During the 1980s, under Argentina's first postdictatorship democratic regime, a low-income district of Buenos Aires, Villa Lugano, accomplished a rare moment of successful, constructive, popular collective action. Residents organized to demand street pavement for their district. Up until then, Villa Lugano had suffered dirt streets, inadequate sanitation and poor sewage control. Residents met in nonviolent moments of protest, incorporated and followed leaders, who were genuinely interested in furthering neighborhood interests, visited party leaders and petitioned city hall. Progress on the pavement project stalled repeatedly owing to resistance from city hall or the construction company or both. Each time, residents of Villa Lugano came together to overcome the obstacles and get the pavement project back on track. In the end they were successful, and improved, modern street infrastructure came to their neighborhood.
The Right to the City is the narrative of this unusual story. Gabriela Ippolito-O'Donnell has done extensive fieldwork in Villa Lugano and taken several years to interview participants, engage in participant observation, and conduct surveys of leaders and neighborhood residents. She knows the neighborhood well and has followed the struggle closely. The result is a careful look at a success story. Hers is a welcome example of extensive fieldwork and multimethod research that has uncovered a story with implications far beyond the neighborhood itself.
The book does not end here, however. Ippolito-O'Donnell follows the neighborhood into a second phase of popular struggle: a larger effort to build or reopen clinics and hospitals that would have brought accessible health care to residents. This second phase of the struggle failed. The book examines repeated instances of clientelistic control by members of both parties, which undermined the popular organization. The author also looks closely at the enormous popular hostility among neighborhood subgroups that emerged as it became clear that the movement would need to focus on one clinic or hospital at a time, serving one subneighborhood first and then moving on to other clinics subsequently.
Ippolito-O'Donnell examines the gradual emergence of what she calls “social antagonism,” the resurfacing of deep social grievances and resentments among groups in Villa Lugano. She argues that such resentments followed lines of neighborhood subgroups: residents living in the old town, housing projects, or shanty towns. Each group harbored deep hostility toward the other groups and none was willing to let a clinic be opened in one subneighborhood that would serve some residents more readily than others. As a result, the second phase of the struggle failed and the neighborhood organization itself disappeared.
Ippolito-O'Donnell's work joins a growing body of scholarship that has focused on popular politics, popular values, and collective action in Argentina since the return to a problematic democracy in 1983 with the presidency of Raúl Alfonsín. Examining Argentina from a variety of angles and using different research methods, many scholars are concluding that Argentina has deep problems with constructive collective action. Citizens are hard put to organize themselves constructively and to accomplish tasks of popular purpose. It is far more common than not to find Argentines succumbing to clientelistic maneuvers by political leaders or to social antagonism among popular groups. It is also likely that Argentines will take illegal action, as happened in the 2001 riots and street lootings. In this sense, Ippolito-O'Donnell has uncovered information that fits with a growing scholarly discourse about the problems of collective action in Argentina.
This book makes a unique contribution to that dialogue in several ways. First, Ippolito-O'Donnell has based her argument in extensive fieldwork, including a willingness to find out what is happening on the streets and in neighborhood meetings. Although she has collected extensive survey data, surveys are not her only source of information. Her in-depth interviews with citizens and leaders and her extensive participant observation make this a rich, interesting book that improves our understanding about why Argentine citizens have such difficulty cooperating and engaging in constructive collective action.
Ippolito-O'Donnell treats this event as a failure because the second phase of collective action was unsuccessful. However, Villa Lugano was a story of initial success and this is quite unusual in Argentina. The fact that the second set of goals was never reached does not change the fact that the streets were paved, and Villa Lugano residents were responsible for that outcome. They successfully navigated their way around all efforts by manipulative, deceitful, and clientelistic political leaders to undermine their efforts. They succeeded, at least once.
It may well be that this popular success was owing to the advent of democracy in 1983 and to the opening of political space provided by democratization, but Ippolito-O'Donnell does not explore this aspect of the narrative. However, the presence of a Radical administration cannot be the whole explanation for success because the neighborhood organization died before the Alfonsín administration ended. Since 1989, Argentina has been governed by Peronists, except for the brief De la Rua presidency, which ended prematurely. Further research on popular movements would need to explore their fate under the Peronist presidencies as well.
The broader political context and the use of clientelism to undermine popular organization cannot fully explain the demise of the neighborhood organization. Ippolito-O'Donnell has done us a great service by showing us that the poor themselves undermine their own success and detract from their ability to improve their own lives by their tendency to sink into the habits of mutual hostility, which has caused other scholars to conclude that Argentina is low in social capital, low in trust, and high in skepticism.
The narrative itself is then followed by several chapters presenting the results of statistical analyses of survey data. The author uncovers deep and troubling contradictions in public opinion about democracy in Argentina. Commitment to democracy is limited and definitions of democracy are numerous. These contradictions bear further investigation and help us understand why individuals find it so difficult to work together for a constructive purpose.
As she moves toward her conclusions, Ippolito-O'Donnell considers her findings in the context of various theories about collective action and democracy. She clearly fits within the predominant perspective that collective action is positive for democracy and that the capacity for popular cooperation is good, both for the population and for the democratic state. She courageously challenges the alternative thesis that distrust is good for democracy. She argues that modest levels of skepticism or distrust might be useful for democracy, as they can produce institutional checking mechanisms whereby government can keep democracy on track. But the high levels of distrust that she found in Villa Lugano clearly do not contribute to democracy. They undermine and ultimately put an end to progress and collective action and, for that reason, cannot be positive for democracy.
This book is useful for students of Argentina and Latin America and for those interested in popular politics and collective action. But it also has relevance beyond these specific issues. Ippolito-O'Donnell has provided a detailed look at collective action: when it succeeds and why it fails in a national context where failure is much more common. Her work allows us to take rich empirical detail and compare it to theories about collective action, popular protest, and democracy. It is a contribution far beyond the neighborhood of Villa Lugano itself and holds relevance for students of democracy everywhere.
