It would be a disservice to The Cotton Kings to label it as just an economic history or as the newest volume to join the growing literature on capitalism and the global economy in the long nineteenth century. While it certainly is an economic history, it is also a work of social history, labor history, urban history, cultural history, and Southern history. The authors' interdisciplinary approach draws upon the rich sub-focuses within nineteenth and twentieth century history and results in a book that enriches our understanding of the symbiotic relationship between commodities and the marketplace. The clear and nontechnical explanations of financial terminology and processes augment this well-researched book, and the integration of the financial language propels the story, ensuring that it will be featured on many reading lists and be useful to numerous scholars.
The Cotton Kings is an economic drama that unfolds in cotton exchanges, cotton fields, brokerage houses, courthouses, and Congress. It showcases the rural, urban, and global context and impact of cotton as both commodity and currency. This book argues that market regulation works, that the system that replaced the antebellum market was shaped by wartime practices, and that it was directly incorporated within and reactive to technological advancements and global business climate. Spanning from the 1870s until World War I—while frequently teasing out connections between earlier legislation and more contemporary bills, such as the 1922 Grain Futures Act and Commodity Exchange Act of 1936 that paved the way for the Commodity Futures Trading Commission in 1974—this book does much to change the traditional narrative of the Gilded Age and of the large-scale business organizations, monopolies, and antitrust actors.
This is a story about individual men and their ambition to make money, but it is also a story about the financial markets, the growth and maturation of the financial market, commodity crops, and the people cultivating that crop. Hahn and Baker put a human face on financial history and trading. They focus on what motivated individuals and the people who staffed the cotton exchanges. They show, particularly in their coverage of the New Orleans bulls, how their background and knowledge of cotton cultivation influenced individual choices with widespread impact. The book profiles numerous scandals and failed and successful markets, but the human element is always uncovered in the handling of these events. This allows the authors to show the far-reaching effect of individual choices and ambition on local, national, and international markets, events, and society writ large.
One fantastic aspect of this book is that it highlights the extraordinary and long-reaching impact that a commodity had in shaping not just the market but trading practices. In today's age where the launch of phone apps, cloud-based platforms, and technology products determines spikes in the market and creates overnight millionaires, it is important to remember that a tangible crop grown in the fertile soil that stretches across the American South directly influenced and changed the face of trading. Cotton, and the cotton futures market at the turn of the century, shaped our current business world, global commodity trading, and government regulation. A significant contribution of this book is to show that that the modern financial world is inextricably tied to and produced by cotton.
Several themes run beneath the surface and amplify the book's major arguments. Environmental factors played a central role in determining current and future crop outcomes. Not only was flooding or drought a major concern to farmers and cotton traders, but boll weevils and rot could have disastrous effects for Southern farmers, factors in New Orleans and New York, and mill owners in England and New England. When the weevil struck, it expanded across the Cotton South in response to their environment. Farmers were powerless to do anything, but the damaged crop meant that they desperately needed cash. Hahn and Baker expertly demonstrate how the Southern Cotton Association grew out of regional conventions called in 1902–4 to form alliances based on mutual interest in higher cotton prices and how New Orleans bulls dexterously built upon this mobilization to draw farmers into the bull network. While “boll weevil was an agent that brought cotton planters into the network of the bull traders” (73), it also brought into stark focus what mattered to farmers versus what mattered to businessmen. Individual farmers' priorities and circumstances changed how business happened. Technology was also critical in remaking the world of farming and of commerce. Cotton pricing and sales were now instantaneous, and futures trading quickly replaced contracts for future delivery of goods. Information from a wide range of sources now shaped the price of goods and crop reports were available to everyone. However, futures trading and crop report access would impact ordinary farmers, and would demonstrate that the price of cotton reflected manipulation of information and not simple supply and demand.
That manipulation of information and prices to achieve the goals of traders on the New York and New Orleans Cotton Exchanges resulted in an ever-widening rift between farmers and the federal government and drove a wedge between city dwellers and rural individuals. The authors adeptly delve into why this schism widened in the aftermath of the 1905 U.S. Department of Agriculture scandal that corrupted that organization's reputation for trustworthiness. Their handling of the protracted battle between the New York bears and New Orleans bulls also reveals how that battle mirrored the chasm between urban and rural America while distorting the market and hurting Southern cotton farmers. The Cotton Kings is an excellent addition to the historiography. It presents new insights into the development of American financial markets while grounding the narrative in the human element of ambition.
