This collection aims to meet the need for critical work on Lecter, characterized in Daniel O'Brien's Foreword as an “archetypal nightmare figure” (5), particularly in Harris's novels which stand as landmarks of recent horror fiction in developing the serial killer as antihero. Szumskyj's introduction credits Harris with the creation of one of the best fictional villains of all time, pointing to his use of real-life serial killers and forensics in establishing a realistic subgenre of the crime thriller. The chapters vary in tone here, resulting in a diverse yet uneven read.
Scholarly chapters focus on genre, with Peter Messent analysing Harris's Gothic in terms of liminality, his “peculiar type of crime fiction” (14) blending Gothic and horror as well as high and low art. Gothic's liminality allows recognition of repressed appetites with the metaphor of cannibalism as “the worst aspects of western culture” (19). Philip L. Simpson casts Lecter's controversial union with Starling at the close of Hannibal (1999) as a Gothic romance, the “shared monstrosity” (65) of their past traumas reinforcing generic affinity between romance and danger. For Davide Mana, Red Dragon's (1981) serial killer Dolarhyde updates noir into neo-noir and embodies the fear of the unknown that lingers in an age no longer convinced by supernatural explanations. S. T. Joshi explores the links between mystery/detective and horror/weird fiction, arguing that Harris's fiction is of the former variety. Not alone in finding the conclusion to Hannibal “preposterous” (129), he reflects that Harris is potentially overreliant on Lecter. Tony Magistrale considers both genre and gender; in tying characters to the “Jekyll–Hyde paradigm” (134) he notes that Dolarhyde fails to achieve the transformation Starling attains in the female-centred The Silence of the Lambs (1988). Phillip A. Ellis expresses similar views in seeing her as the “‘ideal’ American woman” (161); the kind of strong feminine presence lacking in Red Dragon.
John Goodrich analyses Lecter's conversations as revealing of his proclivity for psychology and mentoring those whom he deems worthy of his attention. Tony Williams notes Harris's use of an archetypal pattern, symbolic of the symbiotic relationship between hunter and hunted, so prevalent in American culture. Locating him within wider popular culture, he argues that his clinical style is reminiscent of television franchises such as Law and Order, which also deal with crime investigations. Robert H. Waugh focusses on Harris's symbolism and its relation to classical mythology, with his motifs of butterflies, hounds and labyrinths rooted in the myth of Theseus. Noting contradictions within many of Harris's characters, he concludes that “Ambivalence is in the nature of the myth” (85) as the Minotaur contains both man and beast.
Some chapters fall away from this kind of analysis, however; Ali S. Karim offers a review-style commentary on Hannibal Rising (2006), whilst Szumskyj's reflections on Hannibal become somewhat adulatory, with a final summation of Harris's novels as “written masterpieces” (210). Scott D. Briggs's discussion of the post-9/11 resonance of Black Sunday's (1975) terrorist plot against the United States is interesting, but sits somewhat awkwardly in a book ostensibly about Lecter. Charles Gramlich's Afterword, which sees Lecter as instrumental in “the developing myth of the super predator, the serial killer” (213), situates this book as a welcome and insightful examination of an important cultural icon, although some chapters are perhaps more effective than others.
