In recent years, the idea of the “Sufi order” in the Weberian sense of a discrete religious institution possessing a history and structure shaped by predictable processes of routinization has come under increasing scrutiny as a construct useful for describing the phenomenon of the Sufi ṭarīqa. Situated at the intersection of recent revisionist discussions of the Sufi revival of the 18th century and the legacy of the Moroccan Sufi master Ahmad Ibn Idris (d. 1837), Mark Sedgwick's Saints and Sons proposes a new paradigm that envisions the Sufi ṭarīqa as a dynamic entity marked neither by easily discernable institutional continuities nor doctrinal consistencies but, rather, by complex and recurring instances of organizational transformation and thematic change. Using the case of a widespread Sufi order with a history spanning two centuries and three continents, Sedgwick shows that almost from its inception in Mecca at the end of the 18th century through its diffusion across much of the Arab Middle East, the Sudan, and Southeast Asia, the history of the Ahmadiyya is best described as a roughly cyclical process of individual “remakings” wherein a particular expression of the order rises under a great scholar or saint, then splits as it spreads, and then stabilizes, from whence it can either decline or be remade anew with the emergence of another great scholar or saint (pp. 2–3). As the author's carefully documented study displays, this cycle has occurred at least five times and, if its most recent remakings are any indication, shows no sign of abating.
By way of introducing the subject, the book opens with a lengthy exposition on the career of Ibn Idris and the influence of his concept of the ṭarīqa muḥammadiyya on the rise and subsequent transformation(s) of the Sanusiyya and Khatmiyya, two major orders that themselves resulted from earlier remakings of the Idrisi ṭarīqa as such. Although largely derivative, such stocktaking is appreciated and serves to contextualize the material comprising the rest of the book, namely a carefully crafted history of the ṭarīqa, which sprang from the teachings and activities of Ibn Idris's Sudanese disciple Ibrahim al-Rashid (d. 1874), an energetic propagator of his master's teachings whose followers quickly disseminated his version of the ṭarīqa muḥammadiyya from the Sudan to Southeast Asia.
As the second part of the book, entitled “The First Remaking of the Rashidi Ahmadiyya,” argues, although Ibrahim al-Rashid appears to have stuck much closer to the teachings of Ibn Idris than the founders of the Sanusiyya and Khatmiyya, the order he inspired did not. The succession of, among others, the unlikely Muhammad al-Dandarawi (d. 1911)—an illiterate deserter from the Egyptian army—set a precedent for a recurring positive valuation of charismatic claims to saintly authority in Ahmadi lineages. In addition, from this remaking also emerged the recurring theme of the widespread popularization and integration of the order into local contexts by means as varied as linking Ahmadi zāwiyas to trade networks in the Sudan to capitalizing upon struggles between reformers and conservatives in Damascus. Alongside this remaking, a concomitant remaking took place in Malaya, where the Mecca-educated Malay scholar Muhammad Saעid (d. 1926) disseminated an Ahmadi lineage from Seremban, which grew increasingly distant from Ahmadi centers in the Arab world.
The third and final part of the book, entitled simply “Sons,” concentrates on yet another series of remakings in the history of the Ahmadiyya, transformations differentiated from those preceding them by a shift toward hereditary leadership. Thus, the son of al-Dandarawi, Abu al-עAbbas (d. 1953), gained enough popularity after his father's death to elicit millennial speculation among his followers in the Sudan. Similarly, in Southeast Asia, the sons and grandsons of Muhammad Saעid were able to garner enough popular support to dominate the post of state mufti of Negeri Sembilan, as well as redefine the order, after a period of disarray and subsequent reconsolidation, as a thoroughly Malaysian family ṭarīqa with little overt connections to its founder's Meccan or, indeed, Idrisi roots. As Sedgwick shows, the case of Muhammad Saעid's son עAbd al-Rashid (d. 1992) and the Singapore Ahmadiyya further evinces just how substantial such remakings can be (pp. 181–94).
When considered in the aggregate, what Sedgwick's detailed narrative shows is that each remaking of the Ahmadiyya has been deeply tied to the local contexts in which it transpired. This tie is nowhere more striking than in the final case he discusses, contemporary Cairo and Beirut. Here, we encounter the charismatic millionaire son of Abu al-עAbbas, Fadl al-Dandarawi (b. 1934), who despite his own denial to the contrary is venerated as a Sufi shaykh by thousands, and Suעad al-Hakim (b. 1946), a former graduate student of the well-known Iraqi Jesuit scholar of classical Sufism, Paul Nwyia, and presently chair of the philosophy department at the Lebanese University in Beirut. In the early 1970s, they set out to gather together the remains of the Dandarawi Ahmadiyya and transform it into an Islamic social organization whose mission was not to practice Sufism as such but, rather, to remedy the disunity of modern times. The resulting organization, the Usra al-Dandarawiyya, rejects being called a ṭarīqa in favor of presenting itself as a movement committed to improving the moral and spiritual state of the Muslim world by propagating an ethically focused and nonsectarian ṭarīqa muḥammadiyya that is as thoroughly modern and cosmopolitan as its remakers. In contradistinction to the Singapore Ahmadiyya of עAbd al-Rashid, however, it has met with very limited success.
The final chapter of the book, entitled “The Authority of the Shaykhs,” serves to summarize the study and to synthesize its main contentions, pointing out that the only two constants in the history of the Ahmadiyya are its written literature and, more importantly, the expectations of a particular shaykh's followers. Here, the role of the charismatic authority of individual shaykhs and the vital importance of local context in shaping the order's various remakings is well explained.
Based on the evidence adduced, Sedgwick's paradigm provides a convincing model for the particular, although perhaps rather idiosyncratic, case of the Ahmadiyya. How well it might account for the development of other Sufi orders, however, is still open to debate. Overall, in writing the history of the Ahmadiyya, Saints and Sons fills a major gap in the literature on the Sufi orders and associated movements springing from the teachings of Ahmad Ibn Idris and will certainly serve as the standard work on the subject for the foreseeable future.
