In this book, Stephen Day argues that the root of Yemen's political instability lies in the concentration of power in the hands of people from the northwest highlands of Yemen. For Day, the politics of Yemen are the politics of geographic regions that, he argues, divide Yemen and correspond to particular regional identities. Historically, Day's “northwest highlands” region dominated Yemen, but this domination has been the source of Yemen's instability. The solution to Yemen's political problems, in his view, is a kind of regional “Wilsonianism” in which local inhabitants from each region control their own fates through a decentralized form of local governance. Day hypothesizes that a balance in resource distribution strengthens national identity among the population, while an imbalance strengthens regional identities in opposition to national identity. In his view, balance vs. imbalance of resource distribution is what strengthens, respectively, national vs. regional identities among the population. The more that imbalance is perceived in the distribution of resources, the more likely that regional identities will be strengthened in opposition to a common Yemeni national identity (p. 14).
Day is right to argue that geographic identities have currency in Yemeni politics. In current discussions in Yemen over the political future of the country, political leaders often argue for dividing Yemen into regions that are close to Day's divisions. The protests in the south of Yemen are framed within the politics of geography. Southerners claim that they require a separate state or separate political representation because they are distinct. In the north, a successful insurrection by the Ansar Allah carved out a small territory that it alone controls and governs.
However, regionalism is only one of many elements of Yemeni politics. Notions of geographic identity are complexly interwoven with many other ideas of self and group. Day relies too heavily on geographic identity to the detriment of other factors shaping Yemeni's politics. He reifies regions and misses the fluidity of the process of forming political identities from a myriad of possible markers of group cohesion in Yemen. Fortunately, Day's detailed narrative of political developments in the last two decades allows the reader to interpret Yemeni politics in a more nuanced fashion.
In the first chapter, Day makes his argument for dividing Yemen into distinct regions. Yemeni history is only understood through regions, says Day. In the “Islamic” era (p. 28), the major division in Yemen was between the Zaydi north and the Shafiʿi midlands, west, and south. By the early 16th century, Qassimi Imams consolidated the domination of the northwest highlands over the western, midland, and southern regions of Yemen, and the Mutawakkilite Imams of the 20th century founded a modern state on the same regional basis. The republican movements of 1962 in the North and 1963 in the South did not erase regional inequalities in power; instead, the new republican regimes grew out of the same regional domination. Yemen's current instability, according to Day, is a result of the failure to address the regional distribution of resources and power. “For the sake of drawing relevant conclusions about Yemeni politics since 1990, it is essential to make regional distinctions among the populations” (p. 45).
Day divides Yemen into seven distinct regions, but his means of defining regional distinctions are unclear. He writes, “Yemen's population is filled with lesser ethnic distinctions that correspond to identifiable regions of the country” (p. 43). In contrast, “[i]dentification of these regions is neither meant to imply that people living inside them are distinct, homogeneous subnational groups, nor that they automatically share common political interests” (p. 45). And finally, “[i]n some of Yemen's seven regions, it is true that common political and economic interests, as opposed to ethnic and cultural traits, help distinguish local residents from people living in neighboring regions” (p. 46). Day's regions lack a firm conceptual basis.
The most important region, the highlands around Sanaʿa, the capital of Yemen, is described as “almost entirely from Zaydi-Shia backgrounds” (p. 47). According to Day, the area possesses a distinct dialect, has strong tribal traditions, is resource poor, and is rich in qāt, the mild stimulant plant that Yemenis chew. However, one of the more interesting religious developments in modern Yemen is the demise of Zaydi identity and the rise of Salafism and Wahhabism as well as the spread of the Muslim Brotherhood in the very regions that Day calls “Zaydi.” Such has been the demise of Zaydi identity that a bloody and stubborn insurgency by a group called Ansar Allah, or the Houthis, within this “northern highland region” exploded in defense of Zaydi identity. The highlands are no longer “Zaydi” or even a coherent region. A more apt conceptual lens for Yemen's political dynamics might be center–periphery relations, or the dominance of Sanaʿa's political elite (who hail from all regions of Yemen).
In the second chapter, Day makes his argument for the importance of regionalism through a telling of the history of the two Yemen republics in the 1970s and 1980s. Day argues that the People's Democratic Republic of Yemen (DPRY), South Yemen, was more stable because the leadership in Aden was composed of proportional representation from all of the South's governorates. In the North, ministerial posts were dominated by those hailing from the Zaydi highland region. Likewise, local government posts in the South were filled by “natives” of the governorate whereas in the North government posts in all governorates were occupied by people from the Zaydi highlands. The problem with this argument is that in 1986 the South exploded in a factional war that took on a strong regional component. Day's attempt to explain away this anomaly in his argument is not convincing (p. 75).
The rest of Day's book is a detailed telling of the history of the united Republic of Yemen after 1990. While he leaves aside his attempt in Chapters 1 and 2 to build a theoretical framework for understanding Yemen though regionalism, his telling of the demise of ʿAli ʿAbdallah Saleh's regime is predicated on the inability of the Saleh regime to politically incorporate the southern governorates into the Republic after the civil war of 1994. Day vividly expresses the grievances of those from the middle region, Taʿizz and Ibb, and the southern governorates, against the Saleh regime and those from the “northwest highlands” (p. xx).
While Day's conceptual framework lacks clarity and precision, his detailed history of the past two decades is well worth reading for professionals, scholars, undergraduate and graduate students, and the general public.
