This volume on Roman emperors in the ‘long’ fourth century is the product of a conference held at Radboud University in September 2015. The central premise is a shift in focus from what emperors may or may not have done in antiquity to how these rulers presented themselves, how others presented them and how the resulting constructions could interweave, reinforcing old stereotypes and generating new meanings. The emphasis is on textual representations, particularly panegyric, the analysis of which is central to many of the chapters. However, a range of other ancient material is also used, such as law, coinage and epigraphy. Many of the contributions seek to tease apart the relationship between, and agency of, these media in an attempt to distinguish the imperial image as created by others — the ‘hetero-image’, in imagology terms (see 12) — from that which might have originated from the emperor himself, his ‘auto-image’.
The editors’ introduction sets the scene, summarising the issues, themes and theoretical underpinnings that run through the volume. The chapters are arranged chronologically, moving from the mid third century until the early fifth century. A particular benefit of this approach is the way it places emperors who are well studied side-by-side with those who, for various reasons, have slipped through the cracks. The application of similar questions and methodologies to all of these figures offers a compelling re-assessment of how emperorship could be constructed in Late Antiquity: new angles are brought to well-trodden episodes and new light shone on more elusive ones.
David Potter opens with an investigation of the legacies of Decius and Valerian, examining how later writers emphasised different aspects of these emperors’ stories for their own purposes. He argues that both were reduced to stereotypes, projections that bear little resemblance to what we can reconstruct of their actual lives and activities. Jürgen K. Zangerberg discusses Diocletian and the Tetrarchy: first what can be gauged of how the emperor presented himself and his imperial colleagues, and then how Lactantius subsequently subverted these ‘official images’ with his own ‘counter-images’ (49) in his highly critical De mortibus persecutorum. Though the chapter contains some stimulating close analysis of the De mort. pers., its arguments are somewhat undermined by the author's tendency to group the surviving panegyrics together as a monolithic source of state propaganda, as well as some teleological conclusions concerning Lactantius’ desire for a ‘true monarchy’ under Constantine (60). In the third chapter, Alessandro Maranesi offers a nuanced analysis of Maximian's representation in his western territories, particularly how it was built on the othering of ‘barbarian’ peoples on the neighbouring Rhine frontier, and how this representation was distorted after the emperor's death in 310.
Raphael Hunsucker picks through the slander to reconstruct how Maxentius fostered ideological connections to the founders of Rome during his tenure as emperor in the city. Though the argument that Maxentius’ father promoted a similar ideology, based predominantly on the panegyric of 289, is a little shaky, the chapter offers a valuable perspective on a well-studied emperor. Likewise, Catherine Ware's chapter on the evolution of Constantine's image in the panegyric of 310 manages to bring fresh insights to his now infamous vision of Apollo. Ware offers a refined take on how imperial representation could be the product of communication running from ruler to a local audience and back, mediated through the creativity of an independent speaker. Editor Diederik Burgersdijk then tackles the elusive question of how Crispus, Constantine's eliminated heir, was presented in panegyric, including a valuable discussion of the interplay of language and ideology in contemporary inscriptions.
Moving into the later Constantinian dynasty, George Woudhuysen's fantastically written piece of detective work examines the various representations of Constans, offering insights without over-stretching the available evidence. The second editor, Alan Ross, evaluates how Constantius II was presented through the lens of Julian — an unusual case of one member of the imperial house praising another — and how Julian, in turn, characterised himself as emperor and panegyrist. Marίa Pilar Garcίa Ruiz's contribution stands apart from the others in that it centres on visual iconography, tracing the development of Julian's self-representation on coinage against the emperor's literary output. Jan Willem Drijvers takes on the short-ruling and short-changed Jovian, evaluating his image as created in secular and Christian writings and, most interestingly, the sixth-century Syriac Julian Romance.
The final four chapters move to the Valentinian/Theodosian Dynasty, beginning with Daniël den Hengst's discussion of Ammianus Marcellinus’ portrait of Valentinian. In common with other case studies in the book, this involves investigating the roots of an emperor's reputation and finding a reliance on one particular literary construction that is more ambiguous and contradictory than has been thought. Bruce Gibson then offers a close reading of Ausonius’ speech thanking Gratian for the consulship of 379, discussing its conscious relationship with the tradition of panegyric, especially Pliny's Panegyric, and how the orator navigates a scenario where he, as the emperor's confidant and former teacher, has close access to his subject's private world. This is followed by Roger Rees’ analysis of the interplay between two texts addressed to Theodosius, Ambrose's letter on the Callinicum riot (Ep. 74) and Pacatus’ panegyric, both of which use the unusual tag libertas dicendi, ‘freedom of speech’. This discussion complements the book's wider findings of the agency of imperial representation nicely: authors with disparate agendas projecting models of emperorship onto a living ruler, conscious that they are addressing the emperor but also his subjects, and actively shaping concepts of authority. Finally, Álvaro Sánchez-Ostiz analyses how the poet Claudian situated the half-Vandal Stilicho within rhetorical stereotypes of Roman-ness in his panegyric on Stilicho's third consulship in 400. This consideration of a figure who was in close proximity to imperial power but never actually an emperor provides a fitting conclusion for a volume concerned with blurred and conflicting images.
Imagining Emperors is an attractive book and includes well-placed colour images, most of which are of excellent quality. The introduction reads as a little rushed and under-referenced in comparison to the chapters, and some of the contributions have a few unfortunate typos. It is a relatively accessible volume. The authors do an excellent job of explaining the often complicated political context, but some of the chapters include excerpts of untranslated text. At twelve male contributions to two female, the gender balance is notably poor (see, however, the preface for a more diverse picture of the original conference and wider editorial process). Individually the chapters are thought-provoking and original. Together they form a coherent whole, offering a valuable shift in emphasis that places panegyric and the ‘representational turn’ at the centre of our understanding of later Roman emperorship.
