 times in London in the eighteenth century.Footnote 92 When Irish managers produced illegitimate versions of the unprinted play, Harris prosecuted. In 1777, Harris's case against John Byron Vandermere, manager of the City Theatre, Fishamble Street, was tried in the Irish Court of Chancery. Harris asked that Vandermere and his company “be restrained and injoined from printing, publishing, or acting said piece.” An article in The Gazetteer from 3 May reported that “yesterday se'nnight the great question concerning literary property, received a final decision.”Footnote 93 However, that decision involved only the representation of the work onstage. After hearing both sides, the Lord Chancellor declared that he would not grant an injunction against the acting of the play. What the public perceived to be the “great question concerning literary property” was how it applied to performance.Footnote 94 In 1777, the Lord Chancellor in Ireland declared that theatres could freely produce The Duenna or any other play, printed or unprinted.
A similar case was tried in the Court of King's Bench in 1793. George Colman the Elder had bought the copyright to O'Keeffe's The Agreeable Surprise in 1781. Over a decade later, in 1793, he had still never published the play in print. So when George Wathen, manager of the summer theatre at Richmond, put on the play, Colman brought him to court under the Statute of Anne, claiming, according to one newspaper report, £4,000 in damages.Footnote 95 Because he understood that performance did not count as publication under the Statute of Anne, Colman's lawyer, Thomas Erskine, did not try to argue that Wathen's performance was a violation of the act. Instead, he argued that because performance was so profitable, it should be considered publication. Erskine's arguments constituted one of the first major attempts to amend the laws of literary property to include performance. He argued that “if this [performance] were not held to be a publication within the statute, all dramatic works might be pirated with impunity; as this was the most valuable mode of profiting by them.”Footnote 96 Erskine further argued that authors held rights to their literary property independent of the Statute of Anne, as Millar v. Taylor had shown. This second argument may have been the downfall of his case. By 1793, Millar v. Taylor was no longer the dominant ruling on literary property; Donaldson v. Becket had intervened and reinforced a limited copyright term under statute law. Thus, Chief Justice Kenyon was able to dismiss the case, ruling that “the great copy-right case by the House of Lords,” or Donaldson v. Becket, confirmed that “the statute for the protection of copy-right only extends to prohibit the publication of the book itself. … But here there was no publication.”Footnote 97 While Durnford and East's Reports record that Kenyon made his ruling without hearing from the defense, articles in Lloyd's Evening Post and the Morning Chronicle reported that both sides were heard and that the jury ruled in favor of Colman before the judges found for Wathen on a legal technicality.Footnote 98 If we take the newspaper reports to be accurate, we see that the jury—and perhaps the public more broadly—were beginning to view performance as an essential part of literary property.
John O'Keeffe, the author whose work was at stake in Coleman v. Wathen, saw the case as a direct descendant of Macklin's dealings with theatre managers. In his Recollections, O'Keeffe provided a brief overview of Coleman v. Wathen, in which he acted as a witness for the plaintiff. He then placed it in a tradition of performance copyright debates by transitioning into a longer story about a country manager who had performed Macklin's Love à la Mode without permission.Footnote 99 Macklin was such a visible and notorious figure and his dealings with publishers and theatre managers were so well known by the late eighteenth century that it is no great stretch to attribute the protectionist attitudes of Harris, Colman, and Sheridan to Macklin's example.
T. J. Thackeray, writing in 1832, commented that piracy in the form of performance had essentially become a right: “Another great evil of the present system is that injustice which now sanctions as a right the piracy which managers of theatres commit on dramatic authors by the performance, without the consent of the author, of any play as soon as published.”Footnote 100 Given the rulings in Coleman v. Wathen and Proprietors v. Vandermere, his claim was not unfounded. The next year, a bill was finally passed giving playwrights “the sole Liberty of representing” their dramatic works. The Act to Amend the Laws Relating to Dramatic Literary Property (1833) stipulated that the author of “any Tragedy, Comedy, Play, Opera, Farce, or any other Dramatic Piece or Entertainment”—or his or her assignee—would maintain the exclusive right to represent that piece (or cause it to be represented) for a certain amount of time. If the piece were not published in print, the right was indefinite.Footnote 101 If the author printed the work, his or her exclusive right to representation lasted for twenty-eight years or the author's lifetime. Had the law existed during Macklin's lifetime, he would have been able both to print Love à la Mode and to control its performances. The law would have legally given him the bargaining power (as author) to possess a character perpetually and even exclusively (as an actor).
While dramatic authors were gradually working toward fuller property rights over the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries, actors would never attain a legal right to dramatic parts. Actors could certainly still dominate parts through their popularity in them. But legal ownership grounded in creative labor was exclusive to authors. As an actor-playwright who was determined not just to write parts tailored to his abilities but also to possess those parts permanently and exclusively, Macklin positioned himself well. His maneuverings within the theatres were prescient: he was wise to abandon the failing rhetoric of “theatrical custom” that was traditionally used to bolster part possession in favor of literary property. And he knew that in order to possess his parts fully by controlling his literary property, he would have to forcefully assert his right to control performance, even though such a right did not yet legally exist. In using his authorial rights to advance his career as an actor, then, Macklin also advanced authors' rights and set a crucial precedent for authors and managers fighting for dramatic literary property.
