On November 9, 1882, the crème de la crème of Gilded Age America's intellectual, political, and cultural spheres gathered at Delmonico's restaurant in New York City to celebrate the achievements of Herbert Spencer and to bid him farewell before he returned home to England. Using the guest list of the fete, author Barry Werth examines the explosive growth of Spencer's adaptation of Darwinian evolutionary concepts to human societies in the Gilded Age and reveals how the philosophy became influential in post-Civil War America. The author does an excellent job of tracing the connections between Spencer and the nation's academic, business, political, and cultural elite. However, his lively prose and fascinating insights cannot mask the serious problem that calls his ultimate argument into question.
Banquet at Delmonico's traces the introduction and promotion of what would erringly be called Social Darwinism, an attempt to apply to society and morality the evolutionary ideas of Charles Darwin as detailed in his 1859 Origin of Species. The central figure is Spencer, a British philosopher, sociologist, and author who coined the term “survival of the fittest.” By linking Darwinian ideas of biological natural selection to the evolution of human societies, Spencer struck a chord with American intellectuals and elites who were ripe for a new philosophy. From Cambridge to New York, Washington to the French Riviera, Werth charts the adoption and promotion of Spencer's theories, beginning in 1871, by a small group of influential advocates such as author Edward Youmans, Harvard-based lecturer John Fiske, political operative Carl Schurz, businessman and philanthropist Andrew Carnegie, and Yale professor William Graham Sumner. These and other prominent Gilded Age titans joined the gathering at the New York City institution to pay homage to their philosophical hero.
Using period articles and monographs, Werth presents an argument that is both simple and elegant. In the latter years of the 1860s, leading intellectuals and other powerful figures in the United States experienced something of a crisis of faith stemming from the Civil War. In this postwar age, “traditional theology crumbled nearly to dust,” and “many people craved an alternate system of beliefs—new principles to live and prosper by in the changing world, a creed” (xi). Herbert Spencer provided this creed, a scientific basis to explain the way societies evolved. More importantly, Spencer provided a scientifically based system that could explain biology, society, morality, human behavior, and history. This scientific cosmology stood in stark contrast to the religiously centered basis of American society, and Banquet lovingly details certain aspects of the conflicts that occurred when traditional religious structures and advocates (the Yale board of trustees, Harvard naturalist and rabid anti-Darwinist Louis Agassiz) were forced to face the surging new philosophy that promised a rational explanation for the way the world (and, specifically, American society) operated.
Delmonico's argument seems eminently plausible. However, one serious question remains after the cover is closed … the grandiosity of Werth's claim of Spencer's influence. Werth asserts that “Spencer influenced nearly every area of modern thought,” yet limits his study to a small group of adherents who had already demonstrated their conviction to Spencer's theories (xiii). If Spencer's adaption of Darwinian evolutionary concepts to human civilization were as influential as claimed, then non-adherents have no place in Werth's world. Indeed, in order to support his argument that Darwinian evolutionary theories as applied to American society were widely accepted, the author is forced to gloss over countervailing views. For example, he presents the controversy that exploded in 1880 when it became public knowledge that Sumner was using Spencer's The Study of Sociology in his undergraduate sociology course at Yale. Werth notes that Sumner “was no disciple of Spencer” and had only adopted the book because he considered it the most thorough work on sociology available in English (224). The author's focus, however, is on Spencer and Youmans's reaction to press coverage of the controversy, Sumner's conviction that he was about to lose his teaching position, and the political machinations that occurred in Yale's governing board in June while Sumner was away. The significance of the outrage over Sumner's assigning Spencer's book to his students is ignored.
If this were the only such example, this complaint would be relatively minor. Still, the very fact that the dispute occurred at Yale indicates that Spencer's evolutionary ideas were not universally accepted, especially among the trustees of the university whom Werth does not identify, though he claims that “more than half of them [were] Christian ministers” (227). What implication does such opposition have for Werth's overarching argument? By focusing on such a narrow pool of elite devotees of Spencer, the author is able to avoid such sticky questions, but the argument of those who considered Spencer, Darwinism, and natural law a threat to society remains largely unexplored. Agassiz is the only opponent cited, and after his death in 1873 no individual is elevated to challenge Spencer's ascendency. One possible candidate is Washington Gladden whose views on laissez-faire economics and Darwinian natural selection were highly critical. However, Gladden is nowhere to be seen, and after Agassiz's death Spencer stands alone as the intellectual lion of Gilded Age America.
It is the limited pool of characters that is both this work's greatest strength and aggravating weakness. By concentrating on only a small group of Gilded Age movers and shakers, Spencer presents a simple argument that moves quickly and supports its assertions. At the same time, however, it feels maddeningly incomplete given the lack of opposing viewpoints. The other half of the story is missing. Ultimately, Banquet at Delmonico's provides a streamlined narrative that serves well as a general introduction to the subject of Social Darwinism and its adherents, but anyone looking for more depth into the philosophy or its advocates and opponents will need to look elsewhere.
