How do banks develop when currency is all but non-existent, outlaws and confidence men lurk beyond around every ridge, and cities are established in the blink of a an eye? Michael Hightower sorts through decades of firsthand accounts, newspaper articles, and government records to describe the evolution of banking from merchants to national bankers in the Indian and Oklahoma Territories. The overlapping stories paint a vivid picture of frontier life and finance that has previously gone unseen. At the same time, Hightower shows how the growth of finance in the Twin Territories experienced the same tension between democracy (i.e., goals that accrue to the common good) and capitalism (i.e., goals that accrue to the personal good) that framed the debates of James Madison and Thomas Jefferson at the start of the nation.
The Twin Territories offer an interesting case study. First, their people were a unique blend of entrepreneurs forged out of the struggle to gain, tame, and keep the newly settled land. Exciting stories of get-rich-quick schemes and death defying bank robberies abound as do stories of innovation and neighbors coming together. Second, the Territories were settled relatively late in U.S. history, allowing for many more surviving accounts. Hightower is thus able to make use of the oral histories recorded in the Indian-Pioneer Papers by the Works Progress Administration as well as family accounts passed down over time. The volume and diversity of accounts present a monumental task but Hightower spins this narrative history into a captivating portrayal of Oklahoma's “sooner” spirit.
The people of the Territories were shaped by their environment. Lacking pretty much everything but land and their own human capital, residents had to adapt, experiment, and rely upon each other to survive. This bore out in their financial enterprises. The earliest “bankers” were merchants that saw the advantage of extending credit to their customers, often creating offices out of chicken wire and vaults out of sealed burlap bag. Without much currency in circulation, these merchant bankers had to be jacks-of-all-trades capable of selling or trading the livestock, animal skins, and foodstuffs they often received for interest. Commercial banks quickly followed the land rushes, but the area's meteoric development meant that tents and shacks were often used for a long time before appropriate quarters could be built. The system was not without its setbacks but the positive effects of bankers were unmistakable.
While often depicted as lawless, the Territories defy such easy descriptions. Instead the land, gold, and oil booms brought civilization to live side by side with the wilderness. The banking system was no different as the sudden rise in wealth forced it to begin marching towards maturity. The book covers the installation of banking regulations, the establishment of bankers associations, and the detection and prosecution of frauds.
The book's detailed stories provide tremendous insight into the rise of commerce and finance. However, at the same time, their disconnected nature prevents a consistent and flowing narrative in certain places. Stories of events such as bank creation or fraud are often described back to back in order to emphasize their occurrence in different locations or in different ways. The sequence of stories in some chapters also jumps around in time so as to provide the most relative information rather than a consistent timeline.
Another potential impediment is the need for pre-existing knowledge of Oklahoma. For instance, the book includes stories of famous Oklahomans but only relates that they are well known rather than explaining why they are known. Printing out a map will help locate all the mentioned counties, towns, railroads, and rivers, but more information is needed to fully comprehend the book's connections to historical figures and events outside its scope.
It also bears mentioning that banking in the Territories does not make up the entirety of the book. The initial rise of merchant banking is not described until nearly halfway through the book. Instead, the early chapters focus on the debates and problems surrounding banking in the eastern United States, the adoption of free banking, the establishment of trails linking the Midwest and Great Plains, and early commerce near Oklahoma. These chapters provide the same level of detail devoted to later chapters, but delay the discussion of frontier banking.
Hightower presents one of the most detailed descriptions of the evolution of frontier banking available. Oklahoma's particular brand of commercial activity provides some exciting anecdotes. The narrative approach is probably best suited for historians and sociologists interested in understanding the path of Oklahoma's development, but also holds value for economic historians interested in understanding how banking systems might have evolved in other states and countries, particularly those dependent on natural resources and agriculture.
