The 1944 Education Act made the provision of Religious Education (hereafter: RE) compulsory in all state-funded schools in England, a status that the subject retains today. Having developed at a particular intersection of educational, ecclesiastical and societal influences, RE thus holds a unique position in the curriculum of English schools, and as a consequence it has a religious, educational and political importance.Footnote 1
In terms of the subject's history, there is a general consensus amongst scholars that during the 1960s and 1970s, a new chapter in the history of English RE began; consequently, the period is highlighted as one of great transformation. Between the post-war introduction of compulsory RE and the mid-1960s, most RE in English publicly-funded schools was delivered through a confessional, often proselytizing, pedagogy, whereby children were nurtured in, and encouraged to adopt, the beliefs and practices characteristic of the Christian faith.Footnote 2 During the mid-1960s this Christian confessionalism was swept aside and replaced by a ‘post-confessional, multi-faith’, phenomenological and liberal study of world religions,Footnote 3 with the publication in 1971 of the Schools Council Working Paper 36: Religious Education in Secondary Schools often being situated as the locus of transformation.Footnote 4
There has been a great deal of historical analysis of this change, mostly undertaken through the lenses of pedagogy, curriculum theory and national policy.Footnote 5 However, much of this has been reliant on analyses of a restricted range of policy documents (at local and national levels), with certain highly problematic assumptions made about policy implementation, including the notion that these documents are descriptive of classroom practice, when in reality, they were and are prescriptive (Parker and Freathy in particular highlight examples of these prescriptions’ not being followed).Footnote 6 This has led to the development of a dominant historiography which constructs a narrative of rapid change in the nature and purpose of RE while failing to differentiate adequately between policy and classroom practice.Footnote 7 Review of a wider body of material shows that the widespread adoption of the study of world religions in English schools became possible as a result of a series of complex, concurrent, interlinked and networked changes which took place over a longer period than has previously been described, being more evolutionary than sudden and revolutionary;Footnote 8 changes in classroom practice became widespread, eventually creating circumstances in which a change in policy at both national and local levels became possible.Footnote 9
Furthermore, these developments appear to have been driven by a complex combination of educational, theological and socio-political changes. These changes not only fuelled the furnace in which modern English RE was forged, but were significantly affected by, and affected, race and community relations as well as by the advance of interfaith dialogue and partnerships. Technological developments in communication and worldwide travel made it possible to learn about and experience other cultures and countries in ways previously unimaginable. Increasingly, such encounters were not just happening overseas.
Immigration was a significant political and social issue. Racially motivated riots in Nottingham and Notting Hill in 1958Footnote 10 triggered a national debate over immigration control,Footnote 11 but although immigration control may have reduced numbers, it did not reduce tensions.Footnote 12 The controversial election of Peter Griffiths as MP for Smethwick in 1964, the formation of the National Front in 1967 and Enoch Powell's ‘rivers of blood’ speech given in Birmingham in 1968 all attest to the complex and dynamic state of race and community relations during this period.Footnote 13 However, discussion of immigration has been insufficiently nuanced; tending to focus on colour and / or country of origin, issues of religious affiliation have been marginalized.Footnote 14 Whilst Peter Webster highlights the fact that children growing up in the 1950s and 1960s were the first generation that ‘had widespread experience of having neighbours who practised other faiths’,Footnote 15 the extent to which, during the earlier part of this period at least, many of the families settling from overseas were Christian has been overlooked. A survey by the Schools Council, circulated to a sample of 213 schools in 1969, requested information about ‘Christian immigrant children’ and ‘non-Christian immigrant children’; it reported that numbers within each category were very similar, but small in comparison to non-immigrant children (97%), 1.3 per cent of children being ‘non-Christian immigrant children’ and 1.8 per cent being ‘Christian immigrant children’.Footnote 16
Against this complex backdrop, there was a rise in interest in non-Christian religions and their practices, perhaps influenced by the Beatles phenomenon and the growing influence of teachers such as the Maharishi Mahesh Yogi.Footnote 17 All this took place in the context of reduced interest in institutional Christianity, arguably contributing to a further reduction of interest.Footnote 18 There was an expansion of ongoing discussions under the aegis of the Roman Catholic Church and the World Council of Churches (WCC) between Christians and those of other worldviews, both religious and non-religious. Increasingly such activities were seen as a legitimate activity of the Christian Church, especially in the light of Nostra Aetate, the ‘Declaration on the Relation of the Church with Non-Christian Religions’ of the Second Vatican Council, promulgated in 1965, and the work of the WCC.
Whilst highlighting the change in English RE during the 1960s and 1970s, existing historiography fails to attend to the context in which these developments took place, despite the dominance of the church in both the provision and the development of RE.Footnote 19 Specifically, the role of the British Council of Churches (BCC) has hitherto been overlooked. This article emerges from a three-year project which considered the influence of the ecumenical movement, globally and locally, on the development of the classroom study of world religions, focusing particularly on the role of the British Council of Churches’ Education Department (BCCED).
The Role of the BCCED in encouraging the Study of World Religions
In contrast to earlier attempts at formal ecclesiastical co-operation in Britain, the BCC, formed in 1942, was both successful and fruitful. It soon established effective departments for Youth and Publications, developed work in Scotland and by 1949 had established over 170 local councils of churches.Footnote 20 In 1946 the BCC set up an Education Committee, formally constituting the Education Department in 1951, some seven years after the provisions of the 1944 Education Act had come into force.Footnote 21
A detailed examination of the work of the BCCED during the 1960s, the period in which RE in schools was undergoing the change from Christian confessionalism, reveals a number of examples of its active promotion of the study of world religions. Against the backdrop of increasing opportunity for engagement between Christians and those practising other faiths, the examples that follow relate to the expansion of the concept of RE, seeing this expansion not only as facilitating discussion but as a matter of seeking to encourage the involvement of non-Christian faiths.
In 1961 the BCCED was made aware of a ‘Conference on Teaching about World Religions in Schools’, through an invitation issued by the organizers.Footnote 22 The programme included sessions on ‘knowing about religions’, ‘teaching about world religions in the secondary school’ and ‘report on work done with junior school children’.Footnote 23 The organizers expressed the hope that an observer from the BCCED would be able to attend, stressing that the conference was ‘the first of its kind’.Footnote 24 The acting secretary of the BCCED responded to this invitation positively, undertaking to ‘let other members of the Department know about this’, but no record has been found of who attended the event, or of their reactions.Footnote 25
Eight years later, in 1969, a Consultation on Religious Education in a Multi-Religious Society, convened by the BCCED in collaboration with the Community Relations Committee (later to become the Race Relations Board) was held at Harrogate.Footnote 26 It brought together those ‘who were in some way concerned to take advantage of the possibilities of educational enrichment offered by the presence of considerable number of children of non-Christian faith in our schools’, and included ‘representatives of the Islamic, Sikh, Hindu and Christian communities’.Footnote 27 One outcome of this consultation was an expressed desire to consider how ‘non-Christian religions could form a significant part of RE syllabuses’.Footnote 28
Running parallel to preparations for this consultation, a working party had been established in May 1969 by the BCCED to consider the issue of ‘Recruitment, Employment and Training of Teachers Concerned with Religious Education in Schools’.Footnote 29 Evidence was invited from the Council of Christians and Jews, the ‘Immigrant Communities, and Denominational education representatives’.Footnote 30 Responses were received from the Indian High Commission,Footnote 31 the Sikh community,Footnote 32 the Hindu community,Footnote 33 the Community Relations CouncilFootnote 34 and the National Secular Society.Footnote 35 Compilation of the submitted material resulted in a suggested list of elements that should be included in RE at secondary level, including ‘a knowledge of other religions and philosophies of life combined with a tolerance for those who hold other beliefs’.Footnote 36
A seminar on ‘Religious Education in a Multi-Religious Society’, organized by the BCCED, took place in September 1970, in London.Footnote 37 The event demonstrates that the pattern of involving representatives of a variety of faith communities was becoming routine, or normalized.Footnote 38 Participants were asked to discuss a list of ten questions relating to the place of Christianity and other religions in RE. One of the questions asked was: ‘In multi-racial county schools, is a totally Christian syllabus of religious education justified?’; the recorded answer was an emphatic ‘no’.Footnote 39
Finally, from 10–14 July 1972 a Conference on ‘Interfaith Dialogue in Education’, organized by the BCCED in collaboration with the Office of Education at the WCC and the government's Department of Education and Science (DES), took place at Stamford Hall in Leicester.Footnote 40 This not only demonstrates the establishment of a tripartite link between the department, the WCC and the DES but, taken with the other events organized and supported by the BCCED, it suggests that the BCCED had a positive orientation towards interfaith dialogue within education generally, and within RE specifically.
In different ways, these examples demonstrate a focus on resolving the tension between the teaching of non-Christian worldviews (initially other faiths but increasingly non-religious viewpoints too) and the dominance of Christianity in the curriculum. Key to achieving a balance was the expressed desire to justify RE on ‘valid educational grounds’.Footnote 41 This expressed itself in the enthusiasm expressed at Harrogate in 1969 for ensuring that the study of world religions would not merely be a response in areas with a high proportion of immigrants, but ‘educationally beneficial’ on a much wider scale. This approach was further illustrated at the London conference, where the relationship between up-to-date scholarship on child development and teaching methods was explored. In summary, these events and discussions demonstrate that the BCCED was actively involved in promoting the study of world religions at a time when RE was changing in classrooms across England.
Radical Rethinking of Religious Education and the Alves Report
But from where and when did these ideas emerge? An exploration of the wider discourses of the BCCED reveals that during the period leading up to the late 1960s there had already been an expressed desire for change, which found particular expression through two calls, about a decade apart, for a radical rethinking of RE. In 1963, prompted by the upcoming twentieth anniversary of the passing of the 1944 act, a campaign was launched, calling for ‘the full implementation of the 1944 Education Act’.Footnote 42 In 1962, the BCCED had initiated a discussion of its frustration regarding the lack of success in RE (even though the success criteria were disputed), which observed that ‘from neither the statutory nor the independent stream do we find an influx of committed Christians commensurate with the effort made in schools. Is it a possible task?’Footnote 43 The BCCED agreed that a review of the religious provisions of the 1944 act was necessary, concluding: ‘Today the needs of children and young people demand a radical rethinking and reshaping of the purpose and method of religious education, both in the material itself, in the manner of presentation, and the way in which it is related to life in the school and beyond it.’Footnote 44
However, the phrase ‘radical rethinking’ did not originate here. It is first found in the discourse of the BCCED in 1958: discussing the period since the 1944 act, and considering the future of RE, the BCCED Executive ‘took the view that what was required … was a radical re-thinking of the purpose of Religious Instruction’.Footnote 45
This attempt to rethink religious education led to the establishment of a special committee of the BCCED in 1963. This committee set in motion a detailed research project, funded by the Gulbenkian Foundation (Lisbon), which offered funding of £5,000 over two years.Footnote 46 Colin Alves, who was lecturer in divinity at King Alfred's College, Winchester, was seconded to the BCCED to act as investigating officer for the duration of the project.Footnote 47 Unlike some other projects at the time, which focused on local policy documents, Alves's work centred on issues arising from classroom practice. He deployed a large-scale survey questionnaire, undertaken during 1965–6 with secondary school pupils and focusing almost entirely on biblical knowledge, Christian religious practice (including personal Christian affiliation) and Christian morality.Footnote 48 The final report, Religion and the Secondary School, was published in 1968; however the status of this report is complex.Footnote 49
In mid-1967, a draft report was considered by the BCCED, with the status of the report in relation to the BCC being a focus of some discussion.Footnote 50 As the ‘main body of the report was to the Gulbenkian Foundation’, it was ‘agreed that a factual statement that [the report] had been presented to the BCC would be adequate’.Footnote 51 Consequently, the foreword in the published report, written by the then general secretary of the BCC, opened with the emphatic statement: ‘THIS IS not an official Report of the British Council of Churches, but the Council is glad to have been able, through its Education Department, to initiate the research project it describes’.Footnote 52 The foreword also suggested that ‘[Alves's] conclusions should be assessed on their own merits and not necessarily as representing the views of the British Council of Churches’.Footnote 53 However, the published report also incorporated a ‘Report of the Special Committee appointed by the Education Department of the British Council of Churches’, which introduced Alves's work, reflected on its findings and suggested courses of action.
This later section appears to have had a more authoritative status within the BCC; it is the ‘Report of the Special Committee’ that sets out a proposed ‘New Deal’ for RE.Footnote 54 The report discussed ‘limiting factors which are within the power of the educational system to change’, including the restricted supply of suitably trained teachers, the unsuitability of many public examinations and qualifications that were available to students, the lack of timetabled periods for RE and the loading of ‘the scales of professional advancement … against religious education specialists’.Footnote 55 In addition, this part of the report included an explicit encouragement of the study of non-Christian religions: ‘We can, and should, learn from men of other faiths theistic and non-theistic and they from us’.Footnote 56
The study of non-Christian religions in RE in English schools, as called for in the 1968 report, was not novel, however. Evidence from elsewhere testifies to this. For example, the evidence provided to the Durham Commission during 1968 in response to the question ‘Should provision be made … where circumstances appear to justify it, for religious education other than Christian education?’Footnote 57 shows that a number of respondents believed that the case had already been made,Footnote 58 and in some schools the practice was already established.Footnote 59 Similarly, the evidence submitted by the Church of England's National Society for the Promotion of Religious Education commented not only that the practice was already established, but that representatives from non-Christian traditions were involved in the Agreed Syllabus Committees that set out the content and aims for RE teaching in county schools.Footnote 60 This claim is corroborated by contemporaneous agreed syllabus documents from a number of local education authority areas.Footnote 61
Indeed, looking further back, there is evidence that the study of non-Christian worldviews was taking place in schools as early as the 1920s, even if it was at that point limited to some schools, and in them restricted to later phases of schooling.Footnote 62 There are also examples of the study of other religions during the post-war period – following the provisions of the 1944 Education Act – suggesting an openness towards the study of non-Christian worldviews. Even before the establishment of the BCCED in 1951, there are indications that the study of religions other than Christianity was being discussed by some within the ecumenical movement. A sequence of letters in 1946 between Tissington Tatlow, director of the Institute of Christian Education, an ecumenical group established in 1935 and concerned with engendering cooperation between ‘Christianity and Education … at home and overseas’,Footnote 63 and Sir Walter Moberly, then chairing the BCC's Committee on Christian Education, the forerunner of the BCCED, provides evidence of this.Footnote 64 Tatlow and Moberly objected to the age group for which such material was included rather than to its inclusion per se: it was studied only by students who had reached the age of fifteen, thus excluding the vast majority of students, who would leave school at that age.Footnote 65 However, it is clear that teaching material dealing with other faith traditions was available, that the BCC Education Committee was aware of this material, and that the committee was involved in actively promoting it. For example, one list circulated in 1948, headed ‘Publications [that] can be ordered from BCC’, included Marcus Knight, The Mind of Japan (n.d.); S. S. Milford and W. R. Garrad, Ancient Faiths and Lore of India (1947); Frank A. Smalley, Chinese Philosophy and Religion (1947); and Mabel C. Warburton, The Mind and Ways of Islam (1947).Footnote 66 These examples support the claim that including the study of world religions alongside the study of Christianity in the RE classrooms of England, while perhaps still unusual and not widespread, was not entirely novel, even in the late 1940s.
Encouragement to Study non-Christian Faiths in English RE
Whilst Alves's Religion and the Secondary School does not appear to have been widely circulated, perhaps because it considered RE only in relation to county schools,Footnote 67 the recommendations themselves became influential through repetition.Footnote 68 The recommendation that the study of other religions and belief systems should be encouraged was repeated in The Fourth R (1970), often known as The Durham Report,Footnote 69 which was circulated more widely, perhaps because it considered RE in both county and church schools.Footnote 70 In this way the recommendation became established in church discourse.
The encouragement to study world religions was further repeated in Working Paper 36, which quoted directly from The Fourth R.Footnote 71 Thus the recommendation was introduced to educational discourse. The Schools Curricula and Examination Council (generally known as the Schools Council) had been launched in March 1964 as a representative body to monitor curriculum and examinations in England, taking over responsibility from the Secondary Schools Examinations Council (formed in 1958) and the Curriculum Study Group (formed in 1962).Footnote 72 The Schools Council was seen as an authoritative body, looked to by local and national government, as well as by the inspectorate and individual teachers.Footnote 73 Consequently, publications under its banner, particularly its series of working papers, were considered as having some degree of authority or ‘official’ sanction.Footnote 74
There are strong textual similarities between Alves's report to the BCCED, The Fourth R and Working Paper 36 with regard to learning from non-Christian faith communities, demonstrated by the repetition of a key statement which had first appeared in the Report of the Special Committee: ‘We can, and should, learn from men of other faiths theistic and non-theistic and they from us’.Footnote 75 This statement is repeated in The Fourth R, in a chapter that Alves was involved in drafting,Footnote 76 and again in Working Paper 36. The historiography of English RE has generally presumed that Ninian Smart had authorial responsibility for Working Paper 36, but archival evidence indicates that final editorial control was actually vested in the hands of Alves: publication was agreed by the relevant committee, ‘subject to any amendments being referred to Mr Alves’.Footnote 77 Whilst it would not be true to claim that Alves was solely responsible for the repetition of the statement, his involvement in all three reports is evident, although his contribution has hitherto been unacknowledged.
Thus, although Alves's recommendation in the BCCED report cannot be claimed as the moment at which everything changed in English RE, it can be considered a watershed in the process of the legitimization, normalization and (eventually) widespread adoption of the study of world religions as the dominant approach to RE in English schools in the later 1960s. His report marked a point at which the practice is identifiable as distinct from existing practice within national ecumenical discourse, positively articulating an emerging classroom approach for the first time. This approach in RE, supported by the BCCED, became widespread. By the mid- to late 1970s it was reflected in national and local policy documents.Footnote 78
Conclusion
This exploration of archival material from the BCC reveals that the BCCED played a hitherto unreported role in the adoption of the study of world religions as a dominant approach to English RE. Two calls by the BCCED, a decade apart, for the radical rethinking of RE led ultimately to the 1968 report Religion and the Secondary School, edited by Colin Alves. Alves's encouragement of the study of non-Christian religions in the RE classrooms of England was repeated, and thus imbued with authority, in two spheres. Firstly, it entered the ecclesiastical sphere through being taken into The Fourth R. Secondly, it entered the educational sphere via Working Paper 36. Alongside this, there is evidence of the BCC's active promotion of the study of world religions in the classroom, shown in its encouragement of cooperation with other religions in a series of conferences and meetings in the late 1960s and in the inclusion of, and consultation with, representatives of faith communities beyond Christianity.
The tracing of the BCCED's active encouragement of the expansion of RE in English schools beyond the boundaries of Christianity shows that this was not, as previous studies have suggested, a novel development in the later 1960s; nor did the practice originate with Alves. The beginnings of the practice of studying non-Christian religions in the English RE classroom date back to the inter-war period. From the late 1940s onwards, the BCC was making available materials to support the teaching of non-Christian religions.
It is therefore clear that during the later 1960s the BCCED's radical rethinking of religious education led to practical engagement with non-Christian faiths, together with an explicit call to study these faiths in the RE classroom. In this way, the department's work gave some legitimacy to the study of non-Christian faiths, and it played a role in the normalization and eventual widespread adoption of the study of world religions in English RE classrooms.Footnote 79 This adoption took place at a time when national policy was generally silent on this question and local policy was often constrained to confessional Christianity, and at a time of growing interaction between different religions as immigration began to change the demographic of local communities. However, as normalization of the study of world religions and the impact of immigration took place at different speeds in different areas, there were undoubtedly parts of Britain where school students experienced a shift to the study of world religions in RE classrooms earlier than the expansion of their own inter-religious experience.
