Is there a universal right to the free expression and preservation of cultural heritage, and if so, where is that right articulated and can it be protected? How is the notion of “heritage” used variously to unite and divide communities? Who defines cultural heritage and who should control stewardship and the benefits of cultural heritage?
These are the important questions that Helaine Silverman and D. Fairchild Ruggles pose on the back cover of Cultural Heritage and Human Rights. A volume both broad and rich, it addresses the political aspect of heritage preservation and management as it relates to human rights.
This book is the outcome of a workshop organized in 2006 by the Collaborative for Cultural Heritage and Museum Practices (CHAMP) held at the University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign. The workshop brought together a group of contributors from a range of fields: archaeology, anthropology, history, culture studies, landscape architecture, and geography. Their objective was to examine and interrogate heritage as it relates to cultural identity. Their published essays present a cross-section of the academic discussions about cultural heritage and human rights.
Cultural Heritage and Human Rights has three strengths. First, the editors make the argument that “human rights and cultural heritage are not self contained,” and the chapters insightfully demonstrate how “they may overlap and in doing so may conflict with each other” (p. 6). Second, they have included case studies that show the ambivalence of heritage and the challenges involved in its preservation and production. Third, the volume reveals that much substantive fieldwork on cultural heritage and human rights is undertaken by those critical of conservation discourse and international management practices. In this way the book provides a solid overview of the critical dimensions of cultural preservation for scholars, policymakers, students, and heritage workers.
If, as Silverman and Ruggles argue in their introduction, “cultural heritage does not figure prominently in the extensive literature on human rights” (p. 41), the chapters by William Logan, James Wescoat, Jr., and Christopher Silver are an important corrective. They demonstrate how conservation is a problematic force that undermines as well as supports the maintenance and extension of human rights. Among other succinct examples, Logan correctly points to how in Myanmar the junta is using Buddhist monuments as a way of both legitimizing its own position and marginalizing the rights of minority groups (p. 41). Conversely, through his extended discussion of the Champaner-Pavagadh Project, Wescoat, Jr., shows how heritage can be used quite differently to address conflict and perhaps function as a panacea for human rights abuses in Gujarat, India. Christopher Silver perceptively extends the discussion of cultural heritage and human rights to tourism. With Indonesia as his case study, he ponders the challenges for local governments in implementing tourism in the face of cultural clashes throughout the archipelago in the era since the end of the authoritarian regime of Suharto's New Order government.
In an approach similar to that of Charles Orser, Jan French dwells on descendant communities, the frictions, rhetorical labor, and the obstacles that many community members face in the process of negotiating heritage rights. Orser argues that the right to express and see cultural heritage is a fundamental right, but he cautions that it is “not unproblematic” (p. 93). As French shows, scholars must be concerned with local appropriations and performances of rights (p. 107). More particularly, he looks at the development of narratives of slavery in the context of the struggle for land in the backland of Brazil and finds that heritage legislation provides an opportunity to be not only protective but also productive. Laurajane Smith picks up this theme in her essay, where she considers how in Australia heritage can often become a political resource in which indigenous peoples negotiate political recognition and legitimacy. For Smith, “heritage is a resource in, and a process of, negotiation in the cultural politics of identity” (p. 159).
Hugo Benavides, Larry Zimmerman, and Anne Pyburn's chapters raise the issue of to whom the past belongs. Although they agree that protecting and interpreting heritage is important to indigenous Americans, their writing highlights the political domination that often defines the production of heritage. Zimmerman thoughtfully discusses how three contested Native American sites of conscience (e.g., Fort Robinson, Dull Knife, and Wounded Knee) that were intended to memorialize the “memories of atrocities so that they will not be repeated” came to be seen as sites of exclusion by Native American communities (p. 156). He emphasizes that if tribal groups are coauthors of their narratives and interpreters of history, then national commemorative sites can succeed. For Pyburn, collaboration, such as that advocated by Zimmerman, is critical both in terms of alleviating tensions among stakeholders and of guaranteeing the preservation of archaeological sites. At the core of any conservation work, Pyburn stipulates that a combination of ethnographic research and careful collaboration with local professionals should be sought.
The volume concludes with Elzar Barkan's essay, which prompts us to consider the implications that cultural heritage (here cultural property) in its intangible forms has on human rights. By discussing the recent joint National Geographic Society and IBM 5-year Genographic Project aimed to collect and analyze DNA samples from indigenous people, he problematizes what cultural property comprises and who has the authority to do the interpretation (p. 185). With one result of the project being the mapping of human migration, he warns that the outcome will further demonstrate the polarization of world views.
When, in their preface, Silverman and Ruggles caution that “the relationship between cultural heritage and human rights is complex and cannot be adequately considered in a single volume such as this” (p. vi), they underestimate how much ground they have covered and the extent to which it will be new fodder for future human rights discussions.
