Perhaps more than any other civilization, ancient Rome is known to us through its great men and their deeds. Brutus's execution of his sons, the rise and fall of Manlius Capitolinus, Scipio's victory over Hannibal at the Battle of Zama—this is how Rome presents in the public imagination. In keeping with Roman sensibilities about the educative value of exempla, our concept of Rome reflects our familiarity with these stories and the cultural ideals they express. Whereas some classicists have grown more circumspect about the reliability of these narratives, Jan Blits's Heart of Rome embraces them as crucial sources of insight into the Roman “heart and mind” (xii). Blits proposes to understand what it meant to be Roman “from the inside,” as it were, focusing on what Romans said about themselves to themselves, as opposed to what might be observed or inferred about them using methods of modern historical analysis. The outcome is a rich and engaging study of Roman beliefs, attitudes, and values that makes sense of the political choices that Romans were inclined to make and illuminates the broader complexion of their political world.
Blits's central argument is that it is possible to talk sensibly about “Romanness.” Even prior to any particular claim about who the Romans were, Heart of Rome defends the unity and vitality of Roman political culture against the disaggregative, reductive, and ultimately dismissive tendencies of modern historical scholarship. As the preface makes clear, Blits is highly critical of what he takes to be the defining features of Roman studies as practiced by classicists, which he associates with methodological anxieties that we should feel safe ignoring. These objections are somewhat overstated, as there have been several recent studies of Roman political culture that share Blits's own attentiveness to the testimony of Roman writers concerning the essential components of Roman political identity (e.g., Miriam Pelikan Pittenger's Contested Triumphs and Nathan Rosenstein's Imperatores Victi). Moreover, it seems clear that at least some interpretive sophistication is in order when reading Roman sources from the late republican and early imperial eras given the highly charged, and often unstable, political climate. Still, the fundamental intuition of the book—that something like “Romanness” did in fact exist, and our best source of information is the testimony of Romans themselves—is surely well-founded, and Blits has done an excellent job reconstructing its key elements.
Heart of Rome is organized into seven main chapters, followed by a helpful “Who's Who” of Roman personages and a timeline of major events in Roman history. Each chapter addresses a different facet of Roman culture, with most focusing on some aspect of the city's political culture. Chapters 1 and 2 address different features of Rome's military identity. In chapter 1, Blits explores Rome's ambiguous and evolving relationship with the sea. Although initially characterized by a strong preference for land-based power, which they associated with the manly virtues that comprised their understanding of excellence, Romans proved their adaptability by developing a formidable navy during the First Punic War. Chapter 2, by contrast, examines how Hannibal capitalized on more inflexible features of Roman identity, turning what had long been viewed as the particular strengths of Rome into liabilities. Of particular interest is Blits's discussion of the Roman tendency to move aggressively against its enemies, which enabled Hannibal to provoke Roman troops into fighting under unfavorable circumstances. Again, Blits traces this military disposition to a distinctively Roman understanding of virtue.
Chapters 3, 4, and 5 tackle somewhat broader questions about Roman perception. Chapter 3 considers the importance of spectacles in Roman culture, emphasizing the visual and even theatrical nature of Roman political life. Chapter 4 charts Roman sensibilities about time and memory, including the significance of ancestry, custom, and memorialization in the Roman mind. These themes are brought together in chapter 5, which looks at the role played by the censorship in publicly enforcing standards of moral decency, particularly within the senatorial elite.
Finally, chapters 6 and 7 turn squarely to Roman republicanism and its eventual decline. In chapter 6, Blits highlights tensions between Roman political culture and the two dominant schools of philosophy in the late Republic, Epicureanism and Stoicism. Whatever the differences between them, Blits argues, both Epicureanism and Stoicism shared a kind of inwardness that undermined the primacy of civic attachments in Rome, justifying Cato's famous hostility toward these Greek imports in the mid-second century. The analysis of Roman philosophy offered in chapter 6 is intended to help explain why Roman elites of the late Republic cared less about the common good than earlier generations had; chapter 7 suggests why the Roman people were equally, if not more, unwilling to defend the city's republican regime, holding that Roman history testifies to their “deep-rooted readiness—indeed, a persistent preference—to be ruled by a monarch” (113). Relying primarily on the early books of Livy, Blits argues that while the Roman people surely came to detest the name “king,” they nevertheless valued the benefits and services that kingly figures were inclined to provide them. Thus, Caesar's successful rise to power should be viewed less as a radical break with Roman political tradition than as a clever exploitation of its longstanding promonarchical undercurrents.
All of these essays are a delight to read, and together they provide a lively and encompassing picture of the Roman psyche. Much of the credit goes to Blits's “naive” interpretive style, which, among other things, preserves the vitality of his sources. The drawbacks of this style are most obvious in chapter 7, which proceeds from the unlikely assumption that early histories of Rome are unencumbered by the political controversies of the period in which they were written. Still, Heart of Rome is a book worthy of its subject matter and a great asset to readers looking to familiarize themselves with this extraordinary city.
