Introduction
Dr O’Sullivan is originally from Dublin and has been working as a Consultant Neurologist in the UK since 2004. “The Age of Diagnosis” reads as a serious pause for reflection and consideration of what, according to Dr O’Sullivan, is an unfolding phenomenon of great concern within medicine. Of late, one may have pondered the validity of emerging and expanding diagnoses in passing and been somewhat aware of their changing criteria over time. However, pondering thoughts they may have remained, as the status quo is passively inherited while attending to the acute issues of clinical practice. Undoubtedly, Dr O’Sullivan began this book from the point of view of her own biases, which has attracted criticism, and some have even suggested discounting the book entirely. However it is worth noting that this is not a peer reviewed meta-analysis, which even still must be interpreted cautiously. In this book, we hear instead the opinion of one experienced clinician, although one who draws on those of many others as well as patients themselves, who has become alarmed and feels it is her duty to share her concerns with the public. As Dr O’Sullivan will similarly profess regarding diagnoses, context is everything.
Dr O’Sullivan explores the power of diagnosis, not only the impact on the individual but also the ripple effect on our wider society. This is in how resources are redistributed following the widening criteria for the existence of a pathology and how we conceptualise illness itself. The book is divided into discussions of diagnoses of which autism, ADHD, and long-COVID are included. She interviews both the diagnosed and those with the power to diagnose, where we learn how the line between both entities has become blurred with the emergence of self-diagnosis. A light is shone on conflicts of interest that can exist in providing a diagnosis, the human pressure there can be to provide one and the complicating factor of relying on the approval of health insurance companies to access care. Dr O’Sullivan speaks with a wide variety of specialist clinicians and patients, also questioning herself at times – who is she to disagree with what constitutes as a better quality of life following a diagnosis, as reported by those on the receiving end. Readers are left to make up their own mind on this.
We are brought through a series of philosophical arguments, economic impacts, the history and development of testing, battling ideologies and of course, statistics interpreted correctly. As expected, the problematic nature of false positives is presented, but more intriguingly that also of true positives. This is when the identification of a condition in an individual, occurring through certain criteria, does not necessarily lead to the benefit of the individual and even comes to harm them, or at least from Dr O’Sullivan’s perspective. This harm comes in the form of undue worry, hopelessness and the formation of communities that are based on a shared identity that focusses on one’s limitations.
Dr O’Sullivan does not ask us to distrust the scientific method of testing but rather appreciate what it can and cannot do and to take a result with its appropriate clinical pinch of salt. She implores the reader to understand that a result is not always black and white, but rather a supplement to sound clinical judgement when it comes to formulating a diagnosis. What it means to be “positive”, its relevance depending on our own family history, who this is decided by, and the accuracy of these results is explored with some uncomfortable implications suggested. This is particularly so, according to Dr O’Sullivan, with regard the increasingly available genetic markers of disease of undetermined significance and especially those made available by the commercial sector with little to no genetic counselling provided alongside. This is heavily contrasted by the long established and definitive genetic test for Huntington’s disease. Dr O’Sullivan observes that with the provision of adequate genetic counselling, most of those at risk of Huntington’s choose not to be made aware of their inevitable trajectory. Instead they opt to live in ignorance but alternatively perhaps what one could view as optimism and hope. Dr O’Sullivan never belittles the suffering of those experiencing the severe forms of illness, or the merit of a screening test or a diagnosis if these are to ultimately benefit the individual. However, she challenges the thinking behind expanding what is pathologised given the real-life repercussions.
It is brave to approach this topic. It is no doubt unpopular to express the opinion that harm is being done by well-meaning physician colleagues. Those in receipt of a diagnosis, or who remain in search of a diagnosis may also feel they are being undermined. However, Dr O’Sullivan remains undeterred by the inevitable criticism she will face for writing this book. This is in no small part due to her genuine concern for those she believes are being harmed, which is apparent throughout the reading of this text. The message behind this book could have been more forceful, given the visceral feeling that emanates from between the lines. However, Dr O’Sullivan appears to be conscious to not lose the crowd through invalidation and instead speaks with a tone of concern, using facts, figures, and real-life examples to encourage the reader in joining her in the realisation she herself has come to over years of clinical practice. Some will no doubt disagree with the arguments put forward in this text, but if so, it further stokes the embers of debate to be had as a society. Dr O’Sullivan asks us, can we do better? Is less, in fact, more? And if not, then why?
Funding statement
This research received no specific grant from any funding agency, commercial or not-for-profit sectors.
Competing interests
The author declares none.
Ethical standards
The author asserts that all procedures contributing to this work comply with the ethical standards of the relevant national and institutional committee on human experimentation and with the Helsinki Declaration of 1975, as revised in 2008. The author asserts that the local ethics committee has determined that ethical approval for publication of this book review was not required by their local Ethics Committee.
