Michael Y. Bennett's Words, Space, and the Audience: The Theatrical Tension between Empiricism and Rationalism provokes investigation into what will hopefully become more complex cross-fertilization between histories of philosophy and drama. For Bennett, there is “an inherent, ever-present tension between empirical and rational ways of understanding a play” (8; his italics), and without considering the difference between such a priori and a posteriori knowledges, practitioners may misinterpret playtexts. Unlike previous investigations into theatrical meaning making by Gay McAuley, Bert O. States, and Stanton B. Garner, Bennett's does not employ phenomenology; instead, his philosophical histories contextualize five plays: The Importance of Being Earnest, Salome, Six Characters in Search of an Author, Waiting for Godot, and Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf?
The book's title is somewhat misleading, as Bennett emphasizes words almost exclusively throughout. Although he identifies in his introduction four components of the theatrical event—words, space, gesture, and audience—Bennett defends his text-centric approach. Gesture, he writes, is “generally a choice made for a specific production by the actor/director, and . . . is not necessarily part of the play, per se” (12). His discussions of space, too, are scant, as “the text is the text is the text, and its unchanging reality . . . provides theatre with something both residual and universal” (16–17). Instead, Bennett provides text analysis and occasional references to contemporary performances in order to demonstrate thoughtfully the philosophical implications of, for example, Algernon's wit in The Importance of Being Earnest (38–9), or George and Martha's “language-games” in Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf? (104). Together, these mostly successful analyses argue that “some extremely influential modern plays not only force both the empirical and rational approaches, but actually take up their contemporary empirical versus rational debate” (2).
Bennett first contextualizes Oscar Wilde's writing in light of his Oxford studies, and effectively explicates dialectical tensions within Earnest. The play counterposes empiricism and rationalism, as it “focuses on the philosophical tension . . . between the idea (as a rational concept) that Jack is Ernest and the fact (as an observation, tangible truth) that Jack is actually named Ernest” (36). Bennett links the idea of “bad faith” (40), that is, lying to oneself, to the concept of “Bunburying” (42), and concludes that the final integration of Jack and Algernon into stable respectability is a Wildean resolution of tensions resulting from the rise of British idealism and growing socialist sentiments. Bennett then illustrates how Salome, too, embodies the impossible tension between being and not-being, or performing sincerely and Bunburying. Bennett's connection of Wilde's theatrical work to his philosophical training adds depth to familiar interpretations of Wilde as preoccupied with either class satire or trivial witticisms.
In Chapter 2, Bennett ably demonstrates that Pirandello was conversant in the philosophical transition of his time, as pragmatism was dying and idealist nationalism rising. The chapter's thesis, that “Pirandello forced the audience to reexamine the self in the context of the debate between philosophical idealism and pragmatism” (58), theorizes audience response in terms of identificatory relationships to the Manager and the Father. As evidence, Bennett details the dominance of the Father over others: Father “directs” more effectively than the Manager, he represents frightening psychoanalysis and (then-ascendant) Italian idealism, and he is a naturalist character among expressionistic ones.
Bennett summarizes in his third chapter the public 1952 conflict between Camus and Sartre, and applies the philosophers' differences to his reading of Godot. Whereas Sartre believed action must be undertaken to challenge the absurdity of existence, Camus believed meaning is created not through action but reason. Here, Bennett opposes Esslin and other absurdist critics who suggest that Camus and Sartre agree on the basic tenets of existentialism. By considering, among other things, Vladimir and Estragon's reactions to Pozzo and Lucky, their interpretation of the tree's new leaf, and the play's opening words, “Nothing to be done,” Bennett distills the central, unanswered question of the play: “[D]o we need to do to affirm our existence, or do we need to be to make life meaningful?” (91).
In Chapter 4, Bennett reads Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf? against the rise of American analytic philosophy, especially Wittgenstein's “language-games,” the death of logical positivism, and J. L. Austin's performatives. Although Bennett avoids claiming that Albee intended to dramatize these philosophies, he does state that Albee “thematically deals with the very questions that preoccupied thinkers like Wittgenstein and Austin” (112). Bennett's argument primarily reframes the play's conflicts in philosophical language: George's speech on the “unpredictability” of history becomes a humanist-empiricist rejoinder to the logical positivism of Nick's biology, and performative language challenges empirical facts long before the pronouncement of the son's death. As George and Martha finally confront each other, George triumphs because his empiricist disciplinary training better equips him to face an uncertain cold-war future than does Martha's primarily rationalist understanding of how the world should be.
Bennett concludes by interviewing Coco Fusco. Discussing a range of work, especially her Two Undiscovered Amerindians . . . and Rites of Passage, Fusco emphasizes the structural, logistical, and psychological demands of unscripted, interactive performance. Bennett attempts to identify a consistent, intentional relationship among words, space, and audience, yet Fusco denies she is cognizant of such abstract relationships during performance; this contrasting perspective is welcome. Fusco's tight focus on specific performances arises from a nuanced consideration of historical audiences and a healthy skepticism of performance documentation—including scripts.
Words, Space, and the Audience provides substantive insight into histories of plays and playwrights, though each chapter would benefit from some extension. At points, Bennett's theoretical frame imposes a dichotomy—that audiences must “side” either with rationalism or empiricism—when it seems likely that most audience members use(d) both, and may not be concerned with logical inconsistencies arising from employing the two together. Deeper consideration of the ephemeral, embodied, and paralinguistic aspects of performance, admittedly more difficult to capture in writing, would enhance the project. Occasionally specific performances are considered, briefly suggesting that tensions between epistemologies can be resolved by artistic choices. However, Bennett's primary goal is to describe tensions within texts, rather than to theorize meaning creation in performance. This book's value lies in its linkage of play and context; it would be most useful for scholars of dramatic literature, or directors and dramaturges interested in the plays discussed. Overall, Bennett dares in Words, Space, and the Audience to ask difficult questions about the relationships between the histories of thought and drama, and shows there is still much answering work to be done.
