It is ironic and tragic that during the past two centuries three great powers have invaded the poor and distant nation of Afghanistan for a more or less similar purpose: to control and shape its internal political structure. However, the circumstances and the justifications of the invasions have varied greatly. Britain invaded it twice in the 19th century as part of a strategy to defend its Indian empire and maintain Afghanistan as a neutral buffer zone against Russia. The Soviet Union marched on Afghanistan to stabilize its client socialist regime with the combined motivations of extending its empire beyond the conventional boundaries of Central Asia and of asserting the ideological need to defend client socialist regimes. Currently, the United States, NATO, and a large coalition of other countries are currently engaged in yet another round of costly warfare in Afghanistan, allegedly to rebuild its institutions and restore a sense of normalcy lost during a quarter century of conflict.
However, why, of all nations, has Afghanistan been the target of four major invasions by three different great powers? Any answer to this question requires looking internally at the geopolitics, history, culture, and social structures of the country and externally at the interplay between internal and external actors, their interests, and how actors have played specific and individual games to protect and advance their interests.
This recent book by Victoria Schofield presents an exhaustive and excellent account of the roles of foreign powers and local and regional forces and how they have contested to control the country and the capacity to shape its destiny. The work is very different from many other works that have emerged about Afghanistan during the past twenty years in both its coverage of the subjects and presentation of the long history of Afghanistan's evolution as a state, society, and object of coveted foreign interest.
One of the most prominent themes in the book is Afghanistan's location “as a crossroad and meeting place of divergent interests” nearly since its inception (p. 10). The geography of the country, on top of an ancient invasion route down the legendry Khyber Pass to the valley of Indus, now Pakistan, and beyond to the landmass of the Indian subcontinent, is well documented. Schofield has very competently handled this theme by weaving her narrative around it. She begins with the story of Alexander and describes how his armies encountered the Afghans. The Aryans from Central Asia, however, were the first to actually travel through the valleys and passes of Afghanistan, living there for hundreds of years and finally settling in India almost a millennium before Alexander followed their tracks to the Indus. The advent and spread of Islam in the 7th century entirely reshaped the culture, civilization, and general worldview of the tribes, subtribes, clans, and other social groups of Afghanistan.
Even with the deep imprint of Islam on the values and social orientations of the Afghans, their traditional social structures, mores, and traditions have continued to shape their images of their identity and of the outsiders who have come from beyond their historic homeland. The book presents the cultural and social evolution of the Afghan people and describes their society in the context of the religious, linguistic, and civilizational influences the age of empire building in the surrounding regions left with them. In a social and cultural sense, Afghan character and national identity have been shaped by the cultural dynamics of Central and southwest Asian regions as much as by local customs and traditions. Afghanistan has stood not only at the crossroads of empires and invading armies but also at a meeting point for diverse cultural movements. The author develops these influences in a subtle but forceful way by recounting the narratives, stories, and impressions of various local and foreign actors, all engaged in the quest to control and define Afghanistan.
The single most important quality of the work lies in its multidisciplinary character, as it sketches out not only the long and checkered history of the country but also its cultural, social, and political features. No account of Afghanistan would be complete or even worthy of interest and attention without some discussion of dynastic feuds, tribal conflicts, foreign interventions, and wars imposed by external powers. As the book's subtitle suggests, the author provides very interesting, well-researched, and rich detail about feuds and fighting in Afghanistan. However, each episode of conflict is contextualized and depicted as part of the larger story of Afghanistan. The book covers in detail the British quest to control Afghanistan and its two wars, the motivations behind the “great game” and forward deployment policy, and the failures and pain that the British imperial rulers suffered on this “highway of conquest.” By processing the personal accounts of the main players involved in the British policy toward Afghanistan, as well as their diaries, memoirs, official documents, and private papers, Schofield presents an authentic, readable history of Afghanistan in a fashion that excites the reader's interest in the people and the country.
The author transitions well between narratives and moves with ease from one historical epoch to another. She recasts Afghanistan in its new postcolonial phase, redefining itself in terms of modernization and state and nation building in a bipolar world setting. Afghanistan lost its buffer and neutral status when shortsighted rulers, such as Sardar Daoud and his successor, attached the country to Soviet imperial designs and led it into occupation and war. Afghans using the banner of Islam and nationalism fought back bravely and in the true spirit of their historical image as fighters who are fiercely independent, nationalist, and willing to sacrifice anything and everything to keep their country free and sovereign. With the support of Pakistan, the United States, and other Western countries, the Afghans defeated the once “invincible” Soviet superpower.
However, the agony of Afghanistan did not end with the Soviet retreat. The power struggles first between mujahidin parties and then along religious, sectarian, and ethnic lines between the Taliban and their opponents pushed the country into a deadly civil war. The book touches briefly on the so-called war on terror, although it is clearly an equally important and ongoing period in the history of the struggle and survival of Afghanistan. This is a fascinating book that is beautifully written, with very lucid accounts of individuals, their missions, regional characteristics, social environs, and the conflicting interests of so many powers, both ancient and modern. The book attempts to answer a timeless question: why has impoverished Afghanistan and its people attracted so many foreign powers and transnational forces to battle for control of the country? Schofield's answer to this question only generates more interest in learning why the fate of the country has consistently swung from one extreme of isolation and neglect to the other extreme of foreign intervention and war.
