Inspired by the Palestinian writer Abu Mumammad al-Maqdisi's statement when he aptly stated that “Saudi Arabia is a graveyard of clerics and a prison for preachers,” Pascal Menoret captured the essence of the statement, entitling his book Graveyard of Clerics: Everyday Activism in Saudi Arabia. This pithy title underscores the inevitably perilous destiny faced by clerics, preachers, and young activists when they attempt to unsettle or mobilize against the repressive Saudi apparatus, which “paint[s] its enemies with a wide brush and claim[s] they [are] ‘radicals,’ ‘extremists,’ enemies of reason and moderation” (p. 38). In this study, Menoret directly engages with these constituents, shedding light on Islamic movements in Saudi Arabia, their recruitement strategies, tactics of mobilizations, daily activities, political activism, and unpleasant interactions with the Saudi State and its surveillance apparatus.
The book is divided into four parts: “The Islamic Awakening,” “Saudi Suburbia,” “Awareness Groups and Summer Camps,” and “Leaving Islamic Activism Behind.” In the first part, Menoret discusses the concept of Islamic Awakening, a movement that has swept the Muslim world, and how Islamic groups have been tortured by a repressive regime, zeroing in on the plight of Islamic activists and how “Saudi Arabic has imprisoned them by the thousands since the late 1970s” (p. 7). The second part of the book focuses on building of the city of Riyadh and the false belief that constructing “village-like communities could save modern cities from congestion and revolutions” (p. 53). Menoret shows how, despite the absence of of public squares and space to mobilize, the car has become the essential mobilizing cell in the Islamic Awakening movement. Besides the discussion of urban sprawl, Monoret discusses the complex dynamics of municipal elections. Part 3 examines the Islamic movements’ recruiting strategies and the variety of activities they organize such as Qur ʾan memorizations, sermons, and summer camps “to seduce youth [and] harvest their energy to reform society” (p. 32). Recruiting the youth is an essential component to the continuity of these movements, serving as a conduit to the growth and substantiality of Islamic activism. The last part discusses the status of Islamic activism and how disenchanted some members have become with the Islamic movements, putting activism in “abeyance.”
The structure of this book is unconventional, dividing it into twenty-four vignettes. This unconventionality makes the text so lucid, dedicating each vignette to a single theme under study. Drawing on his rich enthnographic data, Menoret gives the reader a first-hand account about his interlocutors’ subjective experiences. This practice is commendable, making the text easily readable and accessible to a wider readership.
Pascal Menoret's ethnographic fieldwork in the city of Riyadh documents the trajectories of Islamic movements and youth activism against a repressive apparatus. To this end, Menoret uses a rigorous methodological approach that includes participant observation in different settings (schools, summer camps, lecture halls, government offices, and leisure spaces), and numerous unstructured and semi-structured interviews “to understand what [his] interlocutors and interviewees mean when they talk of ‘Islamic action’” (p. 208). This study carefully examines the dynamics of Islamic activism, urban planning, and repression.
Menoret paints a vivid cartographic plan of the city of Riyadh for readers, illustrating how spatial politics is key to the design of this Saudi city. During the intense strikes of the oil workers in the 1960s, when employees were demanding better working conditions, the Saudi ruling family, wary of escalating social and political unrest “commissioned Greek and British planners to manage urban growth” to ward off rural migration and any potential of political incitement. The commissioning of suburbanization was headed by Constantinos Doxiadis, a Greek architect, who had designed other urban spaces, namely Islamabad and Baghdad. This “frontier planning” and “village-like communities,” however, did little to ward off the Islamic Awakening activism. In spite of the difficulty of navigating such a city, these groups manage to navigate masterfully this complex space, initially built to scatter “networks of solidarity” and ward off activities seeking to mobilize youth against the Saudi state. Menoret argues that cars, once viewed as “key to Western Imperialism,” have played an essential role in assisting the youth in circumnavigating this complex urban sprawl and thus staging their mobilization against the regime.
Islamic activism enables the youth to “speak truth to power and act in the face of political danger …to affirm their own agency within a political and social context,” which is being closely monitored by the apparatuses of the Saudi state (pp. 40–1). Pascal Menoret's Graveyard of Clerics adds several important scholarly interventions examining the dialectic dynamics between activism, repression, and urban planning, documenting how activists are preoccupied with innovative ways to mobilize in a space that was intentionally concocted to thwart their acts. These groups are viewed as a leading threat to the state whose preoccupation lies in decentering religion from spaces, specifically schools and camps. Menoret arguably shows how “political repression and real estate development often went hand in hand” (p. 6). Thus, urban planning is inescapably linked to the enactment of state repression.
Menoret ardently shows how “Islamic movements have turned boredom and indifference into a political resource” (p. 208). He avers that that indifference is inextricably tied to youth activism, and without this understanding, any explanation would be inchoate. In a few vignettes, the author shows how the concept of indifference “la mubala” (apathy) weaponizes the Islamic Awakening groups in alluring the youth into becoming active members. “La mubala,” Menoret writes, “triggers the transformation from apathy to outrage and to politicization… the more indifferent [one is]… [the more] audacious, more self-confident [and] more politically active [one becomes]” (p. 14). Although this concept is very appealing, additional explication as to how indifference and boredom lead to political activism might well have enriched this study.
Mernoret argues that his study differs from previous ones that have adopted parochial analyses linking any political acts rehearsed by Islamic movements in Saudi Arabia to the “seizing [of] state power or changing the way the state organizes society” (p. 208). While this claim might be true, a further elucidation would have made this point stronger, offering more substantive examples of pervious studies and where their assumptions went awry. Another issue that the author briefly mentions, but may merit more discussion is the role of women in Islamic activism. While it is fully understood that it is impossible for a man, worse for a foreigner, to interview female interlocutors, Menoret uses the word youth with a sole focus on males. His ethnography would have immensely benefited by adding female voices and how they go about “political action.” In addition to this, while his interactions with his interlocutors seem to be genuine, shedding light on some of the friendships he has fostered during his fieldwork would have given the reader a clear explication about his positionality and how it might have affected his findings and interpretations. These criticisms notwithstanding, this work is a strong contribution to the understanding of inextricable ties between activism, repression, and urban planning.
There is no doubt that this study will be invaluable to anyone interested in Middle East studies with a focus on Islamic activism, youth recruitment and mobilization, spatial politics and the intersection of urban planning, activism, and state repression. This original work is a much-needed intervention that advocates for the urgency and need for activism that “may resurface when the conditions are ripe” (p. 209).
