If Marshall McLuhan's well-worn maxim holds true and the medium is indeed the message, Mapping Intermediality in Performance demonstrates the limits of pulp and print technology, and indicates the possibilities for intermedial study and innovation in scholarly network mapping. Sarah Bay-Cheng, Chiel Kattenbelt, Andy Lavender, and Robin Nelson's volume functions as an “intermedial stage,” while “pursuing the idea that there may be something distinctive about the ways in which mediums work together in digital culture to challenge established modalities of experience” (Nelson, 23, 17). This pursuit leads the reader through philosophical considerations of performance and mediatization; new definitions of key terms in intermedial, multimedia, and performance studies; case studies of innovative performances such as those of Frank Castorf, Robert Lepage, The Builders Association, and Richard Foreman; and incarnations of digital performance such as electronic music and participation in Second Life. The thirty contributors to this volume form an impressive collective of practitioners, professors, and critics, with much overlap among these (perhaps too rigidly defined) categories.
The content of the book, like that of computer networks, is divided among “portals,” “nodes,” and “instances.” The volume's portals comprise one to three essays that present cogent overviews of the following theoretical concepts as they relate to the topics of intermediality and performance: “Performativity and Corporeal Literacy,” “Time and Space,” “Digital Culture and Posthumanism,” “Networking,” and “Pedagogic Praxis.” The first four portals branch out into nodes, which contain three to eight terms and navigate the theoretical space opened by the particular portal through clusters of concepts, which are defined in no more than a few paragraphs. The “Modes of Experience” node is reached through the “Performativity and Corporeal Literacy” portal, the “Dimensions” node via “Time and Space,” “Actuality-Virtuality” through “Digital Culture and Posthumanism,” and “Inter-relations” by means of the “Networking” portal.
“Instances” are the sections of the book where the theories and explorative definitions found in the portals and nodes are applied to specific performance practices. Instances follow the form of chapters in more conventionally edited volumes, examining particular works in light of the book's ideas and themes. The authors of the short essays that appear as Instances are tasked with an especially important element of this volume, as they navigate the spaces between, among, and across various media and performances. Taking on this task with clarity and an eye toward the theoretical concepts articulated in the portals and nodes, they provide production and rehearsal photos of the works discussed that permit the reader glimpses of the intermedial possibilities they describe.
The book concludes with “Retrospection: The Pre- and Proto-digital,” which sets the project of Mapping Intermediality in Performance “within a broader context of 20th-century developments in the arts” (237). Tim Hopkins's “Instance: Give me your blessings for I go to a foreign land,” provides a photocollage of an “intermedial opera” (239) with description, images, and Web addresses that a reader can follow to various aspects of the performance. Klemens Gruber's essay offers “Archeological Glimpses” at intermediality stretching back to the late nineteenth century and, despite being the final essay of the volume, may be an excellent entry point to this book for those who are less familiar with the subject.
One final note on the book's structure: throughout, “a system of arrows points the reader to links across the network” (9), cross-referencing other sections of the book—for example, “(→ prospective mapping),” or “(← term: feeback loop).” These parenthetical insertions are a frequent reminder of this volume's medium and its limitations. Indeed, these interruptions push one to imagine this project expanded into a virtual network or electronic map where hyperlinks might allow the reader more easily to “follow lines of flight between portal, nodal terms, and instances” (10).
Similarly, the nodes suffer from being book-bound. Despite the strength of the model and its innovative definitions, there is simply very little room to begin unpacking the dense references contained in the explication of terms. This is less of a criticism of the editors or the authors than of the medium in which their ideas are presented. Indeed, one can imagine the well-chosen and wide-ranging clusters of terms as starting points for further expansion—these terms might become new portals, which might then spawn additional nodes and instances.
The work of the cartographer must always be revised as new information becomes available, the landscape changes, or the relationship between map and object is rethought. I am wary of drawing associations between this volume and open-source Web sites, as many of those sites, such as Wikipedia, often prohibit original research, and this volume is anything but unoriginal; however, Mapping Intermediality in Performance offers, perhaps, a model of how future scholarship might navigate open-source environments while producing groundbreaking research. Both the structure and the content of the book serve as solid foundations on which further research in intermediality and performance might develop in other media. This volume exemplifies the viability and necessity of complex network maps of disparate and dense theoretical and performance materials. While physical, economic, and institutional pressures currently constrain such innovative scholarship to a technological apparatus that is over half a millennium old, this volume pushes the boundaries of the codex in ways that should be of interest not only to those studying this particular subject, but to anyone interested in innovative models of collaborative research, or in a possible future for academic edited volumes. This book will certainly be used in graduate classrooms; its structure, which allows for many points of access, makes much of its content available at the undergraduate level as well. Mapping Intermediality in Performance marks a welcome expansion of the field, blazing new trails while mapping those currently in use.
