In their focal article, Schiemann and Ulrich (Reference Schiemann and Ulrich2017) provide a broad overview of thoughts and insights by 73 of today's human resources/industrial–organizational (HR/I-O) leaders. It was both interesting and valuable to hear from those “in the trenches” every day and to learn what they considered to be the key recommendations, cautions, and needs central to the HR/I-O practice of today—and tomorrow. That said, we were surprised that, considering the zeitgeist of the current workscape, work–family considerations did not make more of an appearance in these reports of leaders’ values and priorities for their organizations and for the field as a whole.Footnote
1
The Impetus for and Importance of Work–Family Considerations
The recommendations reported in the article go so far as to argue for a need to shift focus away from the “workforce” in favor of the “workplace”—away from “people” in favor of “process”; to “move away from managing the employment relationships to managing risk, governance, and capability across the enterprise” (Schiemann & Ulrich, p. 17). We call into question whether this is an optimal strategy for long-term organizational success in a workscape that is increasingly demanding attention toward human capital and organizational respect for employees’ nonwork demands and responsibilities. Indeed, the capabilities noted under the organization theme neglected any mention of positive organizational behavior (POB) capabilities—an oversight that we consider to be crucial in a workscape that is increasingly welcoming of—and in need of—the positive organizational domain (e.g., Cameron, Dutton, & Quinn, Reference Cameron, Dutton and Quinn2003; Luthans, Reference Luthans2002). Although we recognize that the list presented therein was not (and could not reasonably be expected to be) exhaustive, we suggest that some notable recognition of the value of POB at the organizational level was undoubtedly warranted. The zeitgeist is ripe for this inclusion at multiple levels: the individual level, the organizational level, and even the more macro political and contextual levels.
Work–family considerations have become an increasingly hot topic globally. Perhaps the most notable issue revolves around national family leave policies, an area in which the United States falls dismally behind other industrialized countries. According to the International Labor Organization (ILO), the United States and Papua New Guinea are the only two countries that provide no cash benefits of any kind to women during maternity leave (ILO, 2014)—thereby also isolating the United States as the only industrialized nation not providing such benefits. Although the United States’ Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA) guarantees 12 weeks of unpaid leave, this represents the shortest amount of time mandated when compared with any other developed countries’ (paid) leave policies. Moreover, FMLA's strict eligibility requirements, including company size, exclude many employees, and even those eligible are often not in a financial position to go unpaid for 3 months. In fact, ineligible employees tend to represent lower education and income brackets overall (Ray, Gornick, & Schmitt, Reference Ray, Gornick and Schmitt2009). In this way, FMLA's unpaid leave serves to widen socioeconomic inequities among workers, as those employees who need the benefit the most often have the least access to it. Indeed, although politicians and others often criticize nonprogressive policies of other less industrialized nations, it is humbling to recognize that even many of those nations have better maternity and family leave policies than does the United States. As just one example, Iran, a country oft criticized for its treatment of women/women's rights, has a national maternity leave policy mandating 12 weeks of leave paid at two-thirds salary (ILO, 2014).
As an industrialized nation often claiming to be at the forefront of progressive and innovative policymaking, human rights, and corporate strategy, the United States’ lack of attention to family-friendly initiatives is a grave sidestep in contradiction of those goals. Family-friendly benefits (including but not limited to paid parental leave) have been empirically found to be associated with a number of important benefits at the individual level (e.g., maternal health, breastfeeding rates; e.g., Aitken et al., Reference Aitken, Garrett, Hewitt, Keogh, Hocking and Kavanagh2015; Huang & Yang, Reference Huang and Yang2015), the organizational level (e.g., employee recruitment, commitment, retention, performance; e.g., Bloom, Kretschmer, & Van Reenen, Reference Bloom, Kretschmer and Van Reenen2011; Breaugh & Frye, Reference Breaugh and Frye2007; Wayne & Casper, Reference Wayne and Casper2012), and the macro/societal level (e.g., lower infant mortality, broad economic benefit; e.g., Levin-Epstein, Reference Levin-Epstein2006; Ruhm, Reference Ruhm2000). In line with these multifaceted and numerous benefits, work–family initiatives should be at the forefront of organizations’ strategic movement forward by virtue of active recognition of the value of human capital across multiple stakeholders.
Of course, this is not to say that some organizations have not adopted and embraced a family-supportive culture, regardless of federal mandates. We are operating in a time when select private corporations are taking it upon themselves to voluntarily offer family-friendly initiatives to their employees. For example, Deloitte made recent headlines when it announced that it would allow all employees—both men and women—to take 16 weeks of paid leave to care for a family member and allow birth mothers to take up to 6 months of paid leave (Zarya, Reference Zarya2016). Similarly, Southwest Airlines was recently ranked by Forbes (based on data from Indeed) as one of the best companies for work–life balance due in large part to their focus on work–family issues, which they address through various means including alternate work arrangements such as flextime, job sharing, and compressed workweeks (Dill, Reference Dill2016). In addition to organizations stepping up, some cities and states have likewise taken it upon themselves to voluntarily surpass the minimally required federal family leave requirements. For example, San Francisco (California) provides 12 weeks of paid parental leave to its employees, in addition to mandating 6 weeks of paid parental leave for companies (with 20 or more employees) within the city, with the company shouldering 45% of the wages and a worker-funded state disability program funding the remaining 55%. At the state level, California, New Jersey, and Rhode Island offer paid family and medical leave, with New York to join them in 2018 with an even more extensive policy.
The direction that these organizations, cities, and states have begun to take is one that all leaders interested in the sustainability of their organizations should be striving to emulate. According to Zadek (Reference Zadek2004), the maturity of societal issues can be thought of as lying on a continuum from latent—occurring when there is awareness and attention solely from activists on an issue—to institutionalized—occurring when a far-reaching awareness has infiltrated the broader public to the extent that notable reactions result when an organization fails to act in accordance with popular opinion. It is clear from the growing pressure for organizations to institute first-rate work–family initiatives (e.g., to appear on the Forbes list of Best Places to Work or the Fortune list of Best Companies to Work For) and for changes to the national family leave plan (e.g., U.S. Senator Gillibrand's proposed “FAMILY Act”) that organizational stakeholders are demanding attention to such issues and that failure by organizational leaders to respond accordingly may very well represent a nail in the company's proverbial coffin. Nevertheless, Schiemann and Ulrich's findings unfortunately suggest that this remains an issue that is not yet at the forefront of many leaders’ thinking.
Interestingly, elsewhere the article did recognize the importance of human capital, but only comparatively briefly and as seemingly disparate from the aforementioned goals: At times, it was unclear how the two aligned, particularly in practice (e.g., how does an organization simultaneously move away from a focus on the workforce and its people while at the same time moving toward a focus on the talent of its human capital?). For instance, employee engagement was attended to only insofar as it (along with other employee characteristics) “influence[d] an organization's ability to execute on its brand promise” (Schiemann & Ulrich, p. 11) and was relevant to talent optimization, especially with regard to the C-suite. Likewise, we were hopeful that the work–family interface would be more thoroughly addressed in the talent supply theme, but again it seemed to be addressed only briefly and comparatively vaguely (e.g., “creating more comprehensive strategic workforce plans that capture the variety of talent sources and skills for the future”; Schiemann & Ulrich, p. 12) or with the implication that employees with dual work–family responsibilities may not be optimally equipped for full-time employment (e.g., “building unique work arrangements for talent, which may not be full-time employment but project or contingent work”; Schiemann & Ulrich, p. 12).
Work–Family and Gender
Inherently relevant to the work–family considerations (or lack thereof) are gender considerations (or lack thereof; Mills, Reference Mills2015). Although the talent optimization theme within the article addressed this consideration, it did so only briefly. We suggest that it is not enough to call for organizational diversification through the inclusion of women or for the leveraging of female employees. Indeed, the former perspective is contradicted with sentiments such as that expressed in the talent supply theme: that HR/I-O should ensure that hired talent matches the organization's culture. Besides being an arguably ephemeral selection tool, such a decision standard also opens the door for ethical and legal challenges, as it risks compromising diversity within an organization (gender diversity but also diversity of race, culture/ethnicity, and thought). Further, from an organizational standpoint, hiring into an established organizational culture also increasingly risks a company falling victim to its status quo over time, as it risks stagnation of collective thought that precludes organizational innovation and adaptation to a dynamic external context.
Similarly, it is important to recognize the fine line between accounting for the often-unique work–family considerations of women (e.g., childbirth) and making work–family considerations solely or even primarily a women's issue. This is a challenge widely experienced but, we argue, rarely sufficiently discussed or considered in practice via policy implementation. For instance, as the corporate and political worlds increasingly call for expansion of work–family policies, it is important that an unintended side effect of such enacted policies not be leveraging more of the work–family burden on women. As an example, expanded maternity leave policies are an admirable goal toward which organizations should aim, but without comparable attention toward paternity (or generalized “parental”) leave, such policies inherently place more of the childcare burden on women, as well as more of the burden of taking leaves in general (e.g., compromised career progression opportunities, hampering inclusivity perceptions; Ryan & Kossek, Reference Ryan and Kossek2008). As long as organizations see work–family considerations as a women's challenge, not only will the issue continue to exist but its implications for organizations and diversity will worsen, and the equality gap will widen.
Conclusion
Attention to employees’ work–family interface represents the symbiosis of cross-discipline perspectives that Schiemann and Ulrich (p. 23) argue is so important (yielding “many of the great world insights”), as work–family considerations represent the coalescing of findings from fields such as biological medicine, social sciences, and business/management. It also serves the multiple bottom line perspective for which Schiemann and Ulrich (p. 22) argue (“employee fulfillment, cultural adaptation, and sustainability of talent, environment, community, and family”). Ultimately, Schiemann and Ulrich (p. 22) “call for the professions to rise to the occasion.” We second this call, arguing additionally that if the occasion is anything right now, it is work–family considerations. The zeitgeist for it is here. The need for it is here. Employees are calling for it. Families—and society on a more macro, long-term level—are desperate for it. Whereas some organizations are embracing it—whether enthusiastically or cautiously—others are not addressing the need at all. Certainly, if we are to place stock in Schiemann and Ulrich's findings, it would appear that many if not most of today's thought leaders are not viewing this issue as one of central importance.
We argue that the need to consider work–family issues is central to the effective progression of HR/I-O practice. It must come to be recognized as the business imperative that it is. We appreciate that a detailed discussion of these issues in the focal article was perhaps precluded by length constraints. As such, we sought in this commentary to further the discussion on the need for work–family considerations to pervade the theory and practice of HR/I-O in order to optimize our capitalization of human capital. Moreover, we hope to ignite a discussion toward a broader respect for working within the employee-centric recommendations of POB and scholarship. It is our contention that this is central among the strategies driving the organizations that will survive and thrive into the future.
In their focal article, Schiemann and Ulrich (Reference Schiemann and Ulrich2017) provide a broad overview of thoughts and insights by 73 of today's human resources/industrial–organizational (HR/I-O) leaders. It was both interesting and valuable to hear from those “in the trenches” every day and to learn what they considered to be the key recommendations, cautions, and needs central to the HR/I-O practice of today—and tomorrow. That said, we were surprised that, considering the zeitgeist of the current workscape, work–family considerations did not make more of an appearance in these reports of leaders’ values and priorities for their organizations and for the field as a whole.Footnote 1
The Impetus for and Importance of Work–Family Considerations
The recommendations reported in the article go so far as to argue for a need to shift focus away from the “workforce” in favor of the “workplace”—away from “people” in favor of “process”; to “move away from managing the employment relationships to managing risk, governance, and capability across the enterprise” (Schiemann & Ulrich, p. 17). We call into question whether this is an optimal strategy for long-term organizational success in a workscape that is increasingly demanding attention toward human capital and organizational respect for employees’ nonwork demands and responsibilities. Indeed, the capabilities noted under the organization theme neglected any mention of positive organizational behavior (POB) capabilities—an oversight that we consider to be crucial in a workscape that is increasingly welcoming of—and in need of—the positive organizational domain (e.g., Cameron, Dutton, & Quinn, Reference Cameron, Dutton and Quinn2003; Luthans, Reference Luthans2002). Although we recognize that the list presented therein was not (and could not reasonably be expected to be) exhaustive, we suggest that some notable recognition of the value of POB at the organizational level was undoubtedly warranted. The zeitgeist is ripe for this inclusion at multiple levels: the individual level, the organizational level, and even the more macro political and contextual levels.
Work–family considerations have become an increasingly hot topic globally. Perhaps the most notable issue revolves around national family leave policies, an area in which the United States falls dismally behind other industrialized countries. According to the International Labor Organization (ILO), the United States and Papua New Guinea are the only two countries that provide no cash benefits of any kind to women during maternity leave (ILO, 2014)—thereby also isolating the United States as the only industrialized nation not providing such benefits. Although the United States’ Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA) guarantees 12 weeks of unpaid leave, this represents the shortest amount of time mandated when compared with any other developed countries’ (paid) leave policies. Moreover, FMLA's strict eligibility requirements, including company size, exclude many employees, and even those eligible are often not in a financial position to go unpaid for 3 months. In fact, ineligible employees tend to represent lower education and income brackets overall (Ray, Gornick, & Schmitt, Reference Ray, Gornick and Schmitt2009). In this way, FMLA's unpaid leave serves to widen socioeconomic inequities among workers, as those employees who need the benefit the most often have the least access to it. Indeed, although politicians and others often criticize nonprogressive policies of other less industrialized nations, it is humbling to recognize that even many of those nations have better maternity and family leave policies than does the United States. As just one example, Iran, a country oft criticized for its treatment of women/women's rights, has a national maternity leave policy mandating 12 weeks of leave paid at two-thirds salary (ILO, 2014).
As an industrialized nation often claiming to be at the forefront of progressive and innovative policymaking, human rights, and corporate strategy, the United States’ lack of attention to family-friendly initiatives is a grave sidestep in contradiction of those goals. Family-friendly benefits (including but not limited to paid parental leave) have been empirically found to be associated with a number of important benefits at the individual level (e.g., maternal health, breastfeeding rates; e.g., Aitken et al., Reference Aitken, Garrett, Hewitt, Keogh, Hocking and Kavanagh2015; Huang & Yang, Reference Huang and Yang2015), the organizational level (e.g., employee recruitment, commitment, retention, performance; e.g., Bloom, Kretschmer, & Van Reenen, Reference Bloom, Kretschmer and Van Reenen2011; Breaugh & Frye, Reference Breaugh and Frye2007; Wayne & Casper, Reference Wayne and Casper2012), and the macro/societal level (e.g., lower infant mortality, broad economic benefit; e.g., Levin-Epstein, Reference Levin-Epstein2006; Ruhm, Reference Ruhm2000). In line with these multifaceted and numerous benefits, work–family initiatives should be at the forefront of organizations’ strategic movement forward by virtue of active recognition of the value of human capital across multiple stakeholders.
Of course, this is not to say that some organizations have not adopted and embraced a family-supportive culture, regardless of federal mandates. We are operating in a time when select private corporations are taking it upon themselves to voluntarily offer family-friendly initiatives to their employees. For example, Deloitte made recent headlines when it announced that it would allow all employees—both men and women—to take 16 weeks of paid leave to care for a family member and allow birth mothers to take up to 6 months of paid leave (Zarya, Reference Zarya2016). Similarly, Southwest Airlines was recently ranked by Forbes (based on data from Indeed) as one of the best companies for work–life balance due in large part to their focus on work–family issues, which they address through various means including alternate work arrangements such as flextime, job sharing, and compressed workweeks (Dill, Reference Dill2016). In addition to organizations stepping up, some cities and states have likewise taken it upon themselves to voluntarily surpass the minimally required federal family leave requirements. For example, San Francisco (California) provides 12 weeks of paid parental leave to its employees, in addition to mandating 6 weeks of paid parental leave for companies (with 20 or more employees) within the city, with the company shouldering 45% of the wages and a worker-funded state disability program funding the remaining 55%. At the state level, California, New Jersey, and Rhode Island offer paid family and medical leave, with New York to join them in 2018 with an even more extensive policy.
The direction that these organizations, cities, and states have begun to take is one that all leaders interested in the sustainability of their organizations should be striving to emulate. According to Zadek (Reference Zadek2004), the maturity of societal issues can be thought of as lying on a continuum from latent—occurring when there is awareness and attention solely from activists on an issue—to institutionalized—occurring when a far-reaching awareness has infiltrated the broader public to the extent that notable reactions result when an organization fails to act in accordance with popular opinion. It is clear from the growing pressure for organizations to institute first-rate work–family initiatives (e.g., to appear on the Forbes list of Best Places to Work or the Fortune list of Best Companies to Work For) and for changes to the national family leave plan (e.g., U.S. Senator Gillibrand's proposed “FAMILY Act”) that organizational stakeholders are demanding attention to such issues and that failure by organizational leaders to respond accordingly may very well represent a nail in the company's proverbial coffin. Nevertheless, Schiemann and Ulrich's findings unfortunately suggest that this remains an issue that is not yet at the forefront of many leaders’ thinking.
Interestingly, elsewhere the article did recognize the importance of human capital, but only comparatively briefly and as seemingly disparate from the aforementioned goals: At times, it was unclear how the two aligned, particularly in practice (e.g., how does an organization simultaneously move away from a focus on the workforce and its people while at the same time moving toward a focus on the talent of its human capital?). For instance, employee engagement was attended to only insofar as it (along with other employee characteristics) “influence[d] an organization's ability to execute on its brand promise” (Schiemann & Ulrich, p. 11) and was relevant to talent optimization, especially with regard to the C-suite. Likewise, we were hopeful that the work–family interface would be more thoroughly addressed in the talent supply theme, but again it seemed to be addressed only briefly and comparatively vaguely (e.g., “creating more comprehensive strategic workforce plans that capture the variety of talent sources and skills for the future”; Schiemann & Ulrich, p. 12) or with the implication that employees with dual work–family responsibilities may not be optimally equipped for full-time employment (e.g., “building unique work arrangements for talent, which may not be full-time employment but project or contingent work”; Schiemann & Ulrich, p. 12).
Work–Family and Gender
Inherently relevant to the work–family considerations (or lack thereof) are gender considerations (or lack thereof; Mills, Reference Mills2015). Although the talent optimization theme within the article addressed this consideration, it did so only briefly. We suggest that it is not enough to call for organizational diversification through the inclusion of women or for the leveraging of female employees. Indeed, the former perspective is contradicted with sentiments such as that expressed in the talent supply theme: that HR/I-O should ensure that hired talent matches the organization's culture. Besides being an arguably ephemeral selection tool, such a decision standard also opens the door for ethical and legal challenges, as it risks compromising diversity within an organization (gender diversity but also diversity of race, culture/ethnicity, and thought). Further, from an organizational standpoint, hiring into an established organizational culture also increasingly risks a company falling victim to its status quo over time, as it risks stagnation of collective thought that precludes organizational innovation and adaptation to a dynamic external context.
Similarly, it is important to recognize the fine line between accounting for the often-unique work–family considerations of women (e.g., childbirth) and making work–family considerations solely or even primarily a women's issue. This is a challenge widely experienced but, we argue, rarely sufficiently discussed or considered in practice via policy implementation. For instance, as the corporate and political worlds increasingly call for expansion of work–family policies, it is important that an unintended side effect of such enacted policies not be leveraging more of the work–family burden on women. As an example, expanded maternity leave policies are an admirable goal toward which organizations should aim, but without comparable attention toward paternity (or generalized “parental”) leave, such policies inherently place more of the childcare burden on women, as well as more of the burden of taking leaves in general (e.g., compromised career progression opportunities, hampering inclusivity perceptions; Ryan & Kossek, Reference Ryan and Kossek2008). As long as organizations see work–family considerations as a women's challenge, not only will the issue continue to exist but its implications for organizations and diversity will worsen, and the equality gap will widen.
Conclusion
Attention to employees’ work–family interface represents the symbiosis of cross-discipline perspectives that Schiemann and Ulrich (p. 23) argue is so important (yielding “many of the great world insights”), as work–family considerations represent the coalescing of findings from fields such as biological medicine, social sciences, and business/management. It also serves the multiple bottom line perspective for which Schiemann and Ulrich (p. 22) argue (“employee fulfillment, cultural adaptation, and sustainability of talent, environment, community, and family”). Ultimately, Schiemann and Ulrich (p. 22) “call for the professions to rise to the occasion.” We second this call, arguing additionally that if the occasion is anything right now, it is work–family considerations. The zeitgeist for it is here. The need for it is here. Employees are calling for it. Families—and society on a more macro, long-term level—are desperate for it. Whereas some organizations are embracing it—whether enthusiastically or cautiously—others are not addressing the need at all. Certainly, if we are to place stock in Schiemann and Ulrich's findings, it would appear that many if not most of today's thought leaders are not viewing this issue as one of central importance.
We argue that the need to consider work–family issues is central to the effective progression of HR/I-O practice. It must come to be recognized as the business imperative that it is. We appreciate that a detailed discussion of these issues in the focal article was perhaps precluded by length constraints. As such, we sought in this commentary to further the discussion on the need for work–family considerations to pervade the theory and practice of HR/I-O in order to optimize our capitalization of human capital. Moreover, we hope to ignite a discussion toward a broader respect for working within the employee-centric recommendations of POB and scholarship. It is our contention that this is central among the strategies driving the organizations that will survive and thrive into the future.