Even after more than fifty years, Martin Luther King's indictment that eleven o'clock on Sunday morning is the most segregated hour of America still rings true, as over 90 percent of Christians in the United States continue to attend racially segregated churches. Conservative Protestantism in particular has a lot to answer for in this regard. Historically, twentieth-century white evangelicalism has legitimized Jim Crow-ism and lynchings, and has embraced the coded racism of sunbelt market fetishism and antistatism. As Nancy Wadsworth notes in her remarkable book, despite recent efforts to address the complicity of white conservative Protestants in racism, evangelical rituals of admitting and forgiveness have “continually repressed cognitive reflection, inquiry, and open conversation about power and politics” (147). Or, as one white pastor who features in her study notes, “You talk to black Christians, they want to talk about justice; you talk to white evangelicals, they want to talk about reconciliation” (219).
Nonetheless, change is finally in the air, or so Wadsworth contends. Departing from the pessimistic view expressed by Michael Emerson and Christian Smith in their groundbreaking 2000 study Divided by Faith, she argues that evangelical efforts at racial change “represent gradual challenges to social hierarchies” (21) and have “a good chance of impacting the main body of evangelicalism in positive ways” (259). What is more, the new concern with race holds out the prospect of reorienting evangelicalism away from the political right, particularly on issues such as immigration. As evangelicals are creating genuine multiethnic churches, they start to engage with issues they had previously shunned, such as material inequality and the structural underpinnings of racial injustice.
Competently combining case studies, surveys, and discourse analysis, Wadsworth unravels how evangelical practices and beliefs help break new ground in race relations but also limit critical reflection on white racial privilege. On the basis of a “political ethnography” that investigates the “daily small-scale engagements with power and inequality” she shows how evangelicals in the 1990s were “fumbling toward new language” on race (167). Religious race-bridging efforts by, for example, Promise Keepers and Campus Crusade for Christ promoted racial healing. These approaches, however, often failed to move beyond one-off apology rituals. Nonetheless, they created what Wadsworth calls the “epiphanal spaces” that enable evangelicals to develop the social reflexivity and cultural empathy required for dismantling racist attitudes and structures. In turn, a growing number of multiethnic churches, defined as having at least 20 percent of parishioners from minority backgrounds, engaged in “digging below the surface of comfortable relationships to real points of pain” (245) in order to build long-term commitments across racial lines.
This crossing of racial boundaries, Wadsworth maintains, is the basis for developing political consciousness. Her survey of multiethnic church attendees shows that a higher percentage supported addressing racial and socioeconomic inequality than moral issues, such as abortion and marriage (205, 207). Particularly the issue of immigration began to challenge conservative Protestantism's alignment with the political right when church-based relationships with (illegal) immigrants changed many evangelicals' view on punitive policies. As one pastor noted, “watching a third-grader cry because her dad is deported” opened his eyes to the injustices of the existing policy regime: “And I talk about ‘family values'” (253).
In the end, Wadsworth sketches out a scenario where the multiethnic church no longer sweeps tensions under the carpet, but uses them as means toward the development of sustained transracial interaction. Combining “principled openness to conflict” with a safe and spiritually compelling environment (154) allows parishioners to step out of their comfort zone and open themselves up for “miraculous beginnings.” Following Hannah Arendt, Wadsworth suggests that by linking a secure space for open debate and honest engagement to the ability to transcend the ordinary, the evangelical “tool kit” can overcome the faith's muteness on racial change and pave the way toward different political orientations.
Wadsworth presents a well-researched and compelling analysis of a much-neglected subject. There are some areas of unevenness. The historical and theoretical sections are less developed than the parts on fieldwork and contemporary developments. The text is at times repetitive, the autobiographical references can be distracting, and a more detailed exploration of how evangelical mission work, particularly in Latin America, shaped the emergence of multiethnic ministries and a more liberal stance on immigration would have been useful. Moreover, considering that multiethnic churches constitute less than 10 percent of Christian churches (17), the book's claim of “stunning breakthroughs” sounds at times exaggerated. However, these are minor quibbles. Wadsworth expertly connects the exploration of racial politics with the study of religion and politics in an incisive analysis of a faith historically characterized by a split personality on racial matters.
