Philip Kaisary's The Haitian Revolution in the Literary Imagination attempts a broad survey of modern representations of the Haitian Revolution, with an emphasis on Caribbean and African American responses. It focusses primarily on canonical figures such as C. L. R. James, Alejo Carpentier, René Depestre, Langston Hughes, Aimé Césaire, and Derek Walcott, who have attracted much scholarship already. But Kaisary is the first to study these writers in relation to each other and to scholarship on the Revolution. He also ventures beyond literature, discussing paintings by Jacob Lawrence and the Haitian artist Kimathi Donkor, as well as commemorative postage stamps and William Grant Still's opera Troubled Island.
Kaisary adopts an unfortunate method that almost dooms his study, though parts of it escape its reductive premise. He proposes “dividing these texts along a single axis of distinction, the radical and the conservative,” in order “to draw out the situation and ideological thrust of each of the works considered” (2, original emphasis). As if aware that this dualism risks oversimplification, he adds that this method “provides a framework in which to pose nuanced questions of forms and aesethetics [sic], their political implications, and the politics of their metaphorics” (2). But the book asks “nuanced questions” only intermittently and does not consistently integrate them into its determination of “radical” and “conservative” outcomes. It assumes, rather than argues, that radical ideology is always productive, conservative ideology always a “constraint.” Nor does it define the terms “radical” and “conservative.” “Radical” appears to mean belief in the possibility and desirability of revolution – means and ideological aegis unspecified – that results in a lasting, just society. Scepticism about this belief is “conservative.” But it is no service to radical thinking to ignore obstacles to radical desire. “Radical” and “conservative” are too nearly synonyms for “optimistic” and “pessimistic” respectively.
Nonetheless, parts of the book yield valuable insights. Kaisary's best chapters concern paintings by Lawrence and Donkor and the trilogy of historical novels by Madison Smartt Bell. He contrasts Lawrence's depictions of Toussaint Louverture with earlier portraits, which saw Toussaint's face through the distorting lens of scientific racism; he shows also how Lawrence depicts Toussaint as first among equals, rather than as a Great Man in solitary splendour. He reconciles the ambiguity in Donkor's painting Small Axe with radical intent; we aren't sure what the three figures depicted are doing or thinking, but the canvas is charged with potential subversive violence. He demonstrates, with some subtlety, how painterly composition reveals implicit political ideas. In his negative evaluation of the Bell trilogy, Kaisary argues that instead of delving into the historical meaning of the Revolution, the author becomes obsessed with literal depiction of brutality and sexual exploitation, thus unwittingly producing a pornography of violence. He finds that Bell, for all his determination “to leave nothing out” (165), omits the most important thing: a moral (and narrative) perspective on the horrific details he describes.
Kaisary is least persuasive when discussing the most complex and nuanced of his texts, such as Césaire's La tragédie du roi Christophe and Carpentier's El reino de este mundo, consigned to the “radical” and “conservative” bins respectively. But they resist such easy sorting. They are neither purely conservative nor purely radical; they are ambivalent. They affirm the desirability of revolution, but question its limits of possibility.
El reino's greatest imaginative achievement is its vivid recognition of the epistemological chasm between the vodou religion of the slaves and the discourse of the French Revolution. The French are fatally blinded by their inability to conceive of their adversaries’ understanding of reality. Carpentier's powerful representation of this epistemological split cannot be described as inherently radical or conservative, nor does Ti Noël's dying epiphany necessarily imply, as Kaisary maintains, that revolution is part of a “futile cycle” (133) – only that that there are no permanent victories.
La tragédie du roi Christophe employs a Brechtian dramaturgy, as Kaisary acknowledges (29). That means that we witness arguments for and against Christophe's draconian regime, without full authorial endorsement of either. Christophe himself is a divided man, driven partly by his desire to exorcize internalized European stereotypes of black laziness and incompetence. He is both oppressor and liberator, westernizer and Afrocentrist. His harsh policies are partly – but not entirely – justified by his zeal to keep his nation free in a world of hostile, slaveholding powers. Kaisary's “single axis of distinction” is of little use here.
Overall, The Haitian Revolution in the Literary Imagination, despite its intermittent insights, is something of a disappointment. We have long needed a book like this. What we have is not quite that book, but its forerunner.
