Leisurely Islam presents a thorough and detailed exploration of the emerging leisure landscape in Shiʿi South Beirut. The authors, an anthropologist and an urban studies scholar, have been engaged in research in Dahiya, South Beirut, since the 1990s. They witnessed the emergence of a leisure sector, especially after the Israeli withdrawal from Lebanon in 2000. Deeb and Harb argue convincingly that this sector operates within the parameters of what they characterize as an Islamic milieu. Through a careful analysis of Dahiya's leisure geography, they explore how pious Shiʿi youth craft a balance between fun and religious morality.
Leisurely Islam opens with a detailed chapter on the historical, political, and social context necessary for understanding the growth of South Beirut's leisure landscape. Chapter 2 introduces some of the major political, economic, and religious stakeholders of that leisure landscape, while Chapter 3 moves on to describe the range of styles and venues found in the sector. These chapters are in fact a long introduction to the main argument on morality, geography, and leisure, which is set out in Chapters 4 and 5.
The book convincingly sketches the contours of South Beirut's Islamic milieu and the ways in which young people navigate its morals and geographies. Deeb and Harb develop an analysis of generational difference, which expresses itself through varied engagements with morality and leisure. They argue that, from the 1960s through the 1980s, an Islamic vanguard generation helped develop an Islamic milieu in Dahiya. This religious milieu, in turn, constitutes the almost taken-for-granted social environment of a younger generation. The younger generation sees piety as an important part of their lives but deals with the demands of a pious lifestyle in a more flexible way than the vanguard generation. The authors use discussions of leisure choices, such as the decision whether to visit a place in which music is played, to illustrate the differences between these generations.
The study also ably illustrates how geography and morality interact. Deeb and Harb show how particular identities, based on combinations of class, sect, age, and morality, are inscribed in the urban landscape, and, in turn, inform orientations toward and engagements with various city spaces. For example, the authors describe how local youth engage with and contest Dahiya's long-held reputation of backwardness and rurality in and through their leisure choices. It is also interesting to read how the waxing and waning of sectarian tension influences urban trajectories and leisure choices. During times of rising tension, young South Beirutis are happy that they are able to consume leisure in the familiar surroundings of Dahiya, or may choose to do so as a sign of political allegiance.
Leisurely Islam's rendering of South Beirut's leisure landscape is thorough and at times even overly detailed. Yet, after reading its description of South Beirut's leisure places, this reader was also left with a number of questions. While the descriptions of the sites of leisure are extensive, we learn relatively little about the patrons’ backgrounds or lives. How do these outings fit into their lives beyond the pursuit of leisure, and what does their presence in such public sites mean to them? Also, I would have liked to read more about the classed and gendered religious and social morals that inform the leisure choices of the patrons. We learn, for example, that this leisure landscape caters to a Shiʿi middle class, but a more thorough analysis of how such leisure choices constitute forms of class distinction is missing.
Moreover, the authors refer to some of the ethnographic literature on Cairo, but primarily to argue that mixed-gender socializing is significantly less difficult in Beirut. A more thorough engagement with the literature on leisure geographies in the Middle East would have allowed them to develop an argument on the regional specificity of Beirut in analytical rather than primarily descriptive terms. More generally, the book could have further developed its arguments to engage with broader debates regarding morality and leisure, social identities, and urban space.
Some of the issues raised here are related to the types of data and methods employed in this study: interviews with important stakeholders, focus group discussions with patrons, and direct observation in cafes. The authors indicate that they focus on “what young people say that they do,” which gives them access to “conscious articulations of different ideas of morality and space” (p. 29). Such an approach limits the analysis to explicit rationalizations of spatial trajectories and conscious choices regarding morality and geography. Working on similar issues in Cairo, I encountered the importance of tacit knowledge with respect to morality and geography in choices regarding one's urban trajectories, a knowledge that was only articulated in the moment actual choices were made, or in minor, offhand remarks. A more ethnographic approach that includes participant observation in the lives of various patrons would have helped move the analysis beyond overt, formal rationalizations of leisure choices.
Also, as an anthropologist, I missed a more explicit reflection on the methods that produced the data on which the book relies. While a number of anecdotes provide us with some insight into the production of the data, it would have been helpful if the authors had reflected more extensively on how their position in the complexly stratified Beirut landscape may have affected their findings. This is perhaps all the more significant when one understands that this analysis of young people's leisure and normative choices is largely based on interviews and focus group discussions. It is clear that young Dahiya residents enter these focus group discussions aware of the negative assessments of social and moral worth projected on their neighborhoods. Their perceptions of moderators or researchers—as upper-class Beiruti outsiders, adopted insiders, university professors?—are likely to have influenced how they represented Beirut's leisure geography and reflected on their own moral choices.
Leisurely Islam presents a fascinating, in-depth case study of the development of a leisure sector in a politically and religiously fragmented urban landscape. It does a wonderful job setting out the emergence of South Beirut's Islamic milieu, the complex parameters of Dahiya's leisure venues, and the various ways in which a new generation of pious youth develop their own combinations of leisure and morality. However, this author would have liked to learn even more about the lives of the patron's of Dahiya's leisure spaces, and about the conclusions that we can draw regarding urban life in the Middle East from their urban trajectories and leisure choices.
