The Horse in the City by Clay McShane and Joel Tarr places the horse in the context of the nineteenth- and early-twentieth-century American city. The nineteenth century, they argue, was the golden age of the urban horse, and around 1900, horses were still widespread in large American cities. In Kansas City, for example, there was one horse for every seven people, while in New York there was one horse for every 26 people (p. 16). McShane and Tarr's central theme is that the horse was a living machine with the power to augment human strength and productivity.
The story McShane and Tarr tell is mostly about the challenges associated with using the horse as a machine, and they make clear that most owners placed economic considerations before humane ones. The salience of economics can be seen in a number of examples. When James Watt created his steam engine in 1775, he also developed a measure of horsepower. In this way, the individuals who purchased his engines would know how many horses they could replace. Owners also recognized that, as living beings, horses had limits and traits that differed across breeds and individual animals. So that they would not overwork and ultimately injure their living machines, owners such as street railways often limited the workday for horses to only five hours a day and avoided galloping horses pulling heavy loads.
Chapter 1 describes the market for horses, particularly in urban areas. It begins by describing the complexity of buying a horse, and the methods buyers used to identify horses that might already be lame, or have some other potential problem. These methods included looking for a shiny coat and firm flesh, but of these could be disguised by sellers by dying a horse's hair and by overfeeding. Similarly, teeth were often examined to assess age, but unscrupulous sellers could file down teeth to make the horse appear younger. Many of the problems discussed here mimic those identified by Olmstead and Rhode in their work on bovine tuberculosis and the efforts sellers used to disguise otherwise sick cattle (“An Impossible Undertaking: The Eradication of Bovine Tuberculosis in the United States.” This Journal 64, 3 [2004]: 734–72.) This chapter also describes how the market for horses evolved over the late nineteenth and early twentieth century, suggesting that a sharp drop in the market in the 1890s might have been due to a bicycle fad and the development of the street railway. Another possibility is the severe macroeconomic downturn that afflicted the American economy during this period. Perhaps the most interesting aspect of this chapter is McShane and Tarr's discussion of how dead horses and manure were recycled and marketed for blankets, hair stiffeners, phosphates, and fertilizer.
Chapter 2 addresses some of the issues associated with regulating and controlling the use of horses by both municipal governments and private agencies, such as the American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (ASPCA). Much of the control of urban horses during the mid nineteenth century focused on carters—two-wheeled carts drawn by a single horse—that were used to ferry commodities around the city. Licensed and regulated by the city, they were most commonly used for loads that required dumping, such as coal and garbage. Although their use peaked around 1850, they continued to be used, largely for construction enterprises, well into the twentieth century. Teamsters, those who drove a two-horse team pulling a four wheeled wagon, began to appear in 1850 and gradually undermined the market for carters. Teaming, because it involved controlling two horses simultaneously, was much more difficult than carting. The ASPCA was created in 1866 in New York by the socialite Henry Bergh, whose father had grown rich in real estate and brothels. Dedicated to fighting cruelty to animals, the ASPCA was more than just altruistic; it was able to keep any of the fines courts imposed on teamsters and carters.
Chapter 3 describes the horse's relationship with urban transit systems. Around 1830, entrepreneurs in the United States and elsewhere began using the omnibus, based on the traditional stagecoach, to carry passengers around large cities. Pulled by four horses, the omnibus sometimes seated as many as 14 passengers, though often they carried fewer passengers in smaller cars to better navigate narrow or hilly city streets. Although New York was the first city to employ the omnibus, the technology spread quickly to other large American cities. Omnibus lines were typically licensed and subject to city regulation. It was not long, however, before omnibuses were replaced by the railed street car, which traveled over iron tracks installed in city streets. Still pulled by horses in their early days, street cars were a vast improvement over the omnibus, offering passengers a smoother and much faster ride. Horse-drawn street car lines fundamentally altered urban geography, making it possible for people, for the first time, to move away from city centers and still work in the city. In New York City, for example, the street railways opened up the territory north of 42nd Street Manhattan for development.
Chapter 4 examines the relationship between the horse and leisure, particularly the incredibly high price the wealthy paid to keep and maintain their horses and carriages. Chapter 5 examines the environmental issues surrounding urban stables for horses, including size, fire safety, and public health issues.
From my perspective, the most fascinating chapters in the book were those on nutrition (chapter 6) and health (chapter 7). The nutrition chapter documented the great diversity in the caloric intake of horses across regions and occupational settings. It also highlighted how large advances in agricultural productivity increased hay production by 50 to 200 percent over the late nineteenth century, driving down the price of food for horses. The chapter on health is nicely encapsulated in two graphs. One plots the average death rate of horses and humans by month over a five year interval. This graph clearly shows that the death rates for both horses and humans peaked and troughed in the same months, suggesting that they were both subjected to a common pool of pathogens or that disease spread quickly from one species to the other. The second graph indicates that the same pattern can be observed in annual data. That the for most of the nineteenth century the fate of humans and horses were inextricably linked is perhaps the most important theme to emerge from this study. McShane and Tarr also focus much of their attention in chapter 7 on the great epizootic of 1872, a terrible strain of what was probably influenza that affected horses and thereby disrupted economies across the country.
Overall, McShane and Tarr have written an outstanding and highly creative book. It should interest historians of cities, the environment, economics, and animals.
