The understandings of the greater part of men are necessarily formed by their ordinary employment.Footnote 1
Adam SmithI am seeking to rescue the poor stockinger, the Luddite cropper, the ‘obsolete’ hand-loom weaver, the ‘utopian’ artisan…from the enormous condescension of posterity.Footnote 2
E. P. ThompsonFifty years on, Thompson's statement of intent to create a ‘history from below’ focused on labouring people in the pre-industrial world undoubtedly has a clichéd ring to it. The principle enshrined in these oft-cited lines has long been a fundamental driving force for historians writing the social history of early modern England.Footnote 3 It might seem, therefore, like an odd quote to deploy in calling for a new direction in that field. Yet, for all its familiarity, one of its key implications has been continually overlooked: the importance of occupational identity to the people at the centre of our studies.
When Thompson defined his intended subjects, the identifier he most often deployed was occupational: the stockinger; the cropper; the weaver, the artisan. The assumption was the same as that held by Adam Smith: men were what they did. For historians who have sought to rescue the experiences of non-elite men and women from the margins of sixteenth- and seventeenth-century English history, such an assumption has rarely been their starting point. In the best introduction to identity in this period, the question of ‘the most important determining element of identity’ – whether individual or collective – considers a range of possibilities: ‘was it economic position or social power or cultural knowledge or religious opinion or regional origin or gender role or ethnic character?’Footnote 4 Whilst an individual's occupation may be connected to such factors, it is not accorded the status of a primary determinant of identity in the way it was for Thompson and Smith.
This may result from a perception that occupational identity in this period was relatively weak, ‘frustrated by the tendency of so many individuals to combine different occupations or to move from one form of employment to another’.Footnote 5 There is evidence that attests to the contrary. The common use of an affix of occupation as a form of address and identification in the period – ‘Arnold the Carpenter’, ‘Clarke the Mason’, ‘King the Thatcher’ – can be seen frequently in account books and in particular as a way of denoting tradesmen, reminding us of the ‘bygone equation of man and job’.Footnote 6 Contemporaries thought this equation determined more than just nomenclature: a man's occupation was thought to leave a physical imprint, and could be identified by the deformations it inflicted upon the body. Tailors and bakers could be identified by their legs, miners by the pallor of their skin and porters by their ‘thick, strong and brawny’ backs and shoulders.Footnote 7 Two recent books have drawn on such evidence to argue that occupation was indeed an important aspect of early modern identity. Given that work was expected to fill most of the daylight hours, Keith Thomas has suggested that it was ‘almost impossible to throw off an occupational identity outside working hours’ and therefore men ‘usually looked to their work as the source of their sense of identity’.Footnote 8 Brodie Waddell has revived an older argument that far from being inherently weak, occupational identities in early modern England were so strong as to have created a sense of ‘fraternal unity’ within trades that served to inhibit ‘inter-occupational solidarity’ and ‘disrupted the appeal of “class” identity’ in the period.Footnote 9
This paper starts from the proposition that historians therefore need to pay greater attention to the ways contemporaries understood the relationship between their occupation and their identity in seventeenth-century England. It does so by concentrating on a certain type of source – broadside ballads – and on a particular, albeit ambiguous, occupational group: tradesmen. The next section makes the case for using broadside ballads to investigate early modern occupational identity. The third section explains the focus on tradesmen, exploring definitions of this group and their changing role in early modern society. A longer fourth section offers an analysis of some of the key features of the tradesman's identity as represented by seventeenth-century ballads. These are examined in relation to the three contexts that John Tosh has identified as central to masculine identity: all-male association, work and the home, slightly reconfigured here as alehouse sociability, market exchange and marital relations.Footnote 10
Within these parameters, the paper makes four main arguments. All of these may require revision when considered in relation to other occupations and alternative source material: indeed, it is my intention that they serve as an agenda for further research on this theme, rather than as definitive conclusions. The first is that historians’ neglect of the influence of work on identity should not be overcompensated for by elevating occupation to the status of principle determinant in the way that Smith and Thompson did. It is neither possible nor appropriate to isolate occupational identity from other determinants such as gender, age or social status, and the call made here is to integrate occupation into our understanding of identity, and in particular to encourage historians to consider how occupation influenced identity, rather simply to assert its centrality. To this end, the second argument developed here is that occupational identity may not be the most fruitful category with which to think about the relationship between work and identity, if occupation is understood in narrow terms as relating to working in a specific trade or craft. Rather, broader categories such as ‘tradesman’, which demarcated a group with similar work experiences but made up of individuals working in a range of more specific occupations, had considerable influence on the way contemporaries understood the relationship between work and identity. It may be more appropriate to think of occupational identity in terms of broader ‘work-based’, rather than the narrower ‘craft-specific’, identities. The third key argument is that such work-based identities are best understood as a ‘prism’ through which early modern people sought to make sense of their experiences, rather than necessarily as a direct product of experiences that were peculiar to particular types of worker. Experiences that were in actual fact common to people in a diverse range of different types of work were often understood as being a product of engagement in a specific type of work: general experiences became particularised by individuals as part of a work-based identity. The fourth argument is that work-based identities were not always positive. As we will see, for many seventeenth-century tradesmen constructing and projecting a positive sense of identity would have proved a ‘Herculean task’.Footnote 11
Broadside ballads and social identity
Once described as ‘one of the great neglected forms of evidence for early modern mentality’, the seventeenth-century broadside ballad has now become widely regarded as a valuable source for social and cultural historians.Footnote 12 They are thought to represent the most popular form of print in early modern England, and were purchased by both gentlemen collectors and pasted on walls in the cottages of poor husbandmen. As such, Tessa Watt suggests they are uniquely placed to provide historians with access to ‘shared values’, ‘widespread attitudes’ and ‘commonplace mentalities’.Footnote 13 The fact that they were consumed across the social scale does not prove that consumers necessarily, still less universally, subscribed to the attitudes they expressed, however. Precisely how ballads and their meanings were received and understood by contemporaries will always remain to some extent an ‘elusive quarry’, and as such the conclusions that follow should be understood as suggestive rather than definitive.Footnote 14 Nonetheless, whilst the contents of any given ballad may have served alternatively to enrage, to amuse or perhaps even to flatter different readers and hearers, by paying attention to recurring themes and tropes across a number of ballads, we can begin to glimpse the contours of a cultural landscape that would have been familiar to a broad cross-section of contemporaries.
This potential has been recognised in recent work that has effectively mined ballads for contemporary discourses surrounding politics, religion, marriage, alehouse sociability, old age, economic morality, vagrancy and fashion.Footnote 15 They also represent an untapped resource for the study of work-based identity, as occupational groups were commonly chosen as a focus for ballads. Ballads celebrating the shoemaking trade were, for instance, particularly popular, describing this occupation as ‘the gentle craft’, and reciting the proverb that ‘a shoemaker's son is a Gentleman born’.Footnote 16 Not all ballads dealing with shoemakers were so flattering. The ballad The Shooemaker Out-witted lampooned the celebratory self-image of the ‘gentle craft’, detailing how one over-proud shoemaker had sought a wife with a generous dowry to raise his fortune to a level fitting for a man of such noble calling. Yet, duped by a ‘crafty lass of Surrey’, who had simply borrowed money to make her appear affluent, the shoemaker was ‘caught in a snare’ with a penniless and disrespectful wife, who ‘laughs in Derision and calls me her Fool, / And declares that I have but a pittiful Tool.’Footnote 17 The use of a favourite technique of occupational ballads – the reference to a tradesman's ‘tool’ as a euphemism for his sexual prowess – served to humiliate further the shoemaker, and hammered home the point that occupational pride was just that – the sin of pride – and usually precipitated a humbling. As the contemporary proverb put it: ‘Look high and fall into a cowturd.’Footnote 18
That ballads often characterised occupational groups gives them value as indicators of one of the key components of social identity identified by the sociologist Richard Jenkins: forms of external categorisation, or one of the ways in which social groups are defined by others.Footnote 19 Such definitions have utility for the historian of identity in two respects. First, although potentially pejorative or exaggerated, such categorisations of social groups tended to have some basis in the reality of how these groups were understood and encountered by their contemporaries: as Henry French has argued, printed stereotypes of social description only found purchase if they were ‘sufficiently consonant with the lived experience of the literate public to appear to offer reliable characterisations of society’.Footnote 20 Second, external forms of characterisation had a significant influence on the ways in which social groups both acted and defined themselves. Indeed, French, with Mark Rothery, has recently suggested we see such stereotypes as ‘bundles of experiences, prejudices, and assumptions’ that exerted ‘tremendous pressure’ on social practice and ‘imposed a deep psychological toll’ on the individuals and groups subjected to them.Footnote 21 In short, external categorisations of social identity were both based in the reality of social experience and identity formation, and consequent upon the same.
There is also an argument for seeing in ballads more than just external categorisations of occupational groups. They can provide access to the other side of Jenkins’ equation for the formation of social identity: internal categorisation. They may not match up to the kind of ‘personal documents’ – such as diaries or personal correspondence – on which historians of identity prefer to rely, but they tell us something about how occupational groups liked to envisage themselves.Footnote 22 This is particularly so in relation to urban tradesmen, who represented a core section of the ballad-consuming market with their above-average levels of literacy, their significant disposable income, and their traditions of occupational sociability such as guild feasts, which provided the ideal context for the collective performance of ballads.Footnote 23 Many ballads were therefore directed at artisans and tradesmen, and sought to appeal to these groups by offering celebratory portrayals of particular occupations – such as blacksmiths, tailors and shoemakers – that were intended to ‘flatter the heroic self-image’ of these workers.Footnote 24 They therefore reveal something of the ways in which these occupational groups sought to define, or at the least liked to imagine, themselves. In sum, ballads allow us to reconstruct some of the most prevalent discourses about certain occupational groups, and to disclose assumptions which informed contemporaries’ processes of identification, either in defining themselves or others. They permit us to identify some of the ‘building blocks’ out of which individual and collective identities were constructed.
Defining tradesmen
The ballad Round Boyes Indeed, Or, The Shoomakers Holy-Day offers a ‘very pleasant new ditty’ celebrating the coming together of fellow-shoemakers to ‘drink strong beer, good ale and sack’ in affirmation of occupational pride. It is a classic example of its genre, and many similar examples of what Samuel Pepys called ‘good fellowship’ ballads can be found for both this and other trades.Footnote 25 Of particular interest for the purposes of the argument developed here is the way the ballad deals with the relationship between the shoemakers and other tradesmen. Despite making lofty claims that shoemaking is a particularly noble craft – ‘Shoemakers sonnes were princes borne’ – this identity is not set up in opposition to the inferiority of those working in other artisanal trades: instead, the smith, weaver, tailor, carpenter, mason, bricklayer, costermonger, and a number of other tradesmen, are all described as being ‘noe niggards of their chincke, / But with boone blades will sit & drinke.’ These fellow-tradesmen are welcome drinking companions. Indeed, the shoemakers of the ballad declared: ‘The gentle Craft doth beare good will, to all kind hearted tradesmen’ that would join with them in bouts of good fellowship.
This highlights the existence of an occupational identity based on the more general marker, ‘the tradesman’, that encompassed something broader than a craft-specific consciousness: a marker that occurs regularly in reference to ballad characters. The ballad The Honest Tradesmans Honour Vindicated takes the form of a dialogue between a gentleman on the one hand and a non-craft-specific tradesman on the other.Footnote 26 The gallant blade and the London artisan take turns to trade insults about the negative characteristics of the other man's social type – gentlemen are accused of being sexually promiscuous, and in return tradesmen are derided as cuckolds – until the gentleman accepts that ‘man is blest / that is the Tradesmans friend’. Here, the tradesman is identified as a broader social type, defined not by his specific craft and in opposition to other craftsmen, but by his involvement in artisanal work and his opposition to the idle and spendthrift gentleman.
This broader occupational-cum-social identity of ‘the tradesman’ raises questions about the extent to which narrowly conceived craft loyalty and consciousness cut across any wider sense of worker or ‘class’ identity in this period. That said, we do have evidence of conflicts and hostility between different crafts and guilds. Samuel Pepys recorded news in 1664 of a ‘fray’ on Morefields between the butchers and the weavers, ‘between whom there hath been ever an old competition for mastery’, with the butchers being ‘soundly beaten out of the field, and some deeply wounded and bruised’.Footnote 27 There were also clearly defined hierarchies within crafts, with distinctions between masters, journeymen and apprentices being symbolically reinforced by each category using different drinking vessels and plate, dependent on their rank, at guild feasts.Footnote 28 It may be the case, then, that the inclusive category of ‘tradesman’ had little normative purchase with workers themselves, and was rather a fiction arising from the fact that it made better market sense to pitch a ballad at this broad category than at a specific trade. That said, the common occurrence of the marker of ‘tradesman’ in ballads at least shows that balladeers believed there were elements of identity common to all tradesmen that cut across or overrode differences and rivalries between and within trades. It is these areas of shared identity amongst the category of tradesmen that the remainder of this paper focuses on.
First, we need to define this category of ‘tradesmen’ for the seventeenth century. The issue is complicated by the fact that the term could carry a number of different meanings, as Daniel Defoe recognised in The Complete English Tradesman:
in the north of Britain, and likewise in Ireland, when you say a tradesman, you are understood to mean a mechanic, such as a smith, a carpenter, a shoemaker, and the like, such as here [meaning England] we call a handicraftsman. But in England, and especially in London, and the south parts of Britain, we take it in another sense…in general, all sorts of warehouse-keepers, shopkeepers, whether wholesale dealers or retailers of goods, are called tradesmen…[men] who do not actually work upon, make, or manufacture, the goods they sell.
For Defoe, then, a ‘tradesman’ was one involved solely in the retail or wholesale of goods, whereas those involved in the manufacture of goods were better described as ‘handicraftsmen’.Footnote 29 This was not the manner in which broadside ballads of the seventeenth century used the term tradesman. Instead, they used the term according more closely to the definition Defoe associated with Ireland and Scotland, to denote smiths, carpenters, shoemakers and so on. This difference between Defoe's definition and that prevalent in the ballads may reveal a shift in the meaning of the term over time: that in the seventeenth century the term was used throughout the British Isles to refer to a more artisanal conception of the tradesman, but by the early eighteenth century this was giving way – in England at least – to the term being used to refer specifically to retail tradesmen. This shift may be symptomatic of a growing occupational specialisation, with a clear distinction emerging between those involved exclusively in manufacture and those involved exclusively in retail that was not as pronounced in the seventeenth century.Footnote 30 Indeed, it is not a distinction that is present, let alone emphasised, in the ballad discourse, where grocers, shopkeepers, costermongers and sometimes even merchants might appear alongside smiths and carpenters in lists of tradesmen. It is in this more inclusive sense, meaning craftsmen and small-scale retailers, rather than that deployed by Defoe, that the category of tradesmen is understood here.Footnote 31
If definitions of what constituted a tradesmen shifted over time, conduct literature suggests that so too did understandings of their social role. In the sixteenth century, the tradesman was seen as fulfilling an important function in society, but his was not an aspirational or prosperous calling. As the Aristotelian ethics that underpinned many household management manuals in the period would have it, a tradesman should manufacture goods which he could then exchange to obtain the things a household needed for its welfare that it could not produce by itself. This was ‘a natural art’, and was therefore ‘necessary and honourable’. Producing goods to exchange for profit – or even worse buying and selling goods for profit – was to be ‘justly censured; for it is unnatural, and a mode by which men gain from one another’, and those that ‘believe that getting wealth is the object of household management, and the whole idea of their lives is that they ought to increase their money without limit’ were seen to corrode a sense of community.Footnote 32 A tradesman's calling was, ideally, a not-for-profit one. By the early eighteenth century, though, the conduct literature aimed at tradesmen appears to have adopted a dramatically different tone. Works such as Richard Steele's The Tradesman's Calling (1684), Daniel Defoe's The Complete English Tradesman (1726) and Benjamin Franklin's Advice to a Young Tradesman (1748) have been variously described as embodying the ‘spirit of capitalism’, or as speaking for a bourgeois ‘social consciousness that had come of age’.Footnote 33 These interpretations suggest that the economic developments of the seventeenth century – commercialisation and a growing demand for consumer goods – had tempted tradesmen to embrace market values and the pursuit of profit, and to play a key role as pioneers in the development of bourgeois capitalism.
Is this supposed shift evident in ballad discourses about tradesmen? If so, we would expect to detect a tradesman's identity reflecting a growing confidence, prosperity and embrace of the values of the market, that perhaps even exhibits the ‘self-satisfied smugness’ of caricatures of the ‘middling sort’ in this period.Footnote 34 Before turning to the ballads, we might consider two other hypotheses. Dramatic representations of tradesmen in Elizabethan drama, for instance, suggest an alternative perspective on their values. In her analysis of plays that depicted tradesmen, Laura Caroline Stevenson argues that playwrights increasingly came to recognise that this was a rising social group, and sought to offer a positive vision of tradesmen that would appeal to the growing numbers of such in their audiences. Before the eighteenth century, she suggests, these playwrights lacked the mental apparatus to understand this group's success in terms of bourgeois or capitalist values. Instead, she argues that positive depictions of tradesmen tended to fall back on elite ‘chivalric’ values that had little to do with tradesmen's actual social role.Footnote 35 We might therefore consider whether ballads echo the plays of the period in representing tradesmen as an increasingly self-confident and aspirant social group, but one that sought to appropriate the ethics of their social superiors rather than to forge an identity in relation to new capitalist values.
A third hypothesis emerges from Craig Muldrew's work on credit relations in early modern England. Muldrew reminds us that the growth in consumption and market exchange in the seventeenth century was not matched by sufficient growth in the supply of cash, and the majority of transactions that took place were therefore conducted on credit. As the number of such transactions rapidly increased, the networks of credit became more complex, more important and more precarious. Prosperity for individuals such as tradesmen did not take the form of money in the bank: any new-found wealth was far more mutable, tied up in multiple debt and credit relations, and vulnerable to rapid evaporation if a major debtor defaulted. Given the nature of this credit-based economy, Muldrew argues that we need to rethink some of the values historians have often associated with an emergent ‘spirit of capitalism’. An increased emphasis on industriousness, diligence and thrift amongst the middling sorts were not for Muldrew about the desire for capital accumulation, but about the need to build reputation and credit. Far from embracing bourgeois individualism, tradesmen were seeking to demonstrate to their neighbours that they had working habits that would increase their capacity to pay their debts. These values were less a product of an inward-looking desire for social advancement than an outward projection intended to secure one's credit within the community.Footnote 36 This conclusion raises a third hypothesis: the prospect of identifying in the ballads a tradesman's identity founded on an engagement with the growing significance of credit relations, rather than an identity based on aping elite values, or on a warm embrace of a new spirit of capitalism. This type of identity would reflect the mutable and precarious foundations on which the prosperity of any tradesman stood in the seventeenth-century credit economy. As we will see in the following section, this more anxious identity was indeed the more prevalent in ballad discourse.Footnote 37
Tradesmen in ballads
The ballad Robin Hood and the Tanner told the story of a ‘jolly tanner of Nottingham’, Arthur Bland. In defiance of nominative determinism, Bland had an adventurous streak that took him into Sherwood Forest, where he fought with Robin Hood: ‘like two wilde Boars in a Chase: / Striving to aim each other to maim.’ Ultimately, Bland was able to beat the folk hero into submission, forcing Robin to declare to Little John that ‘the Tanner that stands thee beside / He is a bonny blade and a Master of his Trade, / for soundly he hath tan’d my hide.’Footnote 38 The values associated with the tradesman here were straightforward: he was strong, courageous and not lacking in martial prowess. Adventure ballads such as this were not uncommon, and the writers of such were reaching for a set of conventional elite values to flatter their tradesmen readers. It is clear that these values had little to do with the actual social role of a tradesman in the seventeenth century.
Even so, ballads did not invariably situate their positive portrayals of tradesmen within a fantasy world of chivalric adventure. Others celebrated the routine sociability of ordinary tradesmen. As we have seen above, ‘good fellowship’ ballads provide one example of a genre that articulated a collective identity on the part of tradesmen, depicting such workers joining together in a homosocial alehouse celebration of their occupations.Footnote 39 Such ballads provide the most positive portrayal of tradesmen, and offered an image that their authors hoped would strike a chord with the self-perception of potential buyers. The key principles underpinning the occupational pride expressed in these ‘good fellowship’ ballads – as I have elaborated elsewhere – were a commitment to drink heavily, and an ability to pay your share of the resulting bar bill, or ‘shot’.Footnote 40 We might interpret this emphasis on liberal spending as a form of ‘conspicuous consumption’, with tradesmen using heavy alcohol consumption in alehouses to display in a public arena the new-found prosperity that many were enjoying in the seventeenth century. Was this another example of tradesmen mimicking the values of their social superiors, in this case their symbolic prodigality, in an attempt to show that they could now ‘live up to the standards of the gentry’?Footnote 41
Although ballad celebrations of good fellowship convey a strong sense of self-confidence and prosperity on the part of tradesmen, this was not achieved by drawing positive parallels between themselves and the gentry. On the contrary, ballads tended to contrast the behaviour of tradesmen with a negative critique of the prodigality of their social superiors. A social complaint ballad entitled The Poor Man Pays for All declared that whilst ‘The rich men in the Tavernes rore’ and ‘The rich men eate and drinke the best’, it was only through the labour of the poor man and the hard work of the tradesman that they could afford to do so.Footnote 42 Tradesmen's resentment of the conspicuous expenditure of the elite was also reflected in the exchange between the gentleman and the tradesman in The Honest Tradesmans Honour Vindicated. A key critique levelled at the gentleman focused on his gay apparel and love of sport and recreation, which he was able to indulge despite the fact that he ‘scorned too much to toil’.Footnote 43 This dynamic is also evident in Round Boyes Indeed. Here, the shoemakers declare:
Again, this ballad sought to draw a distinction between the tradesman, who worked for his beer, and the rich gallant, whose prodigal spending was instead funded by the sale of his lands. The further implication of this was clear. The conspicuous consumption of rich gallants on fine clothes and bouts of feasting and drinking could be defined as reckless prodigality: it would stretch the resources of the gentleman, here his land, to the point that they would eventually be entirely consumed. Indeed, the gentleman in The Honest Tradesman's Honour Vindicated was lampooned as having such distorted principles, boasting that: ‘Though I have neither House nor Land / I keep my self in good fashion.’Footnote 45
Heavy alcohol consumption among the shoemakers was not, however, analogous with that of prodigal gallants. For when a tradesman needed more money to fund his good fellowship, he did not need to jeopardise his estate; he could work for more. As the Martin Parker ballad The Three Merry Coblers put it:
Ballad celebrations of tradesmen's good fellowship suggested that their liberality was based on much firmer foundations than was the prodigality of the gentry. They could always generate more income through their labour in order to serve their need.
In reality this was an idealised notion. As we have seen, the seventeenth-century tradesman was enmeshed in market transactions within a credit-based economy that meant that the fruits of labour were rarely delivered in hard cash that could then be immediately spent in the alehouse. The prosperity of the tradesman was not secured through a simple and direct relationship between labour and reward: it was entangled in complex relations of exchange and credit. Although drinking and good fellowship ballads tended to downplay the role of the tradesman in commercial relations, this theme was taken up in other ballad genres. Where this was the case, tradesmen were rarely portrayed in the positive light that bathes the drinking ballads. They tended to appear in social complaint ballads which looked to play on a common stereotype of the tradesman as a deceitful dealer. A common ballad type here was the satirical ‘golden age’ ballad, in which a new age of honesty, free from sin and deceit, was declared to have descended. The honest dealing tradesman invariably appeared alongside lawyers who had resolved to put justice ahead of financial gain, usurers who had given all of their money to the poor, and reformed drunkards now committed to a life of sobriety. These ballads proclaimed that now ‘Tradesmen hate short measures, / false lights, and falser waights’; that ‘All Trades-men grow weary, / of living by wrong’; and that ‘The Taylor doth scorne to deceive any friend, / But unto plaine dealing his mind he doth bend.’Footnote 47 In each case, the proposed new golden age turned out only to be a fantasy. As one ballad character wryly put it, after hearing his friend describe this brave new world, ‘But I will not beleeve it, / tis too good to be true.’Footnote 48 Other ballads dispensed with wishful thinking altogether and condemned the deceitful practices of tradesmen outright. The unambiguously titled Knavery in All Trades lamented that ‘One tradesman deceaveth another, / and sellers will conycatch buyers, / For gaine one wil cheat his own brother.’Footnote 49 If the income-producing virtues of the craftsman-tradesman celebrated in good fellowship ballads were portrayed as a masculine trait, the vices of the retailing trader were seen to apply to male and female alike. Billingsgate oyster women and alewives were the two most prominent examples in a ballad literature that regularly portrayed market women as cunning, cozening and aggressive in pursuit of self-interest. It was a familiar complaint that ‘The Ale-wives they go fine and gay, / Deck’d in their Silks and rich Array’, on the basis of profits gained by selling short measures and frothy beer.Footnote 50 There was therefore a significant theme of ballad discourse in which the tradesman, along with the female trader, was portrayed as a deceitful dealer. The tradesman's role in retail was once again treated with suspicion, and any embrace of a ‘spirit of capitalism’ on their part was disdained.
Interestingly, though, another strand of ballad discourse depicted the sharp practice of tradesmen not as capitalistic, but as a response to the demands of the precarious credit networks within which they operated. The ballad Poor Robin's Prophesy was another satirical ‘golden age’ ballad, predicting a number of positive changes that would occur in society ‘when the devil is blind’ (an early modern equivalent to the modern idiom ‘when hell freezes over’). One part of his prophesy is particularly striking:
Of course, this neat resolution was unlikely to occur, and although the equation of a tradesman with dishonest dealing is present here there is a further implication: the shopkeeper resorted to deceit to balance his books because the gallant was not paying his debts to him.Footnote 52
It was a sentiment echoed in The Country-Mans New Care Away, a similar ballad-type listing remedies to social evils. The country man suggests that ‘If Gallants poore Tradesmen / would honestly pay, / Then might they have comfort, / to sing, Care away.’Footnote 53The Honest Tradesmans Honour Vindicated also picked up on the notion that tradesmen were as often victims of market exchange as they were deceitful beneficiaries of it, and again suggested that the prodigal gallant bore responsibility for this. The gentleman boasted about his fine apparel: ‘a Rapier by my side, / A broad Hat and long curl’d Hair, / My Breeches at the knees so wide / that they would make four pair.’ The tradesman retorted as follows:
The implication in each of these examples was that the prosperity of the tradesman rested on the willingness of their gentry customers to pay them their due and to do so promptly.
This could be taken to have a number of broader implications. We might read ballad attacks on the prodigal gentry who often failed to pay their debts as evidence of an increasingly assertive bourgeois voice, revealing a cultural aggression felt towards their social superiors by the tradesmen consumers of these ballads. Muldrew has suggested that seventeenth-century credit relations were increasingly based upon notions of equality that may have provided tradesmen with an opportunity to hold their social superiors to account for the failure to settle their debts.Footnote 55 This should not, however, be taken as evidence that tradesmen were adopting an assertive and confident capitalist identity. Attacks by tradesmen on the prodigality of the rich ultimately suggest that the growing levels of consumption of clothes and other material goods in the period were not seen by tradesmen as a fount of their own prosperity. There is no sense that tradesmen were embracing a consumer revolution for the opportunities for capital accumulation it might offer them. Instead, ballad discourse tended to invoke a rather more negative set of attitudes on the part of tradesmen towards the growing market in consumer goods. As Knavery in all Trades bemoaned: ‘Some Rorers doe were gallant clothes, / for which they did never pay.’Footnote 56 Another social complaint ballad, The Tradesman's Complaint, elaborated on what the outcome of this failure to pay up on the part of the rich would be:
Whilst the conspicuous consumption of elites may have provided demand for the wares of the tradesman, the growing number of transactions for such goods, conducted as they were on credit, left the tradesman in a particularly precarious position. Indeed, some ballads bemoaned that an aspirational desire for these goods had begun to filter down to tradesmen's own wives, which squeezed the tradesman further still. One London tradesman lamented that his wife was ‘In debt with ev’ry Shop she runs / for to appear in gaudy Pride’, with the consequence that ‘To buy those Trinkets which they lack / Both Stock and Credit goes to Rack.’Footnote 58 As far as ballads reveal anything about the ways tradesmen understood the economic developments of this period, they suggest that anxiety, rather than smugness, was the more prevalent reaction to the growing demand for their goods.Footnote 59
It was not just in the alehouse and the marketplace, but also in the household, that a tradesman's identity was forged – as the number of ballads exploring the role of the tradesman-as-patriarch attests to. In each of these contexts a tradesmen's self-perception was undoubtedly related to concepts of masculinity in early modern England, a component of identity that has received greater attention than occupational identity in the historiography. Alexandra Shepard's ground-breaking work in this area has suggested that contemporary codes of manhood based on alehouse sociability on the one hand, and upon patriarchal ideals on the other, were profoundly at odds in early modern English culture. It was men who were unable to reach the masculine ideal of a proficient head of household that looked instead to a form of ‘anti-patriarchal’ manhood that was articulated through acts of excessive drinking and bravado in the context of all-male alehouse sociability.Footnote 60 To some extent, this was about life-cycle stages, and the transition in status from apprentice to independent master would have been a stage in the life-cycle of the tradesman which coincided with that common shift from youthful, prodigal, ‘anti-patriarchal’ bachelorhood to the differing priorities of the married, patriarchal head of household. Yet, for the married tradesman-patriarch, there does not appear to have been a straightforward age-related shift away from alehouse sociability towards a greater focus on household management. Instead, ballad discourses suggest a tradesman-patriarch was still expected to engage in bouts of alehouse sociability with his fellow-workers to demonstrate his occupational pride and prosperity, but without jeopardising his duty of patriarchal provision.
Conduct literature of the period put great emphasis upon thrift as a principle essential for successful patriarchal provision. Yet, a tradesman who took this to mean that all alehouse sociability should be forsaken would end up labelled as a covetous miser. The ballad A Health to All Good-Fellowes derided those who refused to spend anything with alehouse ‘good fellows’:
As another good fellowship ballad put it, ‘The Miser that doth hoard his Coin’ was ‘a plague to thine and mine’, because keeping wealth circulating was seen as good for trade more generally.Footnote 62 Nor was too strong a commitment to thriftiness conducive to one's creditworthiness: no one wanted to be in a creditor or debtor relationship with a covetous miser. It was therefore essential for a tradesman to be seen to engage in alehouse sociability at least occasionally. Yet, there was also pressure on the tradesman not to over-indulge. Just as thriftiness could be seen to shade into miserliness, liberality and generosity were near neighbours of prodigality. I Tell You, John Jarret, You’l Breake offered a warning to those tradesmen who ‘When you in your shop should be plying your worke, / In some scurvy blinde Alehouse you all day doe lurke’, that they would end up bankrupt and broken: again, hardly desirable qualities in a creditor or debtor.Footnote 63 The household advice manuals of the period drew upon Xenophon and Aristotle to stress that it was important therefore to strike a balance of proper liberality, avoiding the extremes of miserliness and prodigality.Footnote 64
The pressures upon tradesmen to steer such a steady course were not only a result of concerns about credit relations. The ability of a tradesman to manage his resources effectively was also central to broader notions of patriarchal prowess, a quality that was often judged in ballads not by one's male creditors, but by women. Indeed, a feature of ballads addressing the tradesman-as-patriarch theme that runs counter to trends in the historiography of masculinity is the prevalence of a female voice in dictating and upholding approved masculine values. As Jenny Jordan has argued, historians of masculinity often assume that the values associated with manliness were determined by men, to the exclusion of women.Footnote 65 Yet, in many ballads, women assume the mantle of judging the masculine, and in particular the patriarchal, capacities of a tradesman. Sandra Clark has argued that we should see the strong presence of a female voice in ballad literature as evidence that this was a genre that articulated ideas and values held by women as much as by men.Footnote 66 Whilst this may apply to some extent to those ballads about alehouse sociability and market exchange, it is most clearly evident in a genre of ballads that weighed up the relative merits of potential husbands from the perspective of a female ballad voice.
Much of the attention here focused on a husband's capacity to provide for a family economically, and in some ballads the tradesman fared well in comparison to other social types. For instance, in The Maidens Delight, a young maid by the name of sweet Betty rejects the advances of a finely attired young gallant, despite the fact that he had employed that fail-safe wooing technique of adorning his cod-piece with ribbons. Instead, echoing the sentiments of many a ‘good fellowship’ ballad, the maid asserted that she would rather marry a tradesman:
Other ballad females were more sceptical of the tradesman's capacity to act as a reliable provider, and cautioned against tradesmen as marriage choices. One ballad explained that the tailor, for example, ‘For making clothes, is paid with oathes’, and was unable to maintain his charge and pay his house-rent and would end up as a broken beggar. Here, we see the recurrence of the notion that it was unreliable debtors who placed tradesmen in a precarious economic position: he was paid in ‘oaths’, promises which did little to help him provide for his family. The same ballad once again pointed the finger for this at the prodigal gallant:
The fact that a tradesman's prosperity was embedded in uncertain networks of credit was therefore perceived to diminish his ability as an economic provider, and undermined his reputation as an effective patriarchal male. So too could attempts to display his economic prowess in bouts of alehouse sociability: the warning about the impact of alehouse sociability on economic fortunes delivered in the story of John Jarret was voiced by Jarret's wife, and ballad wives urging their husbands to forgo alehouse sociability were a market staple.Footnote 69 Historians of the period have arguably overlooked the extent to which judgements about men's fulfilment of masculine ideals in this society were formulated in a dialogue conducted between men and women, rather than being judged by men alone.
If both men and women contributed to the process of defining masculinity, we also know that both made crucial contributions to household economies which did not in reality rely solely on the capacity of a patriarchal ‘bread-winner’. In fact, recent work by Amy Erickson has suggested that the prosperity of tradesmen-households in particular often rested on husbands and wives working closely together, running joint businesses or complementary enterprises from the same premises.Footnote 70 Some ballads painted a rather different picture of the tradesman's wife as one who does ‘rise about the hour of Noon’, ‘Then goes she to a Ball or Play’, and runs up debts for the household purchasing ‘lofty Topknots’ and ‘Powder’d Hair’.Footnote 71 Others more readily acknowledged the important role played by the tradesman's wife in the household economy. Wives were depicted selling their husbands’ goods in shops or from stalls in the market, and one ballad maid in search of a tradesman husband emphasised the contribution she could make to his work: ‘if a Shoemaker me wed, / his Shop-Thread I can spin’, or:
Indeed, a wife who was an effective spinner was often depicted as a particularly attractive prospect for any man, and it was perhaps here that women's work came closest to achieving something like the appreciation directed at men's productive artisanal work that was celebrated in good fellowship ballads.Footnote 73 A tradesman-patriarch was not then always portrayed as a munificent patriarchal provider, and there was recognition in ballad discourse that a prosperous tradesman-household needed a significant contribution from both husband and wife. Indeed, a tradesman's wife who did not work was not celebrated as a symbol of the new-found prosperity of these workers and their subsequent ability to support a leisured and fashionable wife – instead, they added yet another layer to the anxiety of the tradesman who was seeking to steer a steady course through the challenging economy of seventeenth-century England. A tradesman relied on a working wife.
Whilst some ballads ruminated on the abilities of the tradesman as provider for the household economy, others adopted a female voice to consider other aspects of his husbandly capability: sexual prowess was another important ‘building block’ of a tradesman's masculine identity. The Wanton Maidens Choice placed a man's sexual appetite above his economic standing as a criterion for selecting a partner. Here, the farmer was rejected because: ‘He is so weary all the day, / with holding of the Plow / He is no sooner got to Bed, / but he is fast asleep.’ The preferred choice was instead the tinker: ‘He shall be welcome day and night, / into my Company: / He has a Bag of Tools I swear, / and bravely he can them use.’Footnote 74 Another ballad female was similarly impressed by the abilities of ‘William the Joyner’, and again capitalised on the opportunity for an occupationally themed pun in recalling the ‘pleasure’ derived from their ‘wanton and wild’ sexual adventure: for William was a ‘young Spark’ who ‘can handle his Tools’.Footnote 75
Whilst ballads such as these touched on the sexual prowess of tradesmen in a playful and jocular tone, contrasting ballad discourses probed at the tensions and anxieties of tradesmen-patriarchs. Indeed, tradesmen are commonly portrayed as cuckolds in ballad literature, and whilst this was of course not a sleight directed only at tradesmen, there do appear to have been particular associations between tradesmen and that fate. In the ballad The London Cuckold, the unfaithful wife of a tradesman explained her behaviour to her husband as follows:
This was not an untypical story, and ballads could side-line the fact that tradesmen and their wives often worked together, and suggest that tradesmen were cuckolded while they were away in their workshops. As a turner in one ballad complained ‘To my work straight I go where I labour and toyl’, leaving another man to ‘turn up my wife the mean while’.Footnote 77 Alternatively, engagement in alehouse sociability could create a window for cuckoldry, and whilst a tradesman was at ‘the pipe and the pot’, even his own apprentice might take the opportunity of some ‘sweet Recreation’ with his mistress.Footnote 78 Ballads depicting apprentices as protagonists sought to probe the tradesman-patriarch's anxieties both over his ability to command the obedience of his wife and his servants, and tapped into a discourse about the sexual threat young men posed to older married men. The London Cuckold had an ‘antient’ tradesman cuckolded by a ‘coltish-spark’, and in one amorous encounter between a mistress and an apprentice the former complained of married men that there were ‘Not ten in fifteen that do lie with their Wives’, leaving such wives to seek out ‘a mettle-some Lad’.Footnote 79 Alongside the apprentice, a regular character to fulfil this role, as in the case of both the London cuckold and the turner, was a finely dressed young ‘gallant’: here, as in the world of credit relations, the gallant was the perennial bogeyman that undermined the tradesman's capacity to stake out a positive and assured sense of masculine identity.
This context allows us to see with clarity the resonances of the ballad The Honest Tradesmans Honour Vindicated. Its juxtaposing of the values of the prodigal gallant with those of the hard-working tradesman reflect a wider discursive trope, but more than that its title reveals the crucial point that a tradesman's honour was something that needed to be vindicated: it was not a given. It came under pressure on a number of fronts: from their operation in the unstable world of credit relations; from the judges of a tradesman's patriarchal and sexual prowess; from the challenges presented by steering a course between miserliness and prodigality when it came to engaging in the seemingly escapist world of alehouse sociability. To assert a positive identity in the face of such pressures was undoubtedly one of the most testing dimensions of the tradesman's calling.
Conclusions
These broadside ballads reveal some of the discourses, stereotypes and values – sometimes positive, other times negative and oftentimes humorous – that were associated with a particular occupational-cum-social group in a cultural landscape that would have been familiar to a wide range of early modern English men and women. The ballad discourses reconstructed here represent some of the ‘building blocks’ out of which the identity – whether external or internal, individual or collective – of seventeenth-century tradesmen could have been constructed. This is not to say that this work-based identity was the only, or even the primary, form of identity for those who could be classed as tradesmen. Yet, it seems unlikely that anyone working as a tradesman in this society would have been able to construct a sense of identity that was not in some way influenced by the various discourses discussed here. As such, work-based identity needs to be recognised as one of the many components of identity in this period.
How did this influence manifest itself though? We might suggest that some of the defining features of being a tradesman were not specific to being a tradesman at all. Concerns with patriarchal provision, with sexual prowess, with networks of credit, were surely central tenets of the lives of workers in a range of occupations, and could apply to men – and to some extent women – across the social scale. The experiences from which these preoccupations grew were not necessarily specific to certain types of workers. This does not mean, however, that work was not fundamental to notions of social identity. In fact, what the ballad evidence suggests is that broader aspects of social experience in this society, such as credit relationships, or fears of cuckoldry, were often interpreted by contemporaries as aspects of their particular type of work. General, common concerns were made specific and personalised by reaching for work-based contexts as a narrowing framework through which to organise social experiences that were in reality more widely shared. The job may not have made the man, but it did provide a lens through which he could make sense of the world.
What sort of identity did a tradesman develop by viewing the world through the lens of his working experiences? We set out with three possible hypotheses. One was that although tradesmen were a prospering and aspirant social group in the seventeenth century, there did not yet exist a set of positive values that accurately reflected upon their social role, and they were accordingly left to express their identity by mimicking the values of their social superiors. Whilst some ballads associated tradesmen with chivalric qualities, others made very clear distinctions between the values of tradesmen and those of their social superiors, especially in relation to forms of consumption. Ballad literature tended to contrast the reckless prodigality that underpinned the consumption of the rich with the more sustainable alehouse liberality of the tradesman, which was in turn founded upon an ability to turn to labour in order to fund such consumption. This unease about the ability and willingness of those who were driving the demand for consumer goods actually to pay for their wares has implications for another of our hypotheses: that tradesmen in this period were enthusiastically embracing the development of the market. Whilst some ballads implied that tradesmen sought to gain profit through dishonest dealing in market exchange, any suggestion that they saw the market as a friend was countered by others. There were constant complaints that tradesmen struggled within the economic climate of the seventeenth century because their wealth was dependent on networks of credit, credit that was often extended to social superiors who did not or could not pay their bill. The tradesman's relationship with the growth of consumer demand and the expansion of market exchange was not treated in the ballads as one of affection, but rather as one of precarious and anxious dependency.
This conclusion chimes with our third hypothesis: to understand the identity of tradesmen in this period we need to acknowledge the significance of a credit economy in which ‘household wealth was seen primarily as a social relationship, and not as a thing’.Footnote 80 It would be misguided to assume that the economic developments affecting tradesmen is the period would necessarily lead to their emergence as an increasingly prosperous and self-confident bourgeois class. As Craig Muldrew puts it, ‘it is too simple to think of early modern society as divided into “classes” of wealthy and poor. Wealth was not so much a state of being, or inclusion in a privileged group, as a continual process of ethical judgement about credit’.Footnote 81 Wealth and prosperity were mutable relationships rather than things, and for the tradesman they could very easily and very suddenly be lost – this was self-evidently not a situation about which to feel smug. Tradesmen's anxieties about credit relations also informed their concerns about their capacity to function as patriarchal providers. And as tradesmen spent long hours in their workshops trying to demonstrate to their wives and neighbours that they were diligent, productive and creditworthy, ballads preyed on their insecurities about fulfilling patriarchal ideals by depicting tales of cuckoldry, with carefree gallants, dressed in clothes obtained on credit, sneaking into their homes and marital beds. Within this economic and cultural context, many seventeenth-century tradesmen would no doubt have struggled to find the necessary tools to construct, project and maintain a positive self-image or sense of ‘honour’.
