One of the continuing questions regarding the U.S. policy in Iraq and the larger “war on terror” is the legality of American actions. While much of the debate has focused on domestic American law, one of the concerns many have is whether the actions of the United States conformed to international treaty and legal commitments. While most recognize that the United States does have obligations under international law, there has been a tendency for some to contend that these considerations must defer to pressing national security concerns. While Duffy is not as political as some would like in her analysis, she provides an excellent and exhaustive legal analysis of the role of international law in the current war in Iraq and the larger “war on terror.”
Duffy's book reads almost like an international law textbook that reviews those aspects of international law relevant to the American-led war on terror and the war in Iraq. After a quick review of the sources of international law and an overview of the book, Duffy reviews the international law related to terrorism. She highlights the difficulty the international community has had in constructing a treaty or convention on terrorism. The primary problem has been devising an acceptable definition of terrorism. This difficulty means that Duffy must claim there is not even a customary basis for an international law related directly to terrorism. Nevertheless, Duffy contends that international criminal law clearly provides a legal basis to sanction those, like the perpetrators of the September 11 disaster, who commit acts of violence.
Duffy identifies the legal basis for state responsibility for terrorism. The law is clear that if states are closely associated with private individuals who commit acts of terrorism, states become responsible for those actions. The Bush administration may have overstated the case by blurring the distinction between private terrorists and states that harbor them. International law, however, is clear that Afghanistan and the Taleban regime were responsible for assisting al Qaeda or protecting it from being brought to justice. If a state has clear evidence of a wrongful act by another state or a gross breach of international obligations, then the first state has a legal obligation to end this breach. Duffy is not clear in contending that this justified the military response of the United States against the Taliban regime, but her argument appears to assume this. The difficulty of identifying a terrorist group like al Qaeda's status in international law confuses the legal basis for an American response. International law historically assumed that states were the actors in international politics, and only they could conduct war. It is clear that, after September 11, terrorist groups have ever growing capacity to commit acts that amount to war against a state. No matter what the legal status of al Qaeda or the degree of culpability the Afghan regime should have for allowing terrorists to train in their territory, international law requires that the United States first attempt peaceful means to resolve the quest for justice against al Qaeda in Afghanistan. Only then does the United States have the right to use force to defend itself in retaliation for the attacks of September 11.
In the case of preemptory strikes like the one the United States made against Iraq, “the capacity to inflict harm, however grave, is insufficient, unless the circumstances indicate a real and imminent threat” (158). The legal argument Duffy presents makes it clear that the preemptory strike in Iraq could not be justified according to international law. She contends that “a threat to international peace and security itself is not sufficient to trigger the legitimate use of force” (171). She also finds that no single state has the power to enforce Security Council Resolutions. Only the Security Council has the right to enforce its resolutions. Thus, the effort of the United States to enforce Security Council resolutions against Iraq must be seen as falling outside the accepted international legal framework. Duffy also reviews other aspects of international law and arguments made regarding the use of force by the United States in Iraq. From international humanitarian law, to claims of attempts to promote democracy and preemptive self defense, Duffy finds little in American policy that conforms to traditional interpretations of international law. This finding includes the treatment of detainees and terror suspects in Guantanamo and other prisons outside the United States as well as the attempt to defy accepted definitions and practices regarding torture.
One of the most interesting and compelling aspects of Duffy's legal review is her analysis of the role of international criminal law. Duffy provides a thorough overview of the different elements of international criminal law that are relevant in the recent activities of the American government since September 11. She contends that the initial outrage after this act of terrorism provided the United States an opportunity to utilize the international consensus in favor of policies in the American interest. The questionable conduct of policies by the United States after September 11, especially the denial of criminal rights to detainees, has undermined international legitimacy and support for American policy. Duffy's account does not read as a partisan diatribe against Bush's foreign policy but a carefully crafted legal accounting of American actions.
Nevertheless, this account may not satisfy those who seek to expand or create new international law to conform to the interest of the United States in this age of terrorism. The irony that Duffy suggests but does not dwell upon is that international law supported American interests in the wake of September 11. However, questionable practices and a seeming disregard for the international legal framework have led to the loss of international support for American policies. This book will be of great use to scholars wanting to know more about the legal basis for the response of the United States to September 11 and the war in Iraq. Duffy provides extensive notes and makes claims that are defended by her citation of legal precedents. Her careful reading of international law will be of great interest to both scholars and policy-makers concerned with the legality of American action in the “war on terror.”
