Maria Eva Subtelny's Timurids in Transition is a fascinating study of the Timurid dynasty after the death of the Emir Timur. Although she touches upon many of the Timurid princes, including Timur himself, her focus is on the career of Sulṭan-Ḥusain Bayqara, a great-great grandson of the Emir, and the changes in rule during his reign. Sulṭan-Ḥusain Bayqara ruled Khorasan from 1469–1506, which Subtelny points out is approximately a third of the entire Timurid period. Thus, there is sufficient time and data for a thorough analysis of any acculturation of the Turkic elite into Iranian society.
In Timurids in Transition, Subtelny applies Max Weber's ideas regarding charisma and the legitimisation of authority, or what Weber calls the routinisation of charisma, to the patrimonial-bureaucratic regime of the Timurids. Along with this, Subtelny examines how the Turko-Mongolian elite and the Iranian bureaucratic and religious elite dealt with the changes that occurred as the empire shifted from a nomadic state to a sedentary one. Ultimately, Subtelny seeks to answer the question of why the Timurids “were obliged to make the transition in the first place; what the nature was of the polity they established and how might it best be characterized; what competing political forces were in play during the process of transition; and what effect did their competition have on its outcome; and finally, what mechanisms did Timurid rulers employ in their attempt to effect the transition to a more centralized, sedentary state” (p. 3).
In Chapter One, Subtelny analyses the Timurid state through Weber's ideas on the routinisation of charismatic authority as well as a patrimonial household state. She then argues that while Timur's empire was based on his personal authority, the polities that evolved out of it after his death were truly patrimonial household states. Nonetheless, the Timurids also recognised the dilemma of ruling over a largely sedentary Iranian Muslim populace, and thus came to terms with adopting elements of a Perso-Islmic state. While this in itself, outside of the Weberian analysis, is not new to the study of nomadic empires, it is necessary for establishing the background for later innovation.
Chapter Two is devoted to the ascension of Sulṭan-Ḥusain Bayqara to power. In Subtelny's view, his reign is the paradigm for the Timurid state and culture as it demonstrates all of the contradictions ones sees throughout Timurid rule. In this chapter, a description of the dual administration (military and civil) is provided. Subtelny also discusses what she terms as the ‘blurring’ of those lines as some of the Persian bureaucrats became members of Sulṭan-Ḥusain's household.
Chapter Three examines the tensions between the ideological forces in the Timurid state. The competition between the military elite and the Perso-Islamic bureaucracy peaked during the reign of Sulṭan-Ḥusain's reign. It is this chapter that the routinisation of the Timurid state really emerges as Persians begin to enter the positions that were previously held only by the Turko-Mongolian military elite. The focus of this chapter is on the activities of Majd al-Dīn Muḥammad, who implemented several economic reforms that attempted to centralise the Timurid fiscal administration. The military elite opposed many of these as they diminished the privileges of the military elite and other members of the household.
The failure of the reforms led to a new shift to accommodate the fiscal problems of Sulṭan-Ḥusain's polity. The intensification of an agrarian economy is the subject of Chapter Four. In this Subtelny utilises a number of Persian ‘mirrors for princes’ to explain how the merits of agriculture were presented to the princes. While this method was not always successful, it did find success with Sulṭan-Ḥusain. It is during Sulṭan-Ḥusain's reign that a sizeable number of Timurid agricultural manuals appear, and Subtelny examines the origins of these manuals and their authors as well.
The relationship between agriculture and the waqf, or religious endowment, is the topic of Chapter Five. During the later Timurid period, there was significant increase in the number of endowments. As these could play an important role in the development of agriculture, the increase in waqfs provided a significant contribution to the prosperity of Khorasan. Here, Subtelney does a fine job in her examination of waqf deeds, including those that belonged to wives of Sulṭan-Ḥusain Bayqara. A few of these deeds are included in the appendices.
Chapter Six focuses on Timurid patronisation of an important Muslim shrine through the creation of endowments. In doing so the Sulṭan-Ḥusain was able to use them to promote agriculture throughout Khorasan. Subtelny gives emphasis to three tombs that are gradually developed into sizeable physical complexes that include large tracts of arable land. While this chapter on the surface seems a little out of place in regards to the topic, it does illustrate how not only the Timurid royal family contributed to the development of these shrines but the military elite joined in as well. Previously, this had been more of a task that involved the Perso-Islamic bureaucratic and religious elites. Subtelny points out that the wives of the rulers had long been connected with religious developing religious institutions, but what is new is the increased activity by the male Timurids and their commanders. In many cases this is where the ‘blurring’ of lines or acculturation is most apparent.
Subtelny satisfactorily answers all of the questions that drove her research. Along the way she also demonstrates that during the reign of Sulṭan-Ḥusain Bayqara, the elites maintained their Turko-Mongolian identity, such as a Chinggisid style patrimonial state, without being fully submerged through Iranian acculturation through a Persian style bureaucracy. Yet, at the same time, they successfully promoted an agrarian economy over a nomadic one. So successful was this endeavour, that Khorasan's agricultural output rose to new heights. Finally, Subtelny aptly demonstrates that Max Weber's ideas are still relevant.
