The opening of the archives of the former German Democratic Republic (GDR) has been a boon to scholarship concerning both the Soviet Zone of Occupation (SBZ) and East Germany. Sean Brennan's book, The Politics of Religion in Soviet-Occupied Germany, contributes to this scholarship in at least two ways. First of all, Brennan deals with a subject largely ignored by scholars up until this point—the Soviet occupiers' policies concerning the Roman Catholic and Evangelical churches. Second, Brennan, unlike so many others who have written about the history of the SBZ and early GDR, makes extensive use of Russian-language sources. Indeed, the breadth of Brennan's research—he appears to have left no archival stone unturned—is the most impressive element of his work.
Although Brennan concentrates his efforts upon Berlin-Brandenburg, The Politics of Religion in Soviet-Occupied Germany provides an informative and analytical overview of church-state relations throughout the SBZ. Brennan makes it clear that the kernel of East German totalitarianism was present from the start and that Colonel Sergei Tiul'panov, chief of the Soviet Military Administration's (SVAG) Information Administration, was determined to limit the influence of the churches. Tiul'panov's Marxist-Leninist ideology caused him to view religious groups as the natural enemies of the building of an antifascist society. Contributing to this attitude was the fact that both the Roman Catholic and Protestant hierarchies had long organized groups such as children and women, both of whom the German Communist Party (KPD) and its successor, the Socialist Unity Party (SED) considered vitally important to the future of German Socialism. The Christian Democratic Union's (CDU) embracing of “Christian Socialism,” which both the Soviets and the KPD/SED considered a contradiction in terms, increased tensions, and Soviet officials forced the CDU to abandon the idea. Another bone of contention was the issue of religious instruction in the SBZ's schools, which both the Soviets and German communists opposed on principle. A compromise was worked out, under which children could attend religious instruction after school, but this worked to the detriment of the churches in the long run.
None of Brennan's conclusions will be surprising to scholars. His contribution to historiography is that, making use of hitherto largely unexplored sources and investigating institutions not previously examined, The Politics of Religion in Soviet-Occupied Germany reaffirms the conclusions of other scholars, especially the critics of Wilfried Loth's Stalins ungeliebtes Kind. Soviet policies concerning the churches, Brennan maintains, pointed clearly toward the creation of a socialist Germany. The GDR was not “Stalin's unwanted child.”
While Brennan makes his arguments effectively and supports them with extensive archival evidence, his work is not without its flaws. The book, for example, needed to be edited much more carefully. There are so many typographical errors that a reader might very well find himself or herself proofreading the book rather than reading it. There is even an occasional ungrammatical sentence. As annoying as these flaws are, The Politics of Religion in Soviet-Occupied Germany remains an informative book and makes a valuable contribution to scholars' understanding of Soviet policies in postwar Germany.
