Scholars who write about Latin American cinema have often overlooked Chilean productions. The reasons for this include the small number of films produced (in comparison with Argentina and Mexico) for example, and the fact that many Chilean films have been lost. Yet in the in the last few years, there have been renewed efforts to find, recover and restore many Chilean films, resulting also in a number of recent studies on the subject. This book is an example of this trend, aiming not only to situate Chilean films within Latin American productions, but also to highlight their particularities.
From the late 1950s onwards, a group of young filmmakers began experimenting in Chile. This group later became members of the New Chilean Cinema movement in the late 1960s. In their two-volume study, Cortínez and Engelbert set out to understand this movement from a new perspective, focusing on socio-cultural processes and looking beyond political affiliation and the aesthetics of the times. They do this by presenting what David Bordwell has called a ‘piecemeal history’: an in-depth study of eight Chilean films by eight different directors, filmed and premièred between 1965 and 1970.
The title, which makes reference to the slogan that Eduardo Frei used in his 1964 presidential campaign Revolución en Libertad (‘Revolution in Liberty’), provides a historical context. According to the authors, Frei's cultural policies constituted the background for these filmmakers, who were encouraged to be creative, regardless of their political affiliations. In this way, the cultural, political and social context allowed for experimentation in Chilean cinema (no other moment in Chilean cinema history has shown as much variety as these few years). The sets out to rethink Chilean cinema history by concentrating on films that are often forgotten or underrated by scholars, as well as pairing films that are often considered incomparable. According to Cortínez and Engelbert, the films analysed in this book are unique: they all clearly come from different directors with their own particular views. Yet all the films constitute a reflection of society and a medium to put forward views on Chile and the Chilean identity.
The book is organised in nine chapters. The first two provide a methodological and theoretical framework and historical context. These two chapters position the book within the dialogues between film scholars and cinema historians, thus placing it within the existing literature on the subject. The two chapters also explain the fact that the films and filmmakers discussed in the rest of the book did not magically appear in the 1960s.
The next six chapters focus on one or two films at a time: chapter 3 looks at Largo Viaje and Valparaíso mi amor; chapter 4 discusses Morir un poco; chapter 5 tackles Ayúdeme usted compadre; chapter 6 centres on Tres tristes tigres; chapter 7 analyses El chacal de Nahueltoro; and finally, chapter 8 studies Tierra quemada and Caliche sangriento. Each of these lengthy chapters presents an in-depth study of the film(s) under consideration. Mixing different methodological approaches, the authors draw from biographical information about the filmmakers, details regarding the films’ conception and production, and the reception of each film. Each chapter ends with an analysis of the film(s), which divides the them into segments to offer a comprehensible and organised examination. Chapter 9 presents a conclusion to the study.
The authors of the various chapters criticise the preconceptions surrounding Chilean cinema, which they describe in the first two chapters. The argument that cinema historiography needs to look beyond political affiliation and take economic, social and political processes into consideration appears constantly throughout the book. In fact, it is one of the justifications for focusing on such a small period of time, thus avoiding the mistakes of general histories. In order to analyse the films better, it was also vital to consider the underlying processes affecting the director and the conception of the film. Cortínez and Engelbert aim to place these films in their socio-cultural context, considering not only the aesthetics, but also the historical processes that resulted in these films. In their own words, they are ‘explaining an artistic practice as a sociocultural practice’ (p. 51).
The book has tremendous value because of the amount of information that it presents. However, some of its arguments become repetitive, reappearing constantly throughout chapters and therefore losing strength. Moreover, although the authors do their best to guide the reader through the films they are analysing, dividing them into segments cannot replace actual viewings; thus, some of the aesthetic analysis becomes ‘lost in translation’. Fortunately, the book includes DVDs of Ayúdeme usted compadre and Tierra quemada.
The book sheds light on the process of making these films as well as the reception of each production. As a result of thorough research, each chapter gives a detailed description of how the films were received by both critics and audiences, looking at press reactions at the time of the premières and at the views of critics and scholars since then. Furthermore, the book offers a fresh perspective on Chilean productions of the late 1960s, including in the canon a few films that had been ignored, either due to being upstaged by other films, or because of political and aesthetic prejudices.
This study edited by Cortínez and Engelbert invites the reader to rethink and challenge preconceptions about Chilean films. The authors also develop analyses that, by using different methods, bring out new ways of understanding cinema history.
