The past two decades have witnessed a flourishing of scholarship on immigrants and minorities in modern Latin America, corresponding with a methodological shift emphasising qualitative source materials, such as literature, the press, expressive culture and informant interviews, produced by these communities. The results have yielded exceptional studies on how these communities acted in the face of pressures of adaptation, integration and economic, political and social transformation. Yet the diversity of these newly tapped sources has not produced a matching sensitivity to the changing identities of these groups. Historians of modern immigration, in particular, have utilised categories such as race, ethnicity, Spaniard, Arab and Jew without fully assaying the complex meanings and understandings of these terms. Raanan Rein's fine collection of suggestive essays, entitled Argentine Jews or Jewish Argentines? Essays on Ethnicity, Identity, and Diaspora, is a critical contribution encouraging more subtle approaches to studying the identities of Jewish populations in Latin America. These thoughtful pieces will also prove to be significant for scholars of other immigrants and minorities in the region.
The book consists of ten essays and an extended preface, which are bound together by an exploration of the ‘mosaic of identities’ of the Jewish populations in Argentina and Jewish Argentines residing in Israel, and follows a general chronological order. The preface is a discussion on the genesis of the author's interest in studying the multiple Jewish identities in South America and the development of Latin American Jewish studies and Latin American studies in Israel. Chapter 1, the most theoretical of the collection, reviews the literature of Latin American Jewish studies, arguing that scholars must dispense with the idea that immigrants are either national or diasporic. Rather, he emphasises that immigrants can be both, thus illuminating the highly situational nature of self-identification and subjectivity. In this context Rein advocates the use of the term ‘Jewish-Latin American’, thus giving proper place to the national milieus within which these people live. Rein then offers nine propositions challenging assumptions carried within much of the scholarship on immigrants and minorities, such as the homeland's commitment to its expatriates abroad and the idea that all immigrants or their descendants identify and associate with the community at large.
Chapter 2 offers a brief history of Jewish immigration to Argentina, the development of community institutions and the collectivity's ‘successful integration’ into its new environment. The second portion of the chapter relates the story of Jews from Argentina and elsewhere in Latin America who returned to Israel. Chapter 3 centres around the publication entitled Israel, published by Moroccan Sephardic Jews in Buenos Aires beginning in 1917. In analysing two decades of this periodical, Rein discovers that Zionism could be as much about fashioning a place in Argentine society as it could be about commitment to a Jewish state.
Chapters 4 and 8 discuss the questions surrounding German immigration to Argentina after the Second World War, arguing for an important distinction between Nazis and sympathisers of the Third Reich. In addition, the chapters focus on the May 1960 capture of Adolf Eichmann, a Nazi war criminal, in provincial Buenos Aires by the Israeli Mossad, and the fallout caused by this rendition on the Jewish communities in Argentina. The violation of Argentine sovereignty by Israeli operatives presented an opportunity for anti-Semitic groups to attack Jewish Argentines for questionable loyalty to the state. These assaults led to a variety of activities and strategies, including the formation of self-defence groups and a surge of emigration to Israel.
Chapter 5 examines the strategies employed by the leading Jewish institutions with respect to the inclusion of Catholic doctrine and history in the public school curriculum beginning in December 1943, a major concern of Jewish Argentines. Jewish leaders preferred closed-door lobbying to public pronouncements and confrontation, and key members of community institutions enjoyed good relations with the first Peronist government (1946–55). Rein concludes that perceptions of Peronism as anti-Semitic are unfounded and that Jewish community leaders were particularly skilful in piloting the social and political transformations.
Chapters 6 and 9 scrutinise the representations of Juan Perón and his governments (1946–55, 1973–6) in the Israeli press. For the author, the Israeli organs, especially when compared to British and US periodicals and dailies during the early Cold War era, presented a more complex picture of the Argentine leader. Chapter 7 examines the complicated relationship the Jewish Argentine community had with President Perón. Numerous Jews supported the president; however, many Jewish Argentines and institutions remained leery. Furthermore, the various Jewish institutions went to great lengths to purge the leadership of Peronist supporters after Perón's fall in 1955. The final chapter examines the activities of Jewish Argentines residing in Israel to protest against and boycott the 1978 World Cup, held in Argentina during the military dictatorship and its campaign of state terror against so-called subversives.
Taken together, these essays offer novel approaches to studying immigrants and minorities. There are some conceptual issues, however, in need of deeper discussion. In particular, the terms ‘ethnicity’ and ‘diaspora’ lack clear-cut definitions. Given the richness of the subject, a penetrating discussion on the shifting contours on ethnicity beyond ‘identity fields’ is warranted, as is clearer understanding of what diaspora means to the author and the subjects studied. Without this clarity, awkward statements occasionally emerge, such as studying ‘Jewish identity based on culture rather than on religion or ethnicity’ (p. 15). It is unclear what comprises ethnicity. Secondly, there are fascinating lines that could have been further explored. For instance, Rein asserts in chapter 3 that the Zionism advocated by the Buenos Aires-based Sephardic periodical, Israel, pushed an apolitical agenda in crafting a Jewish-Argentine identity. Rather than a benign, apolitical alternative, however, this seems to be a cultural politics directly confronting a hegemonic cultural and political force incorporating support for a Jewish state into a Jewish-Argentine identity. Finally, I do think the book would have benefited from a brief conclusion revisiting the key arguments. This addition would remind readers of just how important the issues and the author's contributions are for the study of Jewish-Latin Americans as well as immigrants and minorities in modern Latin America.
